Time flies, and after more than two months of wrangling over the issue of debt distribution, the nine governments still haven't reached a conclusion.
Governments around the world are each standing on their own grounds, and the solutions they've come up with are all sorts of bizarre, but very few are reliable.
The debts from last year have not yet been repaid, and the debts for next year are about to mature. The creditors' patience is gradually running out, and the attitude of the representatives of Britain, France, and Bulgaria is becoming increasingly tough.
This time, Europe countries stood together and demanded payment from them. During the Tsarist Government, bonds had been issued to the Europe continent on several occasions.
Now, it's time to pay back the debts. Looking around, all I see are creditors, and regardless of the amount, it's time to repay them all.
Although they don't owe money to governments around the world, they do owe money to the people. Even if it's just for votes, the government has to act like it's collecting debts.
Historically, these individuals were the first to default on their debts, since they lacked the ability to collect them anyway. This was one of the reasons why Europe countries collectively ostracized Russia.
It was only during the reign of Alexander III that the Russian Empire was fully accepted by Europe countries. Just over twenty years later, the Tsarist Government's century-long efforts were destroyed.
"Gentlemen, this arguing can't go on. After deliberation by our League of Nations Executive Committee and considering the demands of all parties, we have decided:"
"We will conduct a comprehensive assessment based on factors such as population, economy, and territory to fairly allocate the debt borne by each party!" United Kingdom Foreign Secretary Attlee began.
Overall, the allocation plan is sound, taking into account the interests of all parties, and focusing on suppressing West Russia and Soviet Russia.
In terms of population, West Russia accounts for nearly half; in terms of economy, West Russia accounts for 60%; and in terms of land area, West Russia accounts for 17%.
In summary: 1/3 * 1/2 + 60% * 1/3 + 1/3 * 17% ≈ 42%
Nicholas II still bears the largest proportion of the debt; if it weren't for ideological issues with Soviet Russia, he would have been responsible for at least half of it.
Following closely behind was the Soviet Russia government, which inherited nearly 21 percent of the Russian Empire's population, 15 percent of its economy, and 58 percent of its territory.
In summary: 1/3 * 0.21 + 1/3 * 0.15 + 1/3 * 0.58 ≈ 31%
The situation was much better for East Russia, which inherited 22 percent of the Russian Empire's population, 16 percent of its economy, and 20 percent of its territory.
In summary: 1/3 * 0.22 + 1/3 * 0.16 + 1/3 * 0.2 ≈ 19%
Apart from these three main debtors, the other countries are not worth mentioning; for example, Finland received only 2% of the debt.
This was calculated by Britain, France, and Bulgaria themselves; it's all an estimate. As for its accuracy? Unfortunately, in this day and age, many things can be estimated, and verification is simply impossible.
The League of Nations would not help them measure their territory at this time, much less conduct a census or study their economic development.
So when this result came out, large countries complained, and small countries cried poverty. Don't underestimate the small percentage of reparations (one or two percent); the base amount is huge!
Even if war reparations could offset some of the debt owed by the Russian Empire, the amount of debt they would still have to share would still be no less than Pound Sterling 3 billion.
For example, two locations in Finland would cost Pound Sterling 60 million, which averages Pound Sterling 21.42 per person.
On the surface, this debt doesn't seem high; in developed countries, it would be equivalent to three months' salary.
But in Finland at that time, it was a different story; this was roughly equivalent to two years' income for an average person.
What can be done? At present, the Finland government's annual fiscal revenue is at most a million Pound Sterling. Even if the Finland government wanted to repay the money, it would be equivalent to sixty years of their fiscal revenue.
Once the interest-free loan matures and converts into an interest-bearing loan, they won't even be able to pay the interest. Even God can't help them if they're broke!
Without a doubt, the Grand Duchy of Finland took the lead in reneging on its promises, and in a way that left everyone helpless—they wouldn't give us money, and they wouldn't even give us our lives.
