"You have always opposed His Majesty's Battle of Luchuan because Battle of Luchuan would be extremely costly with minimal gains. You believe that the annual tax revenue from the southwestern border region is negligible, and in years of famine, a large amount of money and grain would have to be spent, making the annual military expenses for garrisoning the region far exceed the benefits. Is that right?"
Kuang Ye was puzzled as they were discussing the withdrawal, and the topic of the Battle of Luchuan suddenly came up. Nevertheless, he calmly replied, "Your Excellency misunderstands. We have no intention of abandoning Luchuan; we merely wish to win over the hearts of the people, and treat it as a matter of education, so that the border residents may benefit from His Majesty's grace..."
The Duke of England scoffed, "Without martial arts education, how can there be an opportunity for cultural education?"
"Emperor Taizong was so powerful that he commanded respect from all directions, and the people of the land submitted to him. That was because of his power; first came his power, then his submission. He earned it with his sword and spear!" The Duke of England, "During the reign of Emperor Taizong of our This Dynasty, whether in the southwest or the north, even the Japanese pirates at sea dared not land. That was not because Emperor Taizong was virtuous and talented, but because he conquered the south and the north, and his power shook the four directions!"
Kuang Ye frowned. "Governing the four directions with force cannot last. Only through education, making the barbarians understand loyalty, filial piety, benevolence, and righteousness, can they submit without a fight."
"Lord Kuang is also a capable minister in governing the region, and he has accompanied Wang Ji on several expeditions. Does he believe that one can govern with civil administration without authority?"
Kuang Ye paused.
The Duke of England said expressionlessly, "Those sitting here today are not distinguished by military or civil officials. Stripped of these restrictions, I ask you, Lord Kuang, can you govern the surrounding vassal states simply by using culture and education to make them submit?"
Kuang Ye said with difficulty, "Of course not, it's just that the Battle of Luchuan was extremely costly. Due to the ever-increasing military taxes, the people are living in poverty. This time, Deng Maoqi a rebellion..."
"Don't blame Deng Maoqi's rebellion on military taxes," the Duke of England said in a deep voice. "If it weren't for the excessive exploitation by local officials, who were constantly extorting money, the military taxes collected from the military and civilians across the country would have been more than enough to support ten Battle of Luchuan."
Kuang Ye rubbed his forehead and said, "What you say makes sense. The government has been far less efficient in recent years than before. The Imperial Court needs to rectify official conduct and public morals, but Duke, is this the time to discuss this? The most urgent task is to escort His Majesty back to the capital..."
"I have no time," the Duke of England interrupted him again, his voice deep and serious. "I want you to know why I support His Majesty in the Battle of Luchuan."
Perhaps it was the Duke of England's resolute decision and grief that calmed Kuang Ye down, and he began to listen attentively.
The Duke of England was comforted, realizing that his selection of him from among a group of civil and military officials had not been in vain.
Aside from Jing Yuan, perhaps only Kuang Ye remains as a glimmer of hope.
Duke of England: "After the Jingnan Campaign, Emperor Taizong moved the capital to Beijing. As the saying goes, 'taking control of the capital from a higher position,' so Emperor Taizong strengthened the defenses of the north and launched five expeditions to the Mobei during his reign."
Seeing Kuang Ye frown, the Duke of England twitched the corner of his mouth and said, "I know you will say that Emperor Taizong was too aggressive and warlike, which led to an empty treasury and that he was not as benevolent and kind as the two late Emperor Renzong and Xuande. However, Renzong and Xuande were able to govern the country peacefully because they relied on the remaining prestige of Emperor Taizong."
Now, its remaining power is waning, so the southwest and northwest are in chaos. Even a small vassal state across the sea dares to send its soldiers and civilians to invade, and has repeatedly landed to massacre the people of our Ming Dynasty."
"Perhaps to you, the Oirats invasion of the south was sudden, but to me, it was the culmination of over a decade of accumulated strength, a transformation that was finally about to take place."
The Duke of England stood up and put down the map that was hanging there. It was covered with many circles and arrows. Kuang Ye stepped forward to look at it and was shocked.
