Volume One · End-of-volume wrap-up (Part Two)
III. Regarding Bilibili videos and content creators (up主)
"Isn't the plot of this book just a written version of the videos by those Bilibili? So, wouldn't that be considered copyright infringement?"
This is a question raised by a fellow reader.
His attitude was quite good, and since this matter happened to be within the plan summarized at the end of the document, let me formally explain:
1. Bilibili videos are not the main body of this book.
If you simply wrote down the creators' videos, this book would never exist.
We hope everyone can rationally distinguish the differences in presentation between "videos" and "online articles".
Many videos are very interesting and entertaining, but when it comes to actually writing them down, all I can manage are a few sentences.
For example, in a craft video, the creator can't possibly show you the original footage that's several hours or even more than ten hours long. So as a viewer, I also don't know what exactly happened during the creator's production process.
The details and daily routines involved are not as simple as "writing down the videos of Bilibili up-makers."
The equipment used by content creators, the time spent editing, their editing process, and other issues encountered during the process... these are things you can't know just by watching their videos.
Especially the sweet interactions between the male and female leads, which really have nothing to do with the uploader's videos.
The section on dog food is the longest part of the book.
--
2. Regarding infringement
I didn't really consider the issue of copyright infringement when I first started writing the book.
At the time, because school was about to start, this book was just something I wrote as practice. After a long period of poor performance, I thought that if I could get 200 first-day subscriptions, I could slowly continue writing. I really didn't think about copyright infringement.
I've recently learned a little about this topic, and what I'm about to say may not be entirely accurate. If any readers have knowledge of this legal subject, please feel free to mention it in the comments section.
Firstly, the most common way to infringe on a video's copyright is to directly copy the video content, post it on another video website, and then label it as original.
Then, using the same subject matter, the same script and editing techniques, they created videos that were essentially the same as the originals but with a different shell by replacing the characters and scenes.
In some cases, simply focusing on the subject matter makes it difficult to determine copyright infringement. For example, the "Don't Do Challenges" that was very popular on Bilibili had many imitations and followers, but the specific content was different, so it's hard to call it copyright infringement; at most, it can only be considered as borrowing.
As for acts like this book that incorporate video content into written form, determining whether it constitutes infringement requires a more nuanced assessment; it's not as simple as just writing down the content creator's video.
In addition, the book actually borrows more content from the video's bullet comments and the silly comments from netizens in the comment section.
Regarding whether bullet comments and reviews belong to the rights of the video itself, I'm not entirely clear on the legal implications.
--
3. Detailed analysis, let's look at them one by one.
The book initially borrowed from the original video of "Cai Qian of Meager Talent and Learning," in which the silver-inlaid bracelet was only mentioned verbally and the video itself was not actually used.
Secondly, there's a video about modifying meal cards; the production process is omitted, and some comments are borrowed from the video's comment section.
Next is "The Elucidator, the Lambent Light, the Dark Repulser," which is adapted from Cai Qian's "Night Sky Sword" video. However, since the swords made are not the same, and the latter two swords are only mentioned briefly in the text, I use the term "adapted" here.
In particular, Chapter 24, "A Collection of Video Comments from the Elucidator," does, in my personal subjective judgment, have the potential to infringe on copyrights, because I did write it while watching videos and reading comments from "Night Sky Sword."
Next up is the Demon Blade Thousand Blades. Since I didn't understand the principles of epoxy resin, the terms and steps used in the production process all came from a netizen's explanation in the video comments section.
The disassembly of the Silver Play Button was inspired by a video by the content creator "Going Haywire," but the process wasn't detailed; instead, the video's comments were used.
Then there's the bag chair and the umbrella chair, inspired by "Handicraft Geng's" cane chair.
The Moon Slayer, Heavenly Chain Moon Slayer, Hollow Mask, and cosplays from the Bleach series are modified versions of the Heavenly Chain Moon Slayer video created by the content creator "Di'er Who Hibernates".
The Ink Brow that are still being made come from the Ink Brow video by the content creator "Clumsy City Lord of Slow City".
The mini piano, on the other hand, is an original video.
The above is the source information for the video featuring the male protagonist, Chen Wen.
Next up is the female lead, Jiang Qiuyi, whose songs are mostly from the content creator "Feifei". However, the copyright of the songs themselves does not belong to her, nor does the copyright of the characters she cosplays belong to her. Therefore, I cannot clarify whether there are any copyright infringement issues involved.
But at least, the storylines that unfold from these videos themselves should not be included in this category.
For example, what everyone should remember is that Jiang Qiuyi wore Black-Clad Person cosplay outfit, which was too big and required bandages. This is purely from the author's own plot creation and could not possibly be a fact that Feifei herself told me.
The essence of this book lies in the original storylines that unfold based on the videos, not the videos themselves.
As for the videos on their alternate accounts, most of them are original videos based on the plot of the book, while a small number are heavily modified versions, including videos featuring Devil Aunt and romantic interactions.
The videos featuring my mother's reactions, the Qixi Festival video, and other short videos are all original.
--
4. Conclusion
Whether or not there is infringement is not a conclusion I can determine.
If any readers can contact the relevant content creator, they can ask them to make their own judgment.
There are some parts I'm not certain about, and I won't give definitive answers, such as the specific definition and judgment criteria for text-based video copyright infringement, and the copyright ownership of bullet comments and comment sections, etc.
However, some of the credit does belong to my own creative work, and I don't want it to be overshadowed by a casual remark like "writing videos for content creators with a pen."
I've written all this so clearly in the hope that everyone understands that it's my responsibility, which I will take responsibility for and apologize for. Please don't impose on me anything that isn't my responsibility, and please respect my work.
Above.
Please discuss this issue rationally. I will delete any comments that contain personal attacks, as appropriate.
[Pu Jie Ri Ji]: Some things just have to be said. Keeping them inside will only affect my mindset. Now that the first volume is over, I'm going to speak my mind openly. Right and wrong will always become clearer through debate.