This naturally leads to another question—why couldn't Hagoromo Otsutsuki achieve immortality?
This point is not officially explained in the Original Work.
If I absolutely have to guess...
There are two explanations that are relatively more likely. One is that the Ten-Tails itself has a problem. As it was once part of Kaguya's power, Hagoromo was unable to fully integrate the Ten-Tails' power and instead suffered a backlash.
That's why, in his later years, when his power was waning, he took the initiative to separate the Ten-Tails.
This is the first guess.
The second guess is that Hagoromo's bloodline concentration is not high enough, and the Ten-Tails is just a power carrier. What can truly allow her life level to evolve is the fruit that the God Tree, which is the Ten-Tails incarnate, produces by absorbing the planet's Source Power.
Unless Hagoromo transforms the Ten-Tails back into God Tree, allowing it to absorb energy once more and bear fruit for him to consume, he will never become a true 'Otsutsuki' in his lifetime!
Besides these, there are of course many other possibilities.
It's just even less reliable.
However, for Menma, one thing he was certain of was that a mere Ten-Tails could absolutely not provide the energy to grant humanity eternal life. It couldn't even supply one person, let alone the entire world, hundreds of millions of humans!
Even the Sage of Six Paths couldn't do it.
You, Madara Uchiha, can do that?!
This question, almost like Menma knife to the heart, is truly piercing.
This silenced Madara Uchiha once again.
I chose to believe the words of my ancestor, the Sage of Six Paths, and embarked on this path. But now it seems that even my ancestor couldn't do this, or he was clearly deliberately concealing some important information. So what makes me think I can do this?
"I..."
Madara Uchiha's face showed an uncertain expression. He wanted to say something more, but the words caught in his throat, and he couldn't utter a sound for a long time.
"Yes, Madara, Menma- kun said makes a lot of sense. In this whole world, with so many people, even if the peace you speak of in your dreams is real, these people still need to eat, drink, and relieve themselves to survive, right? How could it be so easy to do? Let alone immortality. And if we can't even do that, the human species will be extinct in just a few decades. Is this the kind of peace you really want, Madara!"
Hashirama nearby, also joined the ranks of those trying to persuade them.
Madara's Moon Eye Plan.
In Hashirama's view, it was truly the ultimate, invincible terror. Just as Menma said, what's the point of such peace?
It's just a different way of destroying the world.
No matter how dull a knife is, it's still a knife, and it will eventually kill. Compared to Madara's madness, Hashirama now finds Menma. So what if the Shinobi World is unified? So what if Konoha disappears? Those are minor issues. As long as people are alive and can live freely, that's perfectly fine.
It is indeed a pity that some people die.
But in past wars, even more people died.
Once the Shinobi World is unified, everything can still potentially develop in a positive direction; at least, the probability of that cannot be denied.
Now that Madara is the ultimate negative example, Menma is on the Ippo of justice!
Hashirama is now very glad that he did not obtain his peak strength in life, and Menma is far superior to him.
Otherwise.
That previous battle.
Let alone defeating Menma, what if they both suffer heavy losses?
This world is definitely heading towards the apocalyptic future that Madara is going to create. Even if Hashirama naive and clueless, he can still accurately judge what his best friend's intentions are in staying near the Valley of the End!
It's as obvious as a lice on a bald man's head!
"The path you have chosen is wrong, Madara Uchiha."
Tobirama, standing to the side, calmly continued to deliver the final blow.
To be honest, Tobirama did agree with Menma's approach. To be more precise, when Konoha was first established, and their village had their own Elder Brother and Madara Uchiha, both of whom were top-tier figures capable of sweeping the entire Shinobi World, Madara Uchiha proposed a plan to destroy the major ninja villages. Tobirama didn't say anything, but he also wanted to carry it out!
Tobirama was, in the end, a pure 'egoist'!
However, the "self" he refers to is not just himself, but also the collective he values! It started with the Senju Clan, and later it became the entire Konohagakure.
As long as it is truly for the greater good of Konoha, for the benefit of Konoha, and for the sake of all the people who identify with and depend on Konohagakure, Tobirama is fearless and unwavering, even if it means cooperating with demons.
This is why it's said that Tobirama and Izuna are both...
They were the natural leaders, unlike their older brothers.
They wouldn't consider anything that didn't meet standards, defied common sense, or was impractical. Tobirama scoffed Tobirama Madara's Moon Eye Plan, deeming it something only someone with a brain full of water would believe.
Oh.
You should say he's a brainless person!
Uzumaki Menma Madara Uchiha has already explained things so clearly, and analyzed the pros and cons so thoroughly, yet he is still so stubborn.
Tobirama almost burst out laughing.
At this moment, Madara Uchiha was completely unaware that he had once again lowered the bar for Tobirama's intelligence.
This guy is a complete blockhead.
"Lord Madara, you have not only failed now, but you have been a loser for decades. I am not referring to your actions, but to this: in your heart, you have already disappointed and surrendered to yourself."
Menma looked calmly at Madara Uchiha, pointed to his heart, and slowly spoke.
"Because a truly strong person would never seek such a peaceful method. What is the essence of Genjutsu? As Uchiha Clan, you should know better than anyone else. The peaceful world in the Eternal Dream? Even if everything you mentioned could be achieved, there would indeed be no risks or problems involved. But isn't that just self-exile, self-escape? It's a cowardly act of not daring to face reality, not daring to confront life!"
