It cannot be used as conclusive evidence.
We both have different opinions about what exactly happened during the time they were in the toilet.
And because there is no monitoring in the toilet, I can't call the monitoring to confirm which one is right, and our claims cannot be confirmed.
According to your statement, although Yonekura has never done anything like "bullying" before, there is no guarantee that he won't do it now.
Then I can also think that although Karuizawa was able to abide by discipline before, this does not mean that he will not violate discipline now.
As for the question of whether it is rational to commit a serious disciplinary violation of "bullying a classmate" when the midterm exam is about to take place, it is indeed irrational under normal circumstances.
But in fact, the thing has happened, which means that one of them must be irrational.
As for who is the irrational person...
Let's not mention those things that cannot be verified. Let's talk about things that are actually clear and can be easily verified.
There is surveillance outside the toilet.
As long as we adjust the monitoring, we can know that during yesterday's time, there were only two people, Karuizawa and Yonekura, in the toilet.
Yonekura entered the toilet after Karuizawa.
And Yonekura cried and ran away from the toilet not long after entering the toilet.
This is something clearly stated in the monitoring.
Except.
Judging from the final result, Yonekura was injured, while Karuizawa was fine.,
Judging from the information that can be confirmed so far, it seems that Yonekura is the victim.
As for Karuizawa, no matter how good their words are, they can't produce actual evidence to prove their innocence.
Even if you take ten thousand steps back.
Even if it was really Yonekura that was wrong at the beginning.
But from the fact that Karuizawa was unscathed, it can be seen that the mistakes Yonekura made were just saying some bad words at most, and did not cause any real harm to Karuizawa.
Even if Yonekura is really wrong to say those bad words, it's not that serious, right?
And Karuizawa, even if she was reasonable at first.
But even though she didn't suffer any real harm and the other party posed no threat to her, she still hit Yonekura and injured her to this extent.
Look at the injuries on Yonekura's body. This cannot be done with one or two 'counterattacks'. This requires a 'counterattack' followed by a continuous 'pursuit'!
Is this counterattack too much?
At the very least, it's considered an 'overdefense', right?
In a situation like this, if I am not severely punished, will someone accidentally say something unpleasant in the future and another person will find a reason to rush over and beat me seriously?
Oh my gosh!
In this case, this school is too scary!
How can students dare to study and live here with confidence? "
Listening to what the other party said, Karuizawa and her defenders frowned.
The other party's words captured one of the most important key points of this incident!
That is Karuizawa without injury.
But Yonekura was injured.
The situation of "Karuizawa No injury" will directly determine the "upper limit" of the seriousness of what the other party has done.
In other words, even if the other party is really a bad person, no matter how excessive the other party is, that's all.
In turn, the situation "Yonekura was injured" determines the "lower limit" that can represent the severity of Karuizawa's behavior.
No matter how innocent Karuizawa is, even if she is really protecting herself, forget it if Karuizawa is also injured.
If Karuizawa is also injured, it can be used to prove that the other party's behavior has posed a threat to her personal safety. In this case, in order to ensure her own safety, it is understandable that she cannot hold back and fight back harder.
However, Karuizawa was not injured.
Being able to injure the opponent so seriously while ensuring that he remains unharmed.
This shows that there is a huge gap in strength between the two sides, and Yonekura poses no threat to Karuizawa at all.
With a gun that posed no threat to the other party, it was indeed excessive to beat someone who posed no threat to him like this, and there was a serious suspicion of excessive defense.
Therefore, judging from the results obtained so far, even if Yonekura is judged in the worst direction, and Karuizawa is judged in the best direction, it will still be more beneficial to Yonekura in the end and very detrimental to Karuizawa!
Unless there is any evidence to prove that Karuizawa did not cause any serious harm to the other party at that time.
Or it may prove that Karuizawa did not "pursue" at that time, and the injuries on the opponent's body were actually just the result of Karuizawa's subconscious explosion after being stimulated and the first round of counterattack.
In this way, Karuizawa can be freed from the suspicion of "excessive defense."
Do they have a way to prove this?
Alas! There really is!
At this time, Karuizawa couldn't help but recall the photos, audio recordings, and videos that Bai Lan showed her not long ago, and then her eyes flashed with confidence.
However, because Karuizawa has maintained an "arrogant and powerful" persona from beginning to end at the request of Bai Lan, and she habitually conceals her true emotions.
Coupled with the contrast between the "moral hot girl" that she brought to people before, it gives people the impression that Karuizawa is a "brainless and confident" person.
