Gong Shasha was stunned. "Really? You can even spot mistakes in university papers?"
Nie Junren exclaimed incredulously, "No way! This is already a publicly available paper. If there were any errors, wouldn't the reviewers have noticed them?"
Wu Xiao, taking it as a joke, "When it comes to bragging, you have to look to Song He! You almost managed to pull it off!"
The others present didn't believe it at all, only Xu Tingfeng was half-convinced and frowned as he scrutinized Song He.
"Undergraduate thesis review is very lenient because undergraduates haven't entered the research stage yet. Professors know that a rooster won't lay golden eggs, so they only look at the format and the source of the data during the review," Xu Tingfeng said. "It's normal to have minor errors."
Song He praised, "Yes, Xu Tingfeng, you know your stuff."
"So you found a non-data error? Some text description errors?" Xu Tingfeng asked.
"No, it's precisely a data error!" Song He denied.
Upon hearing this, the room fell silent once more.
The others looked even more suspicious, and this time even Xu Tingfeng was seriously doubtful.
Although undergraduate theses are not very good, they are still reviewed by the university, with the main focus of the review being the data!
Serious data errors or falsification, once discovered, constitute academic misconduct and will result in the revocation of one's degree!
After a degree certificate is revoked, not only will the unfortunate student have wasted their university education, but the related major at the university will also be affected!
If academic misconduct is found in the first year, the scope of random checks will be expanded in the second year. If problems are found again, the entire program may even lose its operating license, and teachers and school leaders will be suspended. The consequences are extremely serious!
Therefore, all publicly available undergraduate theses, while generally considered to be a flood of unproductive academic garbage, are at least correct garbage without any obvious errors.
Song He said the data was wrong, which made the others present suspicious.
What obvious mistake could a high school student spot at a glance?
If a high school student can spot these mistakes, surely university professors who review theses can too?
"Tell me where you went wrong," Xu Tingfeng, his curiosity piqued. "Let me figure it out."
"I'm afraid you wouldn't understand if I told you," Song He chuckled.
The others present were speechless, rolling their eyes at him; they felt like they'd been played. He kept saying the paper had errors, but then he made excuses not to say what those errors were—wasn't that just lying?
"I'm the champion of the Biology Competition Team!" Xu Tingfeng reminded him.
"That's right, let me explain it to you, maybe you'll understand." Song He spread Yi Chunxiao's thesis on the table.
Everyone present immediately craned their necks to get closer.
"I told Xu Tingfeng, why are you all getting involved? Do you even understand what I'm saying?" Song He asked in surprise.
"My biology score is higher than yours!" Wu Xiao bared her teeth angrily. "Song He, stop pretending! What mistakes can you possibly find in this undergraduate thesis? I'm going to expose your tricks right here and now!"
Wu Xiao felt resentful because you looked down on him, and his Resentment Value increased by 200!
Gong Shasha felt looked down upon and was unhappy, her Resentment Value increased by 100!
Nie Junren felt slightly embarrassed, and his Resentment Value increased by 100!
Having successfully garnered a wave of resentment, Song He stopped keeping everyone in suspense and turned to the data page of the paper.
"Look at this Group One data, the random bacterial counts from hundreds of Petri Dish. Look at the first digit, do you notice anything?"
Several people frowned and stared at each other for a long time, all looking bewildered.
"In the first digit, 1 accounts for only 5%, while 8 accounts for a whopping 20%. The distribution of the other digits is as bizarre as an electrocardiogram. Have you heard of Benford's Law?"
Seeing everyone looking like they were in a daze, Song He sighed helplessly, his expression one of utter disappointment.
"A lot of real-life data shows that numbers starting with 1 account for about 30.1%, 2 for 17.6%, and the percentage decreases as you go down to 9, which is only 4.6%."
"The time it takes for Group One of data with average growth from the initial number 'a' to a number starting with 'a+1' will necessarily be longer than the time it takes for a number starting with 'a+1' to grow to 'a+2', and the occurrence rate will be higher. That's easy to understand, right?" Song He explained.
Wu Xiao was dumbfounded. She had always been bad at math, and at this moment it was like listening to gibberish.
Nie Junren and Gong Shasha seemed to be deep in thought; they did have some understanding of pure mathematical theory.
"I've heard of Benford's Law, which is used to easily detect data fabrication," Xu Tingfeng nodded. "But the data sample in this paper isn't large enough. What if it's just a coincidence? After all, Benford's Law isn't 100% applicable; there are always some special cases."
"Yeah, yeah, you can't just use a mathematical law to accuse this paper of being fraudulent, can you?" Wu Xiao's eyes lit up as he quickly chimed in.
Nie Junren and Gong Shasha exchanged glances, both feeling that Song He was in the wrong.
