"Why, why did this happen?"
"Where is the Aether? Where is the Aether?!"
"God, show me your grace, tell me this is not true."
"You are one by one."
Next to the Michelson interferometer.
Looking at the First Regiment scene before him, Xu Yun suddenly felt a strange sense of déjà vu:
At this very moment.
The image board next to him seemed like an inscription with the word "Dian" engraved on it, with the word "Ether" written on it, and the year of his birth and death engraved in the lower left corner:
243 BC – 1851.11.5
As for these authorities or nobles from various industries who stood beside the imaging panel, trembling all over, or even collapsing to the ground and wailing in tears.
These are the mourners who weep and wail before the altar.
Huh?
This seems to match Evelyn's previous outfits.
Just as Xu Yun was sighing.
Specifically, he was about two body lengths away.
An elderly man with gray hair, who had been staring blankly at the imaging panel, suddenly stood up abruptly.
He darted to Xu Yun's side, grabbed Xu Yun's collar with both hands, and cried out to him in despair:
"It's you, it must be you! You must have tampered with this equipment, right?!"
Looking at the elderly man with a heavy Apennine Peninsula accent, Xu Yun let him grab his collar without taking any countermeasures.
Firstly, the other party is already quite old, and making a move could easily harm them.
Secondly, his name is
Ammodio Avogadro.
That's right.
It's Avogadro, the Avogadro constant.
This is a highly respected figure in the history of science, and he was not the Laozi who put pressure on Evelyn.
From a mathematical perspective, the relationship between supporters and pressurers of the Aether theory, as well as Laozi, is actually that of a set and its subset.
The latter is 95% a subset of the former, but the former is not necessarily the latter.
Avogadro's presence here was not to pressure Evelyn, but because Xu Yun had helped Faraday calculate the charge-to-mass ratio of electrons, a discovery that was crucial to his success.
And so...
This molecular expert, despite his declining health, traveled a great distance to Cambridge University to join in the fun.
Who would have thought?
This unfortunate person is just like the middle-aged woman in a news story from later times.
I heard about the fire on my way home from get off work and came to join the fun, only to find out that it was my own house that was on fire.
In fact, there were quite a few people at the scene similar to Avogadro.
For example, as mentioned earlier.
Both Xiao Mai and Old Tang Tom are supporters of the Aether theory. In the original timeline, Old Tang even tried to save the Aether theory on several important occasions.
To some extent.
The foundation of the Aether theory even surpasses that of later relativity:
Because Aether is just a simple and easy-to-understand model, somewhat similar to dark matter in later generations, it does not involve too much calculation or professional knowledge.
To truly understand and learn relativity, a very high level of mathematical foundation is required.
Therefore, it is not surprising to see someone like Avogadro at the scene.
Let's return to reality.
Avogadro gripped Xu Yun's collar tightly, his gaze seemingly fierce, but Xu Yun saw despair, even more so, in his eyes.
A single plea.
He seemed to be hoping that Xu Yun would admit that he had indeed tampered with the interferometer.
But the only response he received was a soft sigh from Xu Yun:
"I'm sorry, Mr. Avogadro, I really didn't make any changes to the interferometer."
"You should already have the answer to that."
Upon hearing this Avogadro murmured a few times, then suddenly relaxed, weakly releasing his grip on Xu Yun's collar.
The previously feigned aura, like that of an enraged lion, vanished instantly.
While Avogadro is widely known as a chemistry genius, few are aware that Avogadro was equally accomplished in physics.
Avogadro was appointed professor of physics at the Royal Academy of Vercelli in 1809, and in 1820 he became professor of mathematics and physics at the University of Turin.
He didn't officially retire until last year.
Therefore, long before it was opened.
He had actually guessed Xu Yun's answer.
It's just that deep down he's never dared to, or perhaps he's unwilling to, believe it.
At this very moment.
Standing in front of Xu Yun was only a disheveled, dejected old man.
Looking at the dejected Avogadro, and then at the other dejected bigwigs not far away.
Xu Yun sighed again.
This is the cruel reality of the history of science.
Every major revolution in the history of human science has essentially involved tearing down the existing edifice and then rebuilding it from the ruins.
The seemingly glamorous edifice of physics that exists in later generations hides countless stories of desolation and despair beneath its surface.
Just as Xu Yun and Avogadro remained silent, a middle-aged man in his early thirties walked towards them.
This person was somewhat overweight, with slightly bulging cheeks.
With his short hair, he appears to be a very upright person.
However, in stark contrast to the newcomer's upright appearance was his hostile tone from the very first word:
"Damn it, Luo Feng, right? I've already discovered the flaws in your experiment!"
