Real Madrid defeated Barcelona 3-1 away from home, putting them one foot in the UEFA Champions League semi-finals.
Interestingly, this match didn't make the front page of major media outlets afterward.
It's not that the match itself wasn't significant enough, but rather that more significant news had arrived.
On the night of the match, FIFA posted a penalty notice on its official website, announcing a 14-month ban on player transfers for Barcelona, which is equivalent to two transfer windows.
The reason for the penalty was that Barcelona violated regulations when signing U18 players.
The news immediately caused a huge uproar.
This is arguably the heaviest fine in history!
In Gao Shen life, Barcelona did indeed receive such a punishment, but through crisis management and continuous appeals, they successfully delayed the execution of the punishment, allowing Barcelona to still make signings during the summer transfer window of 2014.
At the time, Gao Shen didn't have a deep understanding of the specific situation; he only has a partial understanding now.
The so-called violation of regulations can actually be traced back to 2001, when FIFA introduced a series of transfer clauses aimed at protecting underage players, such as Article 19 of the FIFA Regulations on Player Status and Transfers.
According to regulations, players under the age of 18 are not allowed to play abroad.
Upon seeing this, everyone must be wondering, how is this possible?
Leaving aside players like Messi who played before the legislation, just look at recent years: Real Madrid, Barcelona, Atlético Madrid, and Premier League teams like Chelsea, Manchester United, Arsenal, and Leeds United —which of these teams hasn't been poaching players from all over the world?
Especially for a club like Leeds United, haven't they poached a lot of players in recent years?
Let alone those under 18, they're digging up people in their eighties and nineties—isn't that even more outrageous?
However, the fact is that in 2007, FIFA established Transfer Matching System based on these provisions, part of which was specifically to oversee the transfer of players under the age of 18.
What about the signings by teams like Leeds United?
We need to look at the specific terms and conditions; there are three special conditions.
One condition is that the player lives near the border, within 100 kilometers of the club in the neighboring country; another is that the player is 16 years of age or older, and the transfer must be within the European Union; the last condition is that the player's entire family relocates to the country where the club is located for non-football reasons.
It's clear that FIFA has put a lot of thought into this and considered all possible scenarios.
But there's a saying that's very true: where there's a policy, there's a countermeasure.
FIFA has clearly stipulated that clubs have ways to circumvent these rules.
The third option is the most frequently used: the player and their entire family relocate to the country where the club is located for reasons other than football.
What does that mean?
For example, how would it be possible for Mbappé to transfer from France to Leeds United?
Leeds United offered a job directly to Mbappé's family?
No, no, no, that's been explicitly prohibited. It has to be for non-football reasons, and the job can't be directly from Leeds United.
Therefore, Leeds United must first "help" Mbappé's family find jobs in the United Kingdom and have the whole family "move" to live in the United Kingdom so that Mbappé can enter Leeds United's Youth Academy.
Do you understand now?
There are actually many ways to circumvent these clauses, which is why FIFA's clauses have never been strictly enforced.
If strictly enforced, then Real Madrid, Barcelona, and almost all other teams in Europe's top leagues will suffer.
Who hasn't done something like this?
In fact, FIFA's real purpose in setting these clauses has never been to restrict top league teams from poaching Youth Academy, but rather to prevent money laundering and illicit transactions, so they usually turn a blind eye.
You might be wondering, since everyone is doing it, and FIFA follows the policy of "no investigation unless reported," why was Barcelona punished this time, and with such a severe penalty?
The reason is actually quite simple: someone sued Barcelona.
In early 2013, FIFA discovered that Barcelona had violated transfer regulations by 10 Youth Academy players between 2009 and 2013, and suspended six of them, including three South Korea players.
But what is the problem?
More than a year has passed, Barcelona has still not made any thorough rectifications. In fact, someone with ulterior motives seized on this and anonymously reported Barcelona to FIFA, listing in great detail which specific regulations Barcelona had violated.
So, what can FIFA do under these circumstances?
I already punished you a year ago, and gave you a warning. How come you still don't know how to clean up your mess?
In this situation, is it acceptable not to impose severe penalties?
This may seem like a minor issue, but it actually exposes a very, very serious problem.
Even Gao Shen's first reaction upon seeing this news was, "Doesn't Barcelona have any compliance risk management system in place?"
Isn't this a mindset that all normal businesses and organizations should have?
But Gao Shen quickly realized what was going on.
Let alone Barcelona, many football clubs, and even many superstars and famous coaches, lack this awareness.
For example, Chelsea actually managed to get Mourinho to personally sit down with Ashley Cole to discuss the prospects of the Arsenal left-back after he joined Chelsea...
This is absolutely outrageous, isn't it?
Looking at all the things Barcelona has done over the years to poach players, don't these actions tell everyone that Barcelona never follows the rules?
