Uranium Nuclear Fission! A Shocking Mix-Up! Looking Back Suddenly, the Transuranium Elements Were There Where the Lights Grew Dim!
In real history, the process from Fermi's discovery of Transuranium Elements to Hahn's proposal of Uranium Nuclear Fission was a complex one.
In May 1934, Fermi bombarded uranium with Neutron and, through a process of elimination, discovered that Transuranium Elements might have been produced in the products.
This was an absolutely groundbreaking discovery at the time.
At that time, Fermi was already a leading figure in the field of physics, and he was rigorous in his scholarship, so he maintained a highly cautious attitude towards this discovery.
He plans to carefully check it several times before considering publication.
However, the Holy Father of the youth group, Italy Ministry of Education Corbino, was eager to make an announcement upon learning the news.
He had been paying close attention to Fermi's lab's achievements, and with such world-shaking academic results, he naturally wanted to publicize them extensively.
Corbino immediately announced Fermi's groundbreaking discovery at the Italian Academy of Sciences Congress, in front of the King and his ministers.
"Fermi has discovered a new element that goes beyond the Periodic Table!"
The news caused a sensation throughout the country.
Major Italy newspapers rushed to report on it:
"Under the wise leadership of the Fascist Party and the great leader Mussolini, Italy has regained its ancient glory."
"I suggest naming this new element after the leader!"
At that time, Fermi was still very naive, and he was very flustered.
He privately approached Corbino and explained that the results were not necessarily 100% accurate, and hoped that they would not be overhyped.
But Corbino comforted him instead:
"Young people should have confidence!"
Even with all the accolades he received, Fermi began to waver.
Based on his theoretical and experimental analysis, the product should indeed be Transuranium Elements, even though he did not actually separate it.
So he stopped worrying about it.
Thus, with Italy's encouragement, news of Fermi's discovery of Transuranium Elements swept the world like a storm.
The world was shocked!
The scientific community was immediately in an uproar!
Transuranium Elements, like magic, attracted all the Experimental Physics of the time.
However, the scientific luminaries were not as easily persuaded as the King of Italy.
Shortly after Fermi's paper was published, the first voice of criticism emerged.
In the same year, Germany physicist Noddack publicly questioned Fermi's results.
This Noddack is no ordinary person either.
She and her husband discovered element 75 [rhenium] in 1925 and were experts in the field of elements.
In his article "On Element 93", Noddack points out:
"When Fermi analyzed the reaction products, he only ruled out element 82, lead, and elements heavier than lead, but he did not rule out elements lighter than lead."
Therefore, it cannot be proven that the reaction product is Transuranium Elements.
"Unless all light elements are eliminated."
If we only consider this, Noddack isn't all that remarkable.
Fermi would retort: I'd love to do that too! But I simply can't.
At that time, the level of chemistry was relatively backward, and the separation of elements was very complex and difficult.
Moreover, the amount of products generated by nuclear reactions is very small, which greatly increases the difficulty of detection.
The first 30 or so elements may be easy to separate, but as you go further in the sequence, the properties of the elements become more and more similar, making them extremely difficult to distinguish.
It can be said that there were not many chemists at that time who were able to master advanced separation techniques.
However, Noddack also mentioned in the paper:
"Fermi may not have created Transuranium Elements, but rather fragments produced by uranium fission."
"It's conceivable that these fragments are Isotope of elements up to element number 92, rather than Transuranium Elements."
It can be said that Noddack had actually predicted the possibility of uranium heavy Nuclear Fission.
However, her paper was met with ridicule from the academic community.
On the one hand, she was a woman with a low status in academia; she didn't even have the funding to obtain uranium to verify it herself.
On the other hand, thanks to Bohr's Liquid Drop Model, no one at the time believed that a single Neutron could break a uranium Atomic Nucleus into several pieces.
In 1936, Noddack asked Hahn to endorse her, but the latter refused.
Hahn thought Noddack's views were absurd and that citing Nordak's views would make him a laughing stock in academia.
At that time, Hahn himself was also studying Fermi's Transuranium Elements.
In fact, as early as two years ago, Meitner urged Hahn to repeat Fermi's experiment with her, and later the two found a chemist Strassmann.
