Ch. 61An old soldier, a grandfather
Key plot points and events
- Garp visits Water 7, initially appearing to see his grandson, but reveals that he mainly came to speak with Li Ziming. They move to an empty tavern, where Li serves him drinks.
- Garp says Sengoku wants Li eliminated after the events at Enies Lobby. Li remains calm and argues that, although he respects Marine justice, the Marines are constrained by politics and the World Government; he prefers the freedom of being a pirate.
- The conversation turns to Garp’s family and his inability—or unwillingness—to keep Luffy, Ace, and Dragon from choosing their own paths. Garp dismisses himself as a bad grandfather, while Li insists that Garp helped shape Ace and Luffy.
- When Garp realizes Li knows Ace’s parentage, his killing intent flares. Li promises not to reveal the secret and warns that Ace is pursuing Blackbeard, who is far more dangerous than Garp assumes.
- Li predicts that Blackbeard may defeat Ace and turn him over to the Marines. Sengoku could then use Ace to draw Whitebeard into a war; Luffy would likely be drawn in as well. The resulting battle could cost Garp both grandsons, kill Whitebeard, destabilize the New World, and leave another power—implicitly Blackbeard—best positioned to benefit.
- Garp acknowledges Li’s insight but leaves wearing his Marine coat, insisting that he is both a grandfather and an old Marine soldier. Li is unsure how much Garp will act on the warning.
Character developments and interactions
- Li Ziming is composed and perceptive, using his knowledge of hidden facts and future possibilities to challenge Garp’s assumptions. He respects Marine ideals but sees the institution as compromised by politics.
- Garp shifts from testing Li’s nerve to listening uneasily as the risks to Ace, Luffy, and the balance of power become clear. His loyalty to the Marines conflicts with his concern for his family, though he does not openly change his position.
- Their exchange is marked by wary respect: Garp threatens Li, while Li calmly serves him drinks and speaks candidly about his family and the Marines. Garp’s fondness for the cocktail briefly recalls his earlier, freer days as an ordinary soldier.
Significant themes
- Duty versus family: Garp’s identities as grandfather and Marine pull him in opposing directions.
- Freedom versus institutional justice: Li values the Marines’ ideals but sees their restrictions and political compromises as reasons to remain a pirate.
- Power and political consequences: A confrontation over Ace could reshape the Marines’ strength and destabilize the New World.
- Knowledge and persuasion: Li’s warnings guide Garp toward the grim implications without stating every conclusion outright.