The battle between the Wave School and the Particle School
Stared at by so many heretical wizards, Karen's initial surge of anger cooled considerably.
A cold wind blew through the aisle of the auditorium, causing him to break out in a cold sweat and his legs to tremble uncontrollably.
However, seeing that the Son of Light had already covered for her, Karen straightened her back and mustered her courage to speak proudly.
"As everyone knows, the Lord of Radiance wields the Light Authority, Storm Lord wields the Thunder Authority, but the Lord of Radiance power is far more vast and powerful than that of the God of Storm and Thunder! This is the proof!"
As soon as Karen finished speaking, the wizards in the front row frowned repeatedly, their faces full of impatience.
This is a serious Arcane Symposium. They are here to explore the Truths of the world, not to listen to a pastor preaching Church theology and praising how powerful his own god is!
Several hot-tempered elemental wizards were about to shout at them when Herman stroked his chin and spoke up.
"Wait... I think the Dawn Priest is right. If light is really just a ripple that happens when lightning strikes, then the Lord of Radiance could never be among the Gods; he should be subordinate to the Storm Lord!"
The surrounding wizards nodded thoughtfully upon hearing this.
They don't believe in God, but the power wielded by the gods cannot be faked.
Seeing that her words had actually silenced all the wizards present, Karen was so excited that her face turned bright red.
On the podium, Locke was laughing so hard tears were almost streaming down his face. "Hahaha... did you hear that, Baal? Even the pastors of the Church of Dawn can't stand it anymore, they think your Light-Wave Theory is utter nonsense!"
He had assumed that Baal's confident assertion in questioning his academic achievements must be accompanied by some groundbreaking and unconventional argument.
I never imagined it would be so utterly ridiculous!
"And you just said that light is like ripples, similar to sound waves and water waves?"
Locke stopped laughing, took a step forward, scrutinized Baal, and began a full-scale academic interrogation.
"As you all know, if you throw a stone into water, the ripples will spread in all directions. Similarly, when we speak in a room, the sound waves will travel to every corner of the room, and you can hear us even through a wall!"
Locke sneered, reached out and patted the still-warm Laser generator beside him, his tone aggressive.
"But what about light? Everyone witnessed Derek's experiment just now! The light shining through the hole travels in a perfectly straight line!"
"It won't ripple around the barrier like water ripples, illuminating the shadows behind it, and it won't bounce back intact when it hits a mirror! Tell me, where in the world is there a ripple that only travels in a straight line in one direction and can bounce back as precisely as a marble?!"
This questioning was well-founded and based entirely on the experimental phenomena that everyone had just witnessed.
Derek, sitting in the audience, nodded in agreement. "Exactly! If light could scatter and interfere with each other like ripples on water, that beam of light would have vanished long ago. How could it possibly have bounced precisely a hundred times between the mirrors!"
A burst of laughter and applause erupted from the audience; everyone felt that Locke's sword strike had directly severed Baal's vital point.
However, despite the overwhelming public opinion in favor of Locke, Baal, with his dark circles under his eyes, didn't even blink, a mocking smile playing on his lips.
"Who told you that light travels in only one direction?"
Baal slowly extended a finger and pointed to the electric light hanging above the platform. His voice was not loud, but it instantly suppressed the noise of the entire venue.
"You seem to have forgotten that all light sources, at the moment of activation, diffuse simultaneously in all directions—this is precisely the characteristic of waves!"
"As for what you call rectilinear propagation? That's just because it's blocked from other directions. It's like building a sturdy stone dam around a pool, only to carve a narrow slit in the front; the water flowing out will naturally appear as a straight line!"
As soon as he finished speaking, the bursts of laughter that had been rising and falling in the auditorium came to an abrupt halt.
The wizards in the front row stared wide-eyed, looking up at the ceiling lights and then at the Laser cylinder on the stage.
That makes sense!
Normally, candlelight, electric lights, and even the sun in the sky emit light that naturally spreads in all directions when not obstructed!
Locke was stunned for a moment, then another fatal flaw flashed through his mind. He immediately took another step forward and questioned sharply.
"Even if you explain rectilinear propagation using obstruction, what about the medium?!"
"Water waves spread by relying on water flow as a medium. Sound waves, on the other hand, depend on elements in the air to propagate. So what is the medium for light waves? Even in a vacuum where no elements exist, light can propagate without any obstruction!"
This series of sharp rhetorical questions is incisive and hits the nail on the head.
The wizards below the stage nodded in deep agreement.
Ripples, simply put, rely on the vibration of elements for transmission, while the propagation of light does not require the participation of any elements at all.
"Ignorance!" Baal sneered, his eyes filled with a sense of superiority that looked down on mortals.
"Who says waves necessarily need a specific medium to propagate? Water waves and sound waves need a medium because they are primitive! But the alternating vibrations of electric and Magnetic Fields can sustain themselves and propagate forward in the void, without needing any external aid!"
"Just because you see some Dwarves in the Shadow Divine Realm doesn't mean it's a Dwarves kingdom, does it?" Baal sneered.
"What a convenient excuse to say you don't need any external aids!" Locke was taken aback by this sophistry, then laughed in exasperation.
"Can you give me another example of a ripple that doesn't require a medium? If you can find one, I'll admit defeat right now!"
Baal opened his mouth, but the rebuttal that was about to come out caught in his throat. His face turned pale and then red, and for a moment he couldn't say a word.
Because he couldn't find it!
In our current understanding, apart from the "Electromagnetic Waves " he mentioned, all waves in the world must rely on some kind of physical element to be transmitted!
Seeing Baal's frustration and silence, Locke's pent-up anger vanished. He turned to face the entire audience, opened his arms, and loudly proclaimed.
"I believe that if there are no other races besides Dwarves within the Shadow Divine Realm, then whatever it was before, it is now a Dwarves kingdom!"
Similarly, since all waves in the world require a medium, while light does not, that is sufficient proof that light is definitely not a wave!
"Good!!"
"That was brilliantly said!"
A thunderous cheer erupted from the audience, and the wizards all stood up, applauding Locke's exhilarating debate!
Even Karen couldn't help but applaud. Although Locke's "Broken Electron Theory" also disgusted him, compared to Baal's crazy talk that belittled the glory of the Lord as "thunder ripples," Locke was a million times more pleasing to the eye!