"It's a pity that it's not that we're unwilling to take on this debt, but our country is too poor. With our government's fiscal revenue, we can't even pay the interest."
"If we are to assume this debt, please waive all interest. We estimate that we'll have paid it off in about two hundred years!" said Paul, the Finland representative, looking utterly miserable.
He's a great actor indeed; he silenced everyone who wanted to say something. They really didn't have any money, and besides, Finland doesn't have any industries that would attract anyone, so they couldn't even settle the debt with goods!
United Kingdom Foreign Secretary Attlee, who was initially confident of success, is now finding the situation tricky; it's a very real problem.
Due to the civil war, the nine independent nations are now in dire economic straits, with almost all of them unable to pay interest on their national revenues.
If interest were completely waived and they were allowed to repay freely, it's unlikely anyone would be so conscientious. Perhaps, as the Finland representative suggested, the debt would be almost fully repaid in two hundred years.
They're clearly refusing to pay their debts, but now they're acting so pitiful, trying to gain everyone's sympathy.
"How about this, let's extend the terms of the loans that have already matured for a while, and then repay them gradually after the economies of each country have recovered!" Metev suggested.
This very constructive suggestion was immediately rejected by the France, because they were issuing so many interest-free loans.
Despite Russia owing them the most money, the interest they actually receive is the lowest among the three countries. For a loan of over a billion Pound Sterling, the annual interest is only a little over ten million Pound Sterling, which is pitifully low.
"No, the banks providing these loans probably won't accept them. Failure to repay on time could trigger a financial crisis!" France Foreign Minister Ge'osi said, his face ashen.
However, after glancing at the representatives of the nine countries, it seemed that if it weren't for maintaining order in the venue, they would all be playing the victim by now, which gave Ge'osi a headache.
The debts must be collected, otherwise the domestic financial groups will definitely not let him off the hook. Extending the loan term is indeed a good solution, but he doesn't have the final say on that.
"How about we have these nine countries form a joint debt guarantee and share the debt together?" Ge'osi suggested.
"If that's the case, then we probably can forget about receiving the money. Governments are passing the buck; what are we supposed to do?" Metev countered.
"How about we reduce some of the debt?" Attlee suggested.
"I can't make that decision!" Ge'osi said.
"Don't look at me. Bulgaria's loans are all secured by collateral. The Russia can't repay their loans, so it doesn't matter to us!" Metev said with a slight smile.
The two men's expressions changed, and they said that everyone actually had some collateral, but mentioning tariffs at this time was just nonsense.
To enter the Russian Empire from the Black Sea, one had to pass through Bulgaria first. Regardless of how the Russia collected tariffs, Bulgaria would collect them anyway.
The Black Sea Straits are no longer a free port; they are Bulgaria's inland waters, and ships entering them must pay taxes.
With higher taxes, products become less competitive, and capitalists lose interest in continuing trade with Russia. Russia has long since become a haven for Bulgaria goods.
The customs duties that the Russia pledged to them actually amounted to very little money for Britain and France.
The tariffs between Bulgaria-Russia are symbolic. Russia often transit through Bulgaria when importing or exporting goods, since it's on their way. It just involves getting a few more stamps, which allows them to bypass British and French customs inspectors.
Now, apart from some customs revenue from the Baltic Sea, Britain and France have even withdrawn their supervisory personnel from the Black Sea. With only one Lev per ship, the tax revenue they collect isn't even enough to pay salaries.
The remaining taxes—salt tax, tobacco tax, liquor tax, and all sorts of miscellaneous mortgage taxes—were even more embarrassing. The Russia tax authorities were utterly shameless; the figures were shockingly low.
This situation began after the outbreak of the Russian Civil War, so it's better not to mention the collateral; bringing it up is a painful topic.
Attlee knew this was the problem, so they were the only ones left to take the lead. Bulgaria's attitude was very clear: they didn't care at all.
Even if the Russia can't repay their loans, they'll be even happier, getting Ukraine for free—it's a huge profit, isn't it?
