Rong Cishan, controlling the pixelated figure, navigates through the ruins under the gentle guidance of Toriel, the Goat Mom.
The game's combat system is truly innovative—the player's soul is represented by a small red heart, and combat involves maneuvering within the heart's bounding box to dodge various pixelated bullets with different trajectories fired by monsters.
But the core logic seems to be the same as RPGs: encounter monsters, enter battle, defeat monsters, gain EXP (experience points), and then level up.
But...
After two battles, we arrived at the tutorial point.
Rong Cishan suddenly felt something was wrong. Mainly because he had been prejudiced and had a lot of complaints to complain about, so he hadn't looked at the battle interface carefully.
It was only after the in-game tutorial mentioned this that I realized the last option on the combat screen wasn't "Run Away," but rather the very distinctive "Mercy."
"If the monsters don't want to fight... should we be merciful to them?"
Rong Cishan looked at the tutorial text on the screen thoughtfully, and continued to advance the game.
And then they encountered the frog monster once again.
Rong Cishan carefully examined the battle options and then discovered that there was another action option.
What, then, is action?
Curious, he clicked on it and found three sub-menus under "Action": View, Praise, Threaten.
Um??
The "View" option displays the monster's attack and defense attributes, but what do the latter two options mean?
Is that correct?
Rong Cishan tried selecting the "praise" option.
Opponent's turn.
[Froggit doesn't understand what you're saying, but it seems to be getting cocky.]
[Froggit: (Face flushed red) Quack!]
"...?"
While dodging the bullet hell with the red heart representing the player, Rong Cishan typed a question mark and suddenly thought the monster was actually quite cute.
Then.
A new notification popped up.
[Froggit doesn't seem to want to fight you.]
Upon seeing this prompt, Rong Cishan realized something and selected the Forgiveness option under the Mercy menu.
Really.
The battle ended immediately.
But the character did not gain any XP.
"Does this mean you're encouraging players to avoid combat? Or am I misunderstanding something?"
Rong Cishan seemed to be deep in thought, feeling that something about this was not quite right.
However, he did become a little more careful afterward, and would take a quick look before acting on any monster he encountered.
Although the overall operation is indeed more complicated than direct combat.
But he found that the monsters in the game were all quite cute.
There was a melancholy fellow with a sour face who approached meekly, constantly apologizing while pretending to fight.
There are little monsters that wriggle like seaweed, responding by wiggling their hips and shouting "sexy wriggling!"
There are also ghosts who are psychologically fragile, extremely depressed, use tears as a weapon, and will even say they've lost interest and stop attacking altogether...
Rong Cishan didn't attack at all! He encouraged the opponent three whole times!
The first time was to give the ghost a forgiving smile; the second time was to tell the ghost a little joke.
After the third encouragement, the ghost made himself a hat.
Meanwhile, the text box displays. "Ghost Napster eagerly awaits your response."
Rong Cishan: "..."
No, is that right?
It's quite cute.
But this... doesn't really feel like a battle; it's more like interacting with, well, a bit clumsy and a bit sensitive, friend?
No, it can't be said to resemble a battle.
In fact, the process of encouragement...
This monster's attack frequency and methods will increase, making it extremely difficult to dodge the barrage of attacks.
This world isn't a bullet hell game like Touhou Raiden, but there are similar ones. It's just that Rong Cishan hadn't played any before, so controlling the little red heart that represents the player's soul and dodging the increasingly fast and treacherous bullet patterns within a narrow box was quite a challenge.
It's nowhere near as satisfying or quick as direct combat.
But how should I put it?
He always felt that he had grasped some of the game's key features.
Rong Cishan said softly, "Does this game encourage players to use this kind of clever strategy to complete the game?"
This... takes into account the child character settings in the game.
emmm...
That's quite possible.
And these monsters are actually quite cute.
Thinking of this...
Rong Cishan paid even closer attention to the battle that followed, and then he discovered that the monsters did indeed possess methods of outsmarting them.
This made him feel like he had grasped the essence of the game.
Only.
