"Oh, by the way, Weasley, Cardil asked me to tell you that the toilet issue has been resolved, so you don't need to pay any attention to the note he sent!"
Goldstein said this to Percy, and then left in high spirits, completely unlike his earlier aggressive demeanor.
Click—
The office door closed, Amosta pushed the dazed Percy back onto the coffee table. Percy's bottom had barely touched the sofa when he jumped up again, glaring at Amosta with a mixture of surprise and anger in his eyes.
"You intend to plead for Ali Bashir, Mr. Breen? Do you know him?"
"This is the first time I've heard this name, Percy— " Amosta shook her head slightly.
"Then why did you promise Goldstein that you would defend Mr. Crouch when you met him, you know, Ali Bashir—"
Amosta raised his hand to interrupt Percy's long-winded speech and calmly said,
"I'm not solving this Bashir problem, I'm doing it for you, Percy— "
After letting the bewildered Percy sit down, Amosta slowly began to speak.
"When I see Barty, I don't plan to mention this to him. As for the Flying Carpet, I suggest you send Barty a letter. If Barty replies, then proceed according to his reply. If Barty doesn't reply, then follow procedure and send a formal letter to the Minister's Office to request instructions."
Percy blinked, finally realizing that things might not be so simple, but he didn't understand the logic behind Professor Breen's proposed solution.
Seeing his bewildered expression, Amosta paused for a moment, then patiently continued,
"This Ali Bashir is probably backed by Cornelius— "
"What?"
Percy was startled; a moment of clarity flashed through his weary mind, and then he suddenly remembered what Goldstein had said last, and he blurted out...
"But... uh, Madam Umbridge— "
"Goldstein said that the Oswald family is responsible for selling Flying Carpet in the Britain. I suppose you don't know that this family is related to Mrs. Fudge?"
Amosta was hearing about this for the first time, acted as if he knew the whole story very well, and he spoke eloquently.
"Umbridge was just covering for Fudge. When was Bashir arrested, and when did Percy and Barty start taking leave?"
"Bashir was arrested in the middle of last month, while Mr. Crouch took leave four days ago—"
Percy said blankly.
"And when did this Goldstein come to see you?" Amosta continued to ask.
"Yesterday—yesterday—" Percy's answer was halting, as if he had realized something.
"Since Bashir has been captured for almost a month, and Barty has been at the Ministry of Magic for most of that Percy, have you considered why Goldstein didn't negotiate with Barty when he was on duty, but instead chose to do so when you were covering for him?"
Amosta patiently guided him.
"He wanted to use me—" Percy said blankly, his cheeks gradually turning pale, "But I didn't let him succeed."
"The logic of the whole thing is roughly like this—"
Amosta placed his fingers interlaced on his knees.
"The Flying Carpet has a long history of sales in Britain, and this business has probably always been run by the Oswald family, that is, the family of Minister Fudge's wife. However, the ban on the sale of Flying Carpet was passed precisely when Cornelius Fudge was Minister for Magic. Who do you think was behind that?"
As a former top student at Hogwarts, Percy's mouth opened, seemingly understanding something.
"Do you understand? The whole thing was a political confrontation between Cornelius Fudge and Barty Crouch. I don't know how Barty did it, but it must have involved a quid pro quo. He won the confrontation and successfully pushed the Flying Carpet ban bill through the review process."
Amosta said calmly.
"But clearly, Cornelius was not convinced, so the order was probably given by Ali Bashir, who was probably Oswald family's front man. You could call it a provocation, or a way to clear out inventory and recover principal before the bill took effect, but Barty did not tolerate this provocation, so Bashir was arrested."
This Goldstein is probably one of Cornelius's men; his actions are orchestrated. It just so happens that you've been handling Barty's day-to-day affairs lately, so he's come to you to try his luck. That's why he's never mentioned Umbridge and Oswald to you. If he succeeds, Goldstein will undoubtedly gain favor with Cornelius, he'll get a promotion, and you'll be the one to take the blame, because you'll be the one ultimately signing the release order for Barty."
As Percy listened to Professor Breen's reasoning, his heart pounded, and he almost began to question the meaning of life.
"I didn't sabotage Mr. Crouch's plans, I didn't sign—"
Percy said blankly.
"Have you considered that your insistence on not signing might seriously offend the Minister for Magic, thus ruining your career?"
Amosta's chuckled words terrified Percy, turning him deathly pale. His lips moved as if he wanted to ask Professor Breen for help, but remembering his previous ulterior motives, he couldn't utter a single word.
"Just now at the door, Goldstein suggested meeting Barty in person. This means two things: first, he probably realizes you're not someone he can rely on; second, he still wants to get this done for the minister to demonstrate his abilities. So, his idea to meet Barty was probably his own; perhaps he'll offer something to try and sway Barty."
"In that case, Professor—"
Percy didn't realize that his attitude had completely changed. He was now somewhat like he had been before graduation, when he and Penelope were at the Three Broomsticks Inn asking Professor Breen to write him a letter for help.
Why are you still doing this for him?
"You're neither letting Goldstein go to Barty nor signing it yourself. Does this mean you're going to take all of Cornelius's wrath for Barty? Are you willing to use the Weasley family's influence to do this, Percy?"
Amosta calmly watched Percy stammer.
"Have you considered that when Goldstein reports to Fudge, he might shift all the blame for the mission's failure onto you?"
"That despicable scoundrel!" Percy roared in fury. "I'm going to duel him!"
Percy swore and cursed Goldstein viciously, and seeing him like this, Amosta couldn't help but sigh. Arthur had spent most of his life in the Ministry of Magic, with connections in every department; hadn't he ever given his son any pointers?
"You can't make this decision on your own, understand, Percy— "
After all, he was his student, and Amosta didn't want to see him being used. With a heart full of guidance, Amosta spoke earnestly...
"I asked you to write a letter to Barty for instructions. Firstly, whether Barty agrees or refuses, the responsibility for this matter will not fall on you. If it works out, Fudge will thank you for writing the letter for him. If it doesn't work out, then he has no reason to blame you."
Secondly, writing the letter was also to guard against Barty. For example, Barty might tell you not to release Bashir, but when he negotiates with Cornelius later, he might give a different story. He might say you relayed the wrong message, and by then, Bashir would have already been in Azkaban for some time. Releasing him then would save face for the minister and prevent you from appearing weak. The only problem is that you would probably have to bear some responsibility.
"Mr. Crouch wouldn't do that, Professor!"
Percy practically spat out the words, but judging from his expression, he didn't seem to believe it himself.
"Politics is so dirty, Percy. Since you're in it, you shouldn't have any illusions about others," Amosta said solemnly.
"Of course, if Barty doesn't reply to you, then you have every right to ask the Minister for Magic how to deal with Bashir through the normal procedure. Even if Barty comes back, he won't find anything wrong with you. You've already informed him, so it doesn't count as reporting beyond your level. Do you understand, Percy?"