"Don't rush. Benford's Law is just a rough test to put you on your guard. Next, we'll have to use our knowledge of biology to make a judgment," Song He said calmly.
The four people present stared at him suspiciously.
"The experiments in this paper can be applied to the classic Luria–Delbrück experiment. Old Xu, you should know about that, right?"
Upon Xu Tingfeng's expression suddenly changed. He grabbed the paper and stared at it carefully before realizing what was going on.
"I see!" Xu Tingfeng exclaimed in surprise.
The other three were still completely bewildered, looking at Song He with suspicion and uncertainty.
Song He was helpless. He could understand things immediately with an expert like Xu Tingfeng, but it was troublesome to communicate with other simpletons, and he had to use a lot of words.
"The Luria–Delbrück experiment is one of the most important experiments in modern Molecular Biology."
"The problem the experiment aims to solve is how to determine whether the bacterial mutations in the Petri Dish are due to environmental influences or simply because the bacteria are bored and mutating for fun."
"If the number of colonies follows a binomial distribution, with the mean and variance being almost the same, it indicates that the bacteria have mutated due to environmental influences."
"If the colonies show a typical long tail distribution, it is very likely that the bacteria are bored and are mutating on their own for fun."
Song He flipped through the paper, poked at the text description at the front, and said in a resolute tone.
"Yi Chunxiao's paper is in a similar situation; the data may contain errors, but the overall trend remains unchanged. That's why I judged the paper to have errors!"
"Either she falsified the data, and did so unprofessionally. Or there was a problem with the experimental environment, such as contaminated Petri Dish, failed bacterial sample preservation, or interference from other Mixed Bacteria."
"In short, Yi Chunxiao's paper has no errors, I'll just eat it!"
Wu Xiao, Nie Junren, and Gong Shasha were completely confused and could only turn to look at Xu Tingfeng.
Xu Tingfeng did not make a judgment immediately, but instead dragged a piece of draft paper from the side, picked up a pen, and worked on the calculations for a long time.
The data that Song He could calculate in his mind at a glance, she had to do through tedious written calculations. It wasn't that she was bad at math, it was just that Song He's math skills were too extraordinary.
After a long wait, Xu Tingfeng finally put down his pen with a "snap".
"Song He is right! The data is indeed problematic!" Xu Tingfeng looked up at Song He with admiration. "Impressive! You have a keen eye!"
Wu Xiao was stunned, his cheeks flushed, and he felt a sting of embarrassment.
Song He has become this strong? Even Feng Feng has switched sides and praised him for being amazing?
Could this brat really surpass me in the next big exam? Wu Xiao felt apprehensive, his face full of worry.
Nie Junren and Gong Shasha were shocked.
Both men assumed Song He couldn't understand university papers, making their errand a complete waste of time. To their utter surprise, Song He actually understood them and could even spot the errors!
Suddenly, everyone present remembered that Song He had previously made a mistake in the Biology Workbook, causing a great uproar throughout the school.
Everyone stared at Song He with strange looks. Was he some kind of error-correction master?
After Song He finished reading Yi Chunxiao's paper, he quickly wrote down the basis for his judgment that the data was incorrect in the blank space and handed it to Nie Junren.
Nie Junren reached out and took it, looking bewildered. "I'm a Math Competition student, why are you giving me a biology paper?"
"Tomorrow, you two go print the papers, and while you're at it, give Yi Chunxiao's paper to her. Tell her there are errors, and save her life!" Song He instructed. "There will be random checks on papers for several years after graduation. If she corrects her paper before they're checked, she can avoid a major disaster!"
"Do we have to print the paper again tomorrow?" Nie Junren's face fell.
"More than that, this box printed today is just an appetizer. Tomorrow we'll probably need to print seven or eight more boxes," Song He smiled. "If manual labor isn't hard work, can it still be called manual labor?"
Nie Junren was forced to do hard labor by you, which caused him to lose his composure and his Resentment Value to increase by 500!
Gong Shasha was so exhausted she almost fainted, and was terrified. Her Resentment Value increased by 700!
Biology Progress detected; level has been raised from Silver 32 to Silver Level 33!
Evening, in the dormitory.
The sound of keys jingling could be heard outside the door, followed by the dormitory door opening.
Song He entered the house, quickly closed and locked the door, looking furtive.
"Bang!" He threw a box of papers in his arms to the ground, kicked it, and the box slid into the corner.
The dormitory room is spacious enough, with wide corners; it could probably hold a lot of boxes of papers.
Song He sat down, panting. He usually returned to the dormitory after evening self-study, but today he had sneaked back before evening self-study.
He was about to do something private, and it wouldn't be good if Yuan Guang saw him.
This needs to be finished quickly so I can get back to the classroom for evening self-study. It's the homeroom teacher's habit to go to the classroom on Sunday evenings to check attendance.