Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Library
  • Read
    • Popular
    • Charts
    • Browse
    • Categories
    • Wikis
    • Glossary
  • Request
  • Activity
  • Leaderboard
  • Help
Our Apps
  • DaoSearch
  • Narratorr
Social
  • Discord
  • Patreon
I Haven't Watched Naruto!
Chapter 454

Justice and Injustice

2,679 words 9 min read 0 views 2mo ago Source ​
Skip to the end of the chapter
Prev
Next

When your stance is correct enough, you'll find that you're invincible on the debate stage.

Unless we disregard the facts.

If you acknowledge that the lives of ordinary people are also lives, and that the lives of Whitebeard and tens of thousands of pirates are no match for the lives of the millions of people around the world who have been ravaged by pirates, then Whitebeard's death is just!

Will Marco disregard the lives of ordinary people?

That's impossible, because while he was the First Division Captain, he was also a ship's doctor.

Doctors, unless they are like Hogback (the zombie doctor under Moria), generally have a deep reverence for life!

Moreover, a person who can become the First Division Captain cannot only have strength, but also the ability to win people over with personal charisma. Whitebeard was not a cruel person, so the First Division Captain under his command could not be a villain.

The same goes for Ace. People taught by Garp might go astray, but their basic values are still intact.

Therefore, neither of them could refute Sun Keiyun's statement.

The undeniable consequence is that, already heartbroken and devastated, now some are saying your failure was deserved?

The indifference in their hearts instantly turned into anger!

"So, you're here to laugh at us?!" Marco roared.

Sun Keiyun quickly waved his hand and shook his head, saying, "How could I have such a perverse sense of humor? In fact, I came to invite you!"

"Inviting us?" Marco chuckled. "You, a navy man, are going to go to sea and become a pirate?"

"No, that's not it. The invitation I gave you wasn't to invite you onto the ship, but rather to invite a few of you to join the navy!" Sun Keiyun said sincerely, not daring to sound condescending in his words to avoid offending the two men.

Even so, it still angered the two of them.

Marco brandished the chains and banged them on the table. "What do you mean? You killed so many of our brothers, and you even killed our father, and now you want us to join the Navy?"

Sun Keiyun nodded. "Why not?"

Marco was already about to burst out laughing in exasperation, and you're still asking why?

"Because you killed our father, and so many of our brothers! I don't care if you're righteous or if your actions were justified. We're mortal enemies now. You'd better kill us now, or our only reason for living is revenge!"

Sun Keiyun paused for a moment, then turned to Ace and asked, "Is that what you think too?"

Ace nodded emphatically.

"So, you consider the navy your enemy!" Sun Keiyun, seemingly in question, but using a declarative tone.

"What else could it be!" Marco began to wonder. Was this the level of the navy's staff? Did they even have a brain?

But the thought of the Whitebeard Pirates losing to someone like that made him even angrier.

But Sun Keiyun shook his head. "So, why did the Navy and you end up like this? Why did Whitebeard die? Or, why was Ace captured and publicly executed?"

"You!" Marco was about to curse, but he was interrupted again, "Marco, you're supposed to be a strategist on Whitebeard's ship, don't make me look down on you. Calm down, let's use our brains and think this through, okay? Don't just argue with me all the time, what good does that do for our conversation? Or rather, even if you want to kill me, want to kill the Marines, you should at least pretend to be nice to them so you can escape more easily!"

"Hmph, who wants to talk to you!" Marco muttered, finally stopping his arguing. After all, Sun Keiyun had mentioned the Whitebeard Pirates, and now that Whitebeard was gone, he was the representative of the Whitebeard Pirates!

"Because we are pirates and you are marines, isn't it normal for us to fight each other?" he replied.

Sun Keiyun nodded. "Then why are the navy and pirates naturally antagonistic?"

"Uh," Marco said matter-of-factly, "Isn't this normal? The Navy exists to maintain the World Government's rule, while we pirates are the ones who undermine the World Government's rule!"

"Huh?" Sun Keiyun was taken aback. "Shouldn't you say that the Navy is righteous and the pirates are evil?"

"Heh!" Marco sneered, "Only your Navy thinks that way. Who said the Navy is the epitome of justice? Was what you did in Ohara just? Or was being bodyguards for the Celestial Dragons just right?"

"On the other hand, in the territory of our Whitebeard Pirates, we have exempted most countries from various taxes. The people there only need to pay us taxes. Many places that were once heavily harassed by pirates are no longer plagued by them because our flag has been planted there!"

"If we're talking about justice, then the Whitebeard Pirates are the true embodiment of justice!"

"But you can't deny that not the entire Whitebeard Pirates are like you," Sun Keiyun said. "You have plenty of pirates who burn, kill, plunder, and commit all sorts of atrocities where you're from!"