The three of them began their experiment with great enthusiasm.
Between 1934 and 1938, the trio discovered more than a dozen previously unknown Isotope.
They believe these are Isotope of Transuranium Elements.
Unfortunately, they still couldn't obtain the actual Transuranium Elements element, and were always missing a definitive piece of evidence.
Meitner then redesigned the experiment, while Hahn and Strassmann were responsible for improving the Ministry of Education of the experiment.
During this period, the France couple Irène and her husband, were also researching this topic.
In late 1937, after bombarding uranium with Neutron, Irène did not perform chemical separation but directly measured the reaction products.
Therefore, she discovered a new element that remained in the filtrate after the precipitation of Transuranium Elements and could be separated from uranium.
After further testing, Irène concluded that it was likely an Isotope of element 90, thorium.
After the paper was published, the Hahn trio in Germany expressed strong skepticism about the results.
Because this would mean that a tiny Neutron could actually knock an Alpha Particle out of a uranium Atomic Nucleus —that's impossible!
They repeated the experiment, and sure enough, they did not find the so-called thorium Isotope.
So Hahn even wrote a letter himself, hoping that Irène would retract the article.
And at a meeting in Rome, he said to Joliot in a chauvinistic manner:
"I haven't publicly criticized your wife because she's a woman."
"But her result is definitely wrong."
Joliot returned home, he relayed Hahn's opinion to Irène, who then berated him.
"Not only do you not speak up for me, but you also deliberately relay other people's words to me."
Joliot was heartbroken.
Irène completely disregarded Hahn's opinion and continued her experiment.
In May 1938, she published another paper.
This time, she surprisingly discovered an Isotope "very similar to element 57 [lanthanum]" in the products of Neutron bombardment of uranium.
Irène was astonished.
Although she was very unhappy with Hahn, she also agreed with Bohr's theories.
A single Neutron could not cause a uranium Atomic Nucleus to lose so many Proton and Neutron to become element 57.
It's like trying to smash a watermelon with a sesame seed; how could you expect to get a whole bag of seeds out?
So, Irène made another mistake, believing it to be an "inexplicable" Transuranium Elements.
Even though it had already been identified as element 57, due to ingrained thinking, we still leaned towards Transuranium Elements.
Bohr really did a lot of harm!
Regardless, Irène's experimental results cast a shadow over Transuranium Elements, leaving many puzzled.
By 1938, the political atmosphere in Germany and Italy had become increasingly tense.
In July of the same year, Meitner fled Germany to Sweden, and the trio officially disbanded.
In December of the same year, Fermi took his family north to Sweden, and with Bohr's help, escaped Italy and went to the United States under the pretext of receiving the Nobel Prize.
To add to this, Fermi received the Nobel Prize for the application of the Neutron and the discovery of Transuranium Elements.
Even after Meitner left, Hahn did not give up his experiments on Transuranium Elements.
Moreover, he maintained contact with Meitner because he needed the latter's ability to analyze physical theories.
A month ago, he told others: I am not interested in what this lady (Irène) writes.
But now, he shamelessly began to carefully read Irène's articles.
Because a growing body of experimental results indicate that the truth about Transuranium Elements is not so simple.
In October 1938, after repeating Irène's experiment, Hahn discovered Isotope of element 88, radium, in the product.
This is how he explained it:
"When Uranium-238 is bombarded with Neutron, it first emits an Alpha Particle and transforms into element 90, thorium-235."
"Thorium-235 then emitted an Alpha Particle, transforming into radium-231."
It can be seen that Hahn had by this point accepted Irène's experimental results: Neutron can indeed eject Alpha Particle fragments from Atomic Nucleus.
However, he still believes that the claim that the product contains lanthanum is nonsense.
He published his paper in November of the same year.
He then went to Copenhagen, Denmark, to attend a conference. Upon hearing his findings, Bohr immediately expressed his opposition.
Meitner was far away in Sweden, also expressed disbelief after seeing Hahn's paper.
She urged the latter to conduct experiments as soon as possible to confirm this.
So after returning to Germany from Denmark, Hahn continued his experiments.
In December, his experiment achieved a breakthrough!
