"First of all, he is not a god," Horus said, followed by a long pause.
He just stared at Johnny with an interesting look in his eyes, as if waiting for him to ask him something.
The Remembrancers found this extremely perplexing.
He asked, puzzled, "Uh, so, sir?"
You agree with what I said?
"What reason do I have to disagree?" Johnny asked, utterly bewildered. "He's not God. I knew that back when I was still in school. Why would a real God care about our lives?"
Upon hearing this, Horus seemed to have some thoughts, but he didn't say them aloud and simply continued the conversation.
"Very well, then I won't waste my breath on some things. In short, he is not a god, nor is he the perfect monarch or omnipotent hero that many people imagine... What I'm saying is that he has flaws, and many flaws at that."
Could you give me a few examples, sir?
"He refused to engage in normal communication with people," Horus said. "His life was very long, but he never learned how to correct this. He would always say inappropriate things in serious situations, or become unusually silent at moments when he needed to express his true feelings."
"It sounds like some kind of social anxiety disorder..." Johnny said with considerable courage.
Horus shook his head and said very calmly but very seriously, "No, the truth is far worse than your assessment, because the Emperor is not the whole person, but merely an image he created for himself, a mask."
He wore it for so long that he became trapped by the mask, a prisoner of it.
"Throughout human history, such things are not uncommon, but the situation is probably unique to him. Humanity needs the Emperor is omniscient, omnipotent, and supreme, forever majestic, but he cannot remain so forever unless he abandons his humanity and discards the things that made him decide to shoulder the responsibility of leading humanity. But if he does that, he will no longer be himself."
Johnny was silent for a moment, then said, "So, sir, are you trying to tell me that the Emperor is actually... just like us?"
Horus smiled, then shook his head. "We must be realistic, Johnny. There is indeed a part of him who is an ordinary person, just like you and me, but his power is more than enough for him to be regarded as a god and worshipped."
"Uh, so...?"
"He is an extremely powerful Psyker, the most powerful one in history. You can describe him like that in your book."
Johnny took a deep breath and nodded, thinking that if he really wrote that, he would probably be shot by the Ecclesiarchy the next day.
"No, you won't," Horus said. "They know and understand this; they've known it for a very long time."
"What?" Johnny was taken aback, not even caring how Horus knew his thoughts, and immediately pressed for an answer. "They knew? Then why did they—"
"--Because for a very long time, he truly was a god," Horus said. "And during that time, the common people had to rely on their faith in him to protect their souls from certain things. I imagine you've never seen them; they're just fictional monsters from folklore to you, like hell itself—they don't really exist, and are mostly uttered with curses and insults. But the truth is, from ancient times until today, humanity has been free from them for less than five hundred years."
Johnny pondered for a long time before he could shake off the shock, confusion, and irrational fear Horus's words had instilled in him.
He remained stubbornly in place, his back ramrod straight, and no one could tell that he had just experienced a worldview shattering a few minutes earlier.
He spoke softly, "So... those creatures that steal baby food, those monsters— Daemon —that torture sinners with sharp forks in hell—do they really exist?"
"Oh, they don't just torment sinners, they torment everyone, without discrimination."
"But why?"
"Because they were hungry, and never satisfied. I can't tell you in detail exactly what they did to us, I can only say that they ate everything we had."
Johnny remained silent for a long time, clutching the tape recorder tightly in his hand, enduring immense pressure without uttering a sound. The cold metallic touch, in a peculiar way, gave Johnny a precious bit of strength, preventing him from collapsing.
He had a million questions he wanted to ask, but a thought suddenly flashed through his mind and popped out of his mouth before any of them could be asked.
Johnny blurted out, "The rebellion was actually their doing, wasn't it?!"
Horus looked at him with a very surprised expression.
"It's them, isn't it?!" the Remembrancers exclaimed, growing increasingly agitated. "Now everything makes sense. Damn it, I knew it, I knew it, those beasts..."
"Don't get agitated, Johnny, don't get agitated." Horus had to raise his hand to signal him to calm down. "What you said is true, but not entirely. The situation is complicated, and it shouldn't be brought up anymore."
"But that concerns your reputation!" Johnny couldn't help but shout.
As he said this, he had completely forgotten that just a day earlier he had regarded Horus Lupercal as the greatest traitor in the history of the Imperium.
However, while he forgot, the traitor himself did not.
Horus couldn't help but sigh and said, "So what?"
You've been wronged.
"Perhaps."
"Perhaps...? How can you be so ambiguous? You've clearly been wronged! Don't you want to get justice for yourself?"
"In no mood."
"But..."
Johnny wanted to argue, but found himself at a loss for words. However, his mind worked quickly. At this crucial moment, a brilliant idea struck him, and he blurted out a name.
"Well, you might not want to, but Horus Aximand certainly does!"
Horus fell silent.
Seeing that he remained silent, Johnny pressed his advantage, completely unaware that he was now engaged in a debate with a Primarch.
"And those who know the truth as well as he does, your other sons. Yes, and your brothers, even your sons know, how could the other Primarch not know? Ah, and the Emperor, the Emperor must know too..."
As Johnny spoke, he realized something was wrong. His speech slowed down, his tone became less agitated, and suspicion crept onto his face.
"They all know?" he finally asked Horus.
