Some Thoughts on the Classic of Mountains and Seas
I wasn't planning on writing this, but I've seen people mention a content creator named Qi Tian Da Shen Yu Xiaosa twice, asking if I should explain my relationship with him.
I could only answer that it didn't matter; they were probably all people who preferred to view the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas as reliable historical records.
Does it look similar? He mainly introduced why some of the Exotic Beasts in the Classic of Mountains and Seas are so strange. The answer is nothing more than the difference in understanding between ancient and modern people and the limitations of description. They often use metaphors, which leads to many misunderstandings.
Isn't this common sense...? At least in the eyes of those who like the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas, it's common sense...
The He Luo Fish, which both he and I have discussed, was noted by Yang Shen as early as the Ming Dynasty as "Heluo fish, which is now known as octopus."
In other words, people from hundreds of years ago already knew that the Heluo fish was a cephalopod, such as a squid or octopus.
It includes penguins, yaks, parrots, Flying squirrel, and flying fish; these are no longer just interpretations, but rather knowledge...
Furthermore, descriptions of multi-eyed or back-eyed mythical Exotic Beasts mostly refer to the patterns on their bodies; Professor Yuan Ke has already discussed this point...
There were also gods and half-human, half-beast figures, mostly disguised as shamans, who would imitate the characteristics of strange animals and collect offerings. This was basically the tribute collected during the era when shamans held immense power.
Furthermore, the saying "its appearance foretells great floods, its appearance foretells great droughts" is a classic example of reversed cause and effect, and its interpretation has been around for a long time.
All the views expressed by that content creator are basically derived from various scholars of the Classic of Mountains and Seas; this is knowledge...
In the eyes of enthusiasts Classic of Mountains and Seas him and me, this is the 'mainstream interpretation'.
However, his interpretation of hermaphroditic 'kin' as hyena is quite novel and impressive. I was stunned and completely agree.
To be honest, I've watched all the episodes of Animal World, Man and Nature, and Natural Legends. I know hyenas very well, but I never thought they might be a 'kin'...
Hyenas once existed in China; fossils of the Pliocene hyena, dating back over 4 million years, were discovered in the Zanda Basin of the XCAL region of China. Unfortunately, hyenas in China became extinct.
Of course, I have two doubts about his statement:
First, why didn't the author of the Classic of Mountains and Seas describe the hyena's most distinctive cry? It was a cry that sounded like a sinister laugh.
Secondly, hyenas live in groups, which is not described in the Classic of Mountains and Seas.
My personal understanding is that 'ren' refers to a type of animal similar to a hyena, where the female's oviduct is located outside the body. Such animals were quite numerous in the Miocene, but apart from the hyena family, they are basically all extinct.
Based on the above, I don't see any common ground between us in our personal opinions.
Even though this isn't a free chapter, it doesn't constitute plagiarism.
I tend to believe that the Classic of Mountains and Seas is a historical record. For people in ancient times, records of all things in the world belong to historical records.
During the Han Dynasty, Sima Qian placed the Classic of Mountains and Seas and Seas alongside the Yu Ben Ji. During the Tang Dynasty, Wei Zheng was particularly fond of the Classic of Mountains and Seas, elevating it to the status of a historical text.
It must be said that the Tang Dynasty was very open. Because the country was founded on military strength, the regional military governors and warlords were powerful, Confucianism was not as restrictive. Li Bai even dared to directly mention in his poems, "Yao was imprisoned, Shun died in the wilderness."
That was when the culture truly flourished.
When I talked about Exotic Beasts in the previous chapter, I didn't want to say much about these things that can be explained as animals, which are no longer novel.
As I've mentioned before, many people have offered similar interpretations, and the academic community offers even more. So many that 99% of the opinions you see online have been proposed by relevant professors.
Anything not mentioned is basically utter nonsense, and is considered particularly absurd by modern scholars.
As for the Speed of Light spaceship I mentioned, it's considered utter nonsense by scholars.
They simply don't believe that there were aliens or advanced technology in ancient times.
Because it's impossible, even modern humans don't have one, so no one thinks that the Cheng Huang is a spaceship traveling at the Speed of Light.
This is a typical example of a rigid way of thinking. Why should people in ancient times necessarily not have seen something that modern people haven't seen?