Many people say that Real Madrid likes to poach other teams' star players, but Real Madrid always does things in a very proper and orderly manner.
There are actually many ways to circumvent issues like Youth Academy, not just the three mentioned above, but a whole host of other methods, but Barcelona seems too lazy to use them.
There's a strong sense that FIFA isn't really investigating...
After FIFA investigated further and issued a warning, Barcelona didn't seem to care, since the punishments were mainly for young players...
Gao Shen still clearly remembers that at the time, Barcelona also claimed that there were 15,000 underage players from overseas in Catalonia, who would be non-compliant according to FIFA regulations.
This is somewhat of a challenge to FIFA, isn't it?
It's like riding a motorcycle without a helmet, being pulled over by a traffic cop, and then pointing at other pedestrians around you and saying, "They're all not wearing helmets, why are you arresting me?"
The problem is, the traffic police warned you yesterday, specifically reminding you that there's a crackdown going on recently and you should remember to wear a mask...
The even more outrageous move was that after being punished by FIFA, Barcelona held a press conference to clarify the matter and vaguely indicated that there was a mastermind behind the attack on Barcelona.
Gao Shen was truly impressed by this.
In contrast, Leeds United has a very comprehensive compliance risk management mechanism. Whether it is contacting players or making a series of major decisions such as player transfers, there is an assessment plan to ensure compliance with the laws and regulations of FIFA, UEFA, and the national football association and government of the host country.
The team invests a lot of money in this area every year, and the legal advisory team specifically studies these rules and regulations to advise the club in order to avoid such shady practices.
Barcelona, such a prestigious club, even has a vice president in charge of legal affairs, yet they still managed to make such a huge mess. The key point is that they were all punished, and yet they were so slow to realize what had happened. It's truly unbelievable.
"You know what? Every time I see the moves of these big teams, even one like Manchester United, I feel like it's just not fair that Leeds United isn't successful!"
Back home, Gao Shen found it incredibly funny when he mentioned the incident to Su Qing.
He simply couldn't understand how such a thing could happen in a normal company.
The key point is that Bartomeu issued a statement early this morning saying that they knew FIFA was going to punish them last November, but for the past four months, both Barcelona and the Spain Football Federation have been told that they will not be punished at all.
This is why Barcelona has been slow to act.
It would have been better not to explain; once they started explaining, they really tore away the fig leaf.
In essence, it means: We knew we were going to be punished last November, but we received inside information through certain special channels that this time it's all bark and no bite, and they won't actually carry it out.
That's interesting.
"Ultimately, it's a management problem." Su Qing also felt that this matter was outrageous.
Even setting aside the punishment from early 2013, shouldn't they have tried to make amends and mediate as soon as they knew about the impending punishment in November?
How can they be so carefree, thinking they won't actually be punished?
"They're just too arrogant and don't deserve their positions!" Gao Shen pointed out the problem without any politeness.
"That's right. Coupled with bloated management, overstaffing, a lack of basic analysis and judgment, and blind faith, it has ultimately led to the current situation."
At this point, Su Qing gave a wry smile, "Actually, neither FIFA nor UEFA are particularly formal; there are too many gray areas. This makes the industry too murky, with rampant unspoken rules. Gradually, they've come to disregard the rules altogether, even the most basic compliance."
"So how could Leeds United not succeed? What reason is there for us not to succeed?" Gao Shen was particularly confident.
In terms of management, Leeds United is absolutely unrivaled.
"It's not as exaggerated as you say." Su Qing smiled. "But sometimes I really feel that these clubs, even some of the big clubs, should reform their management mechanisms. After all, these are clubs that handle transactions worth tens of millions, or even hundreds of millions of Euros. How can they be so careless?"
I won't even go into the details of corruption; there are just too many examples of that.
When it comes to risk management, especially the risk management of player transfers, there are definitely no more than five teams in the world that can conduct a thorough assessment.
As explained in [Football Economics], these teams' transfers are all happening in a frenzy.
For example, if a player shines in the World Cup, his market value can immediately increase tenfold.
That's outrageous, isn't it?
If we're talking about pure ability, does a player's skill level suddenly increase dramatically after playing in one World Cup?
The answer is clearly no.
The biggest factor behind the soaring player value is that outstanding performances on the world stage lead to greater player fame, attracting more interested teams. Increased demand naturally drives up player value.
As for how much it will rise or how little, isn't that just a matter of a few words?
This also involves the club's transfer operations.
This is a technique almost every shady shop uses.
Leeds United also has a lot of experience in this area.
Gao Shen had a strong premonition that, given it was World Cup year and Barcelona's potential appeal and subsequent postponement of the execution of the sentence, they would inevitably engage in a frenzy of player recruitment this summer.
Well, it would be best to beat them even harder, make them bleed more this summer!