"It's not difficult at all," Sherlock Holmes said. "To be honest, when I heard Gregson's words, I thought I had encountered some rare and extraordinary case, at least the kind that happened on Allen Island in 1832. But when I went to the scene, I found that it was nothing special. Let's start with John's Textile Factory."
Sherlock Holmes paused for a moment, then said, "Do you remember what we talked about this afternoon?"
Are you referring to the impact of professional skills on hand shape?
"Yes, I've been doing research on this lately, interviewing many people from all walks of life in London, including bricklayers, fishermen, cooks, typists, and so on... I go out every morning before dawn and stay in the slums until sunset, spending a lot of time studying their hand shapes, comparing them with each other and with others in the same trade. The results are remarkable, and I'm planning to compile them into a paper," Sherlock Holmes said. "Just now by the river, I focused on examining the child's palms, comparing them with my findings. Although her body had been in the water for quite some time, there is no doubt that she worked in a textile factory, so your previous observations are correct. The long hours of work had weakened her body, and she was likely ill at the time of the incident."
"But there are many textile factories all over London, so how can you be so sure that she was in that John's Textile Factory?"
"Good question," Sherlock Holmes said. "I tend to think that the place where the body was dumped and the place where it was found were very close. This is also easy to explain. The body was found during the day. Although there was some fog on the river, the visibility was actually quite good. In addition, there were cruise ships or cargo ships passing by from time to time. If there was a body on the river, it would be difficult for it to drift too far away without being discovered."
"Wait, but you said before that her body had been in the water for quite some time."
"That's right," Sherlock Holmes smiled slyly, "But please watch my words. I said her body had been in the water for quite some time, not that it had been floating for quite some time."
What's the difference between the two?
"Of course, judging from the state of the body, the victim should have died last night. The perpetrator accidentally killed her and then panicked. He threw the body into the river and probably tied some stones to it so that it wouldn't be discovered. People would just think the child was missing. Every day, people who can't make a living come and go in this city, especially for people from the lower class like her. Not many people care where she went. You know, the police have completely different attitudes towards missing persons and murder."
"Then why was her body discovered by the patrol officers?"
"There are many possibilities. Perhaps the perpetrator was too nervous and didn't tie the rope securely, or perhaps something happened that broke the rope..." Sherlock Holmes said. "I'm not just guessing. Besides the timing issue I mentioned, I did find traces of rope binding on the victim's wrists. This explains why her body was in the water for a long time, but she hadn't actually been out of the water for very long before she was found."
"John's Textile Factory is the closest textile mill upstream, and it was the first place I suspected. In addition, I found some blue crystals in her hair, which are copper sulfate pentahydrate formed when copper sulfate comes into contact with water. Coincidentally, there is a chemical plant right next to John's Textile Factory, which is the most important basis for my final deduction," Sherlock Holmes said.
"Seeing is believing. This has elevated criminal investigation to a level that is almost like a precise science," Zhang Heng exclaimed sincerely.
Sherlock Holmes didn't say anything when he heard the praise, but he looked quite pleased. He paused and continued, "As for the deductions about the perpetrator, frankly, they're nothing special."
"I would like to hear the details."
"We all know that the perpetrator wanted to take advantage of the victim, but the child resisted fiercely. She was very brave and kept fighting with him, but the difference in strength between the two was too obvious, so she ultimately could not escape. However, the guy didn't get to enjoy himself for long either, as the victim scratched his skin. Although the body had been soaking in water for a long time, some skin tissue still remained under his fingernails. This was probably the reason why he was so angry and strangled her to death in a fit of rage."
"Wait... you're saying this child was strangled to death?"
"That's right," Sherlock Holmes said with certainty.
"But wasn't her head hit hard?" Zhang Heng asked.
"As I said, there was a struggle between the two. Judging from the marks on the wounds, I tend to think that her head hit the table, but it wasn't fatal. What really killed her was suffocation, not suffocation in the water, but being choked. There were bruises on her neck, but they were not very noticeable after being soaked in water. Most people probably wouldn't have noticed them. As for the fact that they knew each other, that's normal. At that time, it was already dark. It would be almost impossible for a man and a woman who didn't know each other to be in the same room."
"What about his height? You said he's about six feet tall, how did you come to that conclusion?" Zhang Heng asked.
"Well, that takes a bit of skill," Sherlock Holmes said. "I simulated their positions at the time, well, with the woman below and the man above, and then compared them with the bruises on the neck to determine the direction and angle of the hand, and thus calculated that the assailant's approximate height was about the same as mine."
Sherlock Holmes spoke eloquently and finally clarified all his previous deductions before the food was served.
Many things in this world are like this: when you first hear the conclusion, it seems magical and unbelievable, but once you know the reasoning process, it doesn't seem so mysterious anymore, just like Magician's magic trick.
"Forward reasoning is easy. For example, you can tell it's breakfast just by seeing bread. But the reverse is not the case. This is a skill that detectives need to develop. If you want to learn, you can start by guessing professions. You can guess a person's profession from their sleeves, shoes, calluses on their index and thumb fingers, fingernails, shirt, expression, etc. For example, the gentleman at the table behind you, I can tell just by observing him that he has just returned from Afghanistan and is a military doctor."
Upon hearing this, Zhang Heng showed a strange expression for the first time tonight, thinking to himself, "Could it be such a coincidence?"
Sherlock Holmes, thinking Zhang Heng didn't believe him, said again, "We can make a bet to see who can tell us more about him accurately. Don't worry, I've never met him before."