My personal interpretation is to directly assume that the author of the Classic of Mountains and Seas wrote facts, not fabricated stories; the problem lies in the way the stories were expressed.
Based on this, I believe that even if a spaceship traveling at the Speed of Light is impossible, it is the only explanation.
I had said I wouldn't write anymore, but I couldn't help but explain these things.
Since I've already written it, let me briefly explain a little more.
Let me interpret this Liu Yan Jing about Jingwei. Apparently, some people in the comments section are vehemently criticizing Jingwei's values... saying that the Jingwei myth is Uniting with the Dao and foolish.
First, let's talk about the myth. This is a typical revenge myth, which is very important because the number one Spring and Autumn Great Righteousness in the Confucianism Spring and Autumn Annals is the Great Revenge!
He said, "Can a feud spanning nine generations still be avenged? It can even last for a hundred generations!"
This is the proposition of the Gongyang School, and it is very spirited.
Confucius, "If you repay evil with kindness, what will you repay kindness with? Repay evil with justice, and repay kindness with kindness."
Zigong asked Confucius, "What should one do if one lives with the enemy of one's parents?" Confucius replied, "Sleep on straw mats and use a dry mat as a pillow, do not serve in office, and do not share the world with him. If you encounter him in the marketplace or court, do not turn your troops away to fight."
To translate, Zigong asked Confucius, "What should one do if someone kills one's parents?" Confucius replied, "One should always carry a shield and weapon, even while sleeping on a straw mat. One should not seek official positions or enjoy comforts until revenge is taken, nor should one live under the same sky as one's enemy. If one encounters one's enemy in the marketplace, one should not even bother going back to get a weapon, but go straight for the kill."
The Book of Rites, Quli: "One should not share the same sky with the enemy of one's father, nor should one turn against one's brother with troops to avenge him, nor should one treat an acquaintance with another as a hostile ruler."
To put it another way, it means that the hatred for the murderer of one's father is irreconcilable, and one must find and kill the enemy no matter where he is. If one's brother is killed, one must always carry weapons and be ready to take revenge. One cannot let go of such a thing. If one's friend is killed, one must either avenge the friend or leave the country. In any case, one cannot live in the same country as the murderer.
This is etiquette! Etiquette! Etiquette! I'll say it three times because it's important.
Before the advent of law, ritual was law, and ritual was supreme.
Impoliteness is not civilization, it's barbarism.
In retrospect, this reflects a distorted set of values. If someone kills your friend, does that mean you should kill them in return? This is setting a bad example for children! No individual has the right to decide the life or death of another person; only the law does.
But in early China, this was considered perfectly natural.
If you don't do this, you won't be able to survive in that society.
So that friend was right, this is not in line with modern morality.
However, it conforms to ancient morality, so it has its reasons for existing.
Now that things have come to this, if you're feeling argumentative, you could say, "What does her drowning have to do with the sea? Why would she seek revenge against the sea? Are you brain-dead?"
No, no, no, this is precisely because the ancients weren't brain-dead.
Throughout history, Jingwei's indomitable spirit has been praised. Why? Because everyone knows... she couldn't fill the sea...
Those who think there's something wrong with land reclamation already assume, in the first place, that it's actually possible to reclaim land from the sea...
But everyone knows that even if it takes millions or billions of years, the sea will never dry up, yet Jingwei still perseveres in doing so.
This reflects the Confucianism moral standard. "Even if there are thousands of people against me, I will go."
Using the rationalist ideas that emerged in modern times, and employing the rationalist logic of "what does it matter if someone drowns?", we can criticize the Confucianism propositions of ancient philosophy and academic thought.
This behavior itself is rather... well, rather boring.
Why do I say these are all Confucianism doctrines? Because the story of Jingwei filling the sea is an artistic embellishment of the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas by the Han Dynasty people; it's a typical myth created to express a certain spirit...
The original text from the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas and Seas, "Northern Mountains Classic," states. "On Mount Fajiu, there are many mulberry trees. There is a bird there, which looks like a crow, with a patterned head, a white beak, and red feet. It is called Jingwei, and its cry is like its own name. It is the daughter of Emperor Yan, named Nüwa. Nüwa was playing in the Eastern Sea and drowned, never to return. Therefore, she became Jingwei. She constantly carries wood and stones from the Western Mountains to fill the Eastern Sea."