"That was all before they joined the Whitebeard Pirates. After they joined, we started to control their behavior. Since they were incorrigible, we didn't hold back and dealt with them directly. You can go to the New World and investigate how many evildoers the Whitebeard Pirates have!" Marco said indignantly.

Sun Keiyun nodded. "If that's the case, the Navy claims to be righteous, and you also say you are righteous. Since you're both righteous, why can't we be friends, why can't we be a group, and instead we're fighting against each other?"

"Tch!" Marco shook his head. "What naval justice? It's just a sham justice. You should answer my questions first: Was your behavior in Ohara just? Was your protection of the Celestial Dragons just? You're a senior naval officer, don't tell me you don't know these things!"

Sun Keiyun shook his head. "Actually, it's not just that. After the Sun Pirates disbanded, Arlong, a former member, formed his own Arlong Pirate Crew. They ruled over a dozen villages in the East Blue, collecting taxes per capita. The person protecting their actions is Captain Rat of the 16th Marine Division!"

"Huh?" Marco was taken aback. Wait a minute, something's not right about what you're saying. Shouldn't you be refuting me?

"The Buster Call was not only used on Ohara, but also on Enies Lobby when dealing with the Straw Hat Pirates. Tens of thousands of residents on Enies Lobby were injured, and the Navy offered no compensation or rescue whatsoever!"

"Huh?" Marco was even more surprised. Wait, which side are you on?

"Actually, there are many more examples like this. If we were to list them all, it would probably take three days and three nights!" Sun Keiyun said. "But besides that, you can't deny that the Navy's actions in fighting pirates have indeed protected many civilians, haven't they? So, just like how your Whitebeard Pirates believe you are righteous, but there are also many pirates who are unjust, you may think our Navy's righteousness is unjust, but many of our actions are indeed righteous!!"

"So, you're trying to whitewash your navy's actions?" Marco said.

Sun Keiyun shook his head. "Why would I try to clear his name? I've only been in the Navy for less than two months, and I don't have that much affection for it yet!"

"So what exactly are you here for?!" Marco asked.

"Didn't I say I'm here to invite you to join us?" Sun Keiyun said. "Since you believe you are righteous, and I believe I am righteous too, we can definitely be partners, can't we?"

"Then..." Marco was almost confused. "I already said, it's the hatred between us."

"So, you have no objection to justice, is that right?" Sun Keiyun asked quickly.

"Uh..." Marco fell silent. How was I supposed to answer that?

You've already separated justice and injustice, so of course I can't refute that.

"It seems there's no objection after all. Let's talk about the issue of hatred then!" Sun Keiyun asked, "It was Akainu who killed Whitebeard, Garp and Aokiji who besieged him, and I was the one who devised the plan. More than 10,000 Whitebeard Pirates were killed. If we find the Marines who killed those 10,000 pirates, doesn't that mean that the enemies of your Whitebeard Pirates are us?"

"This!" Marco was somewhat confused. Was it yes, or no?

If so, then it definitely is, after all, they were the ones who directly took action!

But if we say no, that would also work, because those naval personnel were just following orders. Even if Sun Keiyun was the Sun Keiyun who devised the plan, he was still just an executor of the navy's will.

They are like a murder weapon; it's inappropriate to blame the weapon itself.

Shouldn't we hold Marshal Sengoku accountable for giving the order?

But did Fleet Sengoku have any personal grudge against Whitebeard? Or against Ace?

No, there isn't any!

Why did he go against the Whitebeard Pirates?

Because there's something deeper behind it.

Marco grew increasingly confused and terrified as he thought about it. He was suddenly surprised to find that he didn't seem to understand who his enemy was!

"It seems you've already realized it!" Sun Keiyun smiled as he looked at Marco, who was still in shock and confusion.

Marco isn't an idiot; he's the First Division Captain of a Pirate Crew.

Given the strength and influence of the Whitebeard Pirates at the time, it wouldn't be an exaggeration to say they were equivalent to a country. Marco was clearly a prime minister, the kind of super prime minister who didn't have to deal with the king much, but rather oversaw personnel, finances, and all sorts of other matters.

He is clearly not lacking in wisdom.

Conversing with such a wise person is obviously very easy.

"It seems you've already realized it! This principle isn't complicated to understand. After all, if everyone is committed to justice, how can justice itself turn against each other?"

"Then who are our enemies?"

Sun Keiyun smiled and said, "It's very simple. This is something that stands between us who are supposed to be righteous. It's injustice within the Navy and injustice among the pirates. You can't even find out who your enemy is, yet you talk about taking revenge. That's laughable!"

"If you really go and kill Sengoku, believe me, the ones who will be happy won't be you, but those who are unjust?"

Marco turned to look at Ace, then at Sun Keiyun. He seemed to understand, yet also seemed not to.

But he had a vague feeling that this person was saying something extraordinary!