Soon.
He then encountered a challenge.
Goat Mom.
The woman who rescued the protagonist from the Flowey, wearing a robe, with ram's horns, and calling herself Toriel, doesn't seem to want the player to leave the initial map. Instead, she acts like a kind mother, arranging the protagonist's studies and life plans.
But the initial map is only so big, and staying here makes it impossible to progress in the game.
So in every conversation, Rong Cishan said he wanted to go home.
After his repeated insistence, the Goat Mom finally spoke up to explain everything and led the player to the door.
Only.
Players must defeat the Goat Mom to escape this initial map.
The problem is...
This seems like there's no way to outsmart them...
If you stop, she will send the player back, and everything will return to square one.
Rong Cishan tried many times, but to no avail.
He's forgiven them seven or eight times already! But he still can't end the fight!
Is a fight inevitable? Or will they give way when their health is low?
Another attempt at forgiveness failed.
Rong Cishan realized he was on the wrong track, changed his approach, and began to fight.
This battle was difficult, extremely difficult, more difficult than any of the monsters we had encountered before.
The comments section was too dense.
Rong Cishan couldn't dodge it at all, and soon he only had three points of health left.
Just then, when the bullet comments touched the red hearts again, the battle suddenly stopped.
A line of text suddenly popped up in the text box. "[Toriel deliberately avoided you.]"
When Rong Cishan was accidentally touched by a comment again, the text box displayed: --[Toriel took a deep breath.]
It's obvious.
The enemy is letting us through.
And what followed.
When Rong Cishan had only a sliver of health left, a truly spectacular scene unfolded... Even when he controlled the little red heart to actively meet the attacking magic projectiles, those projectiles would disperse like a tide.
Actively avoid him.
It was as if this tall, robed woman with ram's horns had no intention of harming the player.
"... Wow."
Rong Cishan tried several times and found that it wasn't an illusion; the opponent's attacks really did avoid him. He was truly astonished.
He wanted to try forgiveness again.
And this attempt... was repeated fourteen times!
After realizing that the Goat Mom didn't want to hurt the protagonist.
Rong Cishan forgave her a total of fourteen times.
In the end.
The Goat Mom isn't even going to act anymore.
And Rong Cishan forgave her time and time again.
Finally.
The Goat Mom hugged the protagonist in the game and let her go.
The music softened.
Rong Cishan scratched his head, suppressing his doubts, and guided his character toward the gate of the ruins.
The Flowey reappeared, mocked the player, and told them that in this world, it's either kill or be killed.
Looking at Flowey's mockery, Rong Cishan suddenly felt that perhaps his constant forgiveness was the right thing to do.
Perhaps it was because the Goat Mom deliberately avoided the player's attacks afterward, never intending to harm the player in the slightest.
Anyway, this made Rong Cishan feel like he had done a good thing.
But what on earth is this Flowey?
Rong Cishan couldn't understand it.
Let's try clearing the game first...
As he thought about it, he guided his character toward the exit.
Next.
New environment, new monsters.
Rong Cishan continued to advance the game, and the map grew larger.
And then, one by one, interesting monsters began to appear.
Ice Dragon loves telling corny jokes; Ice Cap thinks his hat is really cool; a dog that only gets excited by moving targets; Lesser Dog loves being petted and whose neck grows longer the more it's stroked; a snowman who gives the player a snow block and hopes the player will take it to the Snowman of the earth; Lesser Dog selling delicious popsicles everywhere...
And the characters began to appear one by one.
Skeleton Brothers, Royal Guard Captain, Royal Scientist, Robot...
Every time Rong Cishan encountered a battle, he would try to outsmart his opponent.
He discovered that outsmarting the enemy was much more fun and exciting than fighting!
It can be said that although the graphics are simple, once you get into the game...
Rong Cishan, however, became increasingly happy as he played.
During his long journey, the monsters' actions also overturned his understanding of the world.
This is definitely not a traditional RPG.
The monsters are not inherently evil; they, like humans, yearn for truth, goodness, and beauty.
