Ch. 481Who Was Right? Physics Would Provide the Answer
Chapter Summary
Key plot points
- Li Dong publishes a paper titled Complete Determination of Solar Neutrino Oscillation Parameters and Analytical Expressions for Transition Probabilities Among Three Lepton Flavor States, effectively solving the laws of neutrino oscillations and contradicting the Artemis Experiment Group's earlier claim that neutrinos decay rather than oscillate.
- The paper shocks the physics community (including Rossi's team), who realize Li Dong has produced a definitive theoretical breakthrough.
- At the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, a Nobel Committee member interrupts the final Physics meeting to share the paper, causing the committee to postpone its decision by one week — an unprecedented move.
- At Jinping Mountain (Sichuan, China), the underground neutrino experiment team emerges after months of work. Clara and the team reunite with Li Dong, who has prepared vitamin D supplements and fruit for them.
- As the team travels back, they learn of the Artemis controversy for the first time (Li Dong had kept it secret to protect their morale) and then discover Li Dong's new paper, finally understanding why he had required the earlier fine-grained data analysis — it was for the correlation-function method used in the paper.
Character developments
- Li Dong: Shows care for his team (preparing supplies); his foresight and meticulous experimental design are revealed. He is also portrayed as slightly absent-minded (had missed Clara's emails) but well-meaning.
- Clara: Warms toward Li Dong after his kind gesture; her relief at being above ground highlights her human side.
- Sun Mingyuan and Liang Guodong: Initially worried after hearing the opposite conclusion from Artemis, they become reassured and impressed once they grasp Li Dong's paper and realize his hidden purpose.
- Senior Nobel Committee member: Demonstrates integrity and scientific openness by interrupting the procedure to demand the committee review a new, potentially paradigm-shifting paper.
Significant themes
- Scientific breakthrough vs. established authority (Li Dong overturning a previously accepted interpretation).
- The meticulous, hidden labor behind major discoveries (the fine-binned data collection).
- Emotional and physical cost of underground experimentation (vitamin D deficiency, depression, morale).
- Trust in one's own experimental results versus external pressure.
Character interactions
- Rossi and Fela: Rossi asks Fela to translate the paper title; Fela stammers, and the rest of the team rushes over — showing shock and disbelief.
- Nobel Committee: The elderly member stops the meeting and shares the paper; the chairman proposes a postponement, which is unanimously accepted — their collective awe and urgency.
- Li Dong and Clara: Teasing exchange about him not reading her emails; Li Dong gives her a banana, which softens her view of him.
- Li Dong and Sun Mingyuan/Liang Guodong: Handshakes, reassurance, and the final revealing moment when Sun Mingyuan realizes Li Dong's earlier experimental instructions were deliberate preparation for the theoretical paper.