Regarding the loan, most of the principal has already been recovered, and the Bulgaria government is willing to use the remaining amount to acquire the Ukraine region.
That wouldn't work for them. Now that the Russian Empire is divided into nine parts, those collateral are even less reliable. They can't exactly send people to collect taxes themselves, can they?
"How about we accept in-kind compensation? Let's see what local specialties they have, and we can give them what we need!" Attlee suggested after thinking for a moment.
"That's impossible. Such a huge sum of money! The Russia have practically no industry; what would we need so many raw materials for?" Ge'osi objected.
In those days, ordinary industrial raw materials were worthless. Britain and France had their own colonies to supply them, so they didn't need them at all, and they couldn't sell them back home.
"Then we'll just have to make them repay in installments, prioritizing the bank loans, using the surplus to redeem bonds, and leaving the unpaid portions unpaid indefinitely!" Attlee said slyly.
Clearly, he is prioritizing the interests of conglomerates, while ordinary people holding bonds are essentially being abandoned.
"Then let's extend the Russia debt, at the previous interest rate, and let them repay it whenever they have the money!" Grace said after thinking for a moment.
Metev simply nodded in agreement. In this era, governments around the world were essentially spokespeople for interest groups, so of course they had to stand on the side of those interest groups.
"Alright, we have carefully considered the issues Mr. Paul just raised. Everyone is aware of the actual situation of each country's government."
"After discussion, we've decided to postpone part of the debt. Specific details will be determined later. In principle, we will allocate 30% of your annual fiscal revenue to repay the debt!" Attlee said loudly.
"Mr. Attlee, this ratio is far too high. No country in the world has a fiscal surplus of 30 percent. We cannot afford such a high financial ratio!"
Furthermore, our debt allocation ratio is significant, exceeding the debt we should bear and our capacity to bear it!
"You know, many loans from the former Russian Empire were secured by collateral. We can sell these collaterals and reduce our debt!" Vasilyevich said earnestly.
"This ratio is the result of comprehensive consideration. You can keep your objections if you have any. As for selling collateral to reduce debt, that can be done later; it's not contradictory!" Attlee said with a grim expression.
Opinions? Any distribution plan will have its share of objections, but the distribution plan proposed by the League of Nations has taken into account the interests of all parties as much as possible.
If they still want to find fault, then they are deliberately causing trouble and disrespecting everyone, and they must be taught a lesson.
It can be said that the Soviet Russia representatives were wrong from the start. Neither the United Kingdom, France, nor Bulgaria believed that everyone was an equal.
The status of great powers and ordinary countries was not equal; once that line was crossed, one would suffer losses.
On the contrary, the approach taken by the Finland representative was more acceptable. By placing themselves in a very humble position, people were more likely to give them some preferential treatment out of sympathy for the weak.
Of course, this preferential treatment is mainly for political showmanship, not because they have any real compassion, provided that their interests are not harmed.
Boris had received guidance from Ferdinand. His pleading for poverty and playing the victim in the League of Nations was just the beginning. Later, the Finland representative also went to the media to plead for poverty and play the victim.
Only by first moving the citizens of London can we move the London government to leniently intervene.
Next, he would travel around various Europe countries to gain sympathy so that people would give him a break.
This method is only suitable for small countries, whose debt is not much to begin with, and governments are quite willing to put on a show.
Then, taking advantage of the situation, they sold Finland specialty paper and wood products to pay off their debts, thus opening up sales channels for their domestic products.
Even Paul, the diplomatic representative, was actually an actor, a talent Boris had poached from the Bulgaria film industry.
So at the beginning, Paul was just memorizing his lines; all he had to do was portray the misery of Finland.
He doesn't need to renege on his debts, nor does he need to engage in heated arguments with others. He just needs to adopt a humble attitude and be more sincere.
The Grand Duchy of Finland is determined to repay its debts and will not default on a single penny. The only problem is that it currently lacks the funds and simply cannot afford to pay.
