Ch. 541Who Would Lead When the Daos Contended?
Summary
- At a gathering hosted by Meng Gong, the Hemp-Robed Wanderer’s defense of his obscure Way of Rise and Fall draws criticism. Daoist Min Yue boasts of the long-established Way of Nature and claims the Wanderer’s Dao is incomplete and lacks a sound foundation.
- Old Man Daoquan escalates the dispute by insulting the Wanderer’s founder, True Person Soaring, and suggesting he must be dead because the Way of Rise and Fall has produced no new Divine Pillars of Fixed Law in forty years. He points to the Wanderer as a supposed successor and challenges him to prove his Dao.
- The Wanderer responds calmly but prepares to demonstrate his abilities. A Bronze Man appears around him, revealing that he has gained insight from an ancient Dao Mark connected to Chen Cuo’s Military School. Chen Cuo, watching secretly, admires the Wanderer’s resilience and talent.
- Before the confrontation can turn violent, bells announce the appearance of the Longevity Ranking List above Chang’an. Its blank surface nevertheless registers in everyone’s minds. Daoquan proposes that they settle their differences by competing for places on the list; Min Yue, the Wanderer, and the others hurry off to take part.
- Left behind, Meng Gong remarks that rise and fall are inevitable. Chen Cuo wonders whether his arrival triggered the list’s appearance, but Tingyi says its source is beyond his ability to calculate. She reveals that the list arose from the Li family’s contest among its sons.
Character developments and interactions
- The Hemp-Robed Wanderer remains composed under public insults, showing a strong Dao Heart and a willingness to defend his Dao through action. Chen Cuo recognizes his promise.
- Daoist Min Yue presents himself as a proud champion of an old, prestigious tradition and sides with Meng Gong against the Wanderer.
- Old Man Daoquan deliberately provokes the dispute and uses the Wanderer’s uncertain lineage to challenge both him and True Person Soaring.
- Chen Cuo and Tingyi observe from the sidelines. Chen Cuo identifies the source of the Wanderer’s Bronze Man manifestation, while Tingyi explains the broader sectarian and historical context and cautions him against trying to unravel the list’s origins.
- Meng Gong tries to mediate but cannot keep the gathering together once the ranking list appears.
Significant themes
- Old traditions versus emerging paths: The argument over the Way of Nature and the Way of Rise and Fall reflects a wider contest over legitimacy, history, and influence.
- Proof through action: The Wanderer faces demands to validate his Dao, and the ranking list offers a public arena where status may be tested.
- Rise, fall, and uncertainty: The gathering breaks apart just as the list appears, echoing Meng Gong’s remark that change is inevitable. The list’s mysterious source also underscores how little even powerful figures can know about forces shaping events.