If possible, Zhang Yi actually didn't want to play Silent Hill a second or third time.
Because that feeling of oppression was really unbearable, but he never expected that Old Song would be much more ruthless than him.
Not only did I complete the game myself, but I also used a walkthrough to unlock other endings.
As for why he was so sure that Song Ren had consulted a walkthrough, it was because after learning a little about the trigger conditions for the other endings, he understood that Old Song's wisdom might not be enough to support him in discovering these branching points on his own.
In reality, this is the case for most players; they don't rely on exchanging information with others and then gradually practice.
The conditions for triggering the other endings in Silent Hill are simply outrageous.
In the previous version of Silent Hill, the game itself had a total of 6 endings.
However, there are only three endings that are related to the game's plot itself.
Of the other three, two are parody endings, and the other is an Easter egg ending related to the first game.
Therefore, Chen Xu did not include these three endings during the production process, since these three endings themselves are not closely related to the game's plot.
The three normal endings each have different triggering conditions.
Unlike traditional RPGs with multiple dialogues and branching options, Silent Hill determines the ending based on the player's habits.
It can be said that, without any prior knowledge, the ending a player triggers on their New Game Plus will inevitably be the Silent Hill that the player envisions.
The first ending is about leaving Silent Hill with Lara, which is actually the easiest ending to achieve. This is the ending that Old Zhang and the vast majority of players trigger.
The condition for triggering this ending is also very simple: just keep James's health above 50% at all times.
And after defeating Pyramid Head, you can trigger this ending by listening to Mary's past conversation in the hotel corridor.
These actions suggest that James cared about Mary, but also valued his own life.
So it was only natural that he eventually confronted the sins in his heart and left Silent Hill.
The second ending is a double suicide ending. Players need to control James to go to the hospital roof to read a diary, observe Angela's knife multiple times during the game, read the words encouraging suicide on the wall in the bar at night, keep James in an unhealthy state, and finally listen to the words in the corridor.
These actions also indicate that James still deeply misses Mary and that his love for Mary has led to suicidal tendencies.
Finally, he plunged the car carrying Mary's body into the river with him, a tragic ending that could be considered a natural conclusion.
Of course, there's also the final "scumbag" ending in the last cycle. To achieve this ending, you need to get close to Maria.
In the hospital level, Maria will temporarily leave the party due to feeling unwell.
At this point, if the player controls James, they can occasionally return to the ward to see Maria.
Also, in the later prison scene, after Maria is killed by Pyramid Head, she will continue to the underground labyrinth room where her body is located.
And throughout the game, he maintained a very close distance to Maria.
And if you walk quickly through the corridor and don't listen to the rest of the conversation, you'll trigger Maria's ending.
In terms of conditions, this ending is more time-consuming and complicated, but considering the unique features of Silent Hill, it is actually the second most frequently triggered ending by players.
While Maria initially feels a bit eerie during the game, players actually develop a certain dependence on Maria as the story progresses. After all, having a teammate by your side in the dark and foggy, eerie scenes is always a relaxing thing.
So when Maria is forced to leave the team, many players, out of curiosity and other psychological factors, will involuntarily go back to see if Maria is there and if she is alright.
These actions also mean that James in the game cares more about Maria than Mary, so it is only natural that Maria the end.
But when Maria left Silent Hill, she also started coughing.
This also means that in the near future, Maria may also fall seriously ill like Mary, as if it were a cycle.
From the player's perspective, this ending is undoubtedly a bad one.
However, the theme song for the final ending, "Promise," is loved by many players. If you listen carefully to the music, you can almost feel Mary's feelings after being killed and completely abandoned by James.
The theme song for this ending is titled "Promise," which is clearly more ironic compared to the theme songs for the other two endings, "Overdose Delusion" and "Angel's Thanatos."
The song is called Promise, but in the end, James abandons Mary and chooses to be with another woman.
Different endings also lead to different interpretations.
Regarding these three endings, different players believe that the one they triggered is the so-called true ending.
Because from any perspective, all three endings seem to have their own logic and can be explained.
Many players who have completed the game, or those who have completed it via video, share their opinions on community forums.
Many players are even tagging Chen Xu's Official Blog, hoping for an official explanation.
But clearly, Chen Xu would not grant them this request.
Because which one is the true ending is actually not important.
Silent Hill itself is a game full of metaphors.
Players have various interpretations of games.
Just like Souls-like games, based on various clues and information within the game, players have their own understanding of the game's world view and plot.
That's the charm of leaving things unsaid; there's no truly rigorous answer.
Even game developers don't necessarily have to say that a certain answer is correct.
Why is it that only the official stance is correct, while the players are wrong?
Just like those who go to Silent Hill in the game, everyone has a Silent Hill in their heart.
Similarly, each player has their own Silent Hill story.
As for what this story should actually be like, that should be left to the players' own interpretation and understanding.
Instead of imposing it on them.