This direct refusal was much more shrewd; at least the major creditors were satisfied with the Finland's attitude and showed no intention of making things difficult for them.
"Mr. Attlee, as far as I know, there was a secret agreement between Bulgaria and Bulgaria-Russia if the Russian Empire was unable to repay its debts, it could sell the Ukraine region to Bulgaria for 30 billion Lev, including a 10 billion Lev mortgage loan."
Although the Russian Empire has disintegrated, the treaty remains valid. We, the nine nations, are all successors to the Russian Empire, and we now have the right to sell the Ukraine region.
"Mr. Metev, is what I said true?" Vasilyevich said logically and persuasively.
"That's right, the Bulgaria-Russia countries have a mortgage loan agreement regarding the Ukraine region," Metev replied.
This was an open secret, known to many, so Metev had no need to lie. Besides, being able to buy into the Ukraine region was a good thing!
Don't be fooled by the large sum of 30 billion Lev. After deducting 10 billion Lev in mortgage loans and the debts that the Russia have been owing to Bulgaria, the actual amount that needs to be paid is only around 10 billion leva.
This is simply half a year's fiscal revenue for the Bulgaria government; raising this money is not difficult.
While some people want to sell, others don't. From Nicholas II's perspective, even if land were to be sold, shouldn't he be the one doing it himself?
How could we possibly sell it through the League of Nations? That would be like throwing ourselves to the wolves!
"No, you're betraying the country! Ukraine is our core interest, and we will absolutely not split it!" Sazonov said angrily.
"I regret to inform you, Mr. Sazonov, that we are no longer of the same country. To me, this is not treason!"
We are all heirs to the Russian Empire, and we have the right to enforce the treaties we signed. Now we can vote on whether to sell the Ukraine region to pay off our debts.
"If you want to retain control of the Ukraine region, all you need to do is take on this debt. It's not a difficult problem!" Vasilyevich bluntly stated.
Everyone understood that he had never intended to sell off the Ukraine region; this pressure was simply to force West Russia to assume a larger proportion of the debt.
This time, apart from West Russia, the remaining seven countries have all sided with them. Whether it's selling off the Ukraine region or letting West Russia take over the debt, it's very beneficial for everyone.
Why wouldn't they do it if they could pay off 40% of the debt in one go without paying any price?
"Impossible! At the last League of Nations conference, the Ukraine region was clearly designated as West Russia territory. You have no right to deal with our territory!" Sazonov roared.
"However, the mortgage loan between Bulgaria-Russia was personally signed by you, Sazonov, before the disintegration of the Russian Empire, and was approved by Nicholas II."
"According to international law, this treaty is still in force, so it can continue to be implemented. I propose a vote by show of hands!" the East Russia representative suddenly said.
As soon as he finished speaking, eight hands were raised. At this point, everyone wanted West Russia to take on more of the debt, so naturally they wanted to unite and pressure them into agreeing.
But would Sazonov dare to back down?
This is clearly impossible. Ukraine cannot be lost, at least not just like that!
Similarly, they cannot take on this additional debt; if they do, their finances will go bankrupt, and they will have to sell off parts of Ukraine to pay off the debt.
At this point, Sazonov began to regret his actions. If he had known so many countries wanted independence, he should have sold off Poland and Central Asia in the first place, and all this trouble would have been avoided.
"I suggest we take a break first, let everyone calm down, and then we can continue negotiating at the next meeting!" Attlee said.
Clearly, not only did West Russia not want to lose the Ukraine region, but the United Kingdom also did not want Bulgaria to acquire Ukraine.
The purpose of Attlee ending the meeting early was to buy time for the British Empire's diplomatic activities.
Knowing this, Metev still didn't object; at this time, Bulgaria shouldn't have shown excessive enthusiasm.
No matter what the United Kingdom do, they cannot change the fact that the nine independent republics are all poor. Forcing West Russia to assume its debts is in their best interest.
Unless the United Kingdom can come up with real money, this matter is beyond their control!