Looking at the man in front of him who was making such a firm promise, Xu Yun couldn't help but smile as well.
Earlier, while welcoming guests, Xu Yun and Evelyn had sat under a tree, listening to the rich woman ramble on about the "crimes" of every stressed Laozi or son.
There were many visitors, but Xu Yun only remembered a few.
The man in front of them had a striking appearance, somewhat resembling a square-faced monkey from later times, making him highly recognizable.
Therefore, when Evelyn introduced the many guests, Xu Yun did take note of their identities.
This man's name is Georgia Terry, he's Britain, and he's a typical stress guy.
According to Evelyn's ramblings.
This guy writes an article criticizing Evelyn's personal life almost every Saturday, like a gamer in later times scheduling a weekend raid.
At the same time.
This person differs from Doppler and Clausius in that...
Although Doppler and his team are Laozi pressure, their own abilities are still quite high.
One of them discovered the Doppler effect and became the first professor of physics at the University of Vienna.
Another was one of the founders of thermodynamics, who proposed the concept of entropy.
Although their status is far inferior to that of the Little Ox, they have still made their mark on history.
But it's Georgia Terry.
He was just a newspaper editor; he hadn't even gone to university.
He managed to become a member of the raid group by virtue of his editor status, and frantically used Evelyn to farm achievements.
Based on Evelyn's description of this person's personality, they probably weren't just looking for a casual chat, right?
As expected.
After arriving in front of Xu Yun.
Georgia Trevor waved the Abacus paper propped up on a wooden board in her hand and said to Xu Yun with an exaggerated expression:
"Luo Feng, I've found the flaw in your experiment, you despicable scoundrel!"
He then strode to the interferometer's optical arm, clapped his hands a few times in the air, and shouted loudly to those around him:
"Gentlemen, please look at me, I have something to announce!"
"I, Georgia Terry, have discovered a flaw in Luo Feng's experiment!"
"Aether still exists, and the advantage remains with me!"
Georgia Terry's words were particularly clear in the somewhat deathly silent scene, instantly spreading throughout the open space.
Upon hearing this...
Including the dejected Avogadro.
Many of the previously despairing business leaders regained a glimmer of hope, and whispers of discussion began to rise:
"God, has a savior appeared?"
"Really? Someone has found a loophole in the experiment?"
"With so many experts on site failing to spot the error, can he really do it?"
"What's his name?"
"I can't reach it."
Seeing all the gazes fixed on him, Georgia Terry couldn't help but puff out his chest proudly.
After everyone had gathered, he pointed to the optical arm of the interferometer and said:
"As you can see, if we draw a circle with any point O as the center, and the arms OM1 and OM2 are perpendicular to each other and of equal length with high precision, what kind of shape will appear?"
The answer is an isosceles right triangle.
"Because the Earth is in motion, when the light travels from O to M2, the interferometer's mirror M2 has already moved to the return path point A. From A, it is reflected back to the path point B, and the light finally reaches the receiver R."
"Therefore, the distance that light actually travels in the OM2 arm is exactly the distance between the two legs of the isosceles triangle OAB."
"But what if the light is interfered with by the Aether during this process?"
"Don't forget, since light can form interference fringes on the imaging plate, it means that it exhibits wave properties in this experiment."
"It can be calculated using planar optical paths that if the light is interfered with, the two optical arms cannot actually be perpendicular."
"In this way, although the length of the optical arm remains the same, the actual optical path difference will be shortened."
Having said that...
Georgia Terry pointed at Xu Yun and snorted coldly:
"So Luo Feng, your experiment has a huge flaw: you ignored the effect of the Aether on the wave, which affects the optical path difference!"
After saying that, Georgia Terry seemed to remember something and chuckled:
"Unless you can prove that light exhibits a particle state during its movement through the optical arm, and then transforms into a wave state on the imaging plate. Ha!"
After saying that, Georgia Terry burst into laughter as if possessed by the spirit of Chancellor Cao.
Looking at Georgia Terry beside him, who was completely absorbed in his own world, Xu Yun's expression was somewhat...
Subtle.
How to put it
Is this like someone handing you Condom when you're about to go to sleep?
Georgia Terry's analysis is actually quite simple to explain:
Light has both wave and particle properties. The interference fringes that appear in the final stage of the imaging plate indicate that it exhibits wave properties in the experiment.
Waves require a medium to propagate, so who can guarantee that the ether Aether a medium, isn't interfering with the wave?
Aether interferes with the wave, then the perpendicular and planar optical paths will be affected. The angle between the optical arms may appear to be 90°, but in reality it may only be 89.99999°.
