It's indeed difficult to say whether Sarutobi Hiruzen was right or wrong, because different perspectives lead to different viewpoints.
However, since Shisui has asked, Habara is willing to discuss it with him and also plans to give Shisui some 'advanced' knowledge.
"Shisui looking at a problem, the first thing to consider is your own position."
This world is complex, and good and evil, right and wrong are never so absolute, because everyone has their own perspective.
Always remember that the world is never as black and white as you imagine, because it may very well be a delicate gray.
Therefore, we must consider problems more comprehensively.
Habara smiled as he looked at Shisui, and then slowly asked as he walked.
"From Sarutobi Hiruzen's perspective, he was indeed right, because Konoha did not have a chance to recover after the Second Great Ninja War."
Soon, they were forced to start the Third Great Ninja War, and this Great Ninja War was even more brutal, with Konoha being besieged by the four great ninja villages.
Although Konoha, it was only a Pyrrhic victory, as Konoha's foundation was almost completely destroyed.
Even though Konoha didn't get anything from the Tsuchikage in the final negotiations, there's one thing we can't ignore here.
That means our Hokage probably hoped the Tsuchikage would keep these supplies and fight to the death with the Cloud Hidden Village, but ultimately things didn't go as planned.
On the surface, the Third Great Ninja War appeared to be an attack on Konoha by the four great ninja villages, but in reality, they were not of one mind at all.
The most typical examples are Pakura and the Third Raikage.
Pakura was sent to Kirigakure by Rasa, the newly appointed Kazekage, to stabilize the situation and to allow him to focus his energy on dealing with Iwagakure.
Although Habara was really curious as to why Sunagakure and Kirigakure, two ninja villages that were thousands of miles apart, could fight each other, since they really didn't have any conflict of interest.
But after thinking it over, he wondered if the people of Kirigakure thought that the Sunagakure Village's insects had launched their attack too quickly when facing Konoha.
This would give Konoha the energy and strength to turn around and deal with them in the Land of Whirlpools, ultimately leading to their defeat and prompting them to take retaliatory actions.
The Third Raikage died an even more ignominious death. This Raikage, who was exhausted to death after Ten Thousand Man Assault for three days and three nights, was actually on the front lines of the battle between Iwagakure and Konoha. He was preparing for a possible future battle with Iwagakure, so he went to gather intelligence.
The relationship between Cloud Hidden Village and Iwagakure was already strained, with deep-seated conflicts between them.
Now that the Third Raikage has died at the hands of Iwagakure, how could they possibly stand it?
It must be said that it was the death of the Third Raikage that led the current Fourth Raikage to choose to temporarily cease hostilities with Konoha and return to the village to prepare for the war against Iwagakure.
Meanwhile, Iwagakure noticed Cloud Hidden Village's actions, and the frontline morale was severely damaged by Namikaze's one-against-fifty-enemies strategy.
They immediately chose to cease hostilities with Konoha and went all out to prepare to deal with Cloud Hidden Village.
To put it bluntly, it was precisely because Iwagakure took down the Third Raikage that the Third Great Ninja War, which seemed destined to last forever, came to an end.
Sarutobi Hiruzen's desire to renounce compensation stemmed from his hope that the two sides would clash, allowing him to regroup.
But contrary to expectations, in the end, both sides only went through the motions and had no intention of going to war with each other.
He also suffered heavy losses because of this series of actions, and in the end he had to resign, which led to the rise of Namikaze Minato as the Fourth Hokage.
If you think about it carefully, people have long been disgusted by the constant wars. It wasn't just Konoha that suffered huge losses; other ninja villages also suffered incalculable losses.
The only Kumogakure, because their biggest loss was probably the death of one of their Kage.
Under such circumstances, the Third Tsuchikage, Ōnoki, naturally did not want the war to continue.
The Fourth Raikage A, had just taken office and was not yet firmly established. Even if he was eager for revenge, his subordinates would not allow him to act recklessly.
But in any case, this incident fully demonstrated their mutual distrust, and it was this war of distrust that brought it to an end.
"At that time, Konoha was already at its wit's end and had no choice but to take measures to recuperate and recover."
Habara looked at the setting sun in the sky, and couldn't help but smile as he pointed to it, then continued speaking.
"Back then, Konoha was probably seen by many as the setting sun. Even though it won the Third Great Ninja War, it paid too high a price. Our Third Hokage probably thought the same way."
Therefore, after Kumogakure expressed its desire for a complete peace treaty a few years ago, he became somewhat arrogant and forgot the precautions he should have as a Kage, resulting in tragedy.
Shisui was a participant in this history, as he was already working in the Dark Division during that period. However, he still couldn't help but feel a little emotional when the story was brought up again.
They were far too complacent and too lenient with those invading Hidden Cloud Ninja. With Sarutobi Hiruzen's tacit approval, those guys could roam freely in Konoha.
The result was that they could openly gather information about Konoha, which led to the Hyuga Clan's intelligence being thoroughly investigated, ultimately resulting in this tragedy.
"As I just said, Sarutobi Hiruzen believes that Konoha was at its lowest point and needed time to recuperate and restore its strength."
As Shisui was reflecting on his feelings, Habara spoke up again, this time with a much more serious tone.
