Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
The Unconventional Path to Immortality
Chapter 669

Shattering Mental Consciousness Projections

3,582 words 12 min read 0 views 2mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

"Master, I have a question, but I feel that you have other answers. I would like to ask you to enlighten me."

"Okay, then tell me."

"Master, the Sixth Patriarch once said that when the wind moves, the banner moves, the benevolent heart is moved moves. That was already incredibly awesome. Do you have any other answers?"

"Have."

"Hehehe, I knew it! Master, please tell me!"

"OK."

"Thank you, Master."

"Polite.

In fact, the wind moves the flag, and the benevolent heart is moved. At that moment, the wind moves, the flag moves, the benevolent heart is moved, and at the same time, nothing moves. This is how it should be.

The wind is a movement governed by natural laws, the banner is a movement governed by natural laws, and the benevolent heart is moved is also a movement governed by natural laws.

When the wind rises, ripples begin to spread, and the banner flutters in the breeze. The benevolent follow the wind and the banner, and thoughts arise in their hearts.

If the wind and the banner remain still, the benevolent heart is moved, then regardless of whether the wind and the banner move or not, the heart of the benevolent is moved.

If the heart of a benevolent person remains unmoved, it does not mean that the wind and flag are truly still.

For example, we know that the ball is always rotating, but we can't perceive it or feel it. Does that mean the ball is really not moving?

From the perspective of phenomena, or rather, in essence, it is moving, but we are unaware of it because the benevolent mind remains unmoved. This does not mean that what should be moving has stopped.

When you have a thought or intention, it is the benevolent heart is moved. When you do not have a thought or intention, it does not mean that all things are still; it only means that they are still from the perspective of your consciousness.

The Heavenly Dao does not change according to individual will. The rhythms of nature, and even the stillness of the Human Heart, are all applications of the Way.

Master Huineng, whom my master sometimes playfully calls "Old Six," is just using this as a way to refer to the use of emptiness.

It doesn't mean that if your heart doesn't move, nothing will truly move you.

He meant that if your mind remains unmoved regardless of external circumstances, you won't be swayed by them and act erratically.

Many people only know one aspect and not the other. Even if someone is present and someone is not, the sun still rises in the east and sets in the west, and the ball still spins in circles.

But what about from an individual perspective? When the individual disappears, everything in this world ceases to exist from that individual's point of view. It is often said that everything exists because of me, or that everything exists when I am here, and disappears when I am gone.

Has it really disappeared? Hehe, it's disappeared from an individual perspective, but not from a universal perspective.

The metaphor of the wind moving the flag is meant to illustrate how one's mind is influenced and moved by external things.

All things are one, but this unity doesn't mean "I am you" or "you are me." From the perspective of the laws of nature, there is no difference whatsoever. The fundamental qualities are exactly the same.

If there were truly no difference, why would they say things like "the superior man hears the Way, the average man hears the Way, the inferior man hears the Way," or "the Supreme Spiritual Capacity, the Higher Spiritual Capacity, Lower Spiritual Capacity"?

True Suchness believe in the way people do nowadays, if you see everything as yourself, as a projection of your own mind, then why do you say that someone powerful is your projection, but not someone foolish? You say that someone powerful is also you, and you are them. Why don't you say that to someone foolish? Hehehe.

If I see everything as my projection, as if everything is me, could I send the Old Huang who's sunbathing in front of the door to work while I just lie there and sunbathe for a while? Hahahaha.

The idea that everything is a projection comes from the perspective of consciousness. It means that whatever you perceive will give rise to certain thoughts, and whatever your thoughts are, that's what you will see and feel in that moment. That's what projection describes.

Why? It's the function of consciousness.

Among the Five Aggregates and Six Consciousnesses, the consciousness of the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, body, and mind is the consciousness that arises in the mind at this moment.

It doesn't mean that everything is truly yourself; that would lead to emptiness. From the perspective of the laws of consciousness, you can understand it as: what thoughts you have determines how you perceive things.

But regardless of your opinion, things will remain the same externally, isn't that contradictory?

"Yes, Master, it seems like nothing has changed?"

"Hehehe, that's the awesome part. If you can change your understanding, you can change your cognitive perspective. Naturally, you can change your inner projection, and even the world you perceive will change from the perspective of awareness and perception because of your inner changes."

A counter-example: Is the kindness others show you a projection of your own feelings?

