Morris sighed.
"When we, who are digging into history, have exhausted all our efforts to come to the high wall of the Great Annihilation, and spend our whole lives searching for artifacts and comparing ancient books in order to glimpse the scenery on the other side of that high wall, what we are faced with is such bizarre and wonderful things."
The old man's face was filled with exhaustion and frustration, like a traveler who had traversed most of his life and still could not see the end of his journey, and had to accept reality.
"The history before the Great Annihilation was fragmented and contradictory. The records of different city-states were like bizarre stories or unrelated dreams... There was no conclusive evidence to prove which record was correct, or a theory to integrate these contradictory things."
Duncan remained silent for a moment, as his thoughts surged like waves. In the incredible "fragments of unofficial history" described by Morris, he felt as if he were undergoing a baptism of information storm.
As a "foreigner" who had experienced the information age and possessed a good ability to make connections, he was able to imagine or guess some things from the other person's description—
The dome covering the entire continent could be some kind of man-made ecological device, or an energy system originating from the same source as the sun, relying on substances in the seawater as fuel—that could be fusion technology.
A colossal ship sailing through nothingness, powered by capturing dust and gas clouds in space, could be one or more colony starships.
As for the so-called dream of the demon god... the seawater that came to reality from the dream... he couldn't imagine what this was for a while, but it sounded like a fantasy concept, something completely different from the technological atmosphere and style of the previous two historical periods.
He could find explanations or conjectures for many things, but these things could never be pieced together.
As Morris said, they are more like separate dreams, outlining completely different "prehistoric histories".
Contradictory and fragmented, it is completely unusable to recreate the world before the Great Annihilation.
"Perhaps you are right. There is a 'Horizon Limit' in the key event of the Great Annihilation," Morris's voice came from across the counter, interrupting Duncan's thoughts. The old man rubbed his forehead and said in a low voice, "We cannot observe the 'events' on the other side of the horizon. Therefore, the history before the Great Annihilation is a concept that can never be traced back to us."
Looking at the deeply moved Morris, Duncan's thoughts continued, and gradually, a rather bold idea popped into his head. "What if... all these records are true?"
Morris looked up at Duncan with some surprise. "Oh?"
"If these records are all true, and the history recorded by each city-state or race truly reflects their understanding of the 'world before the Great Annihilation '?" Duncan stroked his chin thoughtfully. "Perhaps our ancestors ten thousand years ago really came from completely different 'homelands,' with entirely different civilizations? The Great Annihilation trapped these exiles from different worlds on this ocean, and their descendants, before their civilizations were completely severed, managed to record what they knew. Ten thousand years later, this has become the 'contradictory history' that perplexes scholars..."
His mind started racing, and after a pause, he continued, "Perhaps the essence of the Great Annihilation isn't the end of the world, but rather a 'great teleportation'?"
Morris looked at Duncan in surprise and suddenly said, "... The Block Bendis School's conjecture? The theory of World Drifting Theory? That's a relatively obscure school of thought. Did you have such a deep understanding of ancient history?"
His words of praise momentarily stunned Duncan: It seemed someone had already considered this possibility?!
He blinked, not letting his surprise show, and simply continued the conversation, "It's all just bits and pieces of knowledge, but I really like this hypothesis."
"I also like this hypothesis—although it's obscure," Morris shook his head, "But like all other hypotheses, we have no evidence, so it remains just a hypothesis."
"The Clark School once hypothesized that the interference of the Subspace with the Real World distorted all historical records, the Velentium School believed that the world before the Great Annihilation consisted of countless isolated lattices, and the people of Bologna City-State even believed that the world before the Great Annihilation did not exist at all, and that all records of prehistory were illusions created by shadows in the Subspace..."
"To be frank, even some heretical cults have their own understanding of world history. The Endtime Evangelists who worship the Subspace firmly believe that the end of the world has already begun and is chasing and devouring our civilization along the river of history. The historical records of conflicts between city-states are the result of real history being gradually torn apart by the Subspace. The Great Annihilation is a barrier that stands in the way of the end times. When history after the Great Annihilation is also gradually contaminated and torn apart, that will be the day when the whole world falls into the Subspace..."
Duncan grew increasingly astonished as he listened, and after a long while, he subconsciously shook his head. "I had no idea there were so many strange and unusual hypotheses..."
"Ordinary people wouldn't venture into this field; studying history, after all, is a dangerous thing in a mystical sense," Morris said. "But one thing is obvious: if thousands of scholars have spent hundreds or even thousands of years groping in a field where there seems to be no way out, then they must have put forward every possible hypothesis."
Duncan gradually understood what the old man meant.
For those who have truly spent their entire lives immersed in classic texts and artifacts, proposing a hypothesis that can explain the current situation is quite simple. As scholars, what they lack is never imagination or vision.
What they lack is evidence, evidence that can prove even any one of their hypotheses.
"... Isn't there any evidence left behind?" Duncan asked. "Is there not a single piece of 'material evidence' from pre -Great Annihilation history that can prove the claims in certain 'unofficial histories' to be true?"
"Nothing has been found so far," Morris said slowly. "Ten thousand years, plus one Dark Age after another, countless city-states rose and fell in the Boundless Sea, it's too difficult for anything from ancient times to have survived... What has been passed down are either unreliable manuscripts or oral stories, and these things themselves may have changed in the process of being passed down."
Duncan remained silent for a moment.
Deep in his spirit, on the distant Lost Homeland, the waves gently rise and fall, the boundless sea as always, covering the entire world.
It also covers all possible truths.
He couldn't help but sigh, "Studying ancient history is truly an extremely difficult task."
"Yes, we are facing not only fragmented 'years', but also a current state of emptiness and despair," Morris sighed. "If there were anything to be found in such a limited land as a city-state, it would have been found long ago. If nothing can be found, it means that the things that can prove our history are hidden in places that mortals cannot reach."
"Like the seabed?" Duncan suddenly said.
"The seabed? Ha, what a terrifying and audacious idea," Morris laughed. "But it's really the only remaining thought for many historians who have reached the end of their rope... There's evidence on the seabed, mountains of artifacts, ancient cities, ruins that can explain everything, but what's the use? When we dive down, we can only touch the shadows; mortals can't reach the deepest part of this world."
He paused for a moment before continuing, "However, this has indeed given rise to another conjecture... Although it has not become a school of thought, many people speculate that the lost 'Old World' in history is actually below the surface of the Boundless Sea, or even precisely located at a certain 'depth' between the Abyssal Deep Sea and the Spirit World —the world before the Great Annihilation was sleeping at that depth."
"Why do you say that?" Duncan curiously, intrigued by the seemingly plausible yet unsubstantiated hypothesis.
Morris thought for a moment and explained, "Because many fragmented ancient histories mention that the world before the Great Annihilation was covered by a 'Starry Sky,' and as we all know, the 'Starry Sky' is located at the boundary between the Abyssal Deep Sea and the Spirit World."
Duncan nearly choked on his own saliva. "Cough cough... Ah?"
"Are you alright?" Morris was startled by Duncan's reaction. "This shouldn't be so unbelievable..."
"I'm fine, I just got so engrossed in listening that I choked a little," Duncan quickly waved his hand. "The Starry Sky is between the Abyssal Deep Sea and the Spirit World, of course I know, of course I know..."