In the office, Li Qingguo held the paper in his hands, his eyes full of inspiration.
Without a doubt, the paper had given even him, a mathematics professor, plenty of inspiration.
In particular, he had never seen an approach that decomposed the convergence of a sequence of functions into three independent directions, each regulated by a control function.
If he hadn't known that a first-year undergraduate had written it, he might even have thought he was reading a top Science Citation Index journal.
Letting out a long breath, Li Qingguo came out of his engrossed reading and looked at Han Chuan. He no longer looked at him as a student, but more like a fellow scholar.
"From the definition of control sequences to the extension to non-reflexive spaces, did you complete this entire paper on your own?"
"Mm."
Han Chuan nodded. "Professor Zhang and Professor Li gave me some suggestions about the direction, but I did the derivations and proofs myself."
Li Qingguo leaned back in his chair and let out a long breath. Smiling, he handed the paper back to Han Chuan and said:
"A first-year student writing a paper like this is almost unheard of, not just at Xiangnan University, but even at Tsinghua and Peking University."
"If it gets published without a hitch, you'll have broken our university's record."
"The mathematics department has never had a first-year student publish in a Science Citation Index journal."
"Old Zhang has a fine student!"
Across from him, Han Chuan smiled sheepishly. He was just about to say something when a voice came from the office doorway.
"Naturally."
It was Professor Zhang Ji'an, who had just returned from the Humanities and Social Sciences Institute.
Across from him, Li Qingguo glanced at Zhang Ji'an. "I said you have a fine student, not that you taught him to be one."
"No difference."
Zhang Ji'an said cheerfully, "It's all the same."
Li Qingguo immediately objected. "Hah, how can you say that with a straight face? How many times have you taught Han Chuan? And you say it's all the same?"
Listening to the two big shots bicker, Han Chuan, caught in the middle, awkwardly rubbed his nose, unsure whether to intervene or laugh.
But soon, his teacher put a complete end to the dispute with a single sentence.
Zhang Ji'an said, "What, are you jealous that I have a fine student?"
That remark killed the game.
Li Qingguo gritted his teeth and snorted, saying nothing more.
He wanted to say he wasn't jealous, but he couldn't get the words out.
After all, this was a student who could independently conduct research and write a paper in his first year. Who wouldn't be jealous?
In the office, having cheerfully gotten the better of Li Qingguo, Zhang Ji'an looked at Han Chuan, his gaze falling on the paper in his hands.
"Solved it?"
Han Chuan nodded and handed him the paper. "Professor, please take a look and see if there are any problems left."
"All right."
Without further ado, Zhang Ji'an reached out and took the manuscript. Once his gaze landed on the first page, it never left.
As he looked at the paper in his hands, his eyebrows rose slightly, a trace of surprise in his eyes.
He had thought Han Chuan had only solved the difficult problem of improving the uniform convergence lemma for sequences. He hadn't expected him to have written the paper already, much less to have done it so properly.
Zhang Ji'an read the introduction quickly, but when he turned to the second page, his gaze slowed at once.
Following Han Chuan's approach to the solution, he read through it point by point.
The Control Sequence Framework, the complete statement and proof of the core theorem, from the reduction to the M-test to the unified construction of the Dirichlet Test and Abel Test, and then the necessary and sufficient conditions on reflexive Banach spaces...
As he read, Zhang Ji'an pulled a red pen used for grading papers from the pen holder and held it above the page, ready to mark any problems and places that could be improved.
But after reading for some time, the tip of his pen still hadn't come down.
There was nothing to correct!
With his discerning eye, he could find a few places where the language could be made more concise, or where a more classic reference could be added for Lemma 2.3, and so on.
But those were just "polishing," not "errors."
He couldn't even find anything that could be optimized.
A paper written independently by an undergraduate, and he, a doctoral supervisor, couldn't find a serious flaw in its logic?
Zhang Ji'an's wrist hung in midair, the red pen casting a long, thin shadow under the light. Even after he finished reading the entire paper, that shadow had yet to descend.
"The logic is consistent, the structure is complete, the innovations are clear, and the proofs are rigorous. The extension to non-reflexive spaces... far exceeds what I expected of you."
"This paper is even better than I anticipated!"
Letting out a long breath, Zhang Ji'an put the red pen back and looked at Han Chuan with a sigh of admiration.
Han Chuan smiled sheepishly and said modestly, "It's all thanks to your teaching, Professor."
Zhang Ji'an shook his head. "As far as this paper is concerned, I didn't teach you much. There's no need to be modest. It really is excellent."
After a pause, Zhang Ji'an changed tack and tapped the manuscript with his finger. "But I still have two questions."
Han Chuan held his breath. "Go ahead."
"First, submission."
At this, Zhang Ji'an's expression grew serious. "I remember you mentioned before that you originally planned to submit this paper to Applied Acta Mathematica Sinica, right?"
Han Chuan nodded. "Yes."
Applied Acta Mathematica Sinica had been founded by Hua Luogeng and was sponsored by the mathematical society and the Academy of Sciences' Institute of Mathematics and Systems Science. It also enjoyed a fine reputation in China.
Although it wasn't a T1 journal, it ranked just below the three major T1 journals: Science China Mathematics, Acta Mathematica Sinica, and Annals of Mathematics.
More importantly, the paper's research direction had emerged from Old Hua's textbook, Introduction to Mathematical Analysis.
That was why Han Chuan thought it would be more appropriate to submit it to Applied Acta Mathematica Sinica.
Across from him, Zhang Ji'an shook his head and said bluntly, "Submitting it to Applied Acta Mathematica Sinica would be doing this paper a disservice!"
After a pause, he went on to explain, "Given the quality of this paper, submitting it to Applied Acta Mathematica Sinica would be casting a pearl into darkness."
"Its core contribution, the unity of the Control Sequence Framework, is enough to attract the attention of the mathematical analysis community both at home and abroad."
"If you're submitting domestically, I'd only recommend Acta Mathematica Sinica and Annals of Mathematics."
"But given the quality of this paper, I'd be more inclined to recommend Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics Journal on Mathematical Analysis (SIMA) or Journal de Mathématiques Pures et Appliquées."
"Both of them are suitable for your paper!"
In the office, before Han Chuan could answer, Li Qingguo looked over. His eyes widened, and he spoke with a look of astonishment.
"Old Zhang, have you gone mad? Going straight for a top Science Citation Index journal? He's only in his first year!"
"What's wrong with being a first-year?"
Zhang Ji'an glanced at him. "Kolmogorov wrote papers at seventeen, and Erdős earned his doctorate at twenty-one!"
"In mathematics, only the proof counts, not age."
"His paper deserves it!"