From his perspective, what he needs to do is prevent the situation from escalating and prevent war from breaking out again.
Perhaps he has assessed the situation from all angles, leading him to conclude that Konoha would inevitably lose if the war broke out.
Therefore, he made a resolute choice: to exchange the lives of one person or even an entire family for peace, since between two evils, one should choose the lesser.
"Shisui, if you look at it this way, do you think Sarutobi Hiruzen was wrong?"
Was I wrong?
Shisui hearing Habara's question and recalling Habara's words, Shisui really wanted to answer: That's right!
From the perspective of Hokage, there really weren't many options at the time. Isn't sacrificing one person's life to achieve peace a good thing?
Shisui simply dared not answer, because he hadn't forgotten that Habara's evaluation and opinion on this matter was contradictory.
This means that Habara had other answers, other answers that conflicted with the current one that seemed extremely correct.
Taking a deep breath, Shisui shook his head. "I don't know, Habara."
If it were someone else, I would probably answer yes without hesitation.
But facing you, I dare not give any answer at all, because I know my answer might be completely irrelevant and unrealistic.
"Be more confident, Shisui."
Seeing Shisui like this, Habara couldn't help but find it a little funny. He reached out and patted Shisui's shoulder before continuing to speak.
"I have said that the answer to this question will be different depending on your perspective."
However, our current position requires us to look at problems from a more comprehensive and holistic perspective, rather than from a single angle.
Now that we've discussed Sarutobi Hiruzen's stance, let's talk about the situation in the Shinobi World.
These past few years have been tough for Konoha. Mission loads have plummeted, and the economy is struggling. Have you considered the reasons behind this?
"This..." Shisui scratched his head in response to Habara's question, he really wasn't good at this kind of thing. "Is it because of the Daimyo?"
"The Daimyo is one reason, but a bigger reason is the overall image of Konoha."
Habara smiled and shook his head, then he proposed a concept that Shisui was both unfamiliar and familiar to him.
"Just as a clan has its own image, a ninja village naturally has its own image as well."
The main reason the Uchiha suffered so much was the negative impression we left on the villagers, which affected their perception of us.
The same applies to the Ninja Village. We won the Third Great Ninja War, even though it was a Pyrrhic victory, but we fought against four opponents with one strength. Such prestige is an intangible asset.
However, with the invasion of Cloud Hidden Village, we chose to settle the matter peacefully, in addition to the unexpected death of the Fourth Hokage eight years ago.
This immediately created the impression throughout the Shinobi World that Konoha was all bark and no bite, leading to a sharp drop in Konoha's credibility.
Naturally, those who commissioned the missions dared not entrust them to Konoha, and these missions naturally ended up in the hands of more powerful and credible ninja villages.
"Having been in the Anbu for so many years, you must have noticed that Cloud Hidden Village is developing quite well, right?"
Shisui nodded seriously. As an Anbu, he had access to a lot of intelligence, so he naturally knew how the Cloud Hidden Village had developed over the years.
He never imagined that the development of Cloud Hidden Village was achieved by stepping on Konoha, and by Sarutobi Hiruzen's concessions!
This made his initial belief that Sarutobi Hiruzen's choice was correct begin to waver.
"Because of this choice, we left a very bad impression on the Shinobi World, and the situation in Konoha is also not good because of this choice."
The fact that the Fourth Hokage had fallen and Sarutobi Hiruzen returned to power already made many members of the major clans unhappy.
However, for the sake of Konoha's stability, and considering that there was no suitable candidate for Hokage at the time, this matter was left unresolved.
However, with the outbreak of this incident, the dissatisfaction of all the major families with Sarutobi Hiruzen reached a new peak.
Shisui, did you know that the village was originally established to protect everyone, especially the children?
During the Third Great Ninja War, Sarutobi Hiruzen to send the children to the battlefield went against the original purpose of the village's founding.
Moreover, the village was established through the alliance of various ninja clans, along with the defection of Civilian Ninja, which led to the creation of Konoha.
Sarutobi Hiruzen's actions are now damaging the village's most fundamental interests, so all the ninja clans are naturally dissatisfied with his behavior.
They all worried, "Since Sarutobi Hiruzen was able to push the Hyūga out this time, who will be next? Will it be their turn?"
At this point, Habara paused slightly, his gaze fixed on Shisui, who looked somewhat uneasy, before finally turning to look at the Hokage Rock.
"Moreover, Sarutobi Hiruzen's unilateral actions this time seem to be for the sake of Konoha, and it seems that everything he has done is for the sake of peace in the Shinobi World."
But in reality, he overlooked something very important: he ignored the will of the people, or in other words, he ignored public opinion.
Are all ordinary ninjas really willing to endure such humiliation, even to the point that they can't get the full amount of missions because of this?
Do the clan ninjas really want him to disregard everyone's wishes and arbitrarily give away his own people as bargaining chips?
Peace is never achieved through compromise; hasn't the Uchiha incident already taught us that?
At this point, Habara paused, looked at Shisui seriously, and then asked, word by word.
"So whether Sarutobi Hiruzen's actions were right or wrong depends entirely on his stance."
This is true for those who do not want war, and for himself as well.
But from the perspective of Konoha as a whole, he was terribly wrong!