As night deepened, the bright moonlight and the constant crashing of waves against the cliffs accompanied Hogwarts Castle for millennia. The first week of school was drawing to a close, and the energetic young wizards had passed their initial excitement. Tonight, apart from the clanging of armor in the castle, the occasional whispering of portraits that had stayed up all night, and Peeves's usual patrol of the territory, all was quiet and peaceful.
"You know who that person is, right?"
In front of the two ugly stone monsters on the Seventh Floor, Professor Snape questioned Dumbledore expressionlessly.
"What has caused this misunderstanding, Severus?"
Dumbledore twitched his aged face in surprise, his waist-length beard gleaming silver in the moonlight streaming through the window, and his eyes looked quite innocent.
Snape moved his thin, cold lips, but didn't ask another question. Instead, he turned and left.
In the past, he might have had a serious argument with Dumbledore, but today his emotions were in turmoil. After confirming that the dark wizard was not Sirius Black, he no longer wanted to deal with the matter, even though the dark wizard had caused Dumbledore and the Ministry of Magic considerable trouble.
Dumbledore stood still, watching Snape fly away until his figure disappeared around the corner of the corridor, then lowered his silver eyebrows and turned to walk into his office.
Fawkes, who rarely gets to move around, has fallen asleep on the golden branch in the brazier. Dumbledore in his office chair, his long fingers interlaced on his desk, silently gazing at the portraits of the past Hogwarts headmasters hanging on the wall.
According to the usual routine of these portraits, they should also be asleep at this time, but tonight, none of the portraits are asleep. They stay quietly in their frames, their eyes all fixed on the empty frame behind Armando Dippet.
The waiting process was incredibly long. The previous headmasters couldn't bear the loneliness and went from room to room, talking quietly. Only Dumbledore, the only living person in this office, maintained admirable patience.
"It's been confirmed, Dumbledore!"
Finally, the original owner of the empty picture frame returned. Before anyone could ask, it spoke in a joyful voice,
"No, during this time, apart from an old House-elves, there has been nothing alive in the Black family manor. My clever great-grandson has not been back."
"Clever?!"
The portrait of Armando Dippet speaks in a very harsh voice, "Headmaster Black, I suppose you know that your 'clever great-great-grandson' is a filthy, stinking traitor, don't you?"
Armando Dippet's blatant mockery stirred up a hornet's nest, Phineas immediately started shouting!
It barked its goatee into the portrait of Dippet and started arguing with him, shouting things like "The noble Black family," "Wizengamot must have made a mistake," "The child is innocent," and "You're targeting him." If Ms. Dilys de Winter hadn't pulled them back in time, a spectacular headmaster's duel might have taken place in the office.
Tap, tap—
"Please keep quiet, everyone. I cannot let this historic office be ruined in my hands."
Dumbledore tapped the table with his fingers and said calmly.
The orders of the then-headmaster of Hogwarts had a strong binding force on these portraits. Under Dumbledore's intervention, the portraits returned to their respective frames. The portraits of Armando Dippet and Phineas Black were placed side by side, but they were looking in different directions and ignoring each other.
Even after her death, the highly respected Lady Deliss continued to ask that crucial question on behalf of all the principals.
"You surely know why that kid wanted to break into the Black family manor, Albus?"
"Oh, that's a problem--"
Dumbledore removed the half-moon frame from his nose, gently rubbing his temples while smiling helplessly. "I have some guesses, and I think mine are very close to the truth."
"What is it?" Lady Deliss pressed.
"That's not important, Dilys— " Dumbledore leaned back in his chair, exhausted, "The important thing is that he did it."
The topic of Amosta Breen had clearly been discussed more than once in this office. The portrait artists knew Albus Dumbledore valued the young man, and seeing Amosta once again take such an almost 'crazy' action, their hearts couldn't help but feel a shadow of unease.
"Speaking of which—"
The kind-hearted Lady Deliss hesitated for a moment. "Could there be a mistake, Albus? According to you, that dark wizard hid his magic very well. Perhaps, I mean, you have to admit that everyone makes mistakes sometimes, right?"
"I don't need looks or magic to recognize someone, Dilys-- "
Dumbledore blue eyes gleamed as he spoke gently.
The office fell silent again. According to the majority of the headmasters, they believed that Dumbledore should send Amosta to Azkaban, but in reality, they all knew that even with Dementor guarding the area, Azkaban probably couldn't control a wizard of that caliber.
"Evil is evil, Albus."
Armando Dippet said firmly, "We should nip evil in the bud while we still have the ability to do so. Albus, if Azkaban can't control that disobedient brat, then you should just kill him!"
"I think I've figured it out!"
Headmaster Dippet's suggestion immediately enraged Phineas, who then spat at Dippet.
"You're just jealous, aren't you? Jealous that the great Slytherin House has produced another outstanding genius, and you want to destroy it!"
Headmaster Black's defense was too broad, and many other headmasters stepped forward to criticize Slytherin, with Armando Dippet being particularly succinct.
"The great Slytherin House? Hmph, I bet you haven't forgotten how much panic that Chamber of Secrets of Secrets left by Slytherin caused at Hogwarts last year!"
"That Chamber of Secrets isn't that simple!" Phineas retorted sharply.
"Albus has already told us that the Chamber of Secrets is a hidden world. To be honest, I am incredibly grateful to Amosta Breen. He has cleared the wizarding world of a thousand-year-old slander against Salazar Slytherin. Slytherin left the Chamber of Secrets and the Basilisk for a specific purpose, not to slaughter the young wizards in the school!"
Phineas's statement was the conclusion reached after joint discussion and did not represent his personal opinion alone, so Armando Dippet did not refute it but remained silent.
As if he had won a holy war, Phineas puffed out his chest, his eyes gleaming as he looked at Albus Dumbledore, and said proudly,
"Would you like to hear my opinion, Albus, about Amosta Breen?"
"I look forward to hearing your insightful opinions, Phineas," Dumbledore said sincerely with a smile. "I'm sure your wisdom will guide us."
Phineas, flattered by Dumbledore, was filled with pride. For a moment, he seemed to be transported back to his days as the current headmaster of Hogwarts, wielding immense power. He glanced haughtily at Armando Dippet, who was also giving him a cold look, and cleared his throat.
"First, there's a question that needs your honest answer, Albus— "
After receiving a nod of approval from Dumbledore, Phineas Black's small eyes gleamed with shrewdness.
"Now that you're here, Albus, are you still capable of dealing with Amosta Breen?"