They attack humans out of fear, and if you win their favor, they'll even foolishly risk their lives for you.
The game's story background is also not complicated.
Simply put, these sealed monsters need to collect the souls of seven humans to break the seal and return to the surface. Six human souls have already been collected, and the protagonist's arrival brings the final batch of human souls.
If the monsters kill the protagonist, they will be able to see the sun again and lie on the ground to see the real stars.
But they couldn't bring themselves to attack players who never picked up weapons.
So sometimes they'll provoke players, throwing stones at them or poking them with branches, but their only goal is to get players to stay with them a little longer.
Pat them on the head, or even just say a few words of praise, and they'll be so happy they feel like they could fly to the sky.
These monsters are so cute!
"How interesting..."
This is my review after spending four hours at Rong Cishan.
What technologies and techniques did the game use? What message did it convey? Was it good or bad?
In fact, it was not important to Rong Cishan at all.
After all, he was just an ordinary player.
As long as a game is fun, it can keep him playing.
And this game...
He found it hilarious! It was so incredibly funny!
This game kept him entertained from beginning to end.
Rong Cishan once went on a date with a skeleton in a game, lay on the floor with a ghost imagining the vast universe, played a quiz game with a robot, and even had an awkward dance...
This game has a truly unique feel to it. How should I put it... it has a kind of cynical vibe, a disdain for traditional RPGs, and a subversive ambition.
This disdain and longing are vividly displayed through the game's various satirical interpretations of traditional RPGs.
The enemy's meticulously designed traps, which should have been essential puzzles in RPGs, were somehow bypassed by the player.
While rummaging through drawers and cabinets in the scene trying to find rare items, they only ended up finding a few lame jokes.
What's even funnier is that the hot dog bought from the prop shop was actually placed directly on the protagonist's head...
It can be said that...
These ingenious ideas are found in every corner of the game, making Rong Cishan constantly look forward to when the next creative idea will appear.
That's really interesting.
At the same time, he also felt that this game world was very vibrant, warm, and healing.
Rong Cishan didn't know why either, but after thinking about it again and again, he figured it was probably because of the characters appearing in the story...
They are all so distinctive and unique.
However, the game is indeed not very long.
Soon.
The happy time has come to an end.
Rong Cishan has reached the final checkpoint.
The courtroom in front of the throne.
Sans, the older brother of the Skeleton Brothers, stood at the end of the corridor, a character that Rong Cishan found hard to understand.
He thought it was a battle.
But quite the opposite...
A dialog box popped up above Sans's head.
The end of the journey is within reach.
[You will soon meet the King.]
You will decide the future of this world, but that's another matter.
[Now, you will stand trial.]
You will be judged for every action you take.
[You will be judged for every point of EXP you gain.]
"?"
Rong Cishan slowly typed a question mark: What trial?
The game seemed to know that the player in front of the screen was confused.
The dialog box popped up again very quickly.
What is EXP? It's an abbreviation.
It means "Execution Points".
[A way to quantify the pain you inflict on others; every time you kill someone, your EXP increases, and when you have enough EXP, your LV increases.]
[LV... LOVE, also an abbreviation, stands for "Level of Level of Violence," used to measure a person's ability to harm others. The more you kill, the further you stray from your true self; the further you stray from your true self, the harder you are to be harmed, and the easier it is for you to allow yourself to harm others.]
"?"
Upon seeing this conversation, Rong Cishan slowly typed a question mark again.
Ah???
What an abbreviation genius?!
Does EXP mean that?
Doesn't LV mean "Level"?
It happened very quickly.
Rong Cishan recalled what Flowey had said at the beginning of the game, and the unconventional yet healing monsters in the game.
I was suddenly stunned.
Then, as if a thunderbolt had exploded in his mind, all the vague disharmony and uneasy doubts he had felt before were completely illuminated, connected, and given a completely new and awe-inspiring meaning!
I see... I see... I see!
Forgive...
The charm of this game... lies precisely in the fact that players can forgive every monster!
