Winning All the Color Doppler Ultrasound Contracts
Ning City, Room 301, 3rd Floor, Provincial Government Service Center.
Lu Tingfeng arrived at the bidding site in the conference room early in the morning with several technical personnel.
The typical bidding process involves first submitting electronic bids, then having major manufacturers come to the site for bid opening, where experts from the bidding committee will ask technical questions and review whether the bids meet the requirements from various aspects, and finally, the bidding results will be announced within three days.
They weren't the first to arrive; when they got to the meeting room, several teams were already sitting in small groups.
Lu Tingfeng recognized one of them at a glance; it was Li Ting, the boss of Mindray Medical.
He was immediately taken aback. "No way, Mindray is such a big company, and the boss actually came to the bidding meeting in person. It seems that he attaches great importance to this procurement."
But thinking about it, it makes sense. It's a provincial-level order worth hundreds of millions. Even if it's just to build good relations with the local area, it's not surprising that the boss would come.
Besides Mindray, other domestic medical device manufacturers such as Mindray Medical, Xiangsheng Medical, Lepu, Wandong also participated.
This tender mainly focuses on medical imaging equipment, divided into three packages: Portable Color Ultrasound, Desktop Color Ultrasound, and DR (digital X-ray imaging system).
DR is the most basic and common X-ray examination equipment in radiology. It has a fast imaging speed, which can usually be completed in a few seconds, and the radiation dose is very small, which is not harmful to the human body and has good safety. However, the density resolution is not high, and it is easy to miss small lesions. It is often used for primary screening such as physical examinations.
The participating manufacturers are all major medical imaging equipment manufacturers, but Three Purities's main competitors are Mindray and SonoScape, both of which are among the top domestic ultrasound companies.
The other companies mainly bid for DR equipment; color Doppler ultrasound is just a supporting player and can't compete with Mindray and SonoScape at all.
Of course, now we need to add Three Purities to form a three-way balance, which also makes up the three bidding manufacturers.
The winner of the color Doppler ultrasound bid will likely be one of these three companies.
Lu Tingfeng greeted each of the manufacturer's representatives. They were all in the same industry, having worked together for over 20 years, and had some connections with each other. Some of them had even been his colleagues.
"Hehe, you must be General Manager Lu of Three Purities, it's an honor to meet you." A hearty voice rang in his ear.
Lu Tingfeng turned around and saw that it was Li Ting, the boss of Mindray. Before Three Purities and his group could walk over, he took the initiative to run over.
He smiled and extended his hand, "President Li, hello, it's been a long time."
Since they are the biggest competitor on this trip, there's no need to be overly enthusiastic; a polite greeting is sufficient.
To his surprise, Li Ting was exceptionally enthusiastic, shaking his hand with a broad smile and speaking to him as warmly as a brother who had been missing for many years.
"General Manager Lu is truly young and promising. In such a short time, he has made Three Purities's medical device business so successful. Both of his products are industry benchmarks, which makes us feel ashamed of our own shortcomings."
After saying that, he instructed his assistant, "Go and bring the things over. We'll sit next to General Manager Lu. I came here specifically for Three Purities, and I'd like to get closer to General Manager Lu and ask him for some advice."
"Not at all, you're too kind." Lu Tingfeng felt a little uncomfortable, thinking the other party was being overly enthusiastic, but he couldn't refuse someone who was smiling at him.
The manufacturers watching all wore thoughtful expressions. The two biggest dragons in the domestic medical device industry met but didn't fight. Especially this Mr. Li, who is known for his bad temper, was so enthusiastic.
Is there something strange about this? Did the two companies reach some kind of secret agreement?
The representative of SonoScape stood to the side, feeling uneasy. Watching his two major competitors chatting and laughing amicably, he felt a sense of unease and couldn't help but worry deeply about the company's future business.
After a while, the experts from the bidding committee also entered the room one after another.
There were five people in total. Apart from the person from the National Health Commission, the other four were technical experts. Surprisingly, one of them was wearing a military uniform.
The nameplate in front of him reads "Guo Shimin, Director of the Equipment Department of the 120th Military Hospital".
The manufacturers began whispering amongst themselves.
Military region bidding and provincial bidding are on equal footing and are usually conducted separately. They did not expect that the provincial procurement would invite experts from military hospitals to serve as judges.
