Liu Zhiyuan read the news several times before the shock in his heart finally subsided.
He immediately logged into QQ and entered the "Oracle Center VIP" group, where the deal was already being discussed Heat.
"I really didn't expect Matthews to be traded. He was playing really well, why did they have to send him away?"
"I'm a bit confused too. 3D players will definitely be a sought-after resource by every team in the future. Coach Z couldn't possibly not see that, could he? How could he let Matthews go?"
"Do you guys think Larry Riley made this trade? I find it hard to believe Coach Z would trade Matthews for Kirilenko; it's so stupid..."
Liu Zhiyuan scrolled up and read through the comments of others. Most people thought the Warriors hadn't made a worthwhile trade.
Although their words were somewhat radical, they were not without reason. When Liu Zhiyuan saw the news, he was also filled with confusion.
Kirilenko is an all-around defender of All-Defensive Team caliber, with exceptional sweeping and Help Defense abilities. He can also orchestrate offense and is a strong finisher around the basket. Swapping him for Matthews would be a powerful addition to the Warriors' Wing defense and ball handling.
However, his inability to shoot has become increasingly apparent with the times, and he has long been marginalized by the Jazz. The Warriors already have poor spacing, so it's hard to say whether bringing him in would be beneficial or detrimental.
Moreover, Kirilenko is already 30 years old this year, and his contract only has six months left, with an annual salary of $17.82 million. The Warriors only have the right to use him for half a season, while Matthews has only played one and a half seasons, has made rapid progress, and still has potential to be explored. His contract is also much smaller than Kirilenko's. No matter how you look at it, this trade is a huge loss for the Warriors.
However, Liu Zhiyuan and realized that Kirilenko's big contract wasn't entirely useless. The Warriors Roster had too many Rookie, and quite a few of them had Minimum Salary contracts. They needed this big contract to fill their Salary Floor, which was why the Warriors were able to offer a $9 million Trade Exception. They had a lot of salary cap space to fill and could afford Kirilenko's contract.
Moreover, Kirilenko's contract expires in six months, which will allow the Warriors to fill their Salary Floor and free up a large amount of salary space. This gives them a good balance of offense and defense, making it a win-win situation.
But Liu Zhiyuan felt a pang of regret when he thought of the Cavaliers draft pick the Warriors.
The past two drafts have been weak, and the Warriors Roster already have so many Rookie. Why did Coach Z trade for another Draft Pick this year? Is he addicted to hoarding Rookie?
Furthermore, he even went so far as to trade Matthews to the Nets. With Deron and Matthews, the Nets could surge in the standings after the All-Star, causing their Nets Pick value to drop. Wouldn't the Warriors end up with nothing?
The more Liu Zhiyuan thought about it, the more confused and regretful he felt about the deal. He had seen that Zhang Yu might trade Matthews, but he never expected that he would make such a deal in the end. It would have been better not to make the deal at all!
Liu Zhiyuan the group chat for a while, then went to the Hupu forum, which was gradually gaining popularity, where fans were also discussing the trade.
However, the atmosphere on Hupu forum is different from that on "Oracle Center VIP". It is a gathering place for a large number of ordinary fans who do not have a basic understanding of advanced data. They judge the level of players more based on their reputation and the size of their contracts. Many people think that the Warriors made a good deal, and many people support Coach Z as enthusiastically as they support Yao Ming, believing that he must have his own considerations for doing so. Non-fans have no right to comment.
As a result, three factions formed on the Hupu forum: one faction was optimistic about the Warriors' trade, another was pessimistic, and the two factions quickly started arguing. The remaining faction, naturally, consisted of fans of other teams watching the drama unfold.
Liu Zhiyuan browsed through several posts, which included both sides of the argument. However, he found that they were full of sarcastic and personal attacks such as "Do you think you know more about football than Coach Z?", "If you're so good, then you do it. If you're not, then shut up.", "Hehe, young people probably don't know how terrifying Kirilenko is. Watch more football.", and "It seems that Huaxia people really don't understand football. Coach Z is nothing special." Several posts with substantial thoughts were also buried among them.
Liu Zhiyuan stared blankly for a long time, then suddenly took a deep breath, picked up the keyboard, and began typing rapidly:
"In my opinion, this trade wasn't worthwhile for the Warriors, but Warriors didn't lose too much either. Here's why..."
He spent an hour writing a long post analyzing the trade in detail. He hadn't originally planned to write so much, but he couldn't stop writing, so he also analyzed the pros and cons of the trade from the perspectives of the Nets and the Jazz.
However, the writing process was also a process of sorting out information. Liu Zhiyuan writing and attached many self-made data charts to the post. The focus was naturally on Kirilenko and Matthews, which changed his views on trading to some extent.
Finally, he concluded:
"... In conclusion, the Jazz's trade is rated A-. They cleared out unstable elements in the team, acquired a high draft Rookie, Draft Pick, and Trade Exception, enabling them to rebuild quickly. However, the loss of Deron is irreparable, so I give the Jazz an A- rating."
The Nets are an A+; they've acquired an Elite Point Guard and quality 3-and-D players, but they still need to continue building their Lineup around Deron Williams. Therefore, I believe their record will definitely improve, but they're still a ways from the Playoffs.
The Warriors' trade is rated B. They lost a promising young 3-and-D player but upgraded their Wing Lineup. Kirilenko's playmaking, Help Defense, and Rim Protection are exactly what the Warriors need, but he will exacerbate Warriors spacing weakness. Furthermore, the Warriors only have him for half a season, and how to Contract Renewal Kirilenko is also a problem... However, judging from the data, losing Matthews didn't have as big an impact on the Warriors as some might think; Butler can completely fill the void... This round of Draft Pick swaps was undoubtedly a loss for the Warriors. The Nets Pick's draft position is very likely lower than the Cavaliers ', but this was Coach Z's decision. Based on the Warriors' past trades, I believe there should be further developments, so I give it a B rating."
This post, which was several thousand words long, quickly attracted attention, and the comments below increased rapidly. Such long, high-quality posts are generally not favored by ordinary fans. Most of the commenters are rational fans who pay attention to data, and they also highly agree with Liu Zhiyuan's well-reasoned and evidence-based views based on data analysis.
Among these people were both proponents and opponents. After seeing Liu Zhiyuan's post, they all changed their minds to varying degrees, and coincidentally quoted Liu Zhiyuan's views in other posts, attracting a lot of traffic to the posts.
In fact, because Liu Zhiyuan had previously posted several medium-length analyses in the "Oracle Center VIP" group chat, some group members recognized Liu Zhiyuan from the writing style of the posts, which gave the group chat a boost in popularity and attracted many fans to join.
Liu Zhiyuan kept refreshing the website, and seeing his post gaining more and more popularity, likes, and comments, a sense of accomplishment welled up within him.
This was the first time he had written a long analysis online, and he never expected it to gain so much recognition. Seeing the enthusiastic response to his analysis, Liu Zhiyuan's heart began to stir.
Or... should I write some more analytical articles later?