Such minute errors cannot be measured with current scientific technology, but they can indeed lead to errors in calculations on the order of the speed of light.
This can be considered a logical closed loop, similar to...
Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
However...
Just as the egg problem can be explained in religion using the concept of creation.
There is also a theoretically possible way to overcome Georgia Terry's problem:
We just need to first use mathematics to refute the computational problems, and then prove that light can exhibit both particle and wave properties in an experiment.
In other words, when light travels along the optical arm, it is in the form of particles and is not affected by the Aether.
When it passes through the beam splitter and hits the imaging plate, it becomes a wave again.
However, in Georgia Terry's view, this situation is absolutely impossible to happen, even if the Little Ox were to revive, they could not achieve this.
Therefore, it was destined to be a problem that Xu Yun was powerless to solve.
Thinking about this...
Xu Yun's gaze towards Georgia Terry immediately became meaningful.
Grateful and gratified.
To be honest.
If this situation, with First Regiment bigwigs in such a state of mourning, continued, he really didn't know how he would be able to successfully launch the third experiment.
Everyone was crying and in despair; how many people would be willing to go with him to the third empty plot of land?
If the experiment on the third empty plot cannot be started, then tonight's main event will be missing a climactic, exciting moment.
The true savior.
Of course.
Before proceeding, it is necessary to refute Georgia Terry's claims from a mathematical perspective.
So Xu Yun thought for a moment, then turned to Xiaomai, who should have been helping Gauss at this moment, but was forced to have a shadow clone due to a mistake by some idiot author, and was in charge of calibrating the Xiao Mai:
"Maxwell, could you please bring me a blackboard? Also, Mr. Thomson, could you please turn on the lights?"
Xiao Mai nodded upon hearing this:
"Clear."
A few minutes later.
Xiao Mai dragged a blackboard back to Xu Yun's side.
A crowd had already gathered around Xu Yun and Georgia Terry, including Avogadro, Doppler, and others.
After the blackboard is properly placed.
Xu Yun glanced at Georgia Terry, picked up a pen, and wrote a few words on the blackboard:
Light source, imaging plate, mirrors m1 and m2.
Then he drew a line under these words and said to those around him:
"Gentlemen, as you can see, these four words are the key to our experiment."
"As for the beam splitter, it is not included since it does not involve mathematical calculations. Is that alright?"
Everyone, including Georgia Terry, nodded.
This is the most direct information, and no one can deny it.
Xu Yun paused for a moment, then said:
"As for the 'light arm' we're talking about, it's actually the whole system consisting of the light source, the mirror, and the line connecting the two."
"At any given moment, the length of the optical arm is constant—or in other words, at any given moment, the distance between the light source and the mirror is a constant."
"Is this alright too?"
His response was still one of agreement.
Having said that...
Xu Yun glanced at Georgia Terry with amusement, a slight smile playing on his lips.
"As for Mr. Georgia Terry's so-called loophole, it can actually be divided into two parts: the vertical optical path and the horizontal optical path."
"Although he mostly focused on discussing vertical optical paths, let's first discuss the mistakes he made when analyzing horizontal optical paths, Maxwell!"
Xiao Mai, standing to the side, was startled upon hearing this:
"Yes, Mr. Luo Feng."
Xu Yun snapped his fingers at him and threw the chalk at him:
"Xiao Mai, give this gentleman a piece of work and tell him exactly where he went wrong."
Xiao Mai nodded upon hearing this, took the chalk, and glanced at Georgia Terry.
After thinking for about half a minute, he wrote two equations on the blackboard:
OM1+M1O.
OM1+Vt1+OM1-V(t11-t1)=2OM1+V(2t1-t11)
Then, an X was put after the first equation.
I put a checkmark after the second equation.
Looking at the two formulas on the blackboard.
One of the mathematics professors in the crowd gasped softly:
"Hiss"
Xiao Mai didn't write much, but there were quite a few real math and science experts present, so her comprehension was excellent.
They understood Xiao Mai's idea immediately after a brief analysis.
Those who have studied high school physics should know this.
The trajectory of an object is different in different frames of reference.
For example, suppose you are on a train; you are a stationary point relative to the train's trajectory.
However, your trajectory relative to the ground reference frame is a straight line.
This principle also applies to optical paths.
The core of the Aether hypothesis lies in its assertion that the speed of light relative to the Aether is constant.
Therefore, if we want to compare the time difference between two beams of light hitting a mirror from a light source and returning to the light source, it is more convenient to choose the Aether as a reference frame.
That's the idea behind Xiao Mai.
When t=0.
Light originates from point O, the light source.
When t=t1.
Light reaches the mirror.
