Brian didn't care whether Dumbledore was embarrassed or not, and continued in a slightly mocking tone:
"To me, whether it's an ordinary person, a wizard, or even Squib... even if it's Voldemort himself, as long as he appears before me, I will treat them all the same."
But the condition is—they don't provoke me first.
Dumbledore still tried to explain for Filch: "Brian, you shouldn't have treated Filch like that. He was just a little anxious because of Mrs. Norris..."
Brian let out an undisguised sneer, his dark eyes devoid of any warmth.
"Are you in a hurry? Because his cat has been petrified, he can act like a mad dog, biting anyone he sees without asking questions?"
Headmaster, if it hadn't been me standing there just now, but any slightly timid junior wizard, he'd probably have pinned the blame on them by now and wouldn't even have a place to cry to, right?
He took half a step forward, his sharp gaze fixed on Dumbledore's Azure eyes, which always seemed tolerant but now held a hint of complexity.
"Why don't you inquire about what our caretaker, Mr. Filch, has been doing in those hidden corners of the corridors, in the empty Trophy Room, and even in those secluded broom sheds?"
"He used his pitiful power to intimidate, insult, and even physically punish all the little wizards who made mistakes—even those who were just 'potentially' wrong or simply didn't like him!"
He twisted and vented his resentment towards his Squib status and his jealousy of magic onto students who were weaker than him!
"Didn't you see? Just now in the corridor, when Mrs. Norris had her accident, did even one junior wizard show the slightest bit of genuine sympathy for Filch's plight? No! Not a single one!"
Brian's voice wasn't loud, but every word was like a nail hardened with ice, striking the silent Office.
"Everyone's just watching the show, even... feeling relieved. Does that mean all the hundreds and thousands of students at Hogwarts are wrong? Are they all a bunch of cold-blooded, heartless, and uncompassionate bad seeds?"
Dumbledore sighed softly and began to narrate slowly.
"Filch... He was born into a wizarding family, but he was born without magic. In the family, he was like an... outcast. His childhood was not happy."
If I hadn't brought him to Hogwarts, given him a job, and provided him with a place to stay... he might have been a wanderer in the Muggle world, or spent his life in repression and suffering. I... am helping him."
"Help him?" Brian almost laughed in anger. He shook his head, his tone full of undisguised sarcasm.
"You brought him to Hogwarts, where he lives amidst magic every day, among thousands of young wizards who possess powers he craves but can never attain... Do you think this is a 'help' for him?"
Every time he saw the young wizards waving their wands, every time he saw Owl deliver a letter—
That was all a reminder to him that he was a defective product, a Squib rejected by the magical world!
"You are not saving him, Headmaster. You are just pulling him from an obvious predicament into another, more hidden, but deeper and more enduring purgatory."
You are using your so-called kindness to slowly, bit by bit, aggravate his suffering and fuel his resentment!
Day after day, he watched others possess everything he dreamed of, while he could only wander like a ghost in the shadows of the castle, gaining a twisted, illusory sense of power and existence by tormenting students who were weaker than him and had temporarily erred!
"Is this what you wanted? To use one person's pain to nourish another's twisted mind, and then tell yourself, 'You've done your best'?"
"Principal, there are too many things in this world that you can't solve, too many people that you can't truly save. You're not a saint, and you can't be one. Why... can't you just admit that?"
Why do you always adopt that compassionate and omnipotent attitude, shouldering all the responsibilities and expectations?
The Office was deathly silent.
Dumbledore fell into a brief silence, his usually wise and peaceful blue eyes appearing unusually deep at that moment.
It was as if Brian's sharp accusations revealed some corners that he had long been unwilling or afraid to face.
After a long silence, Dumbledore spoke, his voice carrying a rare weariness rather than annoyance at being offended.
"Mr. Beaumont, your words... are very direct. Perhaps, in some ways, you are right. But some things must be done, even if I have to let go, I have to wait... for you to grow up a bit more."
Brian understood Dumbledore's meaning: he wanted to eliminate all threats to the Wizarding World, including Voldemort.
However, Brian disagreed.
Who is the Old Bee? That's the White Demon King! The White Demon King isn't a demon king?
Remember— For the Greater Good!
That line came from the Old Bee. Grindelwald was the one who came later.
If it weren't for the fact that every time Dumbledore was about to step into darkness, someone important to him would die, thus serving as a wake-up call!
Now, the entire Wizarding World will be under his and his old flame's rule.
He simply locked himself in this prison called Hogwarts, spending his entire life atoning for his sins!
Later, others will follow! The world won't stop just because anyone is missing.
Cough! Cough!
A voice broke the heavy atmosphere in the room.
At this point, only Professor McGonagall, the vice dean, could say something.
She took a step forward, her gray eyes looking at Brian with a serious expression, a hint of complexity lurking deep within them.
"Mr. Beaumont, watch your words and attitude. When speaking to the headmaster, one must maintain the utmost respect and courtesy."
Brian shut his mouth; he would still listen to what Professor Mao Mao had to say.
I understand that you may have your own opinions, and even... some of your observations may be reasonable.
However, there are many ways to express an opinion; direct, sharp, or even... aggressive accusations are not the most effective, nor are they the most appropriate.
Her gaze swept over Brian, then glanced at the silent Dumbledore, her tone softening slightly.
"Hogwarts is a school, with its own rules and order, and the proper etiquette between teachers and students. Questioning, discussion, and even expressing differing opinions are all permitted, but they must be based on mutual respect. Your remarks just now crossed the line, Mr. Beaumont."
"You're right, Professor McGonagall," Brian said obediently. "I was rude. I apologize to you, and also to the Headmaster for my inappropriate words."
He bowed slightly in Dumbledore's direction, his movements precise and flawless, but in his newly raised black eyes, there was little genuine apology, only a deep, unfathomable calm.
Professor McGonagall stared at him for two seconds, then finally nodded almost imperceptibly.
"It's good that you've realized your mistake. Now, it's getting late." She turned to Dumbledore.
"Albus, regarding the writing on the wall and Mrs. Norris, should we notify the other heads of the house and increase nighttime patrols? Also, should we inform the Ministry of Magic about this?"
Dumbledore seemed to have just been pulled back from some deep thought. He took a deep breath, and that gentle, but now somewhat weary, smile returned to his face.
"No need to alarm the Ministry of Magic for now, Minerva. Increased patrols are necessary, as for that wall and Mrs. Norris..."
He looked at Snape, "Severus, you may need to assist Pomona by closely monitoring the growth of the Mandrake and preparing the other necessary ingredients for the Mandrake Restorative Draught in advance."
Snape nodded expressionlessly, letting out a barely audible snort as a sign of agreement.
Dumbledore's gaze finally settled on Brian, a complex look containing scrutiny, a hint of helplessness, and... perhaps even a faint trace of self-reflection, a result of being touched by those sharp words?
"Well, Mr. Beaumont," Dumbledore's voice returned to its usual gentleness, but was a little lower than usual.
"You can go back now. Thank you for your honest opinion tonight. Although the way you expressed it is debatable, perhaps what I need to hear are precisely these less-than-pleasant words."
He paused slightly, his deep blue eyes, peering through his Half-moon Spectacles, seemed to see into the depths of one's heart.
"Remember, Hogwarts will always be your home, and the professors, including Mr. Filch, are protecting it in their own ways."
Perhaps some of our methods aren't perfect, but... our original intention has never changed. Now, go back and get some rest. Tomorrow is another new day.
Brian listened quietly, his face expressionless. He bowed slightly again.
"Yes, Principal. Good night, professors."
After saying that, he didn't linger. He turned around, opened the door to Lockhart's Office, and his figure quickly disappeared into the dim light of the corridor outside, his footsteps gradually fading away.