This means that the player adheres to their inner principles, striving to do the right thing no matter what difficulties and struggles they face, refusing to hurt anyone, and even when choosing to run away, they do so with a smile on their face.
That player may not receive any LOVE (Level of Violence).
But you will receive love...
Rong Cishan, reflecting on the healing monsters he encountered on his journey, finally understood.
"Wow..."
Rong Cishan stared at the screen, truly stunned, and couldn't help but exclaim in amazement.
Those numbers, those familiar symbols from RPGs that represent the player character's growing strength, are completely deconstructed and subverted in this game, becoming a measure of sin and the degree of soul corruption.
He thought of Flowey's initial words, of every monster he encountered on his journey, and of all the messy, cunning ways he outmaneuvered them: praise, threats, flirting, encouragement, reassurance... options that were far more troublesome than mindless hacking and slashing.
Suddenly everything became clear!
I see...
It truly runs throughout!
At that moment, Rong Cishan even felt a little fortunate, fortunate that he had insisted on forgiveness with the Goat Mom, and that he had mostly outsmarted the monsters he encountered afterward! Although it was troublesome, it was also very interesting!
This game... is awesome!
This RPG can be done like this?!
... etc.
Rong Cishan sighed for a while... then suddenly realized something and frowned.
If that's the case, then it seems I've killed monsters before.
I killed a few frogs at the beginning.
There was nothing he could do; the game didn't give any hints back then, so he just instinctively started fighting.
And I killed some of them afterward... Some of the enemies definitely seemed designed for combat.
Does that mean...?
Rong Cishan didn't continue thinking about it.
Because after SANS finished explaining, there was no follow-up; he simply asked the player to ask themselves if they had done the right thing.
Then.
That's the final boss battle.
Filled with doubt, Rong Cishan controlled his character to venture deep into the royal city, where he met the person the Goat Mom had warned him to be careful of—her husband, the King of the Underground Kingdom, King Asgore, a tall man with ram horns, clad in armor, yet appearing incredibly weary and sorrowful.
This battle.
Equally impressive.
[A strange light illuminated the room; the dawn's rays pierced through the barrier. It seems your journey has finally come to an end, and you are now filled with determination.]
This was accompanied by such a prompt.
This boss pulled out a trident and instantly shattered the Mercy that had accompanied the player all the way.
Yes.
The boss destroyed the Mercy option.
This means that Rong Cishan can only clear the game by defeating this boss!
"Wow..."
Rong Cishan exclaimed "Wow!" again.
But soon, he realized what was going on.
The King must kill the character he controls, collect the last human souls, break the seal, and burst forth from the ground.
The character must kill the King and return home.
The two are truly locked in a life-or-death struggle.
Therefore, there is no mercy.
That makes sense.
Can.
Rong Cishan always felt a little regretful...
Throughout this journey, after playing for so long and encountering so many healing and memorable monsters and NPCs, it's clear that this underground world doesn't actually deserve such a fate.
Is it really that bad?
Are we really going to do that?
Something feels off...
Is there a completely peaceful path? Is it possible to truly not kill a single monster?
Although Rong Cishan was lost in thought, he did not stop moving.
She constantly manipulated the little red heart to dodge the King's attacks.
Finally, after four or five attempts, Asgore's health was depleted.
His tall frame swayed, the battle music stopped abruptly, and a suffocating silence followed.
Rong Cishan, however, did not experience much joy in his victory.
Because right at that moment!
A sharp, jarring laugh, completely out of place with the atmosphere, suddenly rang out!
That persistent Flowey has returned.
Then comes the psychological attack!
An indescribable, terrifying aggregate of plants and twisted machinery.
It filled the entire screen, with countless vines and mechanical arms reaching out, and a barrage of bullets so dense it was almost despairing, surging towards the red heart that represented the player's soul.
There's a second boss...
Rong Cishan was stunned by this sudden and overwhelming development and visual impact... The previous battles, though difficult, were still within the framework of dodging bullet hell.
At this moment, this thing's attack has completely exceeded the norm! The bullet trajectory is not only bizarre, but also ridiculously dense! It even causes game crashes!