At this point, since the entire experimental setup has moved a certain distance to the right relative to the Aether, the position of the mirror has changed from point M1 to a location on the right side at a distance of Vt1.
Therefore, the length of this optical path is:
OM1+Vt1.
When the light returns to the source.
Suppose that the light returns to the source at t=t11, at which point the source has moved for t11 seconds.
Therefore, the position of the light source is the location to the right of point O, at a distance from Vt11.
This section of the optical path is:
OM1 + Vt1 - Vt11 = OM1 - V(t11 - t1).
Combine the two optical paths.
In the Aether reference frame, the total optical path length of a horizontal light beam should be:
OM1 + Vt1 + OM1 - V(t11 - t1) = 2OM1 + V(2t1 - t11). (This should be correct; please correct me if I'm wrong.)
Georgia Terry's version is OM1+M1O, which is clearly incorrect.
Then Xiao Mai shrugged and pointed to the formula, saying:
"Actually, it's easy to see from this formula that 2t1 is significantly greater than t11, because the journey of light is longer than the return journey."
"When light travels from the light source to mirror one, it is 'chasing' the mirror."
"And when the light source returns from the mirror, the light source is moving towards the light."
Therefore, the time it takes for light to travel from the source to the mirror is longer than the time it takes for light to travel from the mirror back to the source.
"Therefore, Mr. Terry, your analysis is incorrect based solely on the reasoning of the horizontal light path."
Georgia Terry opened her mouth, a hint of panic in her eyes:
"I"
However, Xu Yun didn't give him a chance to explain. Instead, he picked up on Xiao Mai's words and added insult to injury:
"Mr. Terry, the light source, the mirror, and the imaging panel are all moving in the direction of east. Or rather, directly to the right—because they are moving relative to the Aether."
"In other words, the direction of motion of the light source and mirror one is along the straight line between point O and point M1."
"The direction of mirror two's movement is along the straight line between points M2 and A."
"In the Aether frame of reference, since the light ray initially aims at point A, when mirror two is translated from point M2 to point A, the light ray will arrive at point A exactly at point A."
"Then it is reflected back to point B by the mirror, so there is actually no problem with the optical path difference."
"So, Mr. Terry, the flaw you're referring to simply doesn't exist from a mathematical perspective!"
This time.
Many people nodded subconsciously in agreement.
Xu Yun's reasoning was very simple and easy to understand.
For example, if the car you drive has a left wheel and a right wheel, the distance between the left wheel and the right wheel is the width of your car.
That is, the length of the drive rod connecting the left and right wheels is fixed at all times, even when the car is moving.
However, in a ground-based frame of reference...
The distance between the current position of the left wheel and the position of the right wheel two seconds later, and the distance between these two spatial positions, is not equal to the distance between your left and right wheels.
Let's assume this very moment.
A little mouse runs from the left wheel of a car along the drive shaft to the right wheel. The mouse's trajectory relative to the ground is a diagonal line.
The length of this trajectory is not equal to the length of the transmission rod.
This is the optical path difference caused by the reference frame.
Therefore, in mathematics...
The Michelson - Morley experiment already took optical path difference into account.
Of course.
Some students might ask:
Since light travels much faster than a car, is there really no error in this optical path difference?
The answer is actually no.
However, this value is so small that it can be ignored even in the calculation of the speed of light.
This phenomenon is supported by actual data and originates from gravitational waves.
As mentioned before.
The LIGO gravitational wave detector is essentially a larger version of the Michelson-Morley device.
Each LIGO detector has two mutually perpendicular long arms. Using lasers, LIGO can measure the length of the two mutually perpendicular long arms.
LIGO's long arms are actually long tubes in a high vacuum, with mirrors 34 centimeters in diameter suspended at both ends of each arm.
The LIGO detector uses laser interferometry to continuously measure the distance between each pair of mirrors with extremely high precision.
Currently, two LIGO detectors have been built, Across the sea in Washington State and Louisiana State, respectively, 3,000 kilometers apart.
Gravitational waves travel at the speed of light, so if a detectable gravitational wave sweeps across the Earth, the two LIGO detectors will detect the signal with a time difference on the order of 10 milliseconds.
Meanwhile, in Europe, there are two very similar gravitational wave detectors called VIRGO, with multiple detectors working together.
The first detection of gravitational waves from the merger of two black holes was at 5:51 PM Beijing time on September 14, 2015, and was announced on February 11, 2016.
The first detection of gravitational waves from the merger of two Neutron star was on October 16, 2017.
At that time, scientists from many countries, including Huaxia, held simultaneous press conferences.