According to what I said before, the author's meaning of the word "youniaoyan" is very clear, it is a kind of bird.
The first half, up to "It is named Jingwei, and its cry is self-deprecating," describes a bird. According to the analysis I mentioned in the previous two chapters, this is the most uncontroversial and calm writing from the original author.
So the problem lies in the second half, where it says that this bird is Nüwa.
Here, I have several interpretations. The most boring one is that the original author didn't write about Nüwa at all. Otherwise, he would have written it directly from the beginning, "There is a bird, which is the daughter of Emperor Yan, named Nüwa, who transformed into a bird named Jingwei."
However, that's not how it's written.
If you remove the first half, you'll find that the passage from Emperor Yan to Yi Yin in the East Sea can stand alone without any sense of incompleteness or missing anything.
If you remove the second half and only look at the first half, there is no sense of incompleteness. Like other passages in the Classic of Mountains and Classic of Mountains and Seas, it simply describes a type of bird.
Compared to other animals in the Classic of Mountains and Seas, many of them end at the point of "their cries and self-complaints," at most with a follow-up question like "how does it taste?"...
Therefore, it is possible that this was added by people in the Han Dynasty, Confucianism who used Jingwei to create a revenge myth.
Jingwei carries tiny twigs in her arms, intending to fill the vast ocean.
The story of Jingwei, which highlights the tiny tree and contrasts it with the vast ocean, emphasizes both Jingwei's resentment and her weakness and perseverance. This is clearly fabricated.
This is the most boring, bland, and unremarkable explanation.
I have another explanation for this, and I want to refute myself.
The question is simple: why did the Confucianism choose Jingwei to create this myth? There were plenty of better subjects in the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas and Seas.
If you remove the second half, the first half is just a very, very, very ordinary description of a Birds. It doesn't even mention what the bird does, or what it tastes like. It's utterly mediocre. Why bother making it up? Is it famous? Is it popular?
If everything from Emperor Yan's statement onwards is fabricated, then this motive doesn't make sense. Why wouldn't the Confucianism find something more popular to capitalize on?
Unless, as described in the Classic of Mountains and Seas, the bird's behavior of carrying wood to fill the sea made them feel that it could be modified, thus giving rise to the later myth of Jingwei filling the sea.
This suggests that the story of Jingwei carrying wood to fill the sea was recorded long ago.
In other words, the entire passage may have been written by the original author.
Upon closer inspection, it's quite possible!
Because in the second half, there were no reflections, no direct explanation of the Nüwa's psychology, and no mention of her motives for revenge.
This isn't a revenge story; the text simply states. "Therefore, he became Jingwei." You'll soon discover how brilliant those four words are.
Based on this premise, we can propose a second interpretation.
As is customary, "there is a bird" means it must be a bird, or at least one that can fly. It is not a person; if it were a person, it would be either a human or a god. The original author was very clear about this point.
So let's look for this bird. Great, this bird is super easy to find. It's very ordinary, basically a migratory seabird or something. Judging from its appearance, it's probably a goose.
"Traveling to the East China Sea" refers to migration. Every year, wild geese cross the Bohai Sea to Siberia and then return south.
Geese occasionally carry logs to fill the sea, partly to disrupt the currents, and partly to rest on floating branches during migration... because the lead geese are the most tired...
This can still be seen in the Bohai Sea.
As we all know, animals develop nest-building and other functions out of necessity; if they didn't have to do them, they wouldn't have evolved these habits.
Although they have crossed the Bohai Sea, Birds can rest on coastal land, so why do they rest at sea?
From the perspective of geese, this is because their 'service stations' and 'rest areas' along the coast, which they have maintained for generations, have been occupied by humans...
They were either cleared out to make farmland or turned into cities, where large numbers of people gathered and geese dared not rest in flocks.
Let's return to the Classic of Mountains and Seas.
The reason I say that traveling to the East China Sea is migration is because the second half of the sentence also describes migration.
The Nüwa, Nüwa, drowned in the East Sea and never returned; thus she became Jingwei.
Many people ignore the word 'not return' when translating!
They think saying the Nüwa drowned is enough; she drowned and didn't come back—isn't that obvious?