"The 120th Military Hospital is Grade A Tertiary Hospitals, so Director Guo should be very knowledgeable about equipment."
"Why would they invite people from a military hospital? The two are completely unrelated. Is it perhaps to show fairness?"
"It's possible. After all, this is an open tender. If it's an open tender, it's easy for things to be manipulated behind the scenes. Inviting a neutral person would make it more convincing."
"Do you think it's possible that military hospitals are also going to put out bidding processes, and Director Guo is here to check things out?"
"We're all old acquaintances; it's always the same faces at every bidding process. What's so interesting about that?"
"This time is different. Didn't you notice a new face?"
"Hiss! Now that you mention it, does that mean Director Guo came here specifically for the Portable Color Ultrasound that Three Purities released?"
"It's not impossible, we'll see in a bit."
"Don't think too much, just focus on the present and think about how to win the bid."
After some discussion, the manufacturers were immediately invigorated. If they could win the bid this time and leave a deep impression on the experts at the military hospital, they might be able to receive large orders from the military region in the future.
At 9:00 AM sharp, an official from the Health Commission took the stage and said, "Welcome everyone to participate in Su Province's medical imaging equipment bidding. I am the person in charge of this bidding. Our order this time is for 200 color Doppler ultrasound and 100 DR machines, which are divided into three packages for bidding..."
Soon, the person in charge finished explaining the bidding process.
This tender was conducted in an open bidding format. After the bids were opened, the review experts would examine each bid and ask questions of the manufacturers.
The judges sat at the front of the conference room and began to carefully review each bid. Their main responsibility was to give technical scores to each medical device company.
As for the price score, it is given by the National Health Commission, and the final score is calculated by weighted average.
The one with the highest score will win the bid.
Soon, the judges began asking questions of the manufacturer, mainly about technical details, to reconfirm the requirements based on the procurement criteria.
First, I contacted the DR manufacturer, and then the color Doppler ultrasound manufacturer.
Perhaps because the products procured this time were all mid-range and the technology was nothing special, the experts didn't have many questions.
It wasn't long before it was the turn of the Three Purities.
This time, the judges did not ask questions immediately. Instead, they looked at the tender documents again and again, and remained silent for a long time.
After a long while, an expert with graying hair wiped his glasses and spoke with an incredulous expression.
"Is there a mistake in Three Purities's tender document? It clearly shows the technical parameters for a high-end color Doppler ultrasound, so why are they bidding for Portable Color Ultrasound?"
"Cardiac Ultrasound and 4D Gynecological Ultrasound are not functions that ordinary Portable Color Ultrasound have. Shouldn't you be bidding for Desktop Color Ultrasound?"
"Even the Desktop Color Ultrasound far exceeds our standards. Didn't you carefully read the bidding requirements?"
"Our technical requirements for Portable Color Ultrasound are: to achieve digital two-dimensional grayscale imaging, color Doppler unit, independently adjustable frequency band, two probes, with specifications of high-frequency linear array and convex array abdominal probe, and the convex array probe has an effective number of ≥128 oscillators."
"Your technical parameters are completely out of the ordinary. Not only are there three probes, but the physical channels are also as high as 256. There is also 3D Imaging and real-time dynamic images, and even 4D True Skin Rendering."
Could you please provide a further explanation?
Lu Tingfeng straightened his back, raised his head, and revealed a confident smile as he spoke eloquently.
"That's right. Sanqing Group has only developed one general-purpose full-body high-end Portable Color Ultrasound. The technical parameters provided are all genuine. We have indeed incorporated the functions of a high-end color Doppler ultrasound into Portable Color Ultrasound."
"This product has been well received by many hospitals. We have already sold more than 200 units, which is enough to prove that its functions are real and there is nothing false."
"We mainly have only one product, which has been perfected in terms of functionality and has achieved a perfect balance between performance and practicality. So we can only offer this one for bidding. There is no need to cut out features and create a bunch of low-end versions, youth versions, or the like."
"As for why we bid for the Portable Color Ultrasound, it was the result of our careful consideration. It looks like it, works like it, and is indeed a Portable Color Ultrasound. We couldn't possibly bid for Desktop Color Ultrasound."