Hahn discovered three more unknown Isotope could be separated from other elements, but not from barium.
In chemistry, this means that these three Isotope are very likely Isotope of element 56 [barium].
That's incredible.
Hahn is facing the same predicament that Irène faced before.
Uranium, element 92, can surprisingly produce barium, element 56, which has a significantly different Atom!
This overturned Bohr's Liquid Drop Model.
On December 19, Hahn wrote to Meitner informing him of the experimental results.
Two days later, through further verification, he completely confirmed that the mysterious Isotope was indeed Isotope of barium!
Therefore, the lanthanum element that Irène discovered also exists, because barium Atomic Nucleus can transform into lanthanum through Beta Decay.
At this point, Hahn was convinced that Neutron bombardment of uranium nuclei would produce barium, which would then decay into lanthanum.
This phenomenon, which is impossible in physics, has now happened.
He feared that Irène would realize what was happening and try to publish the paper first, so he stopped writing to Meitner to discuss it.
On December 23, Meitner's nephew Frisch, came to Sweden to visit his aunt.
Meitner then showed him Hahn's letter, and the two decided to consider the possibility of Uranium Nuclear Fission.
At this time, Frisch was studying under Bohr at the Bohr Institute, and he was very familiar with the Liquid Drop Model.
With his help, the aunt and niece worked together to calculate it theoretically.
Finally, as mentioned in the previous chapter, Meitner proved that Uranium Nuclear Fission is theoretically feasible.
Hahn and Irène's experimental results were correct; the uranium Atomic Nucleus did indeed split!
Fermi's claim about Transuranium Elements is entirely fictitious; they are merely fragments resulting from fission!
Frisch immediately rushed back to Denmark to discuss the matter with Bohr.
Upon hearing this theory, Bohr slapped his forehead and laughed:
"How could I be so stupid!"
Meitner, on the other hand, couldn't wait to write to Hahn, telling him the good news and hoping that he wouldn't rush to write the paper, but would try to incorporate the theory.
Unfortunately, this time, she never received a reply.
On January 6, 1939, the paper co-authored by Hahn and Strassmann was published.
The two researchers experimentally confirmed that Neutron bombardment of uranium can produce barium.
The next day, the paper arrived in Denmark. After reading it, Frisch had no time to defend his aunt.
Because Hahn only discovered this phenomenon experimentally, but did not prove it theoretically.
He wants to publish a paper that will theoretically confirm the existence of uranium fission.
After completing his paper, Frisch even used Cloud Chamber to track the fragmentation debris, proving in the most intuitive way that Neutron bombardment of uranium nuclei did indeed cause fission.
On February 11, Frisch and Meitner co-authored a theoretical article published in Nature.
In the paper, Frisch first used the term "fission," meaning fission.
On February 18, Frisch's paper, published solely under his name, on observing Nuclear Fission using Cloud Chamber, was then published.
After the paper was published, the relationship between Meitner and Hahn officially broke down.
After they read each other's papers, I wonder what their thoughts were.
There are two sides to the story.
Just after Hahn published his paper and before Frisch published his.
On January 7, Bohr was invited to the United States to attend a physics conference.
Before boarding the ship, Frisch handed the first draft of his paper to Bohr he greatly respected and hoped would give it a final review.
Another physicist who accompanied Bohr at the time was Rosenfeld.
The journey was long, so Bohr discussed Frisch's paper with his partner, who was horrified after hearing it!
"Uranium Atomic Nucleus can undergo Nuclear Fission?"
"Doesn't this mean that Fermi's Transuranium Elements was wrong, and the Nobel Prize made a huge blunder?"
Bohr was probably too tired; he forgot to tell Rosenfeld to keep it confidential, since Frisch's paper had not yet been formally published.
On January 16, Bohr arrived in New York, where he was personally greeted by Fermi and a large group of physicists. (At this time, Fermi had only been in the United States for a short time.)
Bohr was very professional and did not spread the news of Uranium Nuclear Fission.
However, that evening, Rosenfeld was dragged by his friend Wheeler to Princeton University to attend a physics club meeting.
At the meeting, Rosenfeld recounted his discussions with Bohr regarding Uranium Nuclear Fission.
