In the Defence Against the Dark Arts classroom, the young wizards all stopped writing with their quills. They looked at Professor Breen by the window for a while, and then at Professor Moody on the podium, who had just told them some amazing things. They were filled with doubt.
What exactly happened?
Professor Moody had just personally demonstrated the Three Unforgivable Curses to them, making them understand why these spells were strictly forbidden, but in the blink of an eye, Professor Breen offered a different perspective.
Professor Breen was unhappy with Professor Moody, so he was undermining him?
Harry couldn't help but think this, but then he quickly dismissed the idea. Given Professor Breen's current standing in the Wizarding World, he wouldn't need to demonstrate his authority in such a clumsy way. Yet, he actually said that these three infamous Dark Magic weren't as terrifying as people imagined, and that they could be resisted!
These young wizards weren't newcomers to the magical world; many came from wizarding families. Ron, for example, had heard some basic magical knowledge from his father, Mr. Weasley. And among those passed-down experiences, the Cruciatus Curse, the Cruciatus Curse, and the Avada Kedavra were definitely terrifying spells.
Moody stood on the podium staring at Amosta. He wasn't angry or embarrassed at being refuted in front of a group of young wizards. On the contrary, his normal eye held a strange, incomprehensible look.
"Why don't you come up and share your insights, Professor Breen?"
Moody said.
How strange!
Harry felt a sense of confusion. When he heard what Professor Moody said to Professor Breen —not because the content was strange, but because of the voice—even though Professor Moody's voice was still that hoarse, deep voice, Harry could detect a hint of gentleness in it.
He wasn't the only one who seemed taken aback; many people, including Professor Breen, cast astonished glances at Professor Moody. Moody, clearly realizing his mistake, quickly cleared his throat and shouted gruffly,
"I and these little guys are waiting for your brilliant insights, Amosta. I'd like to see what novel ideas you can come up with. Oh, of course, even if a wizard casts Unforgivable Curse on you, they can't do anything to you. You can't be hit so easily. But these little guys don't have your abilities, Amosta. They still need to be on guard at all times!"
"It's only natural to remain vigilant."
Professor Breen stood up from his stool, met the young wizards' gazes, and smiled slightly.
"But I don't want to see you over-mystify a certain magic, as that will only deepen your inner fears."
Professor Breen didn't rush up to the podium to take Professor Moody's seat. Instead, he paced back and forth between the two rows of seats, hands behind his back, seemingly pondering how to make the young wizards understand. Finally, he stopped beside Harry's seat.
"Leaving aside the effects of a Charms, I prefer to trace the roots of magic. The Cruciatus Curse, the Cruciatus Curse, and the Avada Kedavra —these are known as the Three Unforgivable Curses. First, you need to understand the nature of these three Charms. Or rather, how exactly do they work?"
Professor Breen spoke calmly, completely unlike the solemnity and intimidation Professor Moody displayed when discussing the three spells. He scanned the young faces around him, seemingly anticipating something.
How could anyone possibly know?
Harry knew from the bulge between Professor Moody's eyebrows how difficult Professor Breen's question was, and he thought to himself.
In class, a professor's question is like throwing a stone at a proud rooster—a complete provocation that demands a response. That's how it was for Hermione, but even she fell silent on Professor Breen's question, eagerly awaiting the answer.
Harry desperately wanted to stand up and grab Professor Breen by the neck, demanding the answer. His parents had died from the Avada Kedavra; if there were any way to resist it, perhaps knowing that would bring them some comfort.
Perhaps finally realizing that his group of fourth-year wizards, plus a retired Auror, couldn't answer his question, Professor Breen let out a slightly disappointed sigh and said unhurriedly,
"The Three Unforgivable Curses, in terms of classification, can all be defined as mental magic. They target the mind or soul of a being, or something like that."
Faced with a multitude of bewildered faces, Professor Breen began pacing back and forth with his hands behind his back.
"The following views are my personal opinions and may not be entirely correct. After all, researching and discussing these three types of magic is illegal. However, they are generally close to being correct. We all know that the body and the soul make up life, and there is an extremely mysterious and complex connection between the body and the soul. Throughout history, whether Muggle or wizards, once we realized the existence of the soul, we have been studying the connection between the two. But unfortunately, no one has been able to see through this connection so far."
Professor Breen strolled back to where he had just been listening to the lecture, standing in a ray of sunlight that shone through the curtains, the brilliant sunlight turning his soft gray hair golden.
"The soul gives life to the body; it is the source of thought and spiritual power. The three unforgivable spells, though simple to cast, possess an irresistible and incurable effect precisely because they do not attack the physical body—"
Moody was probably the only one in the classroom who could barely understand what Amosta was saying; the rest of the young wizards looked completely bewildered. Professor Breen clearly noticed this, paused, and changed his approach.
"Let's talk about the Cruciatus Curse first—"
Amosta glanced at Draco, whose expression was rather unnatural. This unfortunate young man had personally experienced the feeling of being under the Cruciatus Curse; he had been controlled by Peter for several months using the Cruciatus Curse.
"The Cruciatus Curse —the caster uses magic as a medium to overwrite the mind of the cursed with their own will. Did you notice, everyone? There are two key points here: magic and mind—"
Professor Breen said in an obvious tone,
"The Cruciatus Curse is the least harmful of the Three Unforgivable Curses because it affects only the most superficial level of the mind—the transition from thought to heart to soul. From the two key points I just mentioned, you can deduce two things: first, using the Cruciatus Curse to control a being with greater magical power than yourself carries risks; second, using this spell to control a being with a stronger will than yourself also carries risks—if you do so, even without the cursed being using any magic to resist your control, they might still break free—"
This time, most people started to understand.
Draco pursed his lips, looking rather displeased.
According to Professor Breen, his magic and intellect were utterly defeated by that despicable Peter.
"Also, regarding the Cruciatus Curse, I'd like to add something—"
Amosta said calmly.
"On some level, it's actually quite easy to spot a wizard under the Cruciatus Curse —if you use the Cruciatus Curse on someone, it means your mind and magic are entering that person's body, and a wizard with keen perception can easily see through that."
"Professor Breen!"
As soon as Amosta finished speaking, Hannah Abbott immediately raised her hand.
If I understand correctly--
Hannah asked curiously, "Is there some kind of magic that can help people resist the control of the Cruciatus Curse?"
"That's true--"
Professor Breen smiled and nodded.
"There is an ancient magical technique that can effectively resist all mind control spells. Of course, it requires a certain talent to learn, which we'll discuss later. Now, let's talk about the Cruciatus Curse— "
Upon hearing this magic, Neville, whose expression had finally calmed down, turned deathly pale again.
A tribute to the greatest wizard of our time: Principal Michael Gambon!