No, how could it be nonsense? The fact that the words 'no return' are written here makes it very important...
In my opinion, the original author was seriously writing about migration.
Animal migration is a cyclical process of going and returning. If we only mention going without mentioning returning, it is not called migration, but transfer.
That's why the author emphasized "not returning," implying that "they should return."
So why didn't he return? He wrote, 'drowned and did not return,' meaning he drowned and therefore did not return.
In short, these birds, which normally return after swimming in the East China Sea, were driven away by humans when they stopped to rest along the way.
This resulted in the drowning of the leader goose.
Therefore, it is Jingwei! It doesn't mean that after death it transformed into a non-human, but rather that it became the Jingwei bird I see now.
They evolved; to adapt to the presence of humans, the lead goose carried twigs in its beak and filled the sea with them as a landing point.
Some students might say: The Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas doesn't mention humans driving away geese. Why isn't such an important thing mentioned?
I actually wrote it, but very subtly, and some parts may have been deleted.
According to me, people clearing forest land, planting crops, and promoting agriculture on a large scale have destroyed the places that Birds originally used as rest stops during their migrations.
As we all know, farmland is planted with crops, so how could we allow Birds to get close? Therefore, when geese land, people will chase them away.
But who were the ones promoting agriculture and vigorously developing farming?
Emperor Yan!
He invented slash-and-burn agriculture, created two kinds of tilling tools, and taught people to burn forests to create farmland and cultivate food crops.
As a result, human agricultural civilization expanded significantly, reaching coastal areas and altering the habits of Birds, hence the name Jingwei.
What does the word "Jingwei" mean? In terms of the pictograms of oracle bone inscriptions, bronze inscriptions, and seal scripts, "jing" is a grain of rice.
Wei is a person holding a hoe. The extended meaning is to hold a hoe to protect crops from being destroyed and eaten by animals.
This is the original meaning of "defend," and it has nothing to do with protecting one's homeland.
Ancient people used farming tools to drive away wild animals Birds, protecting their crops and ensuring a bountiful harvest; hence the name Jingwei!
This actually refers to a type of Birds that eats our crops and we always have to chase it away.
Therefore, Nüwa was not the daughter of Emperor Yan, at least not in the sense of being a daughter as we understand it.
In fact, if you look at all the daughters of Emperor Yan, you will find that they were all related to agriculture.
Emperor Yan's daughter Sang transformed into a mulberry tree after her death. Yao Ji transformed into a lingzhi mushroom after her death. Nüwa transformed into Jingwei after her death.
Alright, I have a sad story to tell: Emperor Yan had no daughters! Waaaaah...
His daughters were all farmers and herbalists.
Therefore, Emperor Yan may not have had any daughters in that era, or if he did, they were of lowly status and not worth mentioning.
People prefer to believe that the mulberry and lingzhi mushrooms chosen by Emperor Yan, as well as the wild geese that circled the settlements of agricultural tribes, were Emperor Yan's daughters.
Thinking about it this way, it makes sense.
It's like how modern people obsessed with clay sculptures might be told, "You treat all these clay sculptures like your daughters! You don't even care about your own daughters, all you do is tend to these clay sculptures... What do you need a daughter for! These are your real daughters!"
Emperor Yan was a madman. He was obsessed with farming and identifying plants.
He invented a large number of farming tools and carefully selected all the herbs and crops that could be grown. It was not surprising that he was surrounded by a large number of Birds.
For other ordinary people, these things are their children.
Emperor Yan was a good leader, but not a good father.
At least, he's not a doting father; his own daughter's status is lower than that of Baicao in his hands... Alas! I really want a daughter!
That concludes our interpretations of Jingwei.
Tsk, that's all.
P. S.: Sorry, although I haven't mentioned Hou Yi shoots the suns down the suns or immortality yet, I really won't be writing about those for now; the main text is more important. Also, if you're interested, you can buy *The Complete Translation of the Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas and The Annotated Classic of Classic of Mountains and Seas and Seas, which contain many of the most popular and mainstream interpretations of the Classic of Mountains and Seas. A fellow reader mentioned the Bilibili up-master Qi Tian Da Shen Yu Xiaosa, who is also an option. Look for them yourself. However, if you're looking for more imaginative and far-fetched interpretations, it will be harder to find.