Actually, you can't blame him, because he didn't know Frisch's specific situation either.
His words immediately stunned all the physicists present!
This is absolutely groundbreaking news that will shock the academic world.
The next day, Bohr arrived in Princeton University and was shocked to hear the news.
He quickly wrote an article, publicly stating that the theoretical explanation of Uranium Nuclear Fission was attributed to Meitner and Frisch.
Immediately afterwards, he wrote to Frisch: send the paper to Nature magazine for publication as soon as possible.
However, he did not receive a reply from Frisch.
On January 20th, Fermi learned about Uranium Nuclear Fission from his friends Rabi (Chapter 552), Lamb, and others.
At this point, Fermi realized he was wrong; there was no Transuranium Elements.
However, just a month ago, he gave a public speech about Transuranium Elements.
Fermi felt a mix of emotions.
However, no one looked down on Fermi because of this, or thought he didn't deserve the Nobel Prize.
After all, the Four-Fermion Theory alone was enough to establish his status as a leading figure, not to mention other theories such as Neutron Bombardment Method.
At the same time, news of Uranium Nuclear Fission began to spread rapidly.
On January 26, the Fifth Washington Theoretical Physics Conference urgently invited two leading figures, Bohr and Fermi.
The original topic of the conference was low-temperature physics.
However, when news of Uranium Nuclear Fission spread, the meeting was in complete chaos.
Nobody's discussing low-temperature physics anymore; all physicists are talking about Uranium Nuclear Fission.
At the meeting, Bohr once again emphasized Hahn's experiments and Frisch's theoretical explanation.
He knew he couldn't stop others from conducting experiments, but he needed to protect Free and Meitner's priority. (Hahn's paper had already been published by then, so it didn't matter.)
Bohr was indeed a man of impeccable character!
While the meeting was being held, more than a dozen United States universities and research institutes, including Columbia University and California Institute of Technology, had already begun experiments.
On January 28, someone announced confirmation of Uranium Nuclear Fission.
Subsequently, more physicists proved this result.
Furthermore, it was determined that the Uranium Nuclear Fission was not Uranium-238, but rather the rarer Uranium-235.
When the news reached the University of California, Berkeley on the West Coast of the United States, Oppenheimer immediately expressed disbelief.
However, his laboratory immediately confirmed this result.
After staring at the fragmented remains and remaining silent for three minutes, Oppenheimer came to believe in Uranium Nuclear Fission.
On February 7, Bohr published another article in which he explained in detail the origins and development of Uranium Nuclear Fission and advocated for the rights of the aunt and nephew.
Thus, the question of the attribution of Uranium Nuclear Fission came to an end, but research on it only fueled the fire.
All Experimental Physics devoted themselves to Uranium Nuclear Fission.
In mid-February, Hahn published his second paper, predicting that Uranium Nuclear Fission would release Neutron along with the nuclear fusion process.
In March, Irène proved through experiments that Uranium-235 undergoes fission and releases more than two Neutron.
These Neutron will then bombard other uranium Atomic Nucleus, continuing in a snowball effect, forming a chain reaction and releasing enormous amounts of energy.
After reading the paper, Oppenheimer took only a few minutes to think about the possibility of making weapons.
A week later, sketches of a weapon (the Atom) appeared on the blackboard in his office.
At that time, it was just scientists conducting research spontaneously with a scientific attitude; the authorities were unaware of the importance of Uranium Nuclear Fission.
But soon, the truth could no longer be hidden.
The United States, the Soviet Union, the United Kingdom, Britain, France, Germany, Italy the Cherry Blossom Clan, among other powerful nations, officially launched their Atom programs.
A new scientific race has begun!
And in this grand drama about Uranium Nuclear Fission, the most dramatic part is:
In May 1940, McMillan and Abelson of the University of California, Berkeley, actually found Transuranium Elements 93 in the reaction products of Neutron bombardment of uranium, and named it [neptunium].
The two were awarded the Nobel Prize in Chemistry in 1951 for their work.
Some might wonder, "Why could only these two do the same experiment, and not others?"
Because the two researchers used Cyclotron to accelerate Neutron for their experiments, they were able to precisely control the speed of the Neutron.