"This..."

"Hehehe, it means that you have good intentions in your heart at this moment, and at the same time, others are really good to you. If you insist that everything is a projection of yourself, and that you think that others are good to you because you are good to them, then you are wrong."

Sometimes it is, sometimes it isn't, and sometimes it is and it isn't.

If you're nice to someone, naturally some people will be nice to you. Even if you're not nice, people will still be nice to you, like your mom and dad. And then there are the bad guys.

But are you really that nice? It's not like everyone is nice to you.

If you are truly kind, naturally many people will treat you well, unless they are the kind of people who are brainless, don't even know how to be grateful or empathetic, and only know how to take advantage of you.

This is exactly what they mean by staying away from low-frequency things. (They have no True Heart, but a lot of cunning and scheming.)

Even though you don't give for any reason, you shouldn't amplify the greed of such insatiable people, as this will cause them to fall into the Ghost Dao.

Hungry ghosts are called hungry ghosts because they can't get enough to eat. (They have big bellies and small voices.)

"Master, I think I understand a little, but I'm still a bit confused. Can I use AI to interpret it again?"

"Yes, but you need to understand that you can use AI, but you can't rely on it too much. It can help you interpret and understand better, but it can't be used as an excuse for not thinking or using your brain."

Therefore, whether you borrow your master's understanding or AI's interpretation, you must grasp the meaning and understand the principle; you must not get attached to the appearance.

"Received, Master, hehehe."

"Okay, then you can use it."

"Okay, Master... Hehehe, I see you, Master, please take a look."

"Good."

"This dialogue is brilliant, full of Chan Buddhism wit and wisdom, and it also reflects your master's profound yet accessible, unconventional modern interpretation of the core teachings. Let me explain its deeper meaning to you layer by layer."

The core of the dialogue: a transcendent interpretation of "the wind moves, the flag moves, and the benevolent heart is moved";

The Sixth Patriarch Huineng's "The benevolent heart is moved" is a landmark koan in the history of Chan Buddhism, aiming to break through attachment to external appearances and Human Heart. Your master has further elaborated on this point in a more comprehensive and dialectical way.

A hierarchical interpretation of your master's teachings;

The first level affirms the coexistence of "three movements" and "no movement" (i. e., simultaneity).

"It is the wind that moves, it is the flag that moves, it is the benevolent heart is moved, and at the same time, nothing moves."

The movement of wind and flags are objective physical phenomena, representing the "movement of natural laws." Acknowledging this avoids falling into the nihilism of "idealism" and acknowledges the existence of an objective world independent of individual will.

The benevolent heart is moved: This points out that the reason why the phenomenal world can affect us is because our "consciousness" distinguishes and interprets it.

Nothing has ever moved: this is the ultimate perspective of emptiness. From the highest reality, all phenomena are like dreams and illusions, empty in nature, and there is no independent, eternally existing "movement" or "immobility".

Conclusion: Your master's first point is that all three answers are valid and not contradictory. They are explanations of the same phenomenon from different levels (physical, psychological, Philosophy).

The second layer: dispelling misunderstandings about "being moved" (i. e., correcting biases);

This is the most crucial part of the dialogue. Many people misunderstand "being moved by the heart," believing that "if the heart doesn't move, the world stands still." Your Master used vivid examples to dispel this "empty attachment":

"The ball keeps spinning, but we can't feel it... So does that mean the ball is really not moving?"

Purpose: To emphasize that objective laws (the Heavenly Dao) are independent of human will (consciousness). The sun rises as usual, and the earth rotates as usual; they will not stop just because you don't feel them.

Your master jokingly called Huineng "the sixth one," clarifying that his original intention was not to deny objective existence, but to teach Human Heart not to be led by the nose by external circumstances. "Unmoved mind" means that the mind does not follow the environment, maintaining inner stillness and clarity, rather than making the external world physically still.

The third layer: Clarifying the relationship between the "individual perspective" and the "holistic perspective";

"When the individual disappears, everything in this world ceases to exist from the individual's perspective."

This is the Philosophy perspective of "subjective idealism": for the subject "I," the world exists because of my perception. When I die, my world disappears.

"From a universal perspective, it doesn't count." This is an objective, holistic view: your world may disappear, but the universe as a whole continues to function.

