The Archbishop of Toledo and Duke Don Juan of Madrid (Part Two)
The person fortunate enough to become the 243rd pope was Italians, as many had expected, which is not remarkable. What is worth discussing is that his age is right on the edge of the papal election age, at seventy-nine.
Among the seventy cardinals of the Vatican City, there are quite a few bishops who are Italy, pro -Habsburg, and somewhat hostile to France. However, the selection of this particular one is very likely related to the ongoing War of the Spanish Succession.
The discontent of the Roman Church with France had a long history, but because the previous Pope Innocent XI had ascended the throne after making a deal with Louis XIV, he had been trying to mediate and ease the relationship between France and the Roman Church. Louis XIV was able to be relatively unaffected by the Roman Church for the previous twenty years, thanks in no small part to Innocent XI. But now it seems difficult to say that Innocent XI's death was God's will.
We would like to clarify that we have no intention of disparaging the Roman Church here; after all, accidents can happen anywhere.
Let's return to our original topic. The reason why this pope's age is related to his selection is that, given the current state of the War of the Spanish Succession, the Roman Church and its allies could no longer withstand another sudden upheaval. To ensure that this pope was not bribed, intimidated, or cleverly negotiated with the King of France, they chose a pope who was old, foolish, deaf, and blind. Even a puppet placed on the papal throne would be more nimble than him. Only with this pope on the papal throne could the Roman Church's position be guaranteed to remain consistent with Leopold I.
Although Alexander VIII was old, he did not suffer from dementia. He was well aware that since Saint Louis, the France kings had no deep affection for the Roman Church, let alone respect for it. After all, before the Reformation, the Roman Church was practically a living hell, and after the Reformation, it had merely turned from a cesspool into a quagmire. Moreover, successive popes had been tirelessly trying to wrest back the rights that the France kings had usurped from them, namely religious taxes, inheritance taxes, and the power to appoint and dismiss priests—things that were originally in the hands of the popes but were now firmly held by the France kings.
If he complies with the demands of those cardinals, even if Louis XIV is currently immobilized, can he remain immobilized forever? Even if the Sun King loses Spain, he still possesses the behemoth that is the Netherlands, Flanders, and the original France. A repeat of the Avignon Incident is not impossible. In that case, whose authority will the Pope rely on to oppose Louis XIV?
Centuries later, a great man might scoff and ask: How many divisions does the Pope have? Alexander VIII would also like to ask those cardinals, if they angered Louis XIV, who could stop the France army from entering the Vatican City? After all, everyone knows that the one who might be thinking...
Interestingly, many people cursed Louis XIV as "impious," but the Roman Church remained silent, even avoiding the issue—much like the later saying that when someone criticizes you, you'd better be criticized yourself. If Louis XIV had been as devout to the Church as Saint Louis, or as the France kings before Saint Louis, like an eldest daughter serving her father, the Church would have certainly treated him with condescension and humiliation. But precisely because Louis XIV had been almost proven to be an unbeliever, the Church was more wary and respectful of him.
As soon as Alexander VIII ascended the throne, a cardinal eagerly demanded that he deny Charles of France the legitimacy of the Spain throne. Alexander VIII agreed, but then "fell ill." He lived a secluded life in Castle of Sant'Angelo, refusing to see anyone. Or rather, even if someone managed to see him, he appeared to be on his deathbed, as if he were about to meet God at any moment.
The cardinals were naturally furious, but they were helpless. They tried every means to conceal the news of Innocent XI's death and elected a new pope in a day and a night, all in an attempt to use the power of faith to suppress the Sun King — France was a Catholicism country. Unexpectedly, Alexander VIII, who had appeared confused and ignorant before his accession, became clear-headed after ascending the throne—he knew that once he issued the decree, he would be the perfect scapegoat.
The ascension of Pope Boniface VIII to the throne during the Avignon Incident was anything but glorious. As his enemies cursed, he seized the papacy like a fox, ruled the Vatican City like a cruel lion, and died as humiliatingly as a hyena. King Philip the Handsome of France, along with his enemies the Colonna family, captured him in his birthplace, Anagni, stripped him naked, shackled him, and forced him to ride backwards on a mule—like a lowly criminal. Besides this, he suffered numerous humiliations, so much so that even after his release (no one dared to kill a pope), he soon died in disgrace.
Alexander VIII seventy-nine years old today, but that doesn't stop him from wanting to continue living comfortably, nor does he want his family to clash with the Sun King of France. Although he and his family are all in Italy, the Sun King's illegitimate son is already the son-in-law of the Grand Duke of Tuscany. Although the Grand Duke of Tuscany has two sons, the elder son is in Paris, and the younger son is in poor health. The Grand Duke himself suffers from gout and cannot even walk, let alone ride a horse. The people of Tuscany have become accustomed to being ruled by Lord Luciano, and countless voices are saying that Luciano may be the dawn of Italy.
Elsewhere, Luciano's background would be criticized, but only in Italy —a Italy long divided and whose people had suffered from constant warfare—they desperately wanted a savior, whether he was a mercenary, a criminal, or an illegitimate child. Moreover, Luciano's father was such a great king, and with lineage still holding sway, they couldn't help but place high hopes on this handsome young man.
So, with Louis XIV's support, once Luciano became King of Italy, Alexander VIII's family would inevitably be at his mercy. Why would Alexander VIII invite such an enemy for the sake of the Habsburg?
