"Would you, sir, so easily believe the opinions of the world?"
"Whether it's the Chu Kingdom or the Qi Kingdom."
"Including Zhao, Han, Wei, and Yan."
"They fear my Qin Kingdom."
"That's why they slander my Qin Kingdom as a tiger and wolf, using such a derogatory term."
"With your eyesight, sir, you should be able to see clearly that the Qin Kingdom people wandering among the pavilions and towers are no different from the people of the other six states."
"As for the harshness of Qin Law, that is certainly true."
"But the Qin Law were laws that strengthened the country and its people."
"It is also a law to defend the Wey Kingdom and protect the people."
"It's better to obey orders than for everyone to weep."
"What do you think, sir?"
Faced with Ying Zheng's straightforward explanation, Ye Qingcang nodded in agreement. Nothing in the world is perfect; there are advantages and disadvantages. To gain something, you must inevitably lose something. Compared to the people of the six states who are currently living in dire straits, the people of the Qin Kingdom, although not living well either, at least do not have to worry about their heads suddenly disappearing, nor do they have to worry about being inexplicably accused of being criminals and becoming someone's scapegoat without having done anything. As long as they work diligently, they will not starve to death. There is also the clear path of advancement through military merit, which has helped many commoners achieve upward social mobility. Even a squad leader who commands ten soldiers has a much higher status than a farmer who works in the fields every day.
In an era when only nobles could serve as military officers.
The Qin Kingdom stood out from the crowd.
It's really well done.
But this excellence is only due to the contrast with its peers.
All the kings and nobles of the six kingdoms should be treated as individuals.
It wouldn't be so easy for the Qin Kingdom to win.
Unfortunately, there is no such thing as "what if" in this world.
While Qin Law was indeed harsh, it effectively protected the basic interests of ordinary people. The principle that princes should be punished the same as commoners when breaking the law served as a strong Intimidation to all the nobles within the Qin Kingdom, laying a solid foundation for Qin Law and naturally gaining the support of the common people.
Therefore, Ye Qingcang did not want to deny it.
There's no reason to deny it.
However, not denying it does not mean that he was persuaded by Ying Zheng.
He waved his hand.
He politely declined, saying, "Everyone in the world has their own opinion, and I have mine. Although my opinion differs from that of the world, it also differs from that of Your Majesty. While the Qin Law is undoubtedly correct, many things in the world cannot be judged solely by right or wrong. Although we share the same aspirations and have the same understanding of the world, we have chosen different paths. Therefore, it can only end in regret."
However, Ye Qingcang's words piqued Ying Zheng's interest.
He had assumed that Ye Qingcang was merely the newly appointed leader of the Net organization.
Even if they have some ideas.
He also lacks the talent to govern a country.
Compared to the general trend of the world, one could probably talk much more about the Jianghu.
Unexpectedly, Ye Qingcang brought up his personal ambitions in just a few words.
This allowed Ying Zheng to go along with it.
He immediately probed, "From what you're saying, you're very clear about my aspirations?"
"Certainly."
"It's clear from your actions."
"You want to unify the world."
"To fulfill the last wishes of the Qin kings of all time."
"So you're imitating the Zhou emperor, aren't you?"
Ye Qingcang smiled, looked at Ying Zheng with a slightly surprised expression, paused for a moment, and then suddenly shook his head and said, "To be honest, although I agree with your actions and it is time for this chaotic world to end, the reason you uphold is not correct. You can use the reason of the people's desire for peace to unify the world, or you can use the reason of ending the war to unify the world, or you can even use the reason that we are all descendants of Yan and Huang to unify the world. The only reason you should not use the last wishes of the Qin kings of the past to unify the world. Therefore, we have chosen different paths. You are taking the path of Path of Hegemony, while I am taking the Path of Benevolence."
"Path of Benevolence?"
Ying Zheng did not expect Ye Qingcang to give this answer.
After a moment of stunned silence.
The corners of his mouth turned up.
I couldn't help but laugh.
Without sarcasm, but pure bewilderment. "Although this is our first meeting, just as you have a deep understanding of me, I also have a deep understanding of you. You are definitely not someone who advocates governing with benevolence. If that were true, you wouldn't have taken over the Net. But judging from your expression, you don't seem to be lying. Instead, you genuinely believe that you are following the path of Path of Benevolence, and that I am following the path of Path of Hegemony. I wonder how you came to this conclusion?"
What is your understanding of benevolence?
Ye Qingcang did not answer Ying Zheng's question.
Instead, he threw out another question.
Judging from the format of the dialogue, Ying Zheng immediately recognized it as a standard philosophical debate. His smile faded, and he sat upright at the table, speaking earnestly, "Benevolence can be love, or it can be benevolent governance. Its purpose is to allow the people to rest and recuperate, to enable the nation to live in peace and prosperity, and to ensure that more of the people under his rule have enough to eat. This is what I consider benevolence. I wonder, sir, what is your definition of 'Path of Hegemony,' and what exactly constitutes worthy of being called Path of Hegemony?"
"Path of Benevolence and Path of Hegemony are relative."
"Each has its advantages and disadvantages."
"Path of Benevolence is based on people."
"Path of Hegemony, yet in accordance with destiny."
"In the Path of Benevolence, the law is no different from human feelings, but this is also a kind of biased act. Therefore, it can be said that the Path of Benevolence is unfair."
"In the Path of Hegemony, the law is the law, supreme and unalterable, and orders are executed ruthlessly under the premise of absolute justice."
Ye Qingcang has always liked to see through appearances to the essence.
Seeing that Ying Zheng didn't quite understand this repetitive talk.
He snapped his fingers.
He gave an example. "Let's put it this way. Suppose someone, angered by an unfair judgment made by a corrupt official, rises up in anger, kills the official in public, and then surrenders himself. According to the laws of your Qin Kingdom, how would that be judged?"
Those who commit intentional homicide shall pay with their lives.
"According to the law."
"Either beheading or dismemberment by chariots."
"Considering that killing someone in public has a bad influence and should be used as a precedent to warn others, I think the final verdict will most likely be dismemberment by chariot."
Ying Zheng made a hypothesis based on the current Qin laws.
But before he could ask Qin Lu what was wrong,
He was speechless at Ye Qingcang's counter-question, "If this person committed intentional homicide, taking another's life without permission, and should be sentenced to death, then what right does the executioner have to take that person's life without permission?"
The air was quiet for a moment.
Until two or three seconds later.
Ying Zheng then corrected him, saying, "Although it was the executioner who took this person's life, the executioner was merely following orders. What truly took this person's life was the law. These two concepts should not be confused!"
These two concepts should indeed not be confused.
"Because you've never understood these two concepts."
"If an executioner can be spared the death penalty simply because he is following orders, and it is even considered a reasonable decision to decide a person's life or death, then the murderer can also be exonerated for the same reason. The only difference is that the two are following different orders: one is following the command of the law itself, and the other is following the command of God and his own heart. Both should be released without charge."
"Furthermore, the law is merely a tool, a tool created by humans. Tools themselves have no thought. No law can make a criminal commit suicide based on just a single line of text. The decision of a criminal's life or death is made by the judge who wields this tool, by the executioner who obeys the judge's orders. The source should not be attributed to the law, but to the judge himself."
"Do you think this is an embodiment of Path of Benevolence or Path of Hegemony?"
Ye Qingcang took a sip of wine.
He sat down and discussed philosophy with Ying Zheng.
This was the first time Ying Zheng had looked at the problem from this perspective.
After a moment's thought, he countered, "This question cannot be explained simply by Path of Benevolence or Path of Hegemony. The original intention of the law was to uphold justice in the world; it should be a path independent of both Path of Benevolence and Path of Hegemony. Do you mean to say that it belongs to both?"
"Certainly."
"Because the law is a product of Path of Hegemony."
What is Path of Hegemony?
"To put it bluntly, the Path of Hegemony rule is based on one person's own laws, much like Lord Shang, who drafted the laws of the Qin Kingdom. In his hands, the law reflects his will, his understanding and perception of the world. He believes that murder should be punished with death, that there should be fairness and justice in the world, that the law should not compromise for anyone, and that everyone should live under the control of the law... So, have you noticed that all the laws of the Qin Kingdom are what Lord Shang thought should be, or rather, what the majority of people in the Qin Kingdom thought should be? The laws will become whatever they are?"
"But is what Lord Shang thinks necessarily correct?"
Is what most people believe necessarily true?
Nothing in this world is perfect.
"People are the same."
"The minority who disagree are simply suppressed by the majority—suppressed by force, violence, and all its derivatives. A law built on suppressing a minority to win over the majority is, from the very beginning, a flawed and potentially dangerous proposition!"
"Because this kind of law is only beneficial to the majority and is therefore advocated and recognized by the majority, it cannot truly conquer everyone."
"A law that cannot convince everyone."
"A law that only caters to the majority."
"Thinking about it carefully, what kind of fairness is there to speak of?"
"Or, to put it another way, how do you know you're not one of the minority?"
Ye Qingcang never regarded the law as the ultimate truth.
If it is a fundamental principle of heaven and earth, he will abide by it.
Just as an apple, once ripe, will fall from the tree to the ground instead of flying away, he doesn't see anything wrong with this natural law.
But if it's the law...
Excuse me.
Any law is merely a tool.
It is a tool of the strong.
It is a tool for the strong to tame the weak.
What brings fairness to the weak is never the law, but the will of the strong.
But these words sounded like something to Ying Zheng.
That's truly a household name.
It felt like someone kicked open the door, dragged me out of bed, and threw me onto the street, where I was slapped in the face by swirling snowflakes.
I feel terrible.
But when he wanted to argue back.
But then I was shocked to discover a frustrating truth.
That's something he couldn't refute!
Because there are many precedents waiting for him!
They completely blocked any avenues he could possibly use to refute them!
If we must say that the executioner was guilty, then when Crown Prince Qian Ying Si confronted Shang Yang for murder, wasn't it Prince Qian who took the punishment in his place, having his nose cut off by Shang Yang according to the law, while Crown Prince Ying Si was unharmed and only learned from the experience, and was not sentenced to death?
The murderer shall die.
This precept had already been broken during Shang Yang's lifetime; it was only through the help of Prince Qian that the situation was barely salvaged.
Where is the fairness and justice?
But if the executioner is innocent, regardless of whose orders he followed, even if he was carrying out the death penalty according to the law, he is still a murderer, and to put it bluntly, the law should sentence him to death.
This leads to a self-contradictory situation.
The Qin Kingdom boasted of its most impartial and just laws.
The so-called rule of law.
Ultimately, right and wrong are still judged based on the monarch's own will. The only difference is that some of the original limitations have been removed in terms of public acceptance. By appealing to the majority, the monarch's authority has been strengthened.
In fact.
If the monarch himself kills someone in a fit of rage.
Can we simply abide by the existing laws and let the law judge us?
Or should he commit suicide in public to prove his guilt under the law?
Looking back at China's five thousand years of history.
Ye Qingcang had only ever met one person like that.
Without a doubt.
Ying Zheng, the Ying Zheng, could never have done that.
Therefore, Ying Zheng was speechless in the face of Ye Qingcang's questioning.
Because if he dared to claim that Qin Law was fair.
That would inevitably lead to betraying one's own identity and stance.
If he doesn't betray his identity and stance.
This is tantamount to denying the fairness of Qin Law.
The situation was one where one had to be abandoned, but abandoning either one would shake the foundation of the country. Even Ying Zheng, the Ying Zheng, was unable to make a decision for the time being.
But Ye Qingcang spoke without any restraint.
He shrugged.
He declared confidently, "On the contrary, the Path of Benevolence I promote is utterly unjust. Its core principle is simply survival of the fittest. My friends, my family, and everyone connected to me—no matter what they do—I always side with my family, not with what's right. Even if it invites the world's condemnation, I'm fearless. At least I haven't harmed my relatives and friends, and this will be crucial in the future. If I choose you, then in the future, when our opinions differ, when it's necessary to gain a greater advantage with a smaller loss, you will inevitably lean towards the conservatives and won't stand firmly by my side. You might even abandon me for your own benefit. But the friends I've made through Path of Benevolence, even if we ultimately fail to reach an agreement, will never betray me. At most, they'll let me develop on my own. If I succeed, all the better. If I fail, they won't hesitate to give me a suitable way out. This is something you can't guarantee, and I can only express my regret."
"The problems in the Qin Kingdom do exist."
"But to make something bad better."
"I think you would be very interested."
"I can give you the opportunity to showcase your talents."
"Why not give it a try?"
Ying Zheng was making a final effort.
If he initially came with the intention of setting up Net.
So now, he came for this young man in front of him. Although the young man's words were unpleasant, he could tell from the young man's thoughts that the law was no different from human feelings.
Unfortunately, this young man also ventured into darkness.
His style of doing things is unconventional.
These all align with his ideas and needs for further changes to the Qin Kingdom's laws.
He is a talented person capable of governing a country.
But Ye Qingcang still managed to kill the topic with a single sentence.
"I have a friend."
"He also wants this world."
"And I'm the kind of person who sides with my own family regardless of right or wrong."
"I don't want to put you in a difficult position."
"So, when we meet again, we might be enemies."
"I won't use such despicable means to assassinate you."
That's disrespectful to you.
"Either my friend will seize power from you and fulfill our shared dream of unifying the world, or you will seize power from my friend and fulfill the same dream of unifying the world. Do not be sad, do not feel lonely. There are many people on this road, each walking the path they believe is right. But only one person will have the last laugh."
"No need to send it."
Goodbye.
Ye Qingcang waved his hand.
The surrounding space suddenly distorted.
His figure was drawn into it.
Seeing this, Ying Zheng could only sigh.
With mixed feelings, he put down the wine bowl in his hand.
He left with regret.