Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
Academic Ace: All My Teachers Are Giants in Their Fields!
Chapter 7

Pen, Come!

1,230 words 4 min read 2 views 7d ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

"Wait, you're still here?"

Seeing Sang Kai still sitting beside him, Han Chuan paused and asked instinctively, "You don't have a makeup exam. Do you really need to hole up here and grind like this?"

Sang Kai: "..."

What did he mean, "You're still here?"

He had come along at seven that morning and hadn't left this chair since. Han Chuan really hadn't even noticed he was still here?

His lips twitched. He pushed the workbook in his hands toward Han Chuan and said, "There's a problem here I can't solve. Can you take a look?"

"Oh?"

Han Chuan raised an eyebrow and teased, "A top student like you is asking a slacker like me for help?"

Sang Kai retorted, "angry out of embarrassment," "Just tell me whether you can solve it."

Han Chuan reached out, took the workbook, and glanced at the problems. One of them had been circled.

"The one with the circle?"

"Yeah."

"Okay, let me see."

Han Chuan lowered his head and looked at the problem.

[Suppose f(x) is twice differentiable on [0,1], f(0)=f(1)=0, and f″(x)≤0 for x∈(0,1). Prove that f(x)≥0 for every x∈(0,1).]

The problem was short, just two lines.

But in mathematical analysis, the shorter a proof problem's statement, the more difficult its derivation and the more logical traps it tended to contain.

Han Chuan stared at the problem for a while, instinctively turning it over in his mind.

In mathematical analysis, this was a problem applying the mean value theorem, but it was on a completely different level from an ordinary homework exercise.

The problem stated that the second derivative was nonpositive: the function was "concave," with a value of zero at both endpoints. He had to prove that its value was nonnegative at any point in between.

Going by intuition alone, he felt the statement was true.

After all, a curve that met the ground at both ends and never bulged upward in between couldn't possibly dip below ground.

But intuition was one thing. Mathematical proof demanded rigorous logical derivation; intuition alone was nowhere near enough. He had to work through it step by step, each link joined to the next, without a single flaw.

Beside him, Sang Kai leaned back in his chair and quietly watched Han Chuan's expression, thoughts churning in his mind.

This was no easy problem. It was a major proof problem from a university mathematics competition a couple of years ago.

He had just spent two hours trying to solve it himself, only to find he hadn't even touched the door to a solution.

Of course, the answer was actually in the back of the workbook.

He had looked at it too, but his reason for asking Han Chuan was to see just how capable his roommate really was.

Of course, he also wanted to measure himself against him.

After all, everyone in Room 401 knew Han Chuan was a mathematics student admitted without an entrance exam, a genius who had won first prize in the CMO Provincial Competition and had come close to reaching the national finals.

But over the past semester, no one had seen him study seriously, and no one knew just how capable this genius was now.

Sang Kai wanted to find out too.

In the library, Han Chuan knew nothing of the twists and turns in Sang Kai's mind. He simply stared at the problem, rapidly searching his mind for relevant knowledge.

Suppose the function's value is negative at some point, then use the derivative condition to derive a contradiction... No, proof by contradiction won't work.

What about the Lagrange Mean Value Theorem?

That might work, but I'd have to deal with the relationship between the first derivatives on two intervals, and bring in the second derivative to characterize the monotonicity of the first derivative. Because f″≤0 means f′ is monotonically decreasing.

That's a bit too much trouble. Is there a simpler way?

Sang Kai leaned back in his chair, watching Han Chuan frown. The frustration in his heart eased a little, and his anxious heart relaxed considerably. He smiled and said,

"If you can't solve it, forget it. It's fine. I'll take a look at the answer and work through it."

It looked like, after spending all of last semester playing games, his roommate was nowhere near his level anymore.

At the desk, Han Chuan ignored Sang Kai. After thinking for a while, something suddenly occurred to him, and he quickly said,

"Pen, come!"

Sang Kai froze for a moment, then instinctively handed him a pen.

Pen in hand, Han Chuan pulled over some scratch paper and sketched a concave function.

[Let x₀∈(0,1) be any point. Since f″(x)≤0, f′(x) is monotonically decreasing on [0,1]. By the Lagrange Mean Value Theorem, there exists ξ₁ in (0,x₀) such that f(x₀)−f(0)=f′(ξ₁)(x₀−0), that is, f(x₀)=f′(ξ₁)x₀.]

[There exists ξ₂ in (x₀,1) such that f(1)−f(x₀)=f′(ξ₂)(1−x₀), that is, −f(x₀)=f′(ξ₂)(1−x₀). Therefore, f(x₀)=−f′(ξ₂)(1−x₀).]

[Since f′ is monotonically decreasing and ξ₁<x₀<ξ₂, f′(ξ₁)≥f′(x₀)≥f′(ξ₂).]

[If f(x₀)0, then f′(ξ₁)<0 and f′(ξ₂)0. Since f′ is monotonically decreasing, f′(ξ₁)≥f′(ξ₂), so f′(ξ₁)−f′(ξ₂)≥0. But f′(ξ₁)0 and f′(ξ₂)0, so f′(ξ₁)−f′(ξ₂)<0. A contradiction.]

[Therefore, the assumption is false. Hence f(x₀)≥0!]

"Done!"

After writing the final symbol, Han Chuan put the pen down on the desk and handed the scratch paper to Sang Kai.

"D-done?"

Sang Kai's eyes widened, his jaw nearly dropping to the floor in astonishment.

He had assumed Han Chuan would get stuck on this difficult competition problem, but he had never expected him to write out the entire proof after thinking for only a moment.

"Yeah."

Han Chuan smiled and nodded. "This problem is a little difficult, but it's relatively easy to solve using the mean value theorem together with monotonicity."

Sang Kai's lips twitched.

He picked up the two sheets of scratch paper covered in derivations, read them from beginning to end, then read them again. Frowning, he asked,

"How did you derive the contradiction for the proof by contradiction in this step?"

Han Chuan leaned over, glanced at the scratch paper, and said, "In an ordinary proof by contradiction, you directly assume the conclusion is false—that is, assume there's some point x₀ where f(x₀)<0—then force a contradiction out of it."

"But that assumption alone isn't enough, because f(x₀)<0 by itself doesn't tell us much."

As he spoke, he tapped the scratch paper with his pen.

"So instead of fixating on f(x₀)<0, first use the Lagrange Mean Value Theorem to express f(x₀) in two different forms. One uses the left endpoint, 0, and the other uses the right endpoint, 1. That gives you two equations, f′(ξ₁) and f′(ξ₂)."

Sang Kai stared at the two equations for a few seconds, his pupils widening slightly. "So f′(ξ₁) has to be negative. Because x₀>0 and f′(ξ₁)x₀ has to equal a negative number, f′(ξ₁) can only be negative?"

"Bingo!"

Han Chuan snapped his fingers and smiled. "Right! By the same reasoning, −f′(ξ₂)(1−x₀) has to equal a negative number, and (1−x₀)>0, so −f′(ξ₂) has to be negative, which means f′(ξ₂) has to be positive."

After listening to Han Chuan's explanation, Sang Kai stared at the equations on the scratch paper in his hands and slowly let out a breath.

"So that's how it works..."

Before he had finished speaking, he seemed to remember something. He quickly picked up the exercise book beside him and flipped to the answer page at the back.

"Wait, your solution seems different from the standard answer!"

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Before you continue

How was this translation?

Explore the wiki

Han Chuan
Sang Kai

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS