Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
Stepping into the Unscientific
Chapter 321

On the Matter of This Chapter Containing a Lot of Popular Science, and the Third Time I've Recommended Subscribing with Caution

3,650 words 12 min read 0 views 1mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

"Newton turning in his grave?"

In the activity room.

Hearing that word come out of Xu Yun's mouth.

The audience members couldn't help but whisper among themselves, and soon a buzzing discussion arose again.

About half a minute later.

A tall, thin boy with buck teeth tentatively raised his hand, his expression somewhat awkward, clearly indicating he wasn't good at interacting with people.

"Luo Feng, my father was a mausoleum builder who served the royal family and was responsible for making the coffins of many royal members."

"So if needed, my father might be able to help."

Xu Yun raised an eyebrow upon hearing this. He hadn't expected to actually find someone who could make coffin boards for the royal family.

He then looked at the other person and politely asked:

"Excuse me, may I ask your name?"

The buck-toothed boy puffed out his chest:

"Ikosetin Wallace"

Xu Yun nodded to him, organized his thoughts, gestured a framework in the air with his hands, and then said:

"In that case, Wallace, I wonder if your father could polish a marble slab the size of Newton's coffin lid?"

"This stone slab is about five centimeters thick, and its surface is finely polished to a smooth finish, without the slightest wrinkle."

Wallace's eyes flickered a few times, as if he were considering the feasibility, then he stroked his chin hesitantly and said:

"There's no problem with the craftsmanship. My father has been in the business for many years, and his skills and reputation are impeccable. To this day, there hasn't been a single negative review of the deceased."

"However, Luo Feng, you should know that the process of developing marble is not easy."

"The cost of producing stone slabs of this size and precision would be considerable."

Snap--

Wallace had barely finished speaking.

A money pouch landed in front of him, and at the same time, Evelyn's voice rang out:

"Wallace, there are ten two Pound Sterling coins in your purse, totaling twenty pounds."

"Consider this money a deposit. If the finished product meets the standards, I will give you an additional thirty pounds. Are there any further questions?"

Based on the exchange rate mentioned earlier.

£20 in 1850 is roughly equivalent to more than 15,000 yuan in today's currency. (I was typing all night yesterday and my brain is all muddled; £100,000 should be around 80 million yuan.)

Even in 1850, when industrial precision was relatively underdeveloped, this amount of money was enough to persuade royal artisans to personally handle the project.

Not to mention, you'll receive a final payment of £30 after delivery, making it a total of £50!

At the same time, if I give my father a discount and quote him £10, I can still get a £40 commission as a middleman.

Therefore, Wallace was only slightly taken aback before quickly putting away the money bag and patting his chest, saying:

"No problem, Luo Feng, Senior Evelyn, don't worry, go find my father after the meeting!"

Upon seeing this, Xu Yun subconsciously turned his head and exchanged a glance with Evelyn.

The young heiress's expression remained unchanged, but the corners of her mouth curled up slightly, as if she were telling Xu Yun something:

Go ahead and do whatever you want, I'll pay for it!

A true ATM girl.

Xu Yun then withdrew his gaze, pondered for a few seconds, and pulled out a blackboard from behind him—although there weren't many sophisticated instruments in this activity room, it wasn't difficult to equip it with a blackboard.

Then he picked up the chalk.

Two spheres, one large and one small, were drawn on the blackboard and labeled Earth and the Sun respectively.

"Class, I have one more question for you."

"Can anyone tell me what the linear velocity of the Earth's revolution around the Sun is?"

Soon.

A chubby student raised his hand; it was easy to tell from the badge on his chest that he was also a student of Trinity College.

"Luo Feng, that's about 30 kilometers per second."

Xu Yun nodded and snapped his fingers in satisfaction:

Bingo!

Those who knew Kepler in their past lives should know this.

The Earth's orbital speed was calculated as early as Kepler's time, and the specific value is approximately 29.8 kilometers per second.