The document listed the locations of various Wei Suo, especially the northeast, northwest, and southwest regions, and was covered with illegible markings. If it weren't for the Duke of England's explanation, he would have almost gotten dizzy from looking at it.
The Duke of England pointed to the north and said, "Since Renzong neglected his strategic ambitions, Toghon of the Oirats gradually unified the various Mongol tribes; in the south, Le Loi of Jiaozhi began to attack and seize territory; in the southwest, Luchuan made several probing moves; and in the northeast, the Nurgan army's discipline deteriorated... However, in the preceding decade or so, the Imperial Court gradually abandoned Jiaozhi, either ignoring Luchuan's probing attempts or appeasing them with money, even allowing Jianzhou to govern itself..."
The Duke of England scoffed. "In the past ten years or so, Jianzhou and Toghon and Arutai have had frequent exchanges, but the Imperial Court turned a blind eye and tried to win them over with money. The Oirats, Jianzhou and Japanese people were greedy every time they paid tribute and asked for rewards without restraint. But the Imperial Court not only did not punish them, but also kept backing down and used generous rewards to quell the conflicts."
It was precisely because of these repeated tests and concessions that their ambitions were nurtured and their courage increased, which led them to Si Jifa rebellion and ultimately to the southward advance of the Oirats.
Duke of England: "You blame His Majesty for launching the Battle of Luchuan, but I see hope in it. His Majesty is finally not like his grandfather and father, passively defending himself, but..."
He paused for a moment, then said, "He was too hasty, and he blindly trusted Wang Zhen."
Kuang Ye finally remembered that although the Duke of England had always supported the emperor in launching the Battle of Luchuan, he had also always opposed Wang Zhen's involvement in military and national affairs.
Kuang Ye's eyes flickered slightly; he thought of Wang Ji.
Wang Ji's military campaigns were not without their challenges; he was imprisoned and nearly executed.
At the time, Wang Zhen's attitude was ambiguous. Later, the Duke of England intervened, and Wang Zhen asked the emperor to release Wang Ji and let him go to Luchuan to atone for his crimes.
They always believed that Wang Ji's inability to capture Luchuan after a long siege was due to Wang Zhen's instigation.
But did Wang Ji truly listen to Wang Zhen, or was he forced to listen and only made changes within his own power?
The Duke of England briefly touched upon the Battle of Luchuan and then began to discuss the recent southward Oirats.
"Frontline defense should be as ever-present as the people's livelihood, not something to be neglected when peace is achieved, lest one become complacent and assume the world is at peace. You are scholars; I need not elaborate on the idiom 'to be vigilant in times of peace.' This southward Oirats, though seemingly sudden, was in fact premeditated. And of all the officials in the court, only the Left Vice Minister of War, Yu Qian, could foresee this," the Duke of England said in a deep voice. "You are delusional to think that sending just one border general will stop the enemy outside Datong. Such underestimation of the enemy will lead you one day to lose everything, just like Guo Deng."
Kuang Ye was shocked, unable to believe it, yet unable to disbelieve it.
This is the Duke of England, who sensed Datong amiss in Datong as soon as he arrived and was tasked with investigating Datong actual military situation there. With such keen insight, could his words be mere alarmism?
The Duke of England, "I am over seventy years old. I retired during the reign of Xuanzong. What is there left for me to risk my reputation for?"
Kuang Ye then noticed that the Duke of England's lips were somewhat pale, and remembering that he had taken sick leave the day before, her eyes reddened. "Your Excellency..."
The Duke of England gently patted his hand and said, "You civil officials have integrity. Although Wang Zhen has served His Majesty for many years and is cunning, he is not very bright, especially when it comes to warfare. You can tell from his repeated commands and arrangements. I strongly advocate that you stay because I want you to be able to resist Wang Zhen's orders."
When a general is in the field, he may disobey the emperor's orders. As long as you can win the battle, everything else is not a problem.
Once Wang Zhen leaves, he can't possibly come back to settle accounts with you, so just listen to his orders and act accordingly, prioritizing the interests of the Ming Dynasty.