The next day, Ming Yue came to her elder brother's courtyard, made him a cup of tea, and asked him a question;
"Brother, I would like to ask you what the difference is between giving with form and giving without form."
The elder brother thought for a moment and slowly said, "The concept of 'giving alms in the presence of form' means that I do good deeds because they have merit and benefits. Because they have benefits, I believe that doing them will bring me Karmic Blessings."
Offering things like burning incense, worshipping Buddha or other deities, or making offerings to monks, thinking it's for one's own good, completely deviates from the essence of giving.
It's more like a business transaction involving an exchange of benefits. I offer incense to Buddha, and Buddha blesses me; I offer incense to gods, and gods bless me; I make offerings to monks and I'll Karmic Blessings —this way of doing good deeds brings more merit, that way brings less. This is all just being obsessed with outward appearances.
For example, you see an old lady selling vegetables and feel sorry for her, so you buy all her vegetables.
If you think you are doing a good deed and accumulating merit, then that is giving alms with form.
The concept of formless giving refers to giving spontaneously, without attachment to the act. It's done without thinking about any Karmic Blessings, good deeds, or merits. It's pure, without any motive, or you could call it instinct.
You see someone virtuous and want to help them, but you don't expect anything in return—no Karmic Blessings, no merits, no expectation of reciprocation. You're completely selfless, simply wanting to do this from the bottom of your heart.
It's like when you see an old man pushing a garbage cart uphill, you don't think about anything, you just go over and help push the cart, and once you've done it, you're done, without feeling anything about whether it's good or bad, and you don't even have any attachment to the fact that you're doing a good deed.
Or, if you're going to throw away trash and see an older woman picking up bottles, and there are bottles in your trash, you can walk over and politely say, "Auntie, I have some bottles here. I'll put them here for you. Please be careful when you pick them up, the trash is a bit dirty."
Seeing that it was raining, I instinctively went over to help the aunt who was loading the bottles she had collected onto her car. Once I finished helping, that was it; I didn't have any other thoughts.
You go to a dumpling restaurant and see the owner eating. After you order, she puts down her bowl to cook for you first. You say, "Auntie, please finish your meal first. It's alright, you eat first." You do this instinctively, without expecting anything in return. This is selfless giving.
Without ulterior motives, I instinctively strive to be the best version of myself. I am not attached to any particular aspect.
After your aunt makes dumplings for you, if you ask for a couple of cloves of garlic, she'll let you pick out the best ones and take as many as you like. She might even ask if you want some of the side dishes she made at home. You're very grateful, and later you'll find that out of the room full of people eating, you were the only one who added that dish for yourself. This is a manifestation of your Karmic Blessings. However, don't be attached to this event, but rather learn from it what true Karmic Blessings is.
Of course, these are not absolute. What we practitioners do is to transform our goodness into instinct and do what we are good for without expecting anything in return.
If you meet someone as good as you, she will instinctively treat you well too. If you meet someone bad or unpleasant, and because you are good to her, she treats you well but then tries to take advantage of you, you should distance yourself immediately and stop bothering her. Life is long, and when you meet again, I will still be myself, and what happens to you won't affect me.
"Brother, do you really think it's possible to live the way you describe?"
"Yes, you can. Just turn your good qualities into instinct, and what you do will be a form of selfless giving. It's just that because sentient beings encounter so much evil and don't understand it, it's difficult."
The dilemma stems from being too kind to others, knowing that their kindness is not a given, and fearing that one might do something inappropriate and disappoint them.
But they forgot the essence: the essence is that others treat us well because we are good enough, not because we are bad enough that others still have the nerve to treat us well.
All we can do is focus on being the best version of ourselves, and not get bogged down in other things. That way, we won't be bound by such relationships.
"Brother, but... but what if you can't control yourself? Even after knowing this principle, you'll still unconsciously feel that if others are nice to you, you should do this or that, and you won't dare to express your unwillingness. What will happen then?"
"Then they'll be controlled. Just like many parents who don't respect their children, they use their kindness to bind their children, saying that the children talk back and are disobedient. In their eyes, this is called rebellion. But being disobedient is just expressing one's own opinion, and it doesn't mean that one is rebellious."
There are no rebellious or unrebellious children, only parents who impose their own will on their children, because a child is also a living individual.
Looking at it from another angle, do we want to be controlled? This person tells me this is good, and I have to obey; that person tells me that is good, and I have to obey. Listening to all this, we forget who we are. We lose Ego.
What about years later? Even if you want to do something, you'll be at a loss, not knowing what you like, and you'll be numb.
In the average person's life, they listen to their parents when they are young, and their bosses when they are at work. And in their personal life? "Oh, you're so grown up now, you should settle down, you should have children, you should buy a house, you should buy a car, you should do this and that." Whether it's something important or not, because they have good relationships with their friends, they listen to them.
Years later, my children grew up, and I had to listen to them. If I didn't, they wouldn't be happy. I never truly lived for myself. Looking back on my life before I passed, I couldn't help but sigh, "What a tiring life! So exhausting, both physically and mentally." So many things I wanted to do were left undone. I could only regretfully deceive myself by saying, "Maybe next life. I won't live like this next life."
Why am I so tired? I've never listened to myself, I've just been going with the flow. How can my heart not be tired?
"Brother, so tell me, how can we live without feeling tired?"
"Allow yourself to be yourself, and allow others to be others, including your own children. If you want to live a clear life, then treat your children as individual beings and respect and understand them, because they are also friends who will accompany us for a while in this world."
Don't impose your personal will on your child just because you are someone else's parent. Be tolerant and guide them, allowing them to grow into independent individuals, rather than submissive puppets.
Love is never about demanding things of others; it's about how you should respect others.
As parents, all you need to do is teach your children how to be good people; you don't need to worry about anything else. And the best way to teach children how to be good people is to be good people yourself, unaffected by others or things.
Whether a child is sensible or not has nothing to do with whether they are obedient or not. It's not about telling them how difficult things are for you or forcing them to do this or that. That's not love, that's resentment.
His appreciation for your kindness towards him is a prerequisite for a child to be sensible.
One must have an independent personality and learn to think independently. This is what we should cultivate in our children, rather than telling them how to live by our own failures.
People who are always worried about their children's academic performance and fear that their children will lose at the starting line should take a look down at themselves. They are the starting line for their children; their children were already at a disadvantage from the moment they were born. Other people's children are born into wealth, while our children are born into our demands and expectations.
Have some self-respect and calm down. Instead of worrying about how your child might not amount to anything, why not give yourself a better start so that you can provide support in every way possible when your child needs it in the future?
Parents who fear their children won't amount to anything are actually the ones who lack success themselves and don't want their children to follow in their footsteps. Everyone's circumstances are different, and your experiences can't completely guide someone else's life. No matter how much you worry, you can't stop them from experiencing what they're meant to go through. Just be yourself, and while you're alive, be your child's safe haven. That's what being a parent should be like.