Another Mastermind Behind the Night of the Black Knives (Story Discussion)
I spent the whole night thinking about the plot of Night of the Black Knives, and then I couldn't sleep in the middle of the night, so I wrote down this rambling analysis while I had some inspiration.
Because of the missing plot details, I, as the author of the novel, had to fill in the gaps in the story myself.
A note before reading: Please do not assume this is a very serious or reasonable piece, as I only have some clues that can explain this speculation, and cannot say that they are definitive.
Because I stayed up all night writing this, the order of the evidence might be messed up. If possible, please read it through the whole thing before going back to the paragraphs to add to and discuss it, so we can brainstorm together. (Anyway, please don't attack me, I'm very fragile, sob sob)
First of all, many of the previous speculations are no longer valid, including the idea that killing Godwyn would actually be advantageous to Godwyn.
These conjectures are essentially additional speculations derived from the initial hypothesis that Marika was involved in the Night of the Black Knives.
Now that Marika's character has been supplemented in the DLC, explaining her image and personality before becoming a god, it's time to change some of the previous assumptions.
Now that we're talking about the Night of the Black Knives, we first need to establish one thing: Ranni was the mastermind, but she was definitely not the only one.
If you want to know why, it's simple: judging from her performance in the game, Ranni simply couldn't handle such a large task all by herself.
Although she is my wife and an ambitious woman, she clearly lacks the ability to achieve this.
For example, where did Ranni, the Black Knife Assassin, get her?
The text only says that they are the same Numen as Marika, but we also know that the Numen race is not uncommon in the Lands Between. Several branches of the Eternal Descendants have fled outwards, and there are quite a lot of them. We cannot attribute all of them to Marika's attack just because Black Knife is Numen.
Radagon, as a demigod, is Numen, and the Carian Royal Family is also Eternal Descendants (their emblems are directly modified from the Eternal City). The demigods are all of Numen blood, even if they don't acknowledge Caria's Numen bloodline, since they are all born to Marika or Radagon.
In other words, the Black Knife Assassin may have originally been a special unit of the Numen, and their armor and stealth abilities could be said to have originated from the Nox Dynasty (Unseen Form).
There should be several factions or masters among the Black Knife Assassin.
For example, Marika has some men still guarding the gate. And the Two Fingers that Ranni wanted to kill might also be controlling a group of them.
Where are the rest? That's right, in the Ordina, Liturgical Town outside the Haligtree of Miquella.
I'll start by proposing a very, very bold hypothesis, which of course might not even be written in the novel, so you can first read through the story flow and analysis.
My conclusion: The other group involved in the Night of the Black Knives was Miquella, while Marika most likely did not participate at all.
Before the DLC came out, everyone thought that Godwyn was chosen by Miquella, but after the DLC came out, it was clearly told to us that Radahn was actually the king chosen by Miquella, and that this had never changed since he was a child.
In that case, Godwyn's position becomes quite awkward.
Whether considering his achievements or the legitimacy of his status, if the PUBG war hadn't broken out, he would absolutely have been the best candidate to become king.
If Miquella wants to follow his own laws, whether it's to fulfill his own wishes or to heal Malenia, he needs to follow his own laws.
But will 'Golden' Godwyn allow the Haligtree, or even the Laws of Miquella in the DLC, to replace the Erdtree?
As we know from the main storyline, Miquella wanted Godwyn to die properly, but this does not clear his name of suspicion.
Miquella is the kind of person who would even abandon the half of herself that Humanity. So what if she's willing to kill her brother and friend for her own purposes?
Moreover, isn't a body with only flesh and no soul better than Mohg's tattered corpse?
For Miquella, Ranni using part of her Destined Death was no problem at all; in fact, it was more like they hit it off right there.
Ranni can kill the body to get rid of Two Fingers, Miquella can gain the body. (Miquella certainly won't reveal her plan to trick Radahn.)
Unfortunately, the Erdtree showed too much "care" to Godwyn, which turned him into a monster.
In response, Miquella expressed her deepest apology to her brother and friend. "(If I had known it would turn out this way) I wish he had died properly."
However, the goal of removing those who stood in the way was still achieved.
If he wasn't lamenting Godwyn's death, but simply felt pain because of the way Godwyn died, then that would be quite reasonable.
Ranni and Miquella are in agreement on killing Godwyn, as long as they both follow their own laws.
As for stealing Destined Death, assuming that the demigods are no match for the Black Blade, there seem to be only three methods at present.
The first type is a wine that even demigods would get drunk on, as mentioned in the abandoned case.
The scrapped proposal will not be discussed for now, but it Li Ke the novel. Moreover, this thing is also related to St. Trina, as it requires using St. Trina's Crystal Ball to collect the deep slumber fog.
The second type is Miquella's allure.
The Black Blade sword doesn't seem to be bewitched, so pass.
The last method is St. Trina's hypnosis.
All three are related to Miquella or St. Trina; I really can't find any others.
Even after being concocted by Thiollier, an outsider, St. Trina's Nectar had the power to put Ancient Dragons to sleep. If St. Trina were to release it herself, it wouldn't be impossible for her to temporarily hypnotize Black Blade.
Another crucial point is that the mist that puts Kale to sleep when Ranni appears is likely a technique related to St. Trina's. As a collaborator or friend, she probably learned a bit from her, since St. Trina is the only character in the game with sleep-related abilities.
Furthermore, could it be that the Bloodhound Knight, who never mentioned being controlled by Two Fingers (namely Blaidd) and believed his master would never betray him, was seduced by Miquella and planted as a spy under Ranni?
After being discovered, neither Ranni nor Iji stopped Blaidd, which indicates that the betrayal did indeed occur. However, Iji may have been mindful of the past and felt that sealing him away would suffice.
Given Miquella's allure, it's entirely possible that Bloodhound Knight who had already chosen a master might switch his allegiance to her.
Secondly, the Spirit Calling Bell that Ranni gave us was said to have been given to Torrent by her former master. It seems that Miquella was Torrent's former master, and Miquella can indeed summon spirits, don't you agree, Radahn?
As for Torrent being brought by Melina, I guess Miquella abandoned the calf and St. Trina together, so Melina and Ranni delivered them separately.
The timing is a bit strange, but it's not a big deal, since Melina's true form should indeed be in the Lands Between rather than the Land of Shadow.
Furthermore, the DLC explicitly states that both the Boar Rider and Messmer are the elder brothers of the Lion (Radahn), which completely obfuscates the timeline.
So let's leave the time issue aside for now and wait for the experts to sort it out.
Ranni to abandon her physical body was to break free from the control of the Two Fingers, and it didn't affect Miquella's plans at all.
We won't discuss the situation with Miquella's Two Fingers for now, as we don't know the exact details. However, in the worst-case scenario, it's possible that Miquella's Two Fingers have been bewitched.
Without revealing the full plan, Ranni and her group, including Radahn and Rykard, posed no threat to Miquella.
Ranni and Radahn had already been considered by Miquella to be on their side, and with two of the three siblings on the same side, what more could Rykard possibly say?
Rykard:... You know what I'm going to say, what can I say! Together!
Moreover, during the Shattering, the La family army was probably thinking about how to put Ranni, Radahn, or Rykard into power. Who could have imagined that Radahn would be targeted by Miquella?
It's even possible that Rykard's rebellion against the Greater Will is related to the discovery of the Mother of Fingers's whereabouts (although it's unlikely with Rykard, Ranni's absence from the stronghold offers an explanation, since they're all Fingercreepers).
During the Shattering, the Haligtree and the La family army formed a complete alliance to jointly attack the Leyndell of Leyndell.
As for the success rate, it's practically on the verge of success.
The only unexpected variable was the Omen Brothers. One held the line during the attack, while the other stole Miquella himself.
Although Miquella directly charmed Mohg, it genuinely impacted the progress of his plans.
Next, you can connect it to the DLC.
However, the biggest problem with this explanation is that it fails to account for why Marika suddenly smashed the ring.
The only plausible explanation I can think of is that Marika suddenly discovered that 'Greater Will' actually Mother of Fingers when Godwyn died.
Or rather, what did Radagon do?
However, these are not the focus for now; let's wait for environmental scientists to analyze them and only discuss the Night of the Black Knives.
If we feel that the forward argument isn't particularly convincing, we can also try the reverse argument.
Who are the characters capable of participating in the Night of the Black Knives? It's nothing more than all the demigods plus Marika and Radagon.
First of all, Radahn and Rykard have never shown any connection to the Black Knife, nor have they been involved in any major conspiracies (Rykard, at least, has been genuinely assembling an army to fight, and even shouted the loudest slogans).
Messmer and Melina, Morgott and Mohg are all out of contact.
Based on the character design shown in the current DLC, there's absolutely no indication that Marika would actually do such a thing. She even Grace a child like Messmer, who was abandoned, and only imprisoned him with the Land of Shadow. If she were to actually kill someone, she would kill Messmer first.
Marika is actually quite docile, considering how her own people were ravaged by the Hornsent, and how she didn't kill the two Omen on the spot. Look at how Godfrey treats Morgott; even though he's locked up in the sewers, he still treats him like a son.
Godwyn, pass.
The claim that Godwyn profited from his death is completely untenable. Death has long been removed from the Golden Order; he could have simply remained the heir to the gold, there was no need for that.
Radagon, whose mind is filled with the Golden Order, is even more eager for Godwyn to become the heir to the Golden Order.
In the end, the only ones left were the two siblings from the Haligtree.
Only they were among those who possessed Black Knife at the time, and also had the reason and motive to participate.
And that's it. It was a spur-of-the-moment decision at night, and I felt like I'd used every clue I could find. Time to sleep, haha. _(□`"∠)_