Han Luyi stood up, walked to the whiteboard, and picked up a black marker.
He drew a vertical line down the middle of the whiteboard, dividing it into two halves.
Then, on the left, four words were written: Existing Architecture.
"User code is uploaded to the BugKiller cloud, the detection engine runs on the Server, and the results are returned." He drew an arrow on the whiteboard as he spoke. "Throughout the process, the code passes through our Server, and this is the trust gap. Although we have encryption on the Server side and Auditing reports to prove compliance, because of this architecture, others can always question us."
He tapped on the left half of the architecture diagram on the whiteboard.
No matter how strict the agreement is, once the code leaves the user's own environment, whether "you stole it" or not will always be Rashomon.
He then wrote on the right half of the whiteboard: New Architecture.
"The BugKiller detection process works like this: first, the code is vectorized; then, the model detects the vectors, returns the model output, and translates it into modification suggestions. We've made the vectorization tool a locally deployed version, so the code doesn't leave the user's machine; vectorization is done locally. The cloud only receives the anonymized vectorized data. Vectorization can be considered an irreversible operation in engineering. Unless the user actively shares it, we can't even see what the original code looks like."
He put down his pen and added another line of text below the new framework, making it bold and drawing a circle around it.
Client-side vectorization algorithm: Open source.
The meeting room was silent for two seconds.
"Open source?" Lu Mingzhou repeated.
"That's right." Han Luyi turned around. "Any user, security Auditing, or competitor can Auditing the code to verify whether the client has actually uploaded any stolen code."
He paused for a moment.
"You can't prove it yourself, but you can get everyone else to prove it for you."
Lu Mingzhou was the first to settle the business accounts.
"Open source doesn't affect the business model, SaaS pricing remains unchanged, and enterprise customers are buying continuous updates, technical support, and private deployment services." He spoke more slowly than usual, as if addressing both the audience and investors simultaneously. "Do you know which step in the procurement process at large companies is the most cumbersome? Security Auditing. Previously, large companies' security teams would Auditing your code before daring to integrate it, but now the code is there, let them review it themselves. The most time-consuming and laborious step can be skipped entirely."
Su Niannian picked up the pace. "Then let's hurry up, release the statement today, finish the open-source solution as soon as possible, and release an update announcement after it's done."
Han Luyi looked at her.
"The window of public opinion waits for no one," Su Niannian said quickly. "Once the hype dies down after a week, it'll be old news, and the posts criticizing us will still be on the front page. We have to fight back while the hype is still going strong."
Zhao Wenyuan remained silent.
He only spoke after the plan was basically finalized.
"Boss Han." His voice wasn't loud, but everyone present stopped. Zhao Wenyuan's identity was special; his current rival was CodeSafe, which he had founded. Although it had been sold to Dingsheng, his very words drew everyone's attention.
Have you thought about this question?
Han Luyi also looked at him.
"Once your solution is implemented, it will raise the industry standard by a whole level. From now on, all code inspection tools will be compared to yours: 'BugKiller has already open-sourced, why haven't you?'"
The meeting room was completely silent.
"If CodeSafe follows suit, deploying the data masking logic locally and the detection in the cloud, you'll no longer be able to attack them on the 'data security' front. You've essentially played your biggest card."
Only Zhao Wenyuan could ask this question. He came from CodeSafe and witnessed firsthand the entire process of user code being shuffled into the model. He understands the weight of this card better than anyone else.
Han Luyi looked at him and smiled.
"Isn't that a good thing?"
Zhao Wenyuan was taken aback.
"If they actually followed suit," Han Luyi said, "It means they can no longer steal users' code."
Zhao Wenyuan did not respond.
No one in the meeting room raised any further objections.
Three days.
Han Luyi personally led the team to make the changes, Chen Jianye was responsible for the modular decomposition of the engine, and Han Luyi wrote the runtime adaptation layer for local deployment. Zhao Wenyuan's team cooperated to create an anonymization layer for the data pipeline to ensure that the open-source version did not contain any code related to training data.
Shen Congyun executed the plan simultaneously: on the first day, a statement and Lawyer were issued; on the second day, two media outlets were arranged for interviews, with only factual questions to be addressed and no verbal sparring; and on the third day, an open-source announcement was prepared.
Su Niannian called each of the four corporate clients who had inquired. It wasn't a mass-sent message; it was a one-on-one explanation of the plan and timeline. The longest call lasted forty minutes.
On the afternoon of the third day, BugKiller's GitHub repository went live.
The first line of the README states. "BugKiller client-side code vectorization tool is now open source. Your code stays on your machine."
Also released was a technical white paper, which details the architecture design, data flow, and privacy boundaries of the local deployment solution.
Within an hour of its launch, the open-source repository had garnered over a thousand stars on GitHub. The technical community began actively reviewing the code, and the first batch of conclusions emerged within three hours: the client had indeed been fully anonymized locally, and there were no backdoors in the uploaded code.
An External Network security engineer posted dozens of threads on X about this issue, concluding, "This is of great significance to the security standards of the entire industry. Open source and transparency—that's the true spirit of the internet."
It was forwarded more than 4,000 times.
There's a very popular analysis post on Zhihu with a straightforward title. "BugKiller is open source, CodeSafe..."
What?
The post didn't directly criticize CodeSafe; it simply put screenshots of the two companies' user agreements side by side. Netizens compared the screenshots and highlighted the key points in the comments section, and the top comments quickly made the conclusion clear.
"The one with stricter guidelines has been open-sourced; the one with broader guidelines hasn't dared to."
Dingsheng: BugKiller stole code! BugKiller: Okay, I've open-sourced it, your turn. Dingsheng: No, wait, please don't!
The phrase "the difference in quality is immediately apparent" went from being a top-rated comment to defining the nature of this incident.
The panic posts on the BugKiller community have all sunk to the bottom, and the pinned post has become an open-source announcement with a link to the technical white paper. The enterprise users who previously posted the panic posts have all deleted them. One of them edited their original post, adding a line: "Update: After reading the open-source code and white paper, the problem is solved. To be fair, very few companies can do this."
Han Luyi called He Yunshen simply said after listening, "Well done. Let me know if you need anything."
His tone was flat, and he didn't press for further questions.
In an investor's language, this is the best signal.
The air on the 28th floor of the Dingsheng Tower was completely different within the same week.
The Daily Active Users All Things Alive have dropped to just over 10,000, and its rating on the app store has remained stable at 1.7, with one-star reviews accounting for 70%.
Wang Zhiyuan invited Chen Bowen to his office.
Instead of scolding him, Wang Zhiyuan poured him a glass of water, his tone unusually gentle.
"Bowen, you've worked hard. The matter of All Things Alive isn't just your problem."
Chen Bowen looked at the water glass on the table but didn't pick it up.
"The public pressure is immense, and the chairman is also asking questions. I need to stabilize the situation first." Wang Zhiyuan's voice sounded distant. "I'll handle the aftermath of All Things Alive. You should rest for a few days and don't come to the company."
Take a few days off.
During his years at Dingsheng, Chen Bowen saw too many people "take a few days off," only to have their workstations moved away while they were resting.
But Wang Zhiyuan's tone wasn't one of discussion, and he never discusses things with anyone.
"Okay." Chen Bowen stood up. "Then I'll go first—"
"Oh, right," Wang Zhiyuan said, as if remembering something, "Hand over the permissions to the documents and data related to 'All Things Alive' to Yang Zhigang so that the next person can take over."
Handover.
In Dachang, "handover" is the signature field on death sentences.
Chen Bowen didn't go home immediately; he returned to his workstation and turned on his computer.
First, open the internal collaboration tools.
[The Core Project Team of All Things Alive], thankfully, the group is still there, and messages can still be viewed. However, the group owner has changed from Chen Bowen to Yang Zhigang.
There was a light gray system notification, but no one responded. The notification was from half an hour ago.
At that time, he was still "drinking water" in Wang Zhiyuan's office.
In other words, everything was arranged before Wang Zhiyuan even had his "talk" with him; Yang Zhigang already knew, and the group admin had already made changes. His opinion was completely irrelevant.
Whoosh A new message popped up; it was from Yang Zhigang: "Each group should reorder any unclosed work orders according to priority, and synchronize them at 3 PM."
Chen Bowen opened his email. At the top of his inbox was an email copied to all employees, sent by the VP's Office Assistant, with the subject. "Notice Regarding the Establishment of Special Project Working Group for Product Quality Rectification at All Things Alive".
He opened the email and scrolled down to the member list.
Technical Lead: Yang Zhigang; Testing Lead: Fang Hui; Product Lead: Liu Chang.
Chen Bowen is not included.
The last line of the email reads, "This notice is effective immediately."
Chen Bowen then clicked on the project dashboard of All Things Alive.
A pop-up message appears. "You do not have permission to access this project. Please contact the project administrator to request access."
Project Administrator: Yang Zhigang.
Chen Bowen stared at the pop-up window for a long time, lost in thought.
He sat in his seat, in the same office as yesterday, but now he felt like he was falling.
At noon, Chen Bowen went to a restaurant for lunch.
A line formed at the food pick-up window, with Fang Hui standing at the end of the line holding an empty tray. Normally, if Chen Bowen bumped into him in the restaurant, he would just glance at him and that would be it; a nod at most would be unnecessary. The technical director and the test team leader were not the type to exchange pleasantries on the way to pick up their food.
Today, however, he took the initiative to call out, "Fang Hui."
Fang Hui's shoulders tensed, and as if he hadn't heard, he shuffled half a step into the queue, his eyes fixed on today's set meal above the window. He tilted the tray to the other side and moved half a body length to the side.
Chen Bowen opened his mouth, but before he could finish speaking, Fang Hui had already lined up at the window, gotten his food, picked up his tray, quickened his pace slightly, and walked away from the seating area he usually sat in.
Chen Bowen realized that this was a "self-preservation tactic" he often used: keeping his distance from those who had clearly lost power to avoid being implicated. However, this was the first time he himself had been the one to be avoided.
Back at his workstation, Chen Bowen opened WeChat and sent a message to Wang Zhiyuan: "Mr. Wang, if you need my cooperation in providing supplementary materials regarding the quality rectification, please contact me anytime."
No reply.
Three days after the conversation with Wang Zhiyuan.
The HRBP sent a meeting invitation: the topic is [Career Development Communication], 4 PM, Room 208.
"Career development communication" is something that everyone at Dingsheng understands. These six words are mostly the prelude to optimization, and very few people can walk out of this process gracefully.
Meeting room 208 was small, but the lights were very bright.
Chen Bowen pushed open the door and entered. His gaze fell on the opposite side, and his stomach clenched— Zhang Wei was sitting across from him.
Zhang Wei was the HRBP he worked with; Zhang Wei was the one who talked to the people he laid off. He never imagined he'd end up like this.
On the opposite side of the table were printed materials, and next to them was an unopened bottle of mineral water.
"Mr. Chen, please have some water."
Chen Bowen didn't move.
Zhang Wei cleared her throat and began reading an invisible script. "Considering the recent project performance and the impact of quality incidents, your semi-annual performance evaluation result is 3.25."
His performance rating was 3.25, while it was 3.75 in the previous half-year.
"According to the company's performance management system, you will be placed under a performance improvement plan with a three-month observation period. During this period, you will be suspended from participating in core projects, but your salary will not be affected."
Zhang Wei didn't look up at him, speaking at a steady pace, "This is the summary of this communication. Please confirm and sign it."
The folder was pushed over with a swift and steady motion, as if Zhang Wei didn't recognize him. The communication minutes were on top, with attachments underneath.
Chen Bowen opened it.
It's a photocopy of the online approval form.
There were three signature fields; his name was in the "Project Leader" field.
At the bottom, there is a line of small print. "Signing this form confirms that the product has passed all quality acceptance standards and meets the conditions for going live."
He stared at the small print, recalling the glass of water Wang Zhiyuan had poured for him in the office, the academic integrity pledge in his master's thesis, and the motto he believed in.
A lie that goes undetected is not a lie.
It has been discovered.
Or rather, someone has always known, but only brings it out when needed.
Chen Bowen signed the minutes.
He stood up, closed the door, and left conference room 208.
The corridor was long, the fluorescent lights were a cold, white light, and it was already dark outside.
His face was reflected in the glass as he passed by the floor-to-ceiling window.
Same as what I saw in the elevator last time.
Gray.
"Want to come out and meet me?" A message popped up on his phone.