Ch. 285What Kind of Enemy Am I Really Facing?
Kariman questioned Dumbledore over the dangers of protecting the Philosopher's Stone at Hogwarts and accused him of knowingly endangering students. Unable to explain his motives without revealing the prophecy, Dumbledore suspected that Murphy had orchestrated events through Lucas Brightson and the diary, but remained unsure what kind of opponent he faced.
- Kariman asked whether the Philosopher's Stone belonged to Hogwarts or its students, then challenged Dumbledore for placing dangerous traps in the school and exposing students to harm.
- Murphy confirmed that he had warned McGonagall about the risks, and McGonagall admitted that she had passed his concerns to Dumbledore.
- Kariman asked whether Dumbledore had known Voldemort was after the Stone and had brought it to Hogwarts anyway, leaving Dumbledore unable to answer without revealing the prophecy.
- Dumbledore recalled that he had used the Mirror of Erised to monitor Harry and intervene if the situation became dangerous, but Lucas's appearance had signaled an unexpected problem.
- Dumbledore connected Lucas Brightson to the diary Quirrell had mentioned and wondered whether Lucas was under Murphy Darkholme's control, concluding that Murphy might have planned the events before the school year began.