The library usually requires readers to keep quiet, but today there was no one in the library. Even Madam Pince was not there because she was on vacation, so the only people in the entire library were Pomona and Albus.
"I rarely see you in the library, Albus," Pomona said with a smile. "I thought you preferred to stay in the Headmaster's Office."
"I've always secretly imagined that heaven would look like a library," Albus, looking at the library. "This is a poem written by an Argentina poet. Do you think he's right?"
"In most cases, I think he is right. Today the Fat Friar gave me a French lesson, and he mentioned Saint Augustine."
Then Pomona told Albus to her in her mind.
"We cannot deny that there is also knowledge in the library that teaches people to do evil." After listening, Albus looked at the Restricted Section. "The Dark Lord often lingers there."
"He is merely a symbol of evil." Pomona lowered his head, not daring to look in that direction. "We cannot assume that by eliminating him, the world will be cleansed of evil."
"Keep this mindset in mind, Professor; it will be beneficial for us in preparing for future wars," Albus said.
She didn't really like his way of putting it.
"There is more than one Oracle in our school," Albus said. "The Centaur say that we humans are currently in a brief period of peace between two wars, so we cannot let our guard down."
Pomona realized what was happening.
"So that's why you sent Harry to the Muggle world?"
"Have you ever heard Muggle fairy tales, Professor?" Albus asked.
"There are many Muggle fairy tales, which one are you talking about?" Pomona asked.
"The Ugly Duckling," Albus said.
"Of course I've heard of it," Pomona said.
"Don't you think Harry is like Cygnus among ducks?" Albus said. "He's an oddity in the eyes of the ducks."
"But he doesn't have gray feathers, so if he knows how to hide himself, he can blend in with the other ducks," Pomona said.
"We all know that Cygnus are beautiful. If the Ugly Duckling knew that he would become Cygnus, all he had to do was wait with hope, wait for the day of his transformation, and then return to the farm where he was born, to let the animals that had pecked at him see his beauty?" Albus smile. "What is beautiful in the eyes of humans is strange in the eyes of other animals. The Cygnus's long neck is not beautiful at all, and he would still be ridiculed."
"Then we're not going back?" Pomona asked.
"The key point is that the Ugly Duckling doesn't know he's Cygnus, he doesn't know his Beethoven's Fifth Symphony, so he can only stumble forward," Albus said. "He doesn't think that given time, he will definitely become Cygnus that is praised and sung."
Pomona remembered the Mirror of Erised.
"Struggling in despair can forge a tenacious spirit, but hope will vanish like a bubble, just like what Severus promised to do for you, did he do it?" Albus asked.
Pomona shook his head with a smile.
"If you don't have any expectations, you won't be as sad when you're disappointed," Pomona said calmly.
"I hope you don't misunderstand, that it was because of me that he missed your appointment, but it seems you don't need him anymore," Albus said.
She did not answer the question immediately.
"'Hope' makes people easily addicted, wasting time sitting in front of the Mirror of Erised, while despair makes people flap their wings and escape their predicament. Is that what you mean, Albus?" Pomona asked.
"Pandora opened the Pandora's Box and unleashed countless calamities, leaving only hope. Ben Cooper used the Time-Turner to travel back in time and tracked down the woman who gave the music box to his father. He didn't try to change any history," Albus said. "Sometimes we hand over Dark Magic items to the Ministry of Magic, but I don't think that music box is one. I plan to leave it at the school."
"This is your decision, Principal," Pomona said.
"That box didn't contain hope, Professor. Instead, it was the source of Ben Cooper's torment. He was originally a duck, but suddenly became the Ugly Duckling. When he insisted on his views, he attracted attacks from the other ducks. When I handed Harry over to his Muggle relatives, I wrote a letter telling them everything. But they didn't tell Harry the truth about his parents' death. Instead, they pretended it was a normal traffic accident, so he wouldn't know his origins. Minerva was furious, feeling that she had turned a hero into an ordinary person..."
"That's not what Minerva told me," Pomona said.