The old expert pondered for a moment, then chuckled and said, "What you said makes sense. It seems I'm getting old and can't keep up with the latest technological developments."
"I naturally appreciate that Three Purities can make such a good Portable Color Ultrasound, but I'm a little worried that such advanced features will exceed my budget."
Lu Tingfeng patted his chest and said, "You can rest assured that our price is absolutely reasonable and within the budget for Portable Color Ultrasound."
The old expert stopped talking and focused on reviewing the tender documents again.
After hearing Three Purities's explanation, the other experts all showed a hint of curiosity. Another expert in his forties casually asked, "Since it's Portable Color Ultrasound, did you bring a sample machine with you?"
Lu Tingfeng nodded, took a small silver box from his subordinate's backpack, and walked up to place it in front of the expert.
This small box is made of stainless steel, is compact and exquisite, and has a handle so you can carry it around anytime.
Inside, there is a tablet, a color Doppler ultrasound machine, three probes, a charger, a data cable, and other items.
Everything is neatly categorized and placed in its designated compartment, making it clear and easy to see at a glance.
"Huh?" Several experts' eyes lit up immediately, and one of them immediately picked up the Portable Color Ultrasound and examined it carefully, looking like he couldn't put it down.
"This is a specially provided case. Once the lid is closed, you can take it anywhere at any time."
"Look, this 10-inch tablet has a touchscreen. You can zoom in and out to view images and operate it with the touchscreen. There's a clip on the back, so it can stand upright on a table, and the magnet on it can also be attached to the lid of a car, the car body, etc., for easy viewing."
As Lu Tingfeng demonstrated, he explained, "It comes with a wireless charger, but of course, wired charging is also possible..."
His explanation only heightened the experts' curiosity.
Someone immediately opened Portable Color Ultrasound, placed it around their neck, and began the examination.
This can actually be considered as experts conducting on-site testing of the new equipment to see if it meets the requirements.
After each expert had a chance to try it out, they all had excited expressions on their faces.
Director Guo of the military hospital, who had maintained a serious and authoritative expression, couldn't help but become excited and bombarded him with questions about technical details.
"Is this thing durable? The screen is LCD, isn't it easy to break?"
"Your box is quite good. It's very convenient, keeps things neat and tidy, and is also quite lightweight."
Are there multiple measurement and analysis software options available?
What is the maximum imaging depth in centimeters?
"Besides convex array probes, linear array probes, and area array probes, are there any other types of probes? For example, intracavitary probes?"
"Can you offer in-depth customization?"
Upon hearing the last question, Lu Tingfeng immediately recalled Director Guo's background and couldn't help but give him a deep look.
Director Guo was also staring at him, grinning and giving him a meaningful smile.
Lu Tingfeng's heart skipped a beat. He didn't dare to think too much and quickly gave his answers one by one.
The five experts nodded in satisfaction and exchanged glances with each other.
The elderly expert with graying hair said, "Your answer is very comprehensive. I have no further questions."
Director Guo reluctantly put down the color Doppler ultrasound machine in his hand and praised, "It is indeed a good product, and I have no doubts about it."
"Alright, there are no technical issues," the Health Commission official said. "Next, we'll reveal the price."
He opened the commercial part of the tender document, which contained the specific bid price.
As I looked through them one by one, I kept nodding in approval. Basically, all the manufacturers' quotations met my requirements and were within my budget.
In that case, he can simply choose the one with the lowest price.
Actually, he was a little disappointed because after seeing the performance of Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound, he no longer had any expectations for Three Purities's price.
Such a high-end color Doppler ultrasound must be more expensive than my budget.
However, when he opened Three Purities's business tender documents and saw the price, his eyes widened in surprise, and he exclaimed.
"200,000 per unit?"
"That's impossible!"
He suddenly stood up and looked at Lu Tingfeng in disbelief.
"Your Three Purities brand quotes 200,000 yuan per unit? Really?"
"Are you sure it's a 4D Portable Color Ultrasound? The same one that was used for the sample?"
The head of the National Health Commission exclaimed in surprise and asked several times before confirming the number.
"Wow!" He sat down again, his expression now a mixture of surprise and delight.
The bidding for Portable Color Ultrasound is now a foregone conclusion.
Three Purities will definitely win the bid; at a similar price, it's far superior in terms of performance.