Therefore, in the eyes of others, it is quite normal for Karuizawa to show a confident look. It is the problem when he is not confident. There is no way to tell anything strange from Karuizawa's expression.
Others are unaware of the existence of those photos, audio and video recordings.
Horikita Suzune couldn't think of the most powerful way to refute.
After a lot of hard work, Horikita finally came up with a method, but this method had many loopholes and needed to rely on a bit of luck. Once luck was not on their side, or someone discovered the loophole, it would not work.
Horikita Suzune doesn't want to leave his fate to luck or the other party.
Thinking of this, Horikita Suzune put aside the rebuttal method he just thought of and tried to think of another countermeasure.
Karuizawa Fang didn't reply for a long time.
However, Tachibana Akane on the "judge bench" did not urge, and neither did Bai Lan.
Yonekura People on the side saw that the referees did not urge this time and seemed to be trying to sidestep the situation, so they couldn't help but urge it themselves.
"You finally have nothing to say, right? Sure enough, the truth is on our side, President, for the sake of the stability and harmony of the school, please severely punish Karuizawa, this violent maniac!"
At this time, Horikita Suzune still couldn't think of any good countermeasures.
Under the stimulation of people on Yonekura's side, Horikita Suzune finally gritted his teeth.
"I can only take a gamble! "Horikita Suzune thought.
Later, Horikita Suzune retorted, "According to Karuizawa, she just backhanded a few times when she was first stimulated, and then she didn't 'chase' at all!" And Yonekura ran away immediately after being hit a few times!
As for the evidence, I have an idea.
In fact, we can calculate the time it takes Yonekura from entering the toilet to leaving through monitoring records.
Then we can use simulation to estimate the time it takes for Karuizawa and Yonekura to communicate before taking action.
Finally, subtract the time spent communicating between the two of them from the time Yonekura went in and out of the toilet. The remaining time is the length of time it takes Karuizawa to fight back against Yonekura.
If the remaining time is very short, just enough for the two of them to complete the conversation, it means that Karuizawa has no time to 'pursue' at all.
As long as Karuizawa doesn't 'pursue'.
Of course 'excessive defense' is not true! "
"President, what do you think? Do you want to adjust the monitoring? "Bai Lan, who took over the hosting rights of this arbitration meeting, looked selfless.
Horikita Manabu: "It's a very reasonable request, then adjust the monitoring."
After finishing speaking, Horikita Manabu took out his mobile phone and called the school's surveillance department to apply for transfer of surveillance.
Accelerated by the privilege of Student Council, a few minutes later, the surveillance department sent someone to deliver the surveillance records from the entrance to the women's restroom yesterday.
Soon, the surveillance content was projected onto the curtain of the special classroom.
Under the operation of technicians, the moment Yonekura entered the women's toilet yesterday and the moment Yonekura ran out of the toilet were found.
Everyone calculated the time and found that there was a difference of more than two minutes between the two moments.
After learning the result, Horikita Suzune shook his head slightly.
She knew she lost the bet.
More than two minutes, this time is enough time to speak the contents of the conversation that Karuizawa and Yonekura said several times at "normal speaking speed."
Of course, the interaction between people cannot only be "conversation", nor can they use "normal speaking speed" throughout.
People often use "body language" in face-to-face communication.
Body language also accounts for the amount of time spent communicating.
For example, if you are halfway speaking and the other person suddenly raises his fist and rushes towards you, can you guarantee that you can continue speaking at a normal speed?
In addition, when people speak face to face, unless the lines are prepared in advance, they often need to complete the wording temporarily.
Wording also takes time.
A conversation that can be completed in a few seconds at a normal speaking speed may take more than half a minute to complete the wording, or it may be spoken casually without thinking at all.
However, no one can determine how much time is spent on the "body language" part and the "wording" part.
Be able to determine the time it takes for only those words that have been conceived to be spoken.
This uncertain part has a lot of room for movement, and a little "squeezing" it out is enough to complete the "chasing" behavior.
Therefore, Horikita Suzune's countermeasures failed, and surveillance could not clear Karuizawa of the suspicion of "excessive defense."
As a result, Karuizawa will be sentenced to "excessive defense" even at the slightest level, and will be severely punished!
This is still the "lightest" one.
Only when it is determined that the other party was at fault first can it be regarded as "over-defense".
If it is not certain that the other party was at fault first, Karuizawa cannot even be regarded as "excessive defense", but can only be regarded as a unilateral "beating of others".
In this case, the punishment will only be more severe!