Its calculation principle is very simple; simply put, it's the orbital length divided by the period.

The formula for calculating the orbit is L=2πα(1-0.25×e^2), which is the transformation formula for calculating the length of the ellipse.

In the formula, L is the length of the orbit, α is the semi-major axis of the orbit, and e is the orbital eccentricity.

As for the cycle, there are many more options.

It can be used as a reference point, either by using distant stars or by using the point where the sun is directly overhead.

Divide the two.

This allows us to obtain the linear velocity of the Earth's revolution around the sun.

The orbital linear velocity calculated in 1850 is almost identical to the results calculated in later periods, with an average value of 29.783 kilometers per second.

The Earth rotates more slowly, at 466 meters per second.

Of course.

At this point, some readers might have a question:

That's not right.

Revolution is one thing.

But why do I not feel the Earth's rotation so fast?

The reason is simple:

Because of it.

It's too thin.

Anyone who passed high school physics should know this.

a = ωR.

And ω is equal to 2π/T.

Here, T stands for one day, which is 24 x 3600 seconds.

If you incorporate the Earth's radius of 6375 kilometers into the calculation, the final self-centering acceleration you get is only 3.3 cm/s².

How could anyone possibly perceive numbers of that magnitude?

It's so thin, so thin that it's already inside your body, yet you don't feel a thing.

In fact, it's not just Earth that's so small; in the face of the vast cosmos, we are all insignificant.

A very simple example:

As is widely known.

The entire universe is expanding at an accelerating rate; this is the result currently measured.

The Hubble constant is 67.80 + 0.77/Mpc.

What does this number mean?

This means that galaxies in the universe are moving at a speed of 67.8 kilometers per second, with a deviation of 0.77 kilometers, at a distance of 3.26 million light-years.

At 67.8 kilometers per second, that's much faster than the linear speed of the Earth's revolution around the sun.

The reason we can't perceive it visually is explained by the phrase "3.26 million light-years" mentioned earlier in the sentence above:

The distances between galaxies are too great.

Even at the closest distance, it would take light 3.26 million years to travel.

This distance is so great that no matter how the universe expands, the celestial bodies visible to the naked eye still seem to remain motionless.

Meanwhile, the sun is also revolving around the Milky Way center of the Milky Way.

Current observations indicate that the Sun is located on the edge of the Orion Arm of the Milky Way, approximately 26,000 light-years from the Milky Way center.

The sun is currently moving towards the constellation Cygnus, with an orbital speed of approximately 220 kilometers per second. (As an aside, there's a NASA website that simulates the sun's movement daily, although the movement is practically invisible to the naked eye; the URL is 3W.)

The time it takes for the Sun to orbit the Milky Way is approximately 195,043,948,000 hours, or about 222.5 million years.

The sun was born approximately 4.6 billion years ago.

Therefore, it can be said that:

The sun has orbited the Milky Way 20 times since its birth and is currently on its 21st orbit.

Okay, let's get back to reality.

After the chubby boy gave the answer.

Xu Yun then drew an arrow on the blackboard along the direction of the Earth's rotation, labeled it '30km/s', and said to everyone:

"This student's answer is absolutely correct. Now let's return to our original intention, which is Aether."

"According to Descartes's view, all celestial bodies are now rotating and revolving within overlapping vortices, Aether the Aether itself is absolutely still."

"So, if that's the case, when the Earth is orbiting the sun at a speed of 30 kilometers per second, it must be encountering an 'Aether wind' blowing towards it at a speed of 30 kilometers per second."

"At the same time, it must also affect the propagation of light, that is, change the speed of light, am I right?"

No one raised their hand to answer this time, but most people nodded.

Just like how qigong and superpowers were divided into many 'schools' in the 1990s.

These days, the scientific community also has three different views on the relationship between the medium of motion and Aether.

The first method involves the medium completely dragging the Aether.

Its proposer was none other than Xu Yun and Xiao Mai's cheap mentor.

Stokes.

It was proposed in 1845, when Stokes was only 26 years old and had just graduated.

The second type is where the medium does not drag the Ethernet at Aether.

The person who proposed this idea is quite outrageous:

His name is Kevin Husky—this is a real person, written as Husky in English, without any transliteration.

The third method involves dragging the Aether.

This refers to Fresnel's partial drag hypothesis, proposed in 1818, which is quite famous.

Both "dragging the Aether completely" and "not dragging the Aether at all" are easy to understand; they mean exactly what they say.

The former believes that the movement of the medium in the Aether is like a bulldozer pushing soil, and that it will push all the Aether away as it "moves forward".

The latter argues that it's like a net moving in water, having absolutely no effect on the Aether.

In fact.

The most influential hypothesis in 1850 was actually the third one, Fresnel's partial drag hypothesis.

This means that the medium of motion moves within the Aether, neither taking nothing nor carrying away all of the Aether, but rather only taking away a portion of it.

How much was towed away?

Fresnel believed this was related to the refractive index of the medium.

The higher the refractive index, the more Aether it carries.

The specific drag coefficient is 1 - 1/n, where n is the refractive index of the medium.

For example, if the refractive index of air is approximately 1, then the drag coefficient of air is 1 - 1/1 = 0.

In other words, air does not drag the Aether.

The refractive index of water is approximately 1.33, so the drag coefficient of water is approximately 1 - 1/1.33 ≈ 0.43.

In other words...

If the water moves relative to the Aether at a speed of v, it will drag the Aether at a speed of 0.43v.

This statement is not difficult to understand, but it has spawned countless monsters and demons in later generations. (I strongly suggest you take a look here; the following content can be said to be the source of various theories proposed by 90% of amateur physicists in later generations.)

Because after Fresnel proposed this theory, Fizeau, the genius who calculated the speed of light, came up with a water flow experiment.

The core of Fizeau's flow experiment is very simple:

It involves making one beam of light move with the water and another beam move against the water, with the two beams moving in opposite directions.

Then, by using interference patterns, the time difference caused by their different speeds is measured.

However, Fresnel did not use two beams of light; instead, he achieved his goal using a curved water pipe.

Why is there a time difference?

As mentioned above.

According to Fresnel's partial drag hypothesis, when water flows, it drags the Aether at a speed of 0.43v.

If the Aether is in motion, then the speed of light will naturally change accordingly.

The speed of light in a vacuum is c, and its speed in water is c/n.

It's not hard to imagine.

If light travels against the current of water, then the speed of light observed on the ground is the speed of light in water, c/n, minus the speed at which the Aether is dragged, ku.

That is, (c/n)-ku.

Similarly.

The speed of light moving downstream should be the speed of light in water, c/n, plus the speed at which the Aether is dragged, ku.

That is, (c/n) + ku.

In this case.

When two beams of Light Wave meet again, they will form certain interference fringes.

If you reverse the flow of water.

In other words, if you turn the outlet into the inlet and the inlet into the outlet, the time it takes for the two beams of light to travel will change.

And so...

The interference fringes they form will also change, specifically by shifting the fringes slightly.

To Fizeau's surprise, the final result was exactly as expected.

In other words, Fresnel's theory can well explain Fizeau's flowing water experiment, and the two theories corroborate each other.

Now for the main event.

Therefore, some amateur scientists in later generations often use this to "beat down" relativity and Einstein's theory.

Any article, or let's call it a thesis, that claims to have overturned relativity, proven the existence of Aether, demonstrated that the speed of light is variable, or shown that superposition of faster-than-light speeds is possible, will invariably include one sentence:

"Fizeau experiment proved the error of relativity, so aba aba aba."

Almost all amateur scientists—aside from the oddballs who draw a Taiji diagram and claim to have created Perpetual Motion Machine —at least 90% of their so-called theories originate from Fizeau's water flow experiment.

Just as the Xuanwu Gate Incident is invariably mentioned when discussing Li Shimin, Fizeau's water flow experiment has almost become a pseudo-scientific verification code.

The funniest thing was...

Some pseudo-scientists are trying to smear Lao Ai.

He even said things like, "Before 1905, Einstein might not have known about the Fizeau experiment, or he might not have realized that the experiment proved the speed of light was variable. If he had known about the Fizeau experiment, he wouldn't have proposed the theory of relativity based on the constancy of the speed of light."

But in reality...

In a conversation with Professor Shankland in 1950, Einstein mentioned two experiments that had the greatest impact on his development of the special theory of relativity.

The first is the optical aberration experiment.

The principle of slash aberration is very simple; everyone has experienced this when it rains:

Under windless conditions.

If you stand still in the rain, you will feel as if the raindrops are falling directly overhead.

But if you run forward, you'll feel the raindrops falling on you at an angle from in front of you.

This is actually a kind of "poor performance in rain".

The Earth's motion, which is its revolution around the sun at a speed of about 30 km/s, is similar to the feeling of raindrops tilting when running in the rain.

An observer will also perceive that the light emitted by a star is tilted at a certain angle; this is called stellar aberration.

This principle was eventually applied by Bradley to the calculation of the speed of light; he was the misunderstood astronomer mentioned earlier in the discussion of the speed of light measurement.

Another experiment that had the greatest impact on Einstein was Fizeau's flowing water experiment.

Therefore, the claim that Einstein did not understand the Fizeau experiment was wrong from the beginning.

So what's the truth?

To paraphrase a certain Detective Conan, there is only one truth:

Not only did Einstein understand Fizeau's experiment, but he had also explained Fizeau's flowing water experiment long ago without adding Aether.

And it is a more perfect explanation than Fresnel's theory.

His approach was based on the Lorentz transformation, starting with the velocity superposition of the water system and the ground system.

In addition, some calculations that are rarely understood by Classmate Xian Weiren were used to, ultimately leading to a first-order approximation of the velocity transformation in special relativity, which perfectly explained Fizeau's flowing water experiment.

From the perspective of special relativity...

The Fizeau experiment was not due to the Aether being partially dragged, but rather a natural result of the velocity superposition in the Lorentz transformation.

This part was written by Einstein in "On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies," the same article in which he published his theory of special relativity.

These pseudo-scientists haven't even read Einstein's masterpiece, yet they confidently deny his theory of relativity. Isn't that absurd?

Xu Yun had encountered a similar situation in his previous life.

At the time, a video creator who knew Xu Yun recommended his book, and someone left a comment below:

"What's so interesting about a novel that's just copied from Baidu?"

To be honest.

Xu Yun almost burst out laughing.

Theoretically, any reader who has even read a few chapters of that book wouldn't say such a thing— Xu Yun has criticized Baidu countless times.

Saying he copied CNKI is more like it, cough cough.

It's fine to reject a work or theory, but at least take a look at the content—that's not excessive, is it?

Furthermore, compared to relativity, Fresnel's theory is actually the one with flaws.

For example.

Just as classical physics applies to the macroscopic, low-speed world, Fresnel's theory only applies when the speed of flowing water is much less than the speed of light.

When the speed approaches the speed of light, and when u/c can no longer be ignored, using the partial drag hypothesis will lead to incorrect conclusions.

The results of special relativity remain correct.

What Fresnel's theory can explain, relativity can also explain.

What it cannot explain, relativity can.

This is what a better theory should look like.

Indeed.

Both general and special relativity currently have some aspects that are difficult to explain.

Or rather, the key point in theory.

For example, if Grand Unification theory emerges, relativity will most likely become, like classical physics, an approximation and a specific solution under certain circumstances.

You could even say that.

If humanity is still alive 500 years from now, relativity will almost certainly be replaced by a new theory.

But that's five hundred years from now, not now.

Each era has its own theoretical support. Humans can't even land on Mars yet, and we're already preparing to switch to a different theoretical framework?

Isn't this ridiculous?

Perspective and reality are two different things.

As things stand, relativity remains the optimal solution for the present moment.

The scientific community today has chosen relativity not because it is the truth, an absolutely correct and unquestionable golden rule.

Rather, it's because relativity is the most accurate, widely applicable, and internally consistent theory among all current theories describing the universe, matching various observable experiments very well.

For example, QED has now been proven to be accurate to the seventh decimal place, and wide-angle imaging has even been applied to GPS.

Unfortunately, some amateur scientists completely ignore these points.

They treat science like theology, immersing themselves in their own world.

Use intuition, which everyone can understand, to oppose science that most people don't understand.

How tragic.

Alright.

Let's return to reality.

Looking at the many puzzled students below the stage, Xu Yun snapped his fingers again:

"Dear students, as you all know, a few months ago we measured the speed of light to an extremely precise range."

"So, given this, could we set up an experiment to verify the hypothesis that Aether and the speed of light are variable?"

After saying that, he picked up the chalk again, drew an arrow on the blackboard pointing from the sun to the earth, and continued:

"Look, everyone!"

"If Aether exists, then when the Earth revolves around the Sun through the Aether, the speed of light measured in the direction of the Earth's motion through the Aether should be greater than the speed of light measured in the direction perpendicular to the motion."

"Is this alright?"

A chorus of affirmative replies came from the audience:

"No problem."

Seeing this, Xu Yun looked around and smiled slightly:

"In that case..."

"Can we use some methods to prove this by comparing specific numerical values?"

He then opened another page, preparing to draw a diagram.

But just as I was about to put pen to paper...

He suddenly clicked his tongue, stopped what he was doing, and turned to look at the crowd below the stage:

"Dear students, the motto of our Ge Wu Society is 'Gewu Zhizhi,' which emphasizes exploring the world through practice."

"Therefore, one of our goals is to improve everyone's practical skills."

"So I have an idea."

"Let's set aside the question of whether Aether exists for now and instead discuss from an experimental perspective how to design this experiment to achieve the goal I'm referring to."

After saying that, he put down the chalk and stopped talking.

In fact, according to Xu Yun's original idea...

In the following blackboard writing.

He would then fully demonstrate his experimental plan, allowing everyone to try it out.

However, just a few seconds ago, he changed his mind.

After all, barring any unforeseen circumstances

This should be the last experiment I conduct in the instance.

Both morally and logically, we should leave some "legacy" for this era.

Following the normal trajectory.

The first comprehensive laboratory in the history of modern science was not established until 1871 by Xiao Mai.

Before that, the scientific community did not have much of a concept of guiding students to conduct experiments.

This is clearly the wrong approach.

In some ways, the impact of this perception is worse than that of certain erroneous theories.

Therefore, I hesitated repeatedly.

Xu Yun decided to set a precedent and guide the members of the Ge Wu Society to complete this experimental design.

The moment these words were spoken, the audience fell silent.

It's obvious.

Xu Yun's actions were somewhat beyond everyone's expectations.

But soon...

After everyone came to their senses, a glint appeared in everyone's eyes.

Restlessness and eagerness to try.

After all, the reason these members joined the Ge Wu Society was largely due to the atmosphere at the Pluto Night event.

They also hope that one day they can, like the members of the Calculation Group, personally unravel the mysteries of the universe.

Therefore, rather than receiving complete knowledge, they prefer to participate in it personally.

So after Xu Yun suggested brainstorming, the atmosphere at the scene immediately became lively.

A few seconds passed.

The first member raised his hand:

"Luo Feng, I have some ideas."

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Explore the wiki

Xu Yun

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS