A Detective's Work Is Nothing to Be Ashamed Of
One of them was Tadokoro Shunya, a student who went to check the doors and windows of the Collection Room after returning from delivering meals.
The other is Shuichi Hamura, a Vampire researcher who went to the Underground Library next to the Collection Room to look at the books and did not return to the hall for a long time.
Among them, Tadokoro Toshihiko inspected the doors and windows, but only spent a few minutes and didn't have time to do anything else.
So let's rule that out...
Ikumi Soda looked at Shuichi Hamura: "It seems that only you had the opportunity to commit the crime."
Shuichi Hamura paused, then adjusted his pince-nez and shook his head in rebuttal. "The Collection Room and the study are separated by a hall. I did go to the Collection Room, but you were all sitting in the hall during that time. Even if I had the opportunity to get the wooden peg, I wouldn't have gone to the study to commit the crime."
"There's more than one way to the study; it's just that the other paths aren't as conventional."
Ikumi Soda stepped upstairs and walked towards the second-floor window. "If an accomplice lowers Rope Ladder from the second floor and helps you climb up from the Underground Library, you can get to the second floor first, and then climb up the roof—"
As she spoke, she flung open the window in the second-floor hallway, simultaneously completing the sentence: "--heading to the study."
As the window opened, the long, sloping roof came into view in the moonlight. One end connected to this side, and the other end connected to Daisuke Torakura's study. The tiles were covered with evenly distributed, untouched white snow, without a single footprint.
No one passes by here.
Ikumi Soda: "..."
She stared out the window in silence for a moment, then casually raised her hand and closed the window again.
Making hypotheses and verifying them one by one is a basic Detective's operation. It's great if the reasoning is correct, but if it's wrong... well, it's wrong. It's just a hypothesis, nothing to be ashamed of.
Looking down the corridor, Suzuki Sonoko seemed to remember something and whispered, "The culprit probably didn't come from the roof—while Mr. Hamura was in the library, I stayed in the second-floor corridor, and no one passed by."
Ikumi Soda paused, looking at her with a puzzled expression. "What have you been doing in the second-floor hallway?"
Suzuki Sonoko blushed slightly. "... Look, look at the scenery! It's higher up here than on the First Floor, and the view is better than down below."
"..." In other words, yet another person without an alibi.
Ikumi Soda began to stare at her with a suspicious look.
However, looking at Suzuki Sonoko's thin arms and legs, I always felt that she would have a hard time carrying a grown man like Daisuke Torakura, let alone tying him to a cross.
A few seconds later, Ikumi Soda hesitated, then looked away from Suzuki Sonoko and glanced at Jiang Xia again—her colleagues said this High School Detective solved cases as quickly as reading a script, so why hadn't he made a move today?
Is this case particularly difficult? Or are there some crucial clues they haven't yet discovered?
... So it's perfectly normal that she guessed wrong just now. Ikumi Soda tucked a few strands of her slightly curled hair behind her ear, nodded to herself, and felt much more at ease.
At the same time, I decided to put my mind at ease and continue reasoning—making bold assumptions and carefully verifying them, so that I could find a path to the truth even in impossible crimes.
She looked out the window for a moment, then pushed it open again to observe the eaves outside.
--Not only on the roof of this section of the corridor, but further away, even on the roof of the study, there were no footprints to be seen.
In other words, the prisoner should never have been on the roof. Furthermore, the study door was locked from the inside, and the only key was with Daisuke Torakura; the French windows were located right next to a cliff. She had carefully examined the area in the study earlier—the cliff was not only bottomless, but its protruding parts were also covered in snow, showing no signs of climbing.
All roads are blocked... The killer couldn't have flown there like Vampire, could they?
The reasoning briefly stalled.
Ikumi Soda had no choice but to change her approach—starting with the motivation.
She still felt that, judging from the timeline, only Shuichi Hamura could have committed the crime. "Speaking of which..." she suddenly looked at Shuichi Hamura, "You and Mrs. Torakura, you're a couple, aren't you?"
"?!"
Etsuko Torakura's heart skipped a beat, and she nervously grabbed Shuichi Hamura's arm.
Just now, she listened to a lot of seemingly useful information from Jiang Xia's boss. She had just managed to digest some of it and felt that her ability to conceal her knowledge had improved, but before long, she was exposed... Etsuko Torakura subconsciously glanced at Amuro Tooru.
Amuro Tooru looked in the other direction, ignoring her.
... He remembered that when he entered Daisuke Torakura's study and saw the gruesome corpse, Etsuko Torakura instinctively ran to Shuichi Hamura and grabbed his arm, instead of seeking help from Tadokoro Shunya, who was nearby... Any normal person could see something was wrong, let alone Detective like Ikumi Soda, who wasn't exactly stupid. This blame couldn't possibly fall on him...
Beside her, Etsuko Torakura panicked for a moment, then slowly calmed down: Right, Daisuke Torakura is dead. Being suspected of infidelity now doesn't seem to matter much... Wait, speaking of which, who is the murderer? Could it really be Shuichi...?
Shuichi Hamura, however, continued to refute:
"Regardless of my relationship with Etsuko, I am not the murderer of Daisuke Torakura. If you are looking for a motive, you should look at others—such as Editor-in-Chief Doi."
As he spoke, he glanced at the editor beside him, whose forehead was beaded with sweat:
"I heard a rumor at university—that novels submitted to the <Horror Times Weekly> would have their content plagiarized by Daisuke Torakura. However, the plagiarism was quite clever, and since the manuscripts hadn't been published yet, no one could prove Daisuke Torakura was at fault..."
As Shuichi Hamura's gaze fell on Editor-in-Chief Doi's luggage, Doi broke out in a sweat even more profusely.
At that moment, Editor-in-Chief Doi's bag indeed contained the original submissions. These were the Daisuke Torakura had plagiarized, and he was preparing to take them back.
Although Daisuke Torakura hasn't published any Vampire novels in recent years, he's still writing them in private. Therefore, Daisuke Torakura's Computer probably contains fresh evidence of plagiarism.
Editor-in-Chief Doi felt that if he denied everything and concealed the truth, the charge of murder might fall on his head...
... We need to find someone even more suspicious!
Thinking of this, Editor-in-Chief Doi also decisively dragged others into the mess:
"To be honest, Daisuke Torakura actually ran out of creative ideas a long time ago. Seven years ago, I lost money in the stock market and incurred a large debt. Torakura paid it off for me, but he wanted me to submit the manuscripts I received to him for review first..."
At this point, Editor-in-Chief Doi sensed that the way people were looking at him was getting increasingly strange, and realized that his motive for murder seemed quite strong.
So he quickly got to the point. "That's not the point! The point is that five years ago, I felt that letting him continue plagiarizing like this wasn't a solution, so I recommended a ghostwriter to him—Tadokoro! All the novels that Daisuke Torakura has published in recent years are actually Tadokoro's works. If we're talking about motivation, he has a stronger case than I do!"