Johnny's performance was truly captivating; he perfectly captured Captain Jack's madness, wickedness, and romance, even exceeding expectations.
But she always felt something was off. Johnny's madness was too outward, with a deliberate "grotesqueness," as if he was trying hard to show the character's uniqueness, but lacked a sense of restrained loneliness.
The Captain Jack in Irene's mind is outwardly crazy, but inwardly harbors an extreme yearning for freedom and hidden pain from the past. However, Johnny's performance lacks this deep emotional expression, focusing more on outward madness.
Of course, this isn't a problem with acting skills, but rather a subtle deviation in understanding the character.
Perhaps Johnny was too eager to grasp the "madness" label, thus neglecting the complexity of the character. However, this deviation is not irreversible. With targeted training after joining the production team, guiding him towards deeper emotional expression, the character can certainly be made more well-rounded.
"Thank you for your performance, Mr. Depp. We will inform your agent directly of the results," casting director John Irving said quickly when no one spoke.
Depp smiled casually, nodded, and left.
As the auditions of the four big names concluded, the sun was already setting, and golden light streamed in through the studio windows, bathing the props and figures in a warm yellow hue.
A heated discussion ensued among the people behind the long table.
Disney's Amy Carl insisted. "Hugh Jack is the safest bet. He has great action scenes, audience appeal, box office draw, and can boost the Australia market, making him the least risky choice."
Fox's Adelaide Griffin countered, "Robert De Niro's acting skills are beyond question; he just hasn't found his footing yet. Give him another chance to hone his skills, and he'll definitely meet expectations. Moreover, his involvement elevates the film's artistic level."
A CAA representative added, "Jim Carrey's comedic talent is unique, allowing him to reach new audiences, especially young viewers, something the other three haven't been able to do. He only needs to slightly tone down his exaggerated performances to truly fit the role."
Everyone has their own stance and thoughts, and the reasons they give are varied. Irene glanced at Jerry Bruckheimer, "Jerry, what do you say?"
Jerry glanced at her, not immediately responding, but instead flipping through his notes before speaking after a while, "Hugh Jack is too upright, Robert De Niro is too steady, Jim Carrey is too flamboyant, Johnny Depp is too wicked. If I had to say who's the most suitable, I don't think anyone truly fits my image of Captain Jack. But of the four, Jim Carrey and Johnny Depp are slightly closer to the role."
Irene nodded, agreeing with her assessment, and added, "Jerry and I think the same thing. Everyone's performances are slightly different from my image of Captain Jack, but Jim Carrey and Johnny Depp's performances are more suitable for our film's style. However, both of them focus too much on outward madness, neglecting the inner loneliness and struggle of a Pirates. I suggest arranging for these two to audition in costume next, and also asking their thoughts on signing on to three films in a row, as this is quite important."
Jerry nodded, clearly agreeing with Irene's opinion.
He looked at everyone. "I know you're all worried about Johnny's conduct. But when he came for the audition today, he arrived an hour early, was completely focused, and didn't slack off at all. He even proactively discussed character details with the casting director, which shows he's genuinely invested in this role. Moreover, his understanding of the character far exceeds our expectations."
Irene was also surprised that Johnny Depp's performance had won Jerry's approval. It seems that the reason Johnny was chosen to play Jack Sparrow in the previous life was also orchestrated by Jerry Bruckheimer.
Since Jerry thinks highly of Depp, things become much easier.
After the auditions ended, everyone tidied up their materials and left one after another. Jerry, who was walking behind, called out to Irene, "Irene, wait a moment, there are still some things I'd like to discuss with you about Captain Jack."
The others glanced back, their eyes shifting between Irene and Jerry, but said nothing.
"What's up, Jerry?" Irene put down what she was holding and sat down in her seat.
"Who do you think is more suitable, Jim Carrey or Johnny Depp? Don't try to fool me. Although I was brought in by Disney, I also invested in the company. I need the most suitable person."
Irene's eyes widened slightly. She hadn't expected the other party to be so direct, and how come she didn't know that Jerry Bruckheimer had also invested in the film?
"You seem surprised that I would invest in movies?" Jerry asked, noticing Irene's expression.
"Shouldn't that be strange? Disney gave you a share? How come I didn't know?" Irene looked puzzled. This was no small matter. Disney's own share was only 35%. How much would they give up? It couldn't possibly be more than 10%.
"For every film I produce, my company is involved in the investment and production. Before your project even reached us, I had already planned to make a Pirates movie for Disney, but that was just a preliminary idea. Before we even decided whether the lead actor would be male or female, your proposal came to me."
Hearing this, Irene broke out in a cold sweat. If she had been two months later, this movie might have really been out of her reach.
"So I value this movie no less than you do. Tell me your honest thoughts. You created Captain Jack, so you know better than anyone what he should be like."
"From the moment I recommended Johnny Depp for the audition, I had already decided on Captain Jack for me." Irene didn't beat around the bush with Jerry and directly stated her true thoughts.
"Then Jim Carrey..." Jerry laughed halfway through his sentence, "I understand what you mean, but before we get to that, I'm genuinely curious, why are you so certain that Depp is the only choice for Captain Jack? In my opinion, Jim Carrey's comedic tension and physical expressiveness actually fit the Pirates's madness very well."
Irene smiled, her tone firm. "Madness is just Captain Jack's shell, not his core. Jim Carrey's madness is outward, aggressive, like a wielding scimitar, its sharpness fully exposed. But Jack is different; his madness is a drunkard's lucidity. On the surface, he's swaying, grinning, even a bit absurd, but his eyes conceal calculation, a fanatical obsession with freedom, and a kind of insightful understanding that knowing the world is crazy, it's better to be even crazier than it."