Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
Stepping into the Unscientific
Chapter 589

The Authorities Really Were Wrong!

3,529 words 12 min read 0 views 1mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

"Is authority wrong?"

Inside this secret room underground.

As Xu Yun uttered these words...

This time.

It wasn't just Old Guo who was taken aback, but...

The group now gathered around the table, including Lu Guangda and the two men who had previously been at loggerheads.

There is no other reason.

This is because what Xu Yun said was truly impactful.

Was Norris Bradbury's design theory wrong?

How is that possible?

You need to know.

Norris Bradbury was Oppenheimer's handpicked director of the Manhattan Project, and he personally assembled the detonation device for the plutonium at the center of the first Atomic Bomb ever tested in human history.

That's one way to put it.

Aside from Oppenheimer, no one understood Atomic Bomb theory better than Norris Bradbury.

This is a giant who will undoubtedly be recorded in the annals of human scientific history.

He was like a towering mountain standing before everyone, inspiring awe and reverence in all who beheld him—even Old Guo and Lu Guangda felt the same way.

At least for now.

The result was unexpected.

Xu Yun, this 'Foolish Old Man,' suddenly jumped out, pointed at the mountain, and said that its location was wrong and it shouldn't be there.

This is clearly a rather startling statement.

At this moment Xu Yun seemed to be preparing to say something shocking, and facing the astonished crowd, he continued:

"Engineer Guo, Director Lu, why can't authority be wrong?"

"Indeed, Norris Bradbury and Oppenheimer accomplished the Trinity and the Manhattan Project, and their capabilities are beyond question."

"But don't forget, this critical state model of the stationary state is only a cutting-edge theory in Across the sea- Atomic Bomb research, and it has not been technically implemented."

"Therefore, theoretically speaking, why can't Norris Bradbury be wrong?"

"Even."

That brings us to this.

Xu Yun paused deliberately, then looked around:

Is it possible that the theory from Across the sea cannot be iterated upon in application because some aspects of it are actually flawed, thus failing to adapt to reality?

Swish--

After Xu Yun finished speaking...

The area around the table suddenly became so quiet you could hear a pin drop.

This silence, contrasted with the distant sounds of abacuses and conversation, created an extremely subtle scene.

"."

A good while passed.

Lu Guangda finally snapped out of his astonishment and exchanged a glance with Old Guo beside him.

It's no exaggeration to say...

Xu Yun's words were so impactful that they even shook their beliefs.

But on the other hand...

Undeniably.

While Xu Yun's words may be difficult to accept cognitively, they are logically plausible.

According to information proactively released by the Across the sea.

The Manhattan Project used an approximate solution for the Neutron transport equation, namely a parallel SN algorithm in two-dimensional spherical coordinates.

This scheme employs a combination of domain decomposition and parallel pipelines for parallel computation in the spatial-angular direction, achieving a parallel efficiency of approximately 52%.

At the same time, this method has a high error rate; the larger the scale, the more likely errors will occur, and it will inevitably be eliminated.

Therefore, it is similar to choosing to develop a more difficult uranium bomb instead of a plutonium bomb.

The theoretical group led by Lu Guangda rejected this parallel algorithm and prepared to develop their own theory that could be used in the long term.

By the way...

Later, Gaul did not surrender in this regard either, and also abandoned the parallel SN algorithm—but John Bull took a shortcut and continued to use this method.

Then a while later...

Lu Guangda a deep breath, forcing himself to calm down, and asked Xu Yun:

"Comrade Han Li, since you think there's a problem with this model, can you find the part that's wrong?"

"After all, words are not enough; everything needs to be based on evidence."

Xu Yun pondered for a moment upon hearing this, and finally gently shook his head:

"Director Lu, I'm sorry, due to time constraints, I'm definitely not able to find the core error for you."

"After all, I'm not an omniscient and omnipotent god or a time traveler from the future who can know everything in advance."

"However, I'm certain that there's something wrong here at least."

That's all.

Xu Yun extended his index finger and gently pointed to a certain area on the Abacus paper.

Lu Guangda subconsciously peeked over and took a few glances, then paused slightly in surprise:

"High-compression thermonuclear fusion zone?"

Xu Yun nodded, picked up a pen, drew a horizontal line on a parameter, and began to explain:

"Look here, the collapse density is 1.533, right?"

Old Guo nodded.

Xu Yun then picked up his pen again and wrote:

"Look, we first define a transport Mean Free Path, then insert the mean scattering angle cosine, and the neutron will have an extrapolated distance d = 2λtr/3."

"Taking the reciprocal of the characteristic coefficients, without discussing the specific numerical value, the extrapolated number of neutrons will definitely be less than the number of diverging neutrons in the central region A. So how could the calculated number possibly be greater than 1?"