"Then what exactly is this injustice?" Marco felt his throat was a little hoarse, not because he was thirsty, but because he realized that he might be getting closer to the truth.

Sun Keiyun breathed a sigh of relief; finally, they could get down to business.

That wasn't easy!

"You are righteous, and you want revenge. I am also righteous, and I want to fight against injustice. So we have a natural basis for cooperation. But whether it's fighting or revenge, we must first figure out who is righteous, who is unjust, who are our friends, and who are our enemies."

"Otherwise, if you take revenge on your friends while treating your enemies as friends, it will only cause pain to your loved ones and joy to your enemies!"

"Well," Marco said thoughtfully, finally nodding, "Who are our friends, and who are our enemies?"

"I ask you, are Sengoku, Aokiji, Kizaru, and Akainu your enemies?" Sun Keiyun asked.

Marco hesitated for a moment, wanting to say yes, but he knew it wasn't really true.

"Although I don't agree with some of Akainu's actions, I still admire him a lot. Not everyone can fight so resolutely against evil!" Marco hesitated for a moment, but still gave a fair assessment of the culprit who killed his father.

Sun Keiyun nodded.

Back when the manga had just reached the Summit War, Akainu was nicknamed "Red Dog," and the internet was full of insults and abuse.

But as these readers grew up and matured, they realized that Akainu's actions were correct and that he was the true role model for soldiers. On the contrary, Kizaru Aokiji, who were once highly charismatic, saw their reputations decline over time.

Akainu didn't kill their family members, he just killed a popular character, and yet he's being criticized like this.

But he personally killed Whitebeard, yet Marco was able to soberly realize this amidst his burning hatred; it's truly remarkable.

"And what about me? Am I an enemy?" Sun Keiyun asked again.

Marco shook his head. "I only met you today, and I don't know you at all. How would I know if you're a friend or an enemy?"

Sun Keiyun nodded. "Then, who exactly is our enemy?"

Forehead..

You're asking me, we're both illiterate?

Marco stared speechlessly at Sun Keiyun, about to say something, when Ace spoke first, "Aren't the nobles of the Goa Kingdom enemies?"

"Huh?" Marco was stunned. "Ace, what are you talking about? The Goa Kingdom is far away in the East Blue. How could they be our enemies?"

"But isn't the rule that the World Government maintains precisely the rule that these nobles maintain? And whose rule have we pirates disrupted? Isn't it these nobles' rule?" Ace still can't forget his life in the garbage Yamanaka, and he can't forget how those nobles inside the high walls lived such a high and mighty life of extravagance and debauchery!

"They raised prices, oppressed the people, squeezed money out of everyone through various means, kidnapped their wives and children, and even burned everything down for the sake of so-called face."

Ace let out a sigh of relief, "I couldn't accurately describe this behavior before, but now that I've heard what you say, isn't their behavior simply unjust?"

Marco thought about it, and it seemed to make sense!

However, such people are all targets of the Navy's protection!

So, you're asking a navy officer in front of him whether the target he's protecting is unjust?

Then he looked at Sun Keiyun with astonishment and nodded. "The rich are heartless and levy exorbitant taxes; this is certainly unjust!"

"Huh?" Marco was shocked; he actually nodded!

Turning back to Ace, Ace continued, "Those Celestial Dragons enslave people, arbitrarily shoot passersby, and order artillery fire if someone blocks their way. Isn't that also unjust?"

"Huh?" Marco was even more shocked. You dare to criticize Celestial Dragons?

Although he was a pirate, his 800-year-old ideological dominance was no joke. He also regarded the Celestial Dragons as descendants of gods. It was only after Luffy up the Celestial Dragons that his thinking changed a little, but only a little.

I didn't expect Ace.

"Ace, what have you been through all these years?" He suddenly realized that he didn't really know his brother at all.

But what shocked him even more was that the lieutenant general nodded again!

"It's more than just arrogant and domineering. The top leaders of the World Government are the Celestial Dragons, and the Ohara incident was ordered by the World Government. The Navy was merely the executor. Marco, you believe the Ohara incident was unjust, well, now the real culprit has been found!"

"Do you even know what you're saying?" Marco looked outside in a panic.

"No, you're a pirate, why are you afraid of the Sky People?" Sun Keiyun asked curiously, "Shouldn't pirates be lawless?"

"But, but..." Marco stammered for a long time, but couldn't come up with a coherent explanation.

On the contrary, it opened up his mind.

Yeah, I'm a pirate, why should I respect those Celestial Dragons?

That's right, the Celestial Dragons are unjust!

End of Chapter
Prev
NovelSummaries
Next

Explore the wiki

Sun Keiyun

Comments

No comments yet.
AboutStatsAPIChangelogStatusContactPrivacyTermsDMCA
© 2026 RandomTranslator·v3.26·RSS