After its premiere, "The Hulk" received mixed reviews from the audience, but critics considered it a must-see masterpiece.
In his column for the Chicago Sun-Times, Roger Ebert devoted nearly a thousand words to praising the film, his words brimming with admiration for Ang Lee's cinematic language. "Ang Lee's * Hulk * is a visually elegant artistic experiment. He boldly appropriates the split-screen technique from comics, not as a simple formal replication, but by fusing moving frame lines with picture-in-picture narrative, creating a subtle intertextual relationship between foreground and background—when Bruce Banner's pained gaze intertwines with the Hulk's furious figure in the same frame, the tension between humanity and bestiality is far more impactful than mere fighting."
He emphasized that, "As an 'outsider' to the science fiction genre, Ang Lee deliberately downplayed the flashy action effects and instead focused on the emotional depth of the character, making this classic figure in United States comic book history a tragic hero with flesh and blood, burdened by family trauma and a crisis of self-identity."
The New Yorker's review also gave it high praise, "This film completely breaks free from the mold of popcorn blockbusters. Ang Lee, with his unique and delicate touch, elevates the superhero movie into a philosophical exploration of identity and redemption. Split-screen editing is not a new technique, but in his hands, the smooth switching of moving split screens, the rapid interweaving and seamless transition of multiple scenes, make the big screen feel like a living comic book. Every shot pays homage to the original work, while also achieving a breakthrough in the dimension of cinematic language."
Professional media outlets such as <Sight & Sound> and <Film Comment> also followed up, praising the film for "achieving a breakthrough in artistic expression within the framework of commercial genre films."
The endorsements from professional film critics did have some effect. At present, many fans still go to the cinema because of the critics' reviews. In addition, the Hulk's own appeal is not to be underestimated, and the superhero movie craze ignited by Spider-Man has not yet subsided. As a result, the opening week box office of Hulk was not as dismal as the criticism on the opening night predicted.
In its opening weekend, the film topped the North America box office with $62.6 million. While this figure didn't match the explosive success of the "Pirates of the Caribbean" series, nor did it reach Universal's expected peak, it was still a respectable result considering the production budget and marketing investment of $137 million.
Universal Pictures executives breathed a sigh of relief. Ron Mayer emphasized in an internal meeting. "Critics' recognition proves the film's artistic value, and the opening weekend box office also verifies the IP's appeal. As word-of-mouth spreads, the subsequent box office is expected to stabilize."
The company has even begun preparing a small-scale additional promotional campaign, attempting to leverage the positive reviews from film critics to further stimulate the market.
However, this optimism lasted only a week.
In its second weekend, "The Hulk" suffered a precipitous drop at the box office, with its $12.5 million grossing an 80% decrease from its opening weekend, causing it to plummet from the top of the box office charts to the lower half.
Such a drop is unprecedented not only in the history of superhero movies, but also extremely rare in the entire history of commercial film releases, completely shattering Universal's wishful thinking.
Even more damaging was the continued spread of negative word-of-mouth from ordinary viewers on social media, with comments such as "dull and lengthy," "not living up to its reputation," and "a waste of intellectual property" becoming the mainstream. Even with the praise and endorsement of film critics, it was difficult to salvage the public's resistance.
Universal Pictures quickly launched a crisis management campaign, urgently halting all additional promotional plans and postponing its planned overseas promotional activities indefinitely.
Ron Mayer's office lights were on all night. Internal data showed that the film's audience dropout rate was as high as 40%, and the second viewing rate was less than 5%, indicating that the loss of the core audience was inevitable.
Worse still, theaters began drastically reducing screenings, with some even withdrawing their shows altogether, leaving the screens for competitors with greater market appeal.
Suddenly, Universal became the target of ridicule from major film companies, and their public relations departments began to try to divert attention, deliberately downplaying the producers' decision-making errors in positioning the film, and instead pointing the finger at director Ang Lee: "The market response to <The Hulk> did not meet expectations. The core reason is that the director's handling of commercial genre films was flawed, overemphasizing personal artistic expression and ignoring the core expectations of the general audience for superhero movies."
This statement was like a tidal wave, instantly thrusting Ang Lee into the public eye.
Some extreme fans began to direct their anger at Ang Lee, with Facebook saying "Ang Lee ruined the Hulk" popping up everywhere.
Admittedly, he directed the film, and he bears some responsibility for the current effect. However, the script and overall style of the film had to go through layers of review within Universal. Ang Lee is not the CEO of Universal, so how could he just make the film however he wanted?
Those in the know can immediately see that Universal is trying to shirk responsibility.
Critics who had previously praised the film collectively voiced their opposition. Roger Ebert, in a subsequent column, angrily criticized Universal: "Blaming the director for box office failure is Hollywood's most cowardly way of shifting blame. Ang Lee has opened up new possibilities for superhero movies with artistic techniques. The real problem is that the producers want both artistic acclaim and commercial success, but have never clearly defined their own position."
The New Yorker went even further, stating. "Universal fully supported Ang Lee's creative vision from the early stages of the project, but now they've turned their backs on him. This opportunistic approach is more despicable than the controversy surrounding the film itself."
Just as public opinion was at a stalemate, Eric Bana's statement pushed Ang Lee into the eye of the storm.
The actor, who gained considerable attention for his film, posted a lengthy article on his personal Facebook, filled with accusations against Ang Lee, even making extreme statements such as "Ang Lee is the worst director I've ever seen."
He claimed, "During filming, Ang Lee was completely immersed in his own world, refusing to listen to the actors' reasonable suggestions, and his understanding of the character went against the original comics. I repeatedly pointed out that the core of the Hulk should be the manifestation of power and justice, rather than endless inner struggles, but my opinions were always ignored."
Bana's remarks about distancing himself from the situation were a fatal blow.
As the film's core lead actor, his public defection not only left Ang Lee isolated and helpless, but also caused the already precarious reputation of the film to collapse completely.
Many viewers were misled by his remarks, becoming even more convinced that the film's failure stemmed from Ang Lee's "stubbornness," and some extreme fans even launched a campaign to "boycott Ang Lee's works."
There have also been many doubts within Hollywood, with some producers becoming cautious about working with Ang Lee, believing that he is "too stubborn and not suitable for creating commercial blockbusters."