Ch. 41One Against Five
At the Sutra Academy’s Dharma Assembly, Gyatso drew a one-against-five Debate against leading competitors, prompting suspicions that the strongest contender was being targeted for the prize. He calmly proposed “A White Horse Is Not a Horse” and began dismantling his opponents’ arguments, while Namkha’s principled objection to the unfair matchup led him to join the debate anyway.
- The School Monitor opened the Courtyard Competition Dharma Assembly, where Scholar Monks debated in matchups determined by lots.
- Gyatso drew a one-against-five Debate against Gama, Dunzhu, Tsering, Namkha, and Jiumo, and Rinchen explained that the competition’s rewards included completion empowerment and a path to becoming a Geshe.
- Namkha objected to the unfair matchup, but the Iron Staff Lama threatened him with forfeiture, so Namkha took his seat after Gyatso invited him to stay.
- Gyatso proposed the thesis “A White Horse Is Not a Horse,” and Gadeng and Dunzhu challenged it.
- Gyatso used Dunzhu’s agreement that having a yellow horse meant having a horse to expose the inconsistency in his reasoning about a white horse.