"So it's clear that Norris Bradbury must have underestimated a certain divergence scenario."

Lu Guangda's pupils contracted instantly.

As mentioned before.

This is because the framework was calculated by Norris Bradbury.

Therefore, after obtaining the document and translating it, Lu Guangda and others simply performed a one-time verification before using it directly.

After all, this document had previously spurred many stalled projects, so it couldn't possibly be something like a gas exchange membrane that had been tampered with.

This is similar to designing a physical model using a computer, and one day you happen to get a computer that can be used as a physical machine.

After initial testing, the computer performed without any problems in benchmarking, startup, internet browsing, and downloading videos.

Therefore, although you were curious about its internal structure, you didn't pay attention to the specific components and turned it on to use it because the design of the physical model was more important.

The point Xu Yun made is essentially telling them:

Hi, there's a problem with one of the CPU threads in this computer—it wasn't intentionally tampered with, but rather a flaw that occurred during the manufacturing process, which even the manufacturer might not be aware of.

Thinking about this...

Lu Guangda couldn't help but pick up the manuscript paper and pen in front of Xu Yun and began to read it carefully.

As is widely known.

The framework of the Neutron transport equation is broad, but there are only a few particularly important concepts within it, maybe a dozen or so at most.

And within these concepts...

Logarithmic energy reduction is undoubtedly a very important concept.

It refers to the rate of energy loss of neutrons as they move through matter, expressed as u = lnE0/E.

Where E0 is the energy before neutron scattering, E is the energy after neutron scattering, and u is the logarithmic energy drop.

After having the concept of reduction.

This allows us to define the decrease in the average logarithmic energy of a certain substance.

That is, the average energy drop produced by each scattering of a neutron with this atom:

ξ = Δu ≈ 2/(A + 2/3).

This is an approximate formula for calculating the average energy drop, which can be used for atoms with atomic weight A greater than 10.

This allows us to calculate, on average, how many neutron scatterings are required to reduce the neutron density from E0 to a specified E when a material made of a certain type of atom is used as the target:

Nc=u,ξ=lnE0lnEξ.

For example.

The energy drop of a neutron from 2 MeV (average energy of a fission neutron) to 0.0253 eV is u = lnE1/E2 = 18.1856.

Of course.

The concept of energy reduction has undergone some conceptual iterations in later generations and has been applied more extensively in the field of reactors.

However, this concept is still very mainstream in this era, and it wasn't until the 1980s that versions were updated, both domestically and internationally.

For a neutron that has reduced its energy...

Its 'life' involves two processes: slowing down and diffusion.

The average time for slowing down is called the slowing down time, and the average time for diffusion is called the diffusion time.

Neutron lifetime can be expressed as the slowing time plus the diffusion time—this is addition at a first-grade elementary school level.

In other words...

The time a neutron exists in a single nuclear reaction can be obtained by dividing the free path by the velocity, which is equivalent to integrating over the average energy drop.

We've come this far.

A crucial concept then emerged.

This is also a concept that appears extensively in quantum mechanics, Fluid mechanics, and electrodynamics:

Fluid density, j=ρv.

Fluid density is a quantity that can be used to describe changes in physical quantities within a system.

Its meaning can be discerned from its appearance:

Density multiplied by velocity.

Density represents infinitesimal elements, while velocity is perpendicular to the system boundary, representing infinitesimal elements leaving or entering the system.

In nuclear engineering.

If we take the neutron density as n, then we have the neutron flux density, which is also the neutron current density: neutron = nv neutrons/(ms).

That is, the number of neutrons passing through a unit area per second.

Since neutron flux density can measure the change in neutron levels within a system, and considering that the macroscopic cross section Σ has the physical meaning of reaction probability, we can define the nuclear reaction rate R_neutron as R = Σ_neutron/(ms).

This represents the probability of a nuclear reaction occurring, which is the average number of neutrons reacting per unit volume per unit time.

This concept is very simple and easy to understand.

The point Xu Yun pointed out was that the difference in neutron density between the two steps was abnormal.

Let's use a somewhat inaccurate but easy-to-understand example to describe this situation:

Let's say your name is Li Ziming, and you are studying in Class 2, Grade 3 of an elementary school.

Your class is on the third floor of the teaching building. There are dozens of identical classrooms in the entire building, and there is only one entrance on each floor.

So everyone's steps to get to the classroom must be like this:

First, go through the entrance on the first floor, then walk up the stairs to your respective floor, and then enter your classroom.

That is to say...

During a certain period of time.

The number of people entering Class 2, Grade 3 is definitely much smaller than the total number of people entering the teaching building from the first floor.

In other words...

The ratio between the two is not exactly a certain ratio, but it is definitely less than, or even far less than, 1. If we assume a class has 50 students, then at least several hundred students will enter the teaching building.

But Norris Bradbury's calculation framework is different.

The ratio it shows is greater than 1, which means that more people are entering the classroom than entering the school building, so there is clearly a problem.

"N(r, t/)t=S(r, t)Σa(r, t)J(r, t)"

"If we consider a steady-state condition where t=0, then we have d²(r)dr² + 2rd(r)dr(r)L² = 0"

"Introducing Fick's law... therefore, with the neutron flux density (r, t) as the function to be determined, the continuity equation can be rewritten as 1/v/t = SΣa + D4."

That's all for now.

Lu Guangda suddenly exerted force with his pen, piercing a hole in the Abacus paper.

But Lu Guangda, who was usually extremely frugal, didn't show the slightest sign of heartache this time. Instead, he stared intently at the formula he had calculated.

1/v(/t)=SΣa+D4.

This formula might look unfamiliar at first glance.

But if we remove the 4 from the last [4], many clever students will surely recognize it.

That's right!

This is the starting point of all nuclear engineering, and one of the most important equations in the entire physics of nuclear engineering.

Neutron diffusion equation.

It describes the variation of neutron flux density distribution and is a second-order Differential Equation in space, which in some cases can be transformed into the Helmholtz equation to obtain wave solutions.

At the same time, it is a first-order Differential Equation in time, which allows us to obtain the monotonic development over time.

Generally speaking.

For any complete framework, you can deduce the correct expression for this formula.

But

The result Lu Guangda has just released has an extra 4!

The concept of multiple 4s in Differential Equation is so complex that any further explanation of it would be met with criticism.

All in all.

This is absolutely impossible!

You need to know.

The derivations from the Theoretical Department are not all mathematical calculations; many of the parameters they calculated come from experimental teams in the application areas—otherwise, the Rabbits wouldn't have needed to build the bombing laboratory.

For example, the parameters that Lu Guangda and his team used this time.

Some of these parameters come from documents transmitted back from Across the sea, which originally belonged to national-level experimental institutions.

Some of the materials came from the Russian study trip they took seven or eight years ago, such as the Petrov reactor.

Some of them came from the Neutron physics laboratory of Branch Factory 7, which was located in the workshop next to Lu Guangda's group.

Many of these data are parameters from actual nuclear explosions, meaning they are facts that have already occurred—or at the very least, cold explosion data.

The results derived from these facts are problematic, and it's clearly not the data's fault.

In other words

Norris Bradbury's framework does indeed contain some flaws!

The bigwigs present were all top-notch domestic elites, so they quickly realized this as well.

Seeing this situation.

Xu Yun didn't need to remind him again.

Lu Guangda then looked at the crowd and displayed his decisiveness, quickly issuing various instructions:

"Xi Lai, you immediately lead Group Two to re-examine the problem of the mean scattering angle cosine!"

"Comrade Chen Rui, you are responsible for verifying the dimensions of the diffusion length."

"Old Hua, go calculate whether the superposition state of the intrinsic waves is continuous—hmm, try not to introduce the effective multiplication coefficient."

"Old An, you take Little Gao and the others."

Watching Lu Guangda quickly get into the zone, Xu Yun couldn't help but feel a sense of emotion.

No wonder he's the bigwig in the overall planning Theoretical Department.

You need to know.

To avoid revealing too many abnormalities.

Xu Yun only pointed out one error that seems obvious at first glance but actually has far-reaching implications.

The computational modules for this error point radiation number at least twenty or thirty, not to mention the complexity; the sheer number far exceeds the number of teams in this room.

The result was unexpected.

Lu Guangda actually made arrangements so quickly, and the directions he mentioned are at least 80% correct!

This falls purely into the realm of professional instinct, requiring a very solid and substantial accumulation of knowledge to achieve.

Even in the international arena at this time, there are not many who possess this strategic instinct.

There are definitely five fingers, but not necessarily ten.

Then very quickly.

The entire laboratory was quickly mobilized.

The most excited among them were undoubtedly the two big shots who had previously argued and their team members.

These were Hua Yun, the then-head of the second group of the Theoretical Department, and Ma Ruiping, the then-head of the third group.

Hua Yun is one of the few leading scholars in China who have obtained Doctorate in both theoretical physics and Functional Analysis. Although he is no longer Academician, his abilities are still very strong.

In the field of Functional Analysis, he can even be considered the leading expert, perhaps even the foremost expert in China!

Ma Ruiping is an applied mathematics expert who graduated from Michigan State University. Due to his solid English speaking and writing skills, he is now mainly responsible for the translation of foreign journals.

Although Ma Ruiping did not become an academician in later years, he was still just an ordinary associate professor when he retired, and his academic credentials were not officially declassified until 2022.

However, he personally translated as much as 70% of the foreign language documents in the entire Project 596, which is a remarkable achievement.

Previously, the cause of the problem had not been identified.

Hua Yun, Ma Ruiping, and their team were under considerable pressure—otherwise they wouldn't have been questioning each other.

This skepticism stems from two sources: first, confidence in one's own abilities, and second, the crucial importance of analyzing this document, with no one wanting to take the blame.

Now that they've discovered the culprit behind their attacks, how could they not be excited?

Therefore, very quickly.

The entire project team then paused their work and began to perform calculations.

"Ci(r, t)t=βik∞Σa(r, t)λiCi(r, t) i=1,2,3,., m Brother Wang, could you please send me the Group 3 file from the Russian side?"

"Ladies and gentlemen, the spatial part is the Helmholtz equation, and the general solution is a superposition of a series of standing waves, that is, a superposition of a series of eigenwave states. So if we ignore it and study the temporal changes, it is equivalent to assuming that the quantum flux density constitutes a whole wave throughout the process, and the changes at each point are synchronous. Then we should..."

"Xiao Zhao, wanna go to the restroom together later?"

"0.557, 0.559, 8.322, Report: There is a noticeable bump in the calculation process!"

"Very good, what is the density vector?"

"Only a general range is available; it should be around 18.5-19.7!"

"Aba aba."

Looking at the bustling scene...

Xu Yun's gaze, however, couldn't help but fall once again on the piece of paper in front of Lu Guangda.

That is to say...

The record contains a copy of Norris Bradbury's English manuscript.

To be honest.

In 2023, in the future.

Xu Yun was unaware of the existence of this document, which was actually the Steady-state subcritical state model designed by Norris Bradbury.

This is actually quite normal.

After all, there are too many twists and turns and stories in the development of Nuclear Weapon, and many things have not been declassified even in 2023—some may have been declassified, but not fully made public, and it is very complicated to find out.

Xu Yun only knew the surface of these events, namely that many comrades sacrificed their precious lives to ensure the smooth transport of those foreign-language periodicals back to China.

As for the general content of these journals, he couldn't possibly know it all.

But on the other hand...

Based on some of the Rabbits' later findings, Xu Yun was able to roughly make connections to certain situations.

For example, the well-known correction of supercritical scale-up effects.

Xu Yun didn't know which incident led to this conclusion, and he couldn't even quite remember who the team leader who corrected it was.

However, if an event related to the critical adjustment error of the group parameters is encountered, then this event will inevitably be related to the correction of the supercritical amplification effect.

Imagine you travel back in time to a certain era, knowing nothing about the scenery or people around you. Then someone next to you says, "[General, Huanggu Tun is just ahead]," and you can definitely guess what year it is.

The same is true now.

Xu Yun was unaware beforehand of the critical state model for the stationary state designed by Norris Bradbury.

However, it's not hard to deduce from this error that it must be related to that matter.

And if that's really the case...

Thinking about this...

Xu Yun's heart suddenly began to pound rapidly.

Etc!

If the conditions are right.

It seems like we could use this opportunity to pull off something big again?

If that can be done.

This would probably be just as helpful to the Rabbits as beating the U2 team!

After carefully considering the information he had learned from later generations, Xu Yun felt increasingly confident that this matter had potential.

Of course.

This matter is of great importance, involving many aspects, and its difficulty is no less than that of Xu Yun in later generations who wrote 50,000 words a day.

So we still need to think carefully about how to proceed.

At least

From the current perspective...

Even considering the verification done by Lu Guangda and his team, this idea is still missing a piece of the puzzle.

Two hours later.

Hua Yun, who was not far away, suddenly raised his head and shouted to Lu Guangda:

"Director Lu, I've found the cause of the problem!"

Lu Guangda's expression immediately turned serious, and he quickly asked:

What's the reason?

Hua Yun quickly brought the results calculated by his group to Lu Guangda's side and slammed them heavily onto the table:

"Director Lu, look!"

"The critical state model for the stationary state designed by Norris Bradbury is a weak-field approximation, which only works well in the region where (r, t) changes slowly."

"But look at these three sets of data: the results from the Russian bear, the Across the sea, and the results from our own experiments."

"These results indicate that the source, namely S(r, t), interacts nonlinearly with the neutron flux density (r, t)."

"Furthermore, in regions very close to the source, such as near the control rod, where (r, t) changes drastically, the changes are inherently nonlinear!"

"In other words, Norris Bradbury Across the sea used a linear equation to describe a nonlinear situation!"

"The authority has made a mistake!"

Note:

I replaced some processes with reactor principles, for reasons that everyone understands.

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Explore the wiki

Xu Yun
Old Guo
Across the sea
Rabbits
Lu Guangda

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS