Sagres's question is like a cold dagger, pointing straight to the heart of the problem.
Dumbledore did not look away; something heavy settled deep within those deep blue eyes.
"This isn't about surrendering principles, Sagres; it's about a realistic trade-off."
Dumbledore's voice carried a hint of weariness. "Faced with darkness, we cannot Dispel everything with our own light alone. We need power, even if it comes from the grey areas. The key is to guide, not simply to accept or reject."
"Trade off?"
Sagres repeated softly, his tone more sarcastic, "When you're 'weighing' whether to ally with the Giants, you've already stepped into a moral quagmire. Even if such an alliance wins, the Wizarding World won't become any better."
Dumbledore shook his head slightly. "I'm trying to offer them a choice, a path different from the one Voldemort offered, a path filled with destruction and enslavement."
"Unnecessary," Sagres almost laughed out loud, "Because the Death Eaters have probably already given them a choice."
"It's different," Dumbledore corrected. "If they choose to join us, it proves they aren't entirely unreasonable, and darkness isn't their only destiny. If they refuse..."
He paused, then added, "At least we tried, and we stood our ground morally. We clearly distinguished between friend and foe, rather than actively pushing potential neutrals into the enemy's camp."
"A potential neutral party?"
Sagres shook his head. "You're both idealistic and realistic, Dumbledore. The history of the Giants, their habits, and the way they treat other intelligent life clearly show that they were never 'potential neutrals.' They are predators who follow the law of the jungle!"
"So, according to your logic," Dumbledore at Sagres, "Should we preemptively strike, define them as enemies, and eliminate them before the Giants have explicitly expressed their support for Voldemort? Just like you dealt with Scrimgeour, establishing order with absolute terror and nipping all uncertainties in the bud?"
"I generally don't punish someone for a decision they haven't made yet. As for Scrimgeour..."
Sagres sneered. "His deeply ingrained bureaucratic mindset has driven him to oppose me. In his eyes, everyone must yield to the Ministry of Magic's rule, regardless of whether they are right or wrong."
He looked at Dumbledore with a half-smile. "Actually, it doesn't matter who the Giants decide to help, but if they dare to accept Voldemort's invitation, then I have enough reason to let them know what price they have to pay to become my enemies."
Dumbledore shook his head in denial, "This is not a good solution..."
Sagres interrupted him abruptly, "This is far more reliable than trying to appease a bunch of fickle, vicious creatures. We don't need unreliable 'allies,' we need Stabilization order and absolute deterrence."
"But Sagres, how long can a 'peace' built on corpses last?"
Dumbledore sighed, his eyes filled with worry, "Fear breeds hatred, and hatred breeds new rebellion. You have destroyed Giants today, but tomorrow you may face a horde of Werewolf enraged by it, and the day after, Centaurs who feel threatened... Sagres, you are creating a never-ending cycle of revenge."
"I am not afraid to be an enemy of anyone, Headmaster Dumbledore, because I know I am right."
"You may win every battle, but you can never win true peace," Dumbledore said softly. "True power lies not in how many enemies you can destroy, but in how many hostility you can dissolve and how many hearts you can win."
"Deconstruct hostility? Win hearts and minds?"
Sagres shook his head. "That applies to beings that can communicate and possess reason. For some, they only understand one language—power. In the face of war, hesitation and mercy are often the greatest cruelty. I would rather use a clear and unmistakable signal of terror to deter all those who covet it than risk the lives of innocent people with a perilous 'opportunity'."
"I cannot agree with your point of view, Sagres."
Dumbledore's tone hardened. "As long as there is even a sliver of possibility for peace, as long as they haven't truly raised their swords, we should strive to achieve it. This is our responsibility, and the fundamental difference between us and Voldemort and his followers. We cannot, out of fear of future risks, easily abandon hope and fall into the abyss of violence begetting violence."
"And I think your 'hope' is too slim," Sagres replied coldly. "Clear boundaries are the greatest protection for one's own side. We cannot save everyone, much less befriend everyone. If the Giants could truly distinguish right from wrong, they wouldn't have joined the Death Eaters' ranks. But if they ultimately choose to be our enemies, then death is their inevitable fate."
"You're not even willing to try," Dumbledore, his voice filled with regret.
"Because I know perfectly well that what those Death Eaters are promising is a bargaining chip you can never offer."
Sagres said, word by word, "Hagrid's mission was destined to fail, and you pushed him to the brink of danger just to try it out, for the sake of that doomed outcome!"
As dusk deepened, their shadows stretched long and thin.
They stood facing each other, like two mountains that could never merge.
Neither could convince the other; they were self-consistent and steadfast, their starting points and core beliefs diametrically opposed.
Finally, Dumbledore slowly exhaled, breaking the silence. "It seems we cannot reach a consensus on this matter for the time being."
"Yes." Sagres nodded slightly, his expression returning to its usual indifference. "But at least we understand each other's positions."
Dumbledore, said nothing more, turned and left, his long silver hair and beard gleaming in the afterglow of the setting sun.
Sagres remained standing, silently watching the other person's departing figure.
He really didn't know whether to say Dumbledore idealistic or too realistic.
This old man actually wanted, and genuinely believed, that he could form an alliance with the Giant Tribe?
For thousands of years, these creatures have regarded humans as their prey. Even after being killed by Wizards and driven out by humans, greed and savagery still flowed in their veins, and they remained unrepentant.
Sagres would give these Giants who refused to accept civilization and order a chance—as long as they stayed quietly in the mountains, the two sides could live in peace.
He stroked the smooth wooden surface of the Wand, his mind churning with thoughts.
It doesn't matter if they want to join Voldemort's ranks; rather than leaving these potential threats to keep the Wizarding World in turmoil, it's better to find an opportunity now to eliminate them completely and prevent future troubles.
It's a good thing to bring all potential threats to the surface.
At least this way, both sides can stand openly on opposite sides without having to feign compliance.