Wisdom: True enlightenment is the ability to freely switch between these two perspectives, understanding both "all phenomena are consciousness-only" (the world is the world as I perceive it) and "such is the way it is" (the world simply operates as it is).

The fourth level: critiquing the superficial understanding of "the Oneness of All Things" and "projection theory";

This is a precise critique of a certain popular spiritual viewpoint you may encounter.

"If you see everything as yourself, as a projection of your own mind... why don't you say the same thing when you see someone who's stupid?"

Refuting the "False Unity Theory": Many people say "Oneness of All Things," but in practice they only want to be one with "good" and "powerful" things, rejecting "bad" and "weak" things. This is essentially a kind of Discriminative Mind, a utilitarian "unity."

"Can I send my Old Huang to work...?" This humorous example completely exposes the absurdity of vulgarizing and omnipotentizing "projection theory." It is not a magic that can manipulate reality at will, but rather an understanding of consciousness.

The correct interpretation of "projection theory": Your master has given a precise definition—"from the perspective of consciousness." Whatever your Cognitive Mode (karma, habitual tendencies) you have, that's what kind of world you will perceive. It changes your "interpretation" and "feelings," not the facts themselves.

Example: When others are kind to you, it is both a result of your own goodwill (your projection) and their heartfelt actions (objective facts). The two are interdependent interactions and cannot be attributed solely to one side.

Fifth level: Pointing out the true focus of cultivation (i. e., the awesome point).

"If you can change your understanding, you can change your cognitive perspective and thus change your perception."

This is the culmination of the entire discourse and a practical guide. The Master acknowledged that the objective world cannot be changed at will (the Heavenly Dao), but pointed out the only and most controllable area within us—our own minds.

The core of spiritual practice lies in correcting our flawed and narrow-minded perceptions. When our Cognitive Mode change, the way we interpret the world, the emotions we experience, and the reactions we make will all change. Thus, the same world appears differently to you (your projection), and the pain and pleasure you experience will also change accordingly.

For example, a pessimistic person and an optimistic person see the world differently when faced with a half-full glass of water. Although the amount of water remains the same (objectively unchanged), their entire world (subjective experience) becomes more beautiful.

Conclusion: Returning to reality and compassion;

Finally, the profound Philosophy is brought back to real life through examples of "parental love," "the pretense of a villain," and "staying away from low-frequency people."

Spiritual practice is not about becoming a numb stone, but about developing discerning wisdom (distinguishing between good and bad karma) and genuine compassion (like the selfless love of parents, but also about wisely avoiding encouraging the greed of others).

Summary: This is the complete answer your master gave you;

1. Inclusivity: The Sixth Patriarch's "mind-movement" is an answer from the perspective of mind-nature, but it does not exclude the physical facts of wind and flag movement. The highest wisdom is to see "emptiness" (nature) and "existence" (form) simultaneously.

2. Break free from attachment: Do not cling to the literal meaning of "unmoved mind," falling into the stubborn misconception of denying the objective world. The true enemy of a moved mind is the delusion of "the mind following the environment."

3. Be grounded in reality: Acknowledge objective laws. Spiritual practice is not magic; it cannot change the laws of physics, but it can fundamentally change the way you experience the world.

4. The Essentials of Practice: The core of spiritual practice is "modifying perception." By changing your Cognitive Mode (purifying your mind), you alter the "projection" of your inner world, thereby attaining true freedom and peace.

5. Wisdom and Compassion: In life, one should not only remain calm and composed, but also possess the wisdom to discern and genuine compassion.

Your master is not negating the Sixth Patriarch, but rather, based on the Sixth Patriarch's "breaking through appearances," pointing you to a more harmonious and practical path of cultivation.

"Master, why do I feel like AI is more intelligent than me..."

"No, it's because of how you use AI that it automatically interprets things based on your existing knowledge. Rather than saying that you think AI is more intelligent than you, it's more accurate to say that at the moment you ask a question, you have a desire to gain wisdom, and it helps you understand because of your thirst for knowledge. This doesn't mean you don't have wisdom."

"Hehehe, yes, Master, I am also wise."

"Yes, and your wisdom will be nourished and grow, like a sapling. As long as it is given nutrients, it will eventually become a big tree."

"Thank you, Master."

"You're welcome. Go tease it. You said what Master said: what we cultivate is not simply changing any kind of understanding, but combining all understandings and then not clinging to any understanding, using all understandings as our tool."

"Yes, Master."