Several more phenomena were then observed, and the recorded event names were all GW + 6 digits.
In the GW190521 incident, LIGO detected optical path difference for the first time:
The signal source is approximately five gigapasts from Earth—one gigapast is roughly equivalent to 3.26 billion light-years, and the optical path difference is about 27.3% the size of an atom.
By the way.
Gravitational waves were discovered in 2015 and announced in February 2016.
Then, up to GW170814 in September 2017, only four events were observed in total.
That means it's detected on average once every four months.
But can you guess how many gravitational wave events have been detected from September 2017 to November 7, 2021?
The answer is yes.
LIGO 90 times, VIRGO 28 times.
90 + 28, totaling 118 times.
That means it happens on average once every two weeks. (You can find this on the official website by adding three Ws to the beginning; currently, only O3b updates up to November of last year have been released.)
I'll say it again.
Sometimes, the level of technological development really exceeds your expectations.
Alright.
Let's return to the original topic.
To be honest.
Georgia Terry's question is actually quite representative in later generations, and it is one of the powerful 'theories' used by amateur scientists to refute the Michelson-Morley experiment.
It's a shame that these people can't even analyze horizontal light paths, yet they still speak so arrogantly; it's quite laughable.
If some of the problems could be identified simply by calculation, they wouldn't have persisted for so long.
Seeing that the 'loophole' he had found was easily dismantled by Xiao Mai young man, Georgia Terry's face flushed an unhealthy red.
He quickly looked around, but found no one to speak up for him.
After all, mathematics is a subject like that, divided into two extremes, 'one second'.
The first scenario is when you scan the question and within a second realize you know nothing about it and can only write down a solution.
The second "one second" refers to exchanges between industry leaders, where they can immediately determine whether the other person is right or wrong.
For example, the Deduction Process above.
Some people jumped here in a second, shouting that they'd only seen a void and demanding a refund from their little cutie.
Some people understood everything in a second and could even point out certain errors or omissions.
The gap. JPG.
Seeing that she was now isolated and helpless, Georgia Terry took a deep breath and used her last resort:
"Luo Feng, this is just a mathematical derivation; mathematical calculations alone cannot convince people!"
John Cauchy Adams calculated Neptune's orbit in 1843, but until Neptune was discovered in 1846, he was still just a teaching assistant at Cambridge University!
"Unless you can prove that light can exhibit both properties simultaneously during the experiment, the possibility I'm talking about must exist!"
After Georgia Terry finished speaking, several responses suddenly rang out from the crowd:
"Yes, that's possible!"
"I agree with Mr. Terry's opinion!"
"Ah, yes, yes, yes!"
Xu Yun glanced around and found that most of the people who spoke were wealthy and powerful people dressed in fine clothes with badges on their collars.
That's normal.
After all, the theory of Aether was the lifeblood of classical science and also the foundation of the aristocratic system.
The modern school of mathematics led by Gauss has already caused considerable impact on the established classical system. If the Aether theory were to collapse again, the consequences would be unimaginable.
Therefore, even if there is only the slightest chance, these nobles are determined to try to prolong the life of the Aether.
Looking at these die-hard Aether supporters, Xu Yun felt a slight pang of regret.
These nobles and authorities alike.
At this moment, they were all like gamblers, putting all their hopes on a single chip.
However, what they are "betting" on is no longer science or knowledge, but basic logic.
After all, this is true for people of this era.
The properties of light in a given experiment are fixed; it is impossible for light to undergo two different changes in a single experiment.
Thinking about this...
Xu Yun left the interferometer and walked towards the open space on the left.
Xu Yun's action was misinterpreted by Georgia Terry as an attempt to flee, so he quickly shouted:
"That Easterner is trying to escape! Stop him!"
After saying that, he prepared to rush towards Xu Yun.
However, since other members of the Ge Wu Society were still standing there maintaining order, and most people were mindful of their status, they didn't do anything impolite.
And so.
The crowd followed Xu Yun slowly, noisily but barely under control.
Half a minute passed.
Xu Yun arrived at the third open space covered with a black cloth.
He glanced back at the bustling crowd and shook his head:
"They really won't shed a tear until they see the coffin."
That's all.
He then bent down, as if lifting a shroud.
Hoo--
He forcefully dragged the covering cloth over the third open space.
And then the covering was lifted.
The experimental equipment, which had been hidden under the fabric and kept secret by Xu Yun for so long, was finally revealed in its entirety.
"."
At the same time I saw this equipment.
The previously noisy crowd suddenly fell silent.
Swish--
On the stands.
Along with Prince Albert, Faraday, Stokes, and other bigwigs, everyone suddenly stood up:
"What...?!"