Yu Xing recalled the details of her brief time with River Witch.
After meeting them, River Witch did not treat them differently because they were "two people" or "three non-humans".
While chatting in the room, River Witch treated everyone the same, making it impossible to tell whether she preferred humans or non-humans. Given this, what was the point of Aran's question at the door?
Because this was River Witch's residence, after meeting Aran, they quickly determined that Aran was not the legendary Witch, so they subconsciously assumed that Aran was relaying the question to the real Witch.
But what if this is the question Aran himself wants to ask?
Meeting to confirm their identities is perfectly normal. Even if she were being monitored, River Witch wouldn't glean anything detrimental to her from it. But if the answer to this question is interpreted as another hint, then...
Yu Xing brushed her hair, which was damp from the steam, back and listed the existing conditions in her mind.
"One, two people," can be taken literally.
Second, River Witch's red cloth shoes are the same style worn by Master of Ten Thousand's subordinates, which means that River Witch and Master of Ten Thousand have a close relationship.
Third, it is impossible for River Witch to be on the same path as Master of Ten Thousand; the only possible path for the two sides is hostility.
Fourth, Aran, who had lived with River Witch for many years, seemed to be intentionally reminding them.
Fifth, the surveillance area outside River Witch's Tower is vast and contains immense energy, yet River Witch herself does not appear to be able to control this energy.
The possibilities constructed from the clues are already extremely limited. If the logic that still doesn't work after elimination is eliminated, then only one possibility remains.
The River Witch, and the "River Witch who opposes Master of Ten Thousand Wanban" are not the same person at all, but rather two different people!
Yu Xing smiled slightly; that made sense.
River Witch is indeed powerful and an enemy of Master of Ten Thousand, possessing the ability to repair souls. However, the old woman they met today is not the original River Witch at all, but rather an imposter, one of Master of Ten Thousand's subordinates.
Therefore, the old woman knew that their souls had been extracted and placed into the world of the stage, while the resistance organization was unaware of this.
It's possible they arrived a little late, or perhaps River Witch had already been replaced before they entered Fengtou Town, but this time must have been short. At least the imposter River Witch hadn't extracted all the information about the resistance organization, otherwise the resistance organization would have been wiped out long ago.
As the person who knows River Witch best, Aran has already noticed something amiss, but for her own safety, she pretends not to know and continues to play the role of taking care of River Witch. As a result, she is spared, since the real Aran is definitely more natural than the Aran who is pretending, and this will also reduce the chance of being exposed when contacting the resistance organization.
She wanted to remind these outsiders to take this opportunity to change their situation, but the group that came in the morning failed, so she had to resort to the same trick and start reminding Yu Xing and his group.
In this way, everything makes sense. Aran knew that the fake River Witch had murderous intentions towards outsiders, but due to her identity and the ever-present "surveillance," she couldn't give any more obvious hints. Whether she would be noticed depended entirely on fate.
Having figured this out, Yu Xing immediately shared her idea through her earpiece.
There was a moment of silence in the earpiece.
Five seconds later, Zhao Mou's calm voice rang out again. "I understand now. Master of Ten Thousand knew we were coming to see River Witch, so he set a trap for us. If we hadn't noticed River Witch's unusual behavior, we would have been paralyzed by the water and captured without any trouble."
"If we notice anything unusual, we'll just assume that River Witch has deceived us. The bone bells and dolls hanging on the first floor, and the shadow puppets and human flesh in River Witch's room on the second floor, are all a form of guidance, instilling in us the idea that River Witch is the mastermind behind everything. In this way, when Master of Ten Thousand later provides evidence to reverse the situation, we might actually believe it."
The siren asked, "What evidence of a reversal?"
"For example, at the birthday banquet, Master of Ten Thousand secretly told us that he was actually a puppet captured by River Witch to be used as a target. He was an innocent and good person. It was River Witch who had been practicing the Forbidden Art of Living Souls from beginning to end. River Witch controlled him and hoped that we could rescue him from his suffering."
Zhao Mou smiled at the siren, "Now, when we think back to the clues we painstakingly obtained, and how we finally saw through River Witch's true colors, combined with Master of Ten Thousand's words, do you believe it or not?"
"Hmm... Although I won't completely believe it, and might even have a few more doubts, it might still be enough for Master of Ten Thousand to use." The siren thought about it and realized that was indeed the case.
People tend to believe the truth they uncover themselves.
Even the most suspicious person will never doubt themselves.
A cold glint flashed in Zhao Mou's eyes. "This instance has something called soul extraction. There's a lot of potential to exploit in terms of identity. As long as we're misled at River Witch's Tower, there are countless ways to use our abilities later. It's like we've handed Master of Ten Thousand a very useful weakness."
"So, the things hanging there, and the things in River Witch's room, were all deliberately shown to us. They were all unusual clues that were difficult to prove, especially the shadow puppets and human flesh in the boxes and jars. We could only find them by extraordinary means, because River Witch was sitting in the room, and if someone already sensed something was wrong, no one would rummage through her things in front of her."
Ren Yi chimed in, "The person who designed this knew we would use 'unorthodox methods,' but this also exposes their underestimation of us. For us, discovering this was not difficult, and we wouldn't have the effect of obtaining a clue with great difficulty and then believing it wholeheartedly."
In short, it was designed, but poorly designed; it was somewhat superfluous.
"They deliberately left us many clues to arouse our suspicion. The only thing they tried to hide was those red cloth shoes, but they probably didn't expect that one of us would lift up River Witch's skirt." Ren Yi said, looking at Yu Xing with a gaze that was half sighing and half eerie.
In ancient times, people took this very seriously. Who would lift an old woman's skirt just to look at her shoes?
Master of Ten Thousand may be, their thinking is still limited by the era in which they lived.
Zhao Mou, Ghost Wine, and Hai Yao all looked at Yu Xing with complicated expressions.
"... Don't look at me like that. I acted out of suspicion, it's not like I'm a pervert." Yu Xing casually leaned against the rim of the bucket. "Right now, the fake River Witch only knows that I accidentally caught a glimpse of the red shoes, she can't be sure if I recognized them or not, um..."
"The main issue is that the guy in the red shoes I met before was socially awkward, very quiet, and showed signs of being coerced. If I'm not mistaken, that little guy probably didn't report to Master of Ten Thousand's side about almost being caught by me."
In other words, as long as he pretends not to recognize the origin of the red cloth shoes, he won't alert the enemy.
"Now things are getting interesting," Ghost Wine raised an eyebrow. "If this River Witch is a fake, then where is the real River Witch? Is she already dead?"
"She's been at odds with Master of Ten Thousand for six years, and there's no room for leniency in what she's done. If she's caught, she'll most likely be killed alive," Zhao Mou analyzed, ultimately concluding two possibilities. "In short, sometime before we arrived, River Witch lost her ability to protect herself and was replaced by Master of Ten Thousand's men. She either escaped discreetly, so discreetly that even Aran didn't know, or she's dead."
Either way, it's bad news for the strategists.
This means their main storyline... has collapsed.
I wonder if the system will give them a new task after they figure this out.