"I believe that waltz on the exterior wall of the high-rise building under the moonlight will become a classic scene in the entire film, and may even become an unforgettable classic scene in Hong Kong action movies."
"Undeniably, in pursuit of visual spectacle, some scenes in the film do not hold up to scrutiny. However, these flaws do not detract from its overall merit; for a film aiming to please audiences who love special effects, it is definitely a sincere work that cannot be ignored."
"Lu Heng is indeed a newcomer to the directing industry. But he's smart enough and knows how to play to his strengths and avoid his weaknesses. I have to say, the special effects and fight scenes in <Cats and Dogs War> really impressed me."
"With a cast of handsome men and beautiful women, a host of big-name cameos, a tight plot, exciting fight scenes, and realistic and thrilling special effects, 'Cats and Dogs War' definitely shows enough sincerity for a commercial film and is a movie worth looking forward to during the Lunar New Year season..."
In contrast to the overwhelmingly positive reviews from industry media and film critics for "Cats and Dogs War," "Return of the Planet," which was released at the same time, was less than satisfactory.
"The plot is dry and clichéd, the fight scenes are extremely drawn out, and there are too many details that deviate from the main theme. If you haven't seen the previous Planet series films, you simply won't understand what this movie is about..."
"A half-hearted, slapstick comedy. While Hollywood blockbusters dominate the world, the proliferation of franchises is eroding audience enthusiasm. Undeniably, the * Planet series * series holds a landmark position in Hollywood, a true classic that pioneered special effects action films. However, Universal Pictures' sincerity has been severely diminished by repeated box office successes. The * Planet series * series, which once captivated global audiences, is now reduced to a nostalgic sentiment. But what worries me more is whether this the U.S. nostalgia, so prevalent in Hollywood and the Huaxia film market, will resonate with Huaxia audiences who haven't seen many * Planet series * films...?"
"Bang!"
The day after the premiere, facing the overwhelmingly negative sentiment from major media outlets and the internet, Qi Jiaming, his face ashen, smashed his coffee cup. His attention shifted back to the overwhelmingly positive reviews for * Cats and Dogs War *. Qi Jiaming scoffed angrily, "It's just a premiere. I refuse to believe that a Hollywood blockbuster can't compare to the practice work of that third-rate director, Lu Heng."
In any case, there aren't many commercial films that have won over professional media and film critics in terms of word-of-mouth. Looking at the trends in word-of-mouth for Hollywood blockbusters in recent years, there are countless high-grossing films that received low scores on Rotten Tomatoes and Garlic Petal. Not to mention that "Return of the Planet," which was released simultaneously in Hollywood and the European and American markets during the Christmas season, has swept the box office in the U.S. and the European and American markets. In terms of word-of-mouth, it is regarded by many die-hard fans of "Return of the Planet series" as a sincere work that carries on the classic.
That's why Qi Jiaming wasn't too worried about the box office performance of "Return of the Planet" in Huaxia. On the contrary, Qi Jiaming was even more excited about its upcoming nationwide release.
At that time, he will use his soaring box office record to teach the people behind "Cats and Dogs War" and the Lu family's Wei family what a real movie is!
Chapter 240 Stealing Box Office Revenue
On Friday, January 18, 2007, three days after the simultaneous premieres of "Cats and Dogs War" and "Return of the Planet," both films were released nationwide at the same time.
Starting at 6 PM, long queues had already formed at the ticket counters of major cinemas across the country.
Although there were several other films of different genres released on January 18th besides "Cats and Dogs War" and "Return of the Planet," the audience waiting at the ticket counter almost exclusively chose between these two.
In the ticket hall of Huaxia Cinemas, the theater manager looked on with satisfaction at the long lines stretching from the ticket counter all the way to the steps at the cinema entrance. Due to Wei Linxuan's special status within the Huaxia Group, "Cats and Dogs War" had achieved an astonishing 65% of the screenings nationwide in Huaxia Cinema Circuit. In addition, "Return of the Planet" had a 20% screening share, while the other films joined together to share the remaining 15%.
Of course, this is only the treatment of "Cats and Dogs War" in Huaxia Cinema Circuit. As for other cinemas in China, the average screening rate of "Cats and Dogs War" is only about 25%, which is much worse than the 52% screening rate of "Return of the Planet".
However, this arrangement is understandable. After all, for most theaters, the credibility of Hollywood stars is always more reliable than that of domestic films, and the phenomenal success of the Planet of the Planet series in the global film market has given theaters more confidence.
As for the simultaneously released film * Cats and Dogs War *... if it weren't for the reputations of the lead actors Lu Heng, Zhao Miao, Chen Mengyi, Xu Baoyan, Wang Zhen, and a host of guest stars, as well as Huaxia Group's leading position in the domestic entertainment industry, other cinemas probably wouldn't even give it 25% of the screenings. After all, the director of * Cats and Dogs War * is Lu Heng, a complete novice in the field. Even though * Cats and Dogs War * received rave reviews after its premiere, whether those reviews will translate into high attendance... other cinemas really can't guarantee.
After all, there are plenty of films in the movie industry that are critically acclaimed but not commercially successful.
When you open a business, who isn't in it to make money? The production team of "Cats and Dogs War" certainly understood the concerns of other cinema chains—after all, Huaxia Cinema Circuit alone controls a third of all cinemas across the country. With that huge sum, "Cats and Dogs War" really didn't care much about the number of screenings on other chains.
However, while they understood the situation, the creators of "Cats and Dogs War" were still privately quite unhappy that their film couldn't compete with "Return of the Planet" in terms of screenings. This was because it meant that, apart from their own people, some outsiders didn't have as much faith in "Cats and Dogs War" as they claimed.
After reviewing the screening schedules across major cinemas nationwide, Zhao Miao, one of the male leads, angrily slammed down the phone and complained to his girlfriend, "These profiteers, they're all the kind of guys who won't act until they see results. Just you wait. They don't think much of 'Cats and Dogs War' right now, huh? I'll see if those bastards give us more screenings after 'Cats and Dogs War' surpasses 'Return of the Planet' at the box office!"