It looks like it's attacking players outside the game!
After defeating this boss... Rong Cishan was completely exhausted.
The final boss's twisted, blasphemous form disappeared.
The battle is over.
Flowey reappeared.
But Rong Cishan was not happy at all.
Especially after recalling Sans's words in the courtroom.
He suddenly became curious whether a true Pacifist Route existed in this game.
So after thinking about it, he simply forgave Flowey.
... I'm thinking of just starting a new save file!
At the same time.
Avalon Game Assistant has been available for some time now since the game was unlocked.
However, there are still not many related posts.
After all, they're still playing.
However, around 3 a. m., the situation changed slightly.
A post suddenly appeared.
Have you guys played Undertale? What's it like?
[As the title suggests, I recently saw this mentioned in the indie game scene and came here out of curiosity. Pixel-style RPG? The name sounds pretty ordinary. For those who have played it, what do you think? Is it worth the time? How long is the game? Is it fun?]
This is just a very ordinary post.
It's simply that Avalon has become very famous, and then suddenly released such a special game. Some players came here because of its reputation, and when they saw that there was a forum, they didn't rush to buy it, but instead came to ask other players first.
But this seemingly ordinary post received over a hundred replies in less than a minute after it was published.
It's 3 a. m...
Just finished my first playthrough, and I have mixed feelings. All I can say about this game is... it's really fun. It completely overturned my understanding of RPG experience points, levels, and combat. The game isn't long, but it has a huge impact!
It doesn't attract players with its graphics or fast-paced combat, but rather... I don't know how to put it, but the monster design is truly amazing! Each one is distinct and has a personality, which is very heartwarming. However, I always felt like I wasn't playing the true ending, so I won't comment on that yet. But if you're thinking of buying the game, I'd advise you not to kill any monsters! Don't get any EXP! Treat the monsters kindly; everyone in the underground is really nice!
[Highly recommended! This game has such a unique feel! It's full of playful deconstruction and parody of traditional RPGs! The Third-rate Teacher, is truly a genius at abbreviating! He can even abbreviate like that! However, I also killed the monsters and finally defeated the Mental Pollution Flower, so I won't comment on it yet. I'll wait and see the other ending. But even without it, I still think this game is worth playing.]
I also recommend it! Ah... the way this game tells its story is absolutely amazing. In this tiny pixelated world, it uses all sorts of narrative techniques: narrative tricks, environmental narratives, interconnected beginnings and endings, character-driven narratives, and countless foreshadowing and setups... the ending really moved me to tears.
Hey you two upstairs! Don't kill the monster! There's another ending! Trust me! That ending is truly amazing!
[Successfully completed the game! I realized from the beginning that something was off about the choices! And sure enough! But seeing from the comments above that there seem to be multiple endings, I won't spoil it! But I can tell you all! Without killing any monsters! The ending is really great! I love the final ending so much!]
It filled me with determination!!!
[I also achieved the no-kill ending! Seriously! This is a heartwarming fairy tale written in the form of a game! With simple pixel graphics, innovative gameplay, and a profound storyline, it tells players about the power of choice, the preciousness of kindness, and the meaning of life! I think players who enjoy story-driven games will definitely love this one!]
[I've finished the game! Highly recommended! AAA games are like skyscrapers, beautiful in their grandeur, magnificence, and order. This game is like a magical little house built of seashells next to those skyscrapers—beautiful in its simple exterior but full of wonder inside! It's truly amazing! After finishing it, I'm filled with determination!]
[...]
It's obvious.
Each player's progression path is different.
Some reached Pacifist Route, while others fought along Neutral Route.
Only.
Regardless of which lane they played, almost all players gave positive reviews, and also... offered advice.
That is.
This is a bit hard to understand for the person who posted it.
Capital.
Player Yi Lichao, who had come specifically for this game, sat in front of his computer, looked at the comments below, and slowly typed a question mark, "No... no killing monsters? What kind of RPG is that? Is this really a game??? And the reviews are so good???"