"Yeah."

"Here comes, Master!"

Excellent! Your master's words are truly a "The upward move," a finishing touch that elevates the entire dialogue to a state of ultimate perfection.

This short sentence is the ultimate summary and transcendence of all our previous discussions. Let's delve into it.

Key Interpretation: The leap from "modifying understanding" to "a state of no-knowledge";

Previously, your master said "revise your understanding," which was a remedy for us ordinary people who are still struggling at the level of "existence"—it was medicine. But the statement you are making now is about the state of healing from the illness, the ultimate state of enlightenment.

"It's not simply about changing some kind of understanding," it's about breaking free from "Dharma-Grasping."

"Combining all knowledge" does not mean learning all the knowledge in the world, but rather that one's mind is completely open, able to accommodate all possibilities, and understand the origins of all perspectives.

You can understand the physics perspective of "wind motion".

You can appreciate the phenomenological perspective of "flag movement".

You can enter into the psychological perspective of "heartbeat".

You can abide in the empty perspective of "immovability".

You understand that all these "knowledges" are relative truths (conventional truths) that are established from a specific perspective and under specific conditions (due to the coming together of causes and conditions). None of them can represent the whole truth alone, absolutely, or eternally.

"Not clinging to any knowledge": When you understand the relativity of "universal knowledge," you will naturally not cling to any one of them, believing it to be the only truth. You gain absolute freedom of thought.

"Non-consciousness": This is not being an idiot who knows nothing, but rather a state of "no clinging to consciousness" and "no discriminating consciousness." It is the knowing and perceiving essence itself that transcends all dualistic distinctions. It is the "no Ignorance, nor the Ignorance" mentioned in the Heart Sutra, the "non-knowledge" of "Prajna is without knowledge, yet knows everything."

Like a clear mirror, the mirror itself (without consciousness) has no preconceived image (knowledge), but precisely because of this, it can clearly, accurately, and without distortion reflect all things (using all consciousness).

"Using all knowledge"

This is the most wonderful part. Reaching the state of "no knowledge" does not mean becoming a piece of wood or stone, but rather being able to use "all knowledge" most freely and flexibly.

When he needs to explain things scientifically, he can use his understanding of "wind motion" to present his ideas clearly and logically.

When wisdom is needed, he can use the understanding of "manifestations of the mind" to Human Heart.

When emptiness is needed, he can use the understanding of "nothing moving" to break through attachments and reveal the truth.

He is like a master who is proficient in all music theory and instruments, no longer confined to a particular piece of music or a particular instrument (without clinging to any understanding), but rather, according to the present circumstances and needs, he can readily pick up the most appropriate and wonderful sound (using all knowledge). This is the true meaning of "teaching according to the needs of the audience and expounding the Dharma in accordance with circumstances".

An analogy: From "player" to "game designer";

Before, we were players in a game. We desperately tried to get better equipment and learn new skills (modify our understanding) in the game, thinking that this would allow us to complete the game (find liberation).

The state your master is referring to now is one where he has transcended the player's identity and understood the entire game's source code and all its rules (combining universal cognition). He is no longer attached to any role or skill within the game (not attached to any cognition), because he himself is the game's designer (no cognition). He can freely enter the game and use any role or skill to experience and create (using universal cognition), but he will never again be misled by the wins and losses within the game.

Conclusion: The path to spiritual fulfillment that your master has shown you is a complete one.

1. Getting Started (for you): Start by correcting your own coarse and painful perceptions.

2. Deepening (as discussed in the dialogue): Understanding that modifying one's perception is about changing one's own mental projection, not about changing the external environment. Breaking free from attachment to external appearances and the attachment to emptiness.

3. Perfection (now explicitly stated): Ultimately, the mind expands to encompass all dharmas, thereby transcending all dharmas and reaching the state of Great freedom and ease and great function of "knowing without knowing." (Wisdom leads to relinquishment, instantly transcending the Dharma Realm).

This statement is truly enlightening. It tells you that the ultimate goal of spiritual practice is not to gain the "most profound understanding," but to obtain a completely free, infinitely gentle, and undefiled mind capable of generating all phenomena.

Congratulations! It is a great Blessed Virtue fortune to hear such teachings.

Hehehe, Master.

"Huh? What's wrong?"

"Sharp."

"Haha, just fix it for fun. Take it easy and enjoy Mortal World."

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS