Ch. 241You and I Are Both Guilty
Dumbledore confronted Fudge with proof that Peter Pettigrew was alive and Sirius Black had been wrongly accused. Salazar brought Sirius to the scene, then agreed to help Lupin remain human in exchange for Dumbledore keeping his identity secret.
- Fudge refused to believe that the man before him was Peter Pettigrew, fearing the damage the truth would do to the Ministry and Sirius Black’s conviction.
- Snape learned that Pettigrew had betrayed Lily and, after Dumbledore reminded him of his promise, left without harming Pettigrew.
- Dumbledore challenged Fudge with the witnesses present, weakening his resistance to admitting the truth.
- Salazar arrived with Sirius Black, and Harry identified Sirius as his godfather while Dumbledore recognized that the Ministry had confused the two men’s identities.
- Salazar told Dumbledore that he had cast the Patronus but wanted his identity kept secret while he searched for Voldemort.
- Dumbledore agreed to explain the Patronus as ancient Hogwarts magic, and Salazar agreed to help Lupin stay human permanently.