Starfish Technology, Legal Department.
A legal specialist handed a newly received notification letter to Dong Jin of Starfish Technology.
Dong Jin checked the time; it was almost time to leave work. Why was a letter arriving at this hour?
After thinking about it, he decided that since he was taking responsibility for this unusual occasion, he wouldn't leave it until tomorrow and would first open the package to see what it contained.
As soon as Dong Jin opened it, he regretted it.
How could this be a collective labor dispute resolution?
As the legal director of Starfish Technology, Dong Jin knows inside information that many employees are unaware of.
For example, Starfish Technology's layoffs this time were not a spur-of-the-moment decision at all, and had nothing to do with "embracing i".
This round of layoffs was planned months in advance, with the aim of reducing costs and increasing profitability before Starfish Technology's Hong Kong IPO.
As for the so-called "embracing i," it's just a convenient excuse that company management has found to follow the trend.
To maintain the company's healthy cash flow, several key personnel from the Legal Department and Human Resources Department have been working overtime this month, creating highly personalized plans for almost every laid-off employee, none of whom received compensation. Of course, these so-called personalized plans cannot withstand scrutiny; if they were to go to Arbitration Tribunal, Starfish Technology would most likely lose.
The Legal Department also made contingency plans, anticipating that some of the laid-off employees would apply for arbitration—with so many people, it's inevitable that a few troublemakers will emerge.
However, firstly, only a minority of people will apply for arbitration; most people will choose to suffer in silence.
Furthermore, the arbitration result will be several months away. By then, Starfish Technology will have already successfully listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange, and its cash flow pressure will have been relieved. It can then directly pay the compensation to the troublemakers, and the matter will be resolved satisfactorily.
But now someone has organized a collective arbitration. If Xingyu loses the arbitration, it will probably have to pay compensation to all the laid-off employees, which will be much more than the original compensation.
Ignoring the fact that it was almost time to leave work, Dong Jin quickly called Zhou Jiaying from Starfish Technology.
"Mr. Zhou, do you have a moment? I have something urgent to report to you, and it would be best if we could discuss it in person, otherwise it might be difficult to explain. It's related to—something important that's been happening these past few days."
Dong Jin's voice was filled with anxiety, and Zhou Jiaying had no choice but to take it seriously.
"Come to my office now," Zhou Jiaying said.
Soon, Dong Jin arrived at Zhou Jiaying's office. After entering, he glanced outside to make sure no one was around before closing the door and walking quickly to Zhou Jiaying.
"Mr. Zhou, look at this. Some employees have organized a collective arbitration and sent us Lawyer."
To be precise, this notification letter isn't exactly Lawyer, but Dong Jin said it this way to reduce communication costs, since the boss might not be able to distinguish between different legal documents. Zhou Jiaying frowned and said, "What do you mean?"
"Our previous plan was to lay off a group of employees for different reasons, and none of them would receive severance pay. However, if it's a class-action arbitration, the outcome will generally tend to cover all employees who filed complaints, which means—"
"So you're saying we have to pay severance to everyone who was laid off?" Zhou Jiaying raised her voice. "Didn't you say before that the severance pay would be double the compensation? How can there be such a problem?"
Dong Jin was also troubled.
He's used this same approach with other companies before, and it didn't cause any problems then.
Are people's legal awareness really that strong now?
But at this point, he certainly couldn't admit his mistake, so he could only bite the bullet and say, "President Zhou, I think someone is probably pulling strings behind the scenes. Otherwise, if only one or two employees came to arbitrate, it would have been all within our contingency plan."
Zhou Jiaying didn't bother listening to Dong Jin's explanations and simply asked, "So what do we do now? Can we still prevent them from initiating arbitration? Can we even win the arbitration?"
Faced with a series of questions thrown at him by his boss, Dong Jin's mind raced, and he answered the ones that were easiest to answer first.
Whether we can win the arbitration depends on the Arbitration Tribunal, but our current situation is not very optimistic.
Seeing Zhou Jiaying's unfriendly expression, Dong Jin could only bite the bullet and continue, "Your initial strategy prioritized efficiency above all else, so we didn't follow the complete dismantling procedure, which is a fatal flaw."
"Then there's the issue of withdrawing the lawsuit. There are actually ways to handle that. With so many people involved in a class-action arbitration, Clubhouse everyone will follow through. The Arbitration Tribunal will require a few key representatives to be selected. These representatives are usually the main organizers. As long as we reach a private settlement with them—" Having experienced this failed layoff plan, Zhou Jiaying no longer trusted Dong Jin's professional abilities. She looked at Dong Jin suspiciously and asked, "Even if these ringleaders withdraw, can't the rest still choose to continue suing?"
Dong Jin was calmer than when he first entered. He smiled and said, "President Zhou, you are a benefactor. You don't know the mentality of these ordinary employees. Among this group, there are only a few who dare to cause trouble. As long as we win over the troublemakers, the rest would rather suffer losses than go to court."
Before becoming the General Counsel of Starfish Technology, Dong Jin was a Lawyer specializing in dispute resolution, and he had a very accurate grasp of his clients' mindset.
Zhou Jiaying, however, thought of something else entirely.
"If our arbitration case gets out, it'll already sound bad enough. Now you're trying to bribe former employees? What if you can't reach an agreement? What if they leak it to the media?"
Dong Jin silent; this question was difficult to answer.
"If you go to a well-known law firm outside, do you have a chance of winning? Boheng?" Zhou Jiaying asked.
When planning this layoffs, Zhou Jiaying reviewed the budget and estimated that it would save the company about 20 to 30 million yuan in compensation.
In other words, if the arbitration is lost, the party will have to pay 50 million yuan in compensation upfront.
This puts considerable pressure on Starfish Technology's current cash flow, not to mention that it will be listed on the Hong Kong Stock Exchange next month, and time is of the essence.
Top law firms charge hefty fees, but even the most expensive Lawyer can't cost more than fifty million, right?
When the topic of arbitration came up, Dong Jin suddenly remembered to check which law firm had sent the letter. Siheng Law Firm — Dong Jin paused, taken aback by the name.
Isn't this the boutique hotel that Origin Group has been partnering with for a long time?
Two days ago, Zhou Jiaying made a last-minute decision to follow the lead of several other listed companies that had benefited from the layoffs, linking the layoffs to the story of "embracing i and improving efficiency." To prevent a possible backlash from Origin Group, Dong Jin even went to investigate the background of Origin Group.
In addition, Dong Jin had heard some gossip from friends in the legal profession, saying that the director of this law firm was the mistress of the owner of the Origin Group.
Netizens love these kinds of stories. First, they throw mud at them, and once the matter gets heated up online, the employees who were organized for collective arbitration will start to have doubts, and their organization will collapse on its own.
Could we perhaps focus on this aspect?
Dong Jin shared his brilliant plan with Zhou Jiaying nodded in agreement.
Whether it's a business battle or a lawsuit, online public opinion can be very useful in many situations.