If not this one, who else can we choose?
Seeing the other person's expression, Lu Tingfeng felt much more at ease.
Although he used his authority to offer a super low price, almost a 30% discount, there are still 120 units.
For such a large order, worth over 20 million, a certain discount must be offered.
The prices we previously offered to some Grade A Tertiary Hospitals were discounted because the quantities were quite small.
Li Ting from Mindray watched the entire process and even tried out the Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound himself.
After the trial, he felt despair and a sense of frustration and anger towards his company's color Doppler ultrasound business.
However, he didn't show it and still had a smiling face.
Mindray's main target this time is the Desktop Color Ultrasound, and they have offered a low price close to cost.
Since Portable Color Ultrasound can't compete with Three Purities, they can only stick to the Desktop Color Ultrasound market and try to keep the price as low as possible.
As for DR, they also participated in the bidding, but the competition was fierce, so they didn't have high hopes.
Despite his heartache, he comforted himself with this thought.
The bidding meeting ended quickly, and everyone left one by one, waiting for the results to be announced three days later.
Actually, everyone knows in their hearts that Mindray will probably win the bid for the Desktop Color Ultrasound, and Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound will definitely win the bid, because these two companies have too many advantages.
As for DR, it's hard to say, as the prices of several companies are quite similar, and their technologies are also comparable.
Although Mindray also bid for DR, its advantage is not that great, and it may not be able to compete with the other companies.
It may depend on the power struggles behind the scenes among these manufacturers.
Three days later, the winning bid was announced.
However, everyone was shocked when they saw the announcement and could not believe their eyes.
"What the hell? Portable Color Ultrasound and Desktop Color Ultrasound have all been taken over by Three Purities!"
"DR was given to Mindray? This is probably compensation for Mindray!"
"What's going on? This isn't fair! Why should Three Purities's Portable Color Ultrasound be able to get the same label as the Desktop Color Ultrasound?"
The other manufacturers who participated in the bidding were shocked and also very dissatisfied.
They had thought they would at least get a few pieces of meat, but they didn't even get a sip of soup.
Immediately, some people went to the Health Commission to file a complaint. "We feel this is unfair and hope that the bidding process will be restarted."
After receiving the complaint, the National Health Commission quickly issued a new statement.
"After careful consideration, Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound machine is affordable and powerful, which not only meets the bidding requirements but also provides additional Four-dimensional Ultrasound functions."
"This procurement is mainly for primary healthcare institutions. Portability and price are of great importance. We hope that for the same price, we can have more functions and be applicable to a variety of application scenarios. Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound perfectly meets the requirements."
"As for DR, given that the technical parameters are similar, we chose Mindray because Mindray was the cheapest."
This makes it very clear: I originally wanted to buy Desktop Color Ultrasound, but the Three Purities Portable Color Ultrasound can perfectly replace it, so why would I need Desktop Color Ultrasound?
In terms of price, Portable Color Ultrasound costing 200,000 yuan is much more attractive than Desktop Color Ultrasound costing 500,000 yuan, and the total purchase amount is directly halved.
The 40 million Desktop Color Ultrasound was replaced with a 16 million RMB Portable Color Ultrasound, without any reduction in functionality.
It's absolutely wonderful; anyone would make the same decision.
Moreover, in terms of functionality, Three Purities offers so much more. For the same price, who would choose the low-end when they can use the high-end version?
Of course, this is also due to Three Purities's consistently good reputation.
If you switch to a new company, it certainly won't be that easy.
It will take several years of testing in the market before people can trust it.
With the National Health Commission having made an official statement, the manufacturers couldn't cause any more trouble, otherwise they would offend people, so they had no choice but to leave feeling extremely frustrated.
Upon hearing the news, Lu Tingfeng was overjoyed, his smile practically stretching to the back of his head.
"Haha, another big order for 200 units!"
"I feel so awesome! Let me put my hands on my hips for a bit!"
However, his joy was short-lived, as he received another phone call.
"Director Guo, hello."
"What? The military is also interested in Portable Color Ultrasound?"
"Do we need to visit them in person for a detailed discussion and further customization?"
After hanging up the phone, Lu Tingfeng was completely stunned.
After a long while, he finally realized what was happening and jumped up and ran out.