"Yes, they all know."
Johnny felt an intense wave of dizziness and stammered, "Then why don't they... I mean, this? You?"
Horus walked over to him, bent down, and pressed down on the shoulders of the Remembrancers, who was already unsteady on his feet, to help him regain his balance. His expression looked very calm, completely detached, as if the person Johnny was talking about who had suffered a great injustice was not actually him.
A few minutes later, the Remembrancers's breathing finally calmed down. Gasping for breath, he left Horus's help and stubbornly threw out a follow-up question.
Why won't they help you?
Horus crouched slightly, his hands crossed and resting on his knees, and replied softly, "Because it is more beneficial for humanity and the Imperium as a whole."
Johnny stared at him blankly.
Horus patiently continued to explain, "Once the rebellion has occurred, the truth is no longer important."
My comrades, children, brothers, even a servant within the legion will become part of it, reduced to despised traitors; no one will be spared.
"Similarly, so were the victims. There aren't many descriptions of this in your time; you can't imagine how many people died, how many suffered, and how many endured hardship for the next ten thousand years because of that rebellion... How could they possibly exonerate me for what I did? People wouldn't agree; they needed someone to hate, even if it was just for venting their frustrations."
Johnny struggled to get a sentence out. "Couldn't they just explain that you didn't actually do those things?"
Horus smiled with a gentleness that bordered on tenderness.
"No, Johnny, because those things have taken over my body, leaving only the appearance and skin as their disguise. Think about it, if even I can experience this, what about others? Those who are powerless? The Great Crusade was an era of Imperial Truth, where people believed there were no supernatural forces or superstitions, only a simple scientific faith, and that everything could be discovered, understood, and correctly explained... But those things that killed me, they don't belong to that category. If the truth were revealed, what panic would engulf the Imperium?"
Johnny couldn't utter another word. For some reason, his eyes were filled with tears, and he didn't know why he was like this. But the reason was probably not just because of Horus Lupercal's fate, but also because of everything...
The truth represents something far too heavy to bear.
He cannot bear it; he cannot shoulder it.
The Remembrancers clenched his left fist, raised it, and pressed it against his teeth. He was trembling, trembling uncontrollably.
Horus extended his right hand to him.
"Let's call it a day, Johnny," he said apologetically. "Take my hand, I'll take you home. Get some rest, I'm so sorry."
The Remembrancers didn't speak, but simply nodded and grasped the hand. A flash of golden light, and he vanished from the spot.
Horus slowly stood up, a wistful smile unconsciously appearing on his face.
He turned and left the valley where the rock face was located, walking towards a field. It was only about two acres in size, divided into four sections, planted with some vegetables whose varieties were not discernible. Horus stared at them for a while, then bent down, sat on the edge of the field, and placed his hands on the ground, feeling the warmth of the soil.
He sat there until night fell, when a man approached from behind. The last rays of the setting sun shone perfectly on the man's face, illuminating his eyes. He looked very much like Horus, but his eyes were older and more serene.
He walked up behind Horus and said, "You should have informed us before taking him away."
"I'm sorry," Horus said without turning around, his voice barely audible. "I only intended to pay him a visit at first..."
But he was truly a natural Remembrancers.
Aximand took a few steps forward, sat down, and nodded in agreement.
"Yes, he has a talent he himself hasn't even realized. He's good at listening and thinking, has strong empathy, and good intuition. If he had lived during the Great Crusade, I think he would have accomplished something remarkable."
Horus turned his head to look at him. "You really think so?"
"Yes."
I thought you weren't too fond of Remembrancers.
"That's not true, but I wouldn't get that close to a Remembrancers like Garviel did."
Horus chuckled at the unexpected teasing, "Ah, he is indeed somewhat... different. But from today's perspective, it's nothing."
Aximand nodded, then suddenly said, "She died on Terra, her body never to be found. Garviel erected a monument for her and all our Remembrancers, sculpted it himself, and it should still be in the Iron Fortress. If you'd like to see it, I can show you the way. The Iron Warriors shouldn't refuse my visit."
Horus remained silent for a long time, unsure of what to say.
He lowered his head, lost in thought, staring at the ground. Distant memories flooded back, transforming into the thunderous hooves of warhorses, racing through his mind. Aximand remained silent, his gaze lingering on the vegetables in the field.
After some time, he asked, "These are the improved varieties left behind by Lord Roboute Guilliman, right? I heard from the Ultramarines that they were left for you. He knew you would keep them, didn't he?"
They all knew, Horus thought. Each of them had entrusted something to me.
"Will they come back?" Aximand asked again.
Horus slowly raised his head and gazed at the starry sky.
"I'd love to give you a definitive answer, but I don't know the answer either. The reason I'm here is because I'm not the Primarch, nor the real Horus Lupercal... Many years ago, on Krieg, Skaradrik of the Crimson Claws called me the Protector, but now, no one needs my so-called protection anymore. The Imperium is now marching towards the best version of what its founders envisioned. I no longer see tyranny and oppression, perhaps corruption and greed will persist for a long time, but someone will always deal with them, and there will always be successors who disdain such things to seize power."
What are you trying to say?
Horus looked down at him and smiled.
"I feel like I'm just a monument, responsible for remembering everyone... Will they come back? They should, Aximand, they should."