How Many Holy Grail Wars Had There Really Been?
After her initial surprise, the junior student seemed to realize something and calmly said, "No, that's not right. Although the director did say that a ritual known as the Holy Grail War was held in Singularity X, could that be the truth behind the Humanity Incineration, the cause?"
Holmes said, "It was not the cause, but it was a very important factor. The Holy Grail War was a grand ceremony to summon Heroic Spirit, make them fight, and finally the remaining Magus and Servant would obtain the Holy Grail."
"Tohsaka Rin and the two Ritsuka Fujimaru, you should know about this, especially Tohsaka Rin. You should have even experienced the Holy Grail War in 2004, since you should have been living in Fuyuki at that time."
Tohsaka Rin nodded slightly. "Yes, you are basically right. The Fifth Holy Grail War was held in Fuyuki City in 2004. However, I am not Tohsaka Rin from your world, so I have never participated in the Holy Grail War in your world."
Speaking of which, where did I, the self in this world, go? Was I erased by Humanity Incineration?
Holmes paused for a moment, then said, "Well, Ms. Rin, as long as you can corroborate that such a ceremony was indeed held in Japan in 2004, that's fine. We also have relevant information in our world. I investigated the records of this battle, but I still can't figure out the process and the outcome."
"The only information that can be traced back to the beginning of the Holy Grail War, and the roster of the seven Magus who gathered together in pursuit of the Holy Grail..."
Holmes was about to continue, but seeing Ritsuka Fujimaru hesitate, he paused his explanation. "Ritsuka Fujimaru, is there something you've remembered that you want to say?"
Seeing that Holmes had noticed her, Ritsuka Fujimaru nodded and said the information she had carefully prepared, "Detective Holmes, I actually know some inside information about the records of this battle."
Holmes raised an eyebrow in surprise, having assumed the Chaldea didn't know much. "Oh? What is it?"
Ritsuka Fujimaru said definitively, "Mr. Holmes, you mean some of the participants in the war are people we know, right?"
Holmes: "Yes."
Ritsuka Fujimaru: "Among those participating in the war is Marisbilly, the father of our Director Olga Marie."
Holmes: "That's right!"
Gudao stared at the two in astonishment. "Director Olga's father participated in the Holy Grail War in 2004? The former director actually did such a thing...?"
He wouldn't know that!
Holmes looked at Gudao, who seemed to know nothing, and said thoughtfully, "Yes, Marisbilly, as the Lord of the Clock Tower, secretly went