"If Lord Hashirama has been wallowing in the old ways, completely lacking any pioneering spirit, and only wanting to live a life of conformity and endlessly following the 'yesterday's' choices, then Lord Madara, what you have done is to ruthlessly sever all connections, unwilling to face the past, and even less courageous to embrace the future, only wanting to bury your head deep in the ground, living your own life, constantly repeating 'today's' life. Isn't that even more ridiculous?"
Menma seemed unable to hold back any longer, and chuckled, speaking each word clearly.
"Yesterday is gone, and today will eventually pass as well. Only tomorrow will keep coming. The future I want is a future with ever-evolving tomorrows, a future that I can control in my own hands. My destiny is in my own hands. This is a choice that comes from the bottom of human nature. Therefore, Lord Madara, you are a complete loser, a utterly cowardly person!"
Speaking of the very last part.
Menma's tone also unconsciously became more enthusiastic.
Tomorrow may not be perfect, and the road ahead may indeed be bumpy, but at least we can choose our own future.
Whether it's failure or success.
Even if you just buy a lottery ticket, there's still a theoretical chance of winning a big prize, right?
All of this requires you to make your own choices and take your own steps.
Passively awaiting one's fate?
No!
That's not the future Menma wants.
Even if it's really about lying down and waiting to die, it's still a choice I made myself. I would absolutely resist Menma imposed on me by others.
If I had to give an example...
Just like most people, when they were children, the sentence they least liked to hear from their elders was, "Everything I do is for your own good!"
You could call it rebellion.
In any case, by nature, humans are unwilling to passively accept everything imposed upon them by others.
Hashirama was at least a bit conservative.
Madara Uchiha's idea of forcing all of humanity to stop at this point and never move forward, even if there were no conspiracy in the Infinite Tsukuyomi Jutsu, would be 100% unacceptable to Menma.
Does such a world, such a future, have any meaning? Does it have any value?
The answer is obvious!
When Hashirama, Tobirama, and Madara heard Menma's words, their expressions all changed slightly.
Tobirama is still alright.
Although it was surprising that Menma could say such things at his age, it wasn't a particularly shocking experience. Tobirama was an extremely calm and rational person at all times, and it was difficult for such a person to be moved by others. In his entire life, Tobirama had only ever been persuaded by his own brother Elder Brother, and that wasn't because Hashirama's words were particularly touching or reasonable, but simply because Hashirama was his own brother.
Not to mention the Menma.
But Hashirama and Madara are different.
How can two people with such different personalities become lifelong friends?
Are they really as close as brothers, or is it because of the influence of Asura and Indra's chakra?
Perhaps.
But it's definitely not the main reason.
The key point is that, in essence, both of them are still the ultimate 'simple people'.
It's the kind of self-awareness that easily gets you into a state of self-consciousness, where you constantly hypnotize yourself and deepen that self-awareness.
Such people are often easily touched by a single sentence at a certain point in time!
It's obvious.
At this moment.
Menma's words were like a special door that had been completely opened in the hearts of Hashirama and Madara.
Both of them stared blankly at Menma at that moment.
After a long time.
Hashirama shook his head slightly and said with a hint of self-mockery, "The old-fashioned yesterday? It seems that's true. I think that's what I told my father back then. I never thought that in the blink of an eye, I would become an old stubborn person just like my father."
The words of the man with Menma.
This undoubtedly brought back memories of the God of Shinobi's childhood.
Didn't I have a similar conversation with my father back then?
I never imagined that I would be walking the same path again.
Yes, for the sake of Konoha, they have forgotten their original intentions. The Senju Clan, they could generously choose to disband with their younger brother. Konoha now is just an expanded version of the Senju. The people are still the same, just a different name. It won't bring any significant changes. In the end, it depends on what the higher-ups do!
How you viewed it before is not important.
At least for now, Hashirama genuinely admires Menma.
Young people like this are the ones who are qualified and capable of leading the future of the entire Shinobi World.
"Menma, you're the one who's right. The future of the Shinobi World is in your hands now!"
Hashirama his hands on his hips and laughed heartily as he spoke.
At this moment, Hashirama truly resolved his inner conflict, not only through his actions but also by choosing to trust Menma for everything in the future.
Tobirama, standing to the side, shook his head with a hint of helplessness.
That's just the kind of personality my own Elder Brother.
Same recipe, same taste.
However, Menma does seem to be a trustworthy and reliable person. If Konoha is gone, then so be it.
Anyway, it's because I lack the ability and because I entrusted the wrong person.
At least people are alive, that's good enough.
This Second Hokage could only offer himself silent solace.
Hashirama suddenly understood.
Ban, however, was still trapped in endless troubles.
As I said before, the more someone like Ban is, the less likely they are to turn back once they've chosen a path. Even if they crash into a wall and die, they might not think they chose the wrong path; they'd just think they crashed into the wall the wrong way.
The previous freckles clearly belonged to this pattern.
He kept trying to find patches for the Moon Eye Plan, constantly hypnotizing himself, and even attempting to hypnotize Menma, Hashirama, and everyone else.
Because he had truly reached the end of this path, even if there was an endless abyss ahead, Madara had the courage to jump down, but not the courage to turn back.
This is the last mental barrier that Ban himself set up for himself.
However, this barrier has now been ruthlessly shattered by Menma.
A cowardly act of escaping reality!
These words pierced Madara's heart, causing his expression to become noticeably distorted.
"A complete loser? You're right, Uzumaki Menma. Perhaps I was destined to be a loser the moment I lost to Hashirama decades ago. Hahahaha, what a meaningless life!!!"
Madara Uchiha into laughter, but within that laughter, one could hear an endless sense of sorrow.