"The lives of ordinary people seem dull and lackluster, not only because they are unrelated to all exciting lives, but also because being content with ordinariness and not pursuing success is seen as strange. People take success and failure extremely seriously, and in fact, even 'winners' live very hard lives."
"But you told me that we won the first game, and there's another game to win," Pomona said.
"Because this isn't about winning or losing," Albus said.
"What is that?" Pomona asked.
"For the greater good," said Albus Dumbledore. "You've read Saint Augustine; what is his view on free will?"
"If a person is good, he cannot act uprightly if he does not want to. Therefore, a person should have free will. Just because a person commits a sin with free will does not mean that God gave a person free will so that he would sin," Pomona said.
"What do you think?" Albus asked.
"If God is unjust, and uses me as a wager with the devil like Job did, why should I believe in him?" Pomona said. "Don't talk to me about despair and hope, Albus. Not everyone is like an obedient dog, which remains loyal to its master even when the master is unhappy and beats it for no reason."
Albus sighed deeply. "Do you think that giving fairly leads to a better life?"
"Isidora took pain out of people's bodies. I don't think she was right to do that, but I also don't agree that it is right to cause pain to prove something, let alone that she compensated Job for everything he lost with new children and wealth."
"You want revenge?" Albus asked.
"No."
"Is it that you can't, or that you don't want to?" Albus asked.
In the story of Swan Lake, the prince chose the white Cygnus, who represents purity, but he did not know that the white Cygnus had already been defiled, and that she spoke foul language. She had even miscarried once.
"I forgot," Pomona said softly. "And I will never choose a prince in my life."
"Can I ask why?" Albus asked.
"He's a golden-crowned the Idiot."
"I don't know where you came from. I just hope you can remain fair. Sometimes people use dishonest means to achieve their righteous goals, and that's where free will comes in."
Pomona couldn't help but marvel at how Albus Dumbledore and Grindelwald could become such close friends.
The Fat Friar said that Grindelwald abused justice to achieve his own ends, so what were Albus Dumbledore's ends?
"It's like taking a wrong turn temporarily for the right goal, and then, like the Return of the Prodigal Son, you go back," Pomona said with a smile.
"Sometimes, we have to put on a show for others." Albus shook his head. "A child's voice may be incredibly sincere, but it's worthless to those who are unwilling to listen."
Some criticize losers like the ancients criticized illegitimate children. Valmont left no heirs, even though he had impregnated his young bride. However, he cared nothing for the child or the bride's life; even after the surgery, his primary concern was profit.
Madame de Merteuil, being a woman after all, was driven mad by Valmont and told him directly that his love for Mrs. Dewey was so profound that he could not be unfaithful to her. However, he was never a good friend or companion to women, but always a tyrant or servant to them.
"Yes, Headmaster," Pomona said meekly.
Albus looked at her for a long time before continuing to pace and telling the story of the Dale family.
Marmaduke Dale was Granam Dale's younger brother. He grew up to be a Herbology, discovering different properties in Herbology and plants, and his work influenced Herbology and Potions. Granam Dale, on the other hand, was mediocre in all aspects. When their mother died, Marmaduke Dale inherited the family, but according to the custom at the time, the eldest son should inherit everything.
After Marmaduke Dale's death, Granam Dale cursed his brother's sarcophagus, and all descendants who entered the Dale family would be cursed, starting from the toes, and the cursed person would gradually turn into a plant.
"Similar to Blood Beastfolk?" Pomona asked.
"There's a difference, because Blood Beastfolk can switch between human and beast, and this transformation is irreversible," Albus said.
Pomona did not ask Albus how he knew such family secrets.
"How did Marmaduke Dale die?" Pomona asked.
"Are you asking about something like Cain's jealousy of Abel, which led him to kill his own brother?" Albus asked.
She didn't know what to say.
"Nobody knows," Albus said. "It happened centuries ago."
Pomona recalled the pictures of Albus Dumbledore and Grindelwald in the history book; they were beautiful, not at all like the Ugly Duckling, but born Cygnus.
How could they possibly know the despair the Ugly Duckling experienced?
But she continued to accompany Dumbledore on walks in the library; after all, it was much more spacious Nurmengard.