However, Alexander VIII knew that those "people" wouldn't just stand by and watch him stall and delay. He secretly contacted Yilalue, Louis XIV's representative in Rome, as a warning to the Sun King. He then feigned illness for a few days before issuing a papal bull. This bull didn't deny Charles of France's right to the Spain throne, but rather condemned Louis XIV for monopolizing the power of appointing priests and for policies such as "no outflow of precious metals and assets"...
This isn't entirely wrong; almost every pope, upon ascending the throne, would severely reprimand the France king on this issue. However, like many "condemnations" around the world, such condemnations are merely superficial and generally receive no response. Nor would any country see this as an opportunity to attack France.
Thus, by the time Alexander VIII finally began to deny France's legitimacy to the Spain throne on a religious level, as demanded by the cardinals, Carlos III had already been formally crowned in Toledo Cathedral.
Let's go back to the day Alberoni returned to Toledo.
How familiar was Alberoni with Toledo? He was the son of a gardener, but was taken away by the archbishop when he was still a child. His memories of home were hazy, or rather, his concept of home was Toledo Cathedral, and his concept of father and family was the Archbishop of Toledo. He had once thought that he would stay here for a long time. By the side of the king and the archbishop, he had made quite a few friends, especially Patiño, who was the same age as José. He also thought that he would become a minister of Carlos II —to be honest, when he first met the king, he didn't look like a Devil, even if he didn't look very good.
But the devastation came so quickly. As he stood outside the cathedral, a priest hurried past, and he looked back several times in disbelief before realizing that the person was none other than the familiar young Alberoni. He exclaimed in surprise—of course, most people don't know the archbishop's actions and thought he had been sent to do something important. He pulled Alberoni into the cathedral.
As mentioned earlier, Toledo Cathedral is a building with a turbulent history. It was originally a cathedral during the reign of Reccared, and later it was converted into a temple by the Moors. In the 12th century, the king and archbishop converted it back into a Catholicism cathedral and gave it more decoration and expansion, such as the five halls, fifteen altars, eighty-eight columns, and stained glass windows that were added in the last three centuries. Countless brilliant spots are projected onto the floor, seats and walls, making this earthly dwelling of God as sublime and glorious as its name suggests.
The people in this church seem destined to share the same fate.
When the Archbishop of Toledo met Alberoni, he was first delighted, then hesitant, then doubtful, and finally his expression froze on a look of sorrow.
"Teacher," Alberoni said.
"Why have you returned?" the archbishop asked. "Or rather, what made you return?"
Alberoni was silent for a moment. "I wanted to come back myself, teacher."
"Go back to Paris, or anywhere else, just not Toledo," the archbishop said. "This place will soon become hell."
"Your words puzzle me," Alberoni said. "I asked His Majesty the King, and he promised that he would treat the people of Toledo with leniency."
"The people? The priests?"
"His Majesty's Lord will select and examine them one by one—if they truly live up to their oaths..."
"Stop talking nonsense," the archbishop said bluntly. If the Inquisition in Toledo was in such a state, the Church was even worse. He had tried to reform the Church in Toledo, but he had neither the support of the Church nor the support of those in power. The Spain Church was like a large tree; although it was rotten and decaying, no one could imagine how intricate, complex, and vast its roots were. They were intertwined and interconnected, so much so that no one could touch them—even a small member of the choir might be hiding a huge secret behind him.
"Sir Bishop," Alberoni said, "His Majesty says that if you wish... you can become the abbot of the Poblet Monastery."
"A good price." The archbishop didn't even bother to ask who Alberoni's so-called emperor was— Louis XIV would not allow the archbishop to remain in his current position. The Archbishop of Toledo was undoubtedly a man trusted by the Bourbon, and he would become a trusted minister of Carlos III in the future. The Poblet Monastery was one of the largest and wealthiest monasteries in Spain, and it was once the burial place of the royal families of Aragon and Catalonia. Becoming the abbot of this monastery was not a bad place for the Archbishop of Toledo, even.
"But you've seen it," the archbishop said, "We will not surrender." He stared at Alberoni, "Unless Louis XIV agrees to our terms."
"What are the conditions?"
"The church in Spain remains the church in Spain, and Spain remains the Spain of the Spain."
"Impossible."
"Then you may reply to your king like this," the archbishop tapped the ground with his toe, "Guess what's down there, Alberoni, my good disciple?" Alberoni followed his gesture and looked down. The church floor was made of smooth stones, but there was clearly fresh soil in the gaps. Alberoni wouldn't believe that someone had brought soil in from outside. He looked up at the archbishop.
"Yes," the archbishop said, "There is enough gunpowder buried below to completely destroy this cathedral."
"... You're just telling me this?"
The archbishop gave a mocking look. "Otherwise what? I'm not so naive as to think the King of France would come here unprepared. Yes, even if I say nothing, the French will know, but knowing is one thing, stopping us is another."
Indeed, stopping an assassination is easy, but the archbishop's words indicate that those who are hiding— Alberoni glanced at the cathedral's soaring dome. Perhaps the gunpowder buried beneath wasn't enough to destroy the cathedral, but they would certainly set it on fire. Once such a tall, open building catches fire, the howling winds between the halls alone can carry the flames in all directions, turning this magnificent hall into a blackened coal mine with minimal effort.
"This will not hinder His Majesty in any way." Does this mean the France army will remain stationed outside Toledo and refrain from advancing? Impossible.
"All I know is that His Majesty loves his children very much," the archbishop said. "And he certainly doesn't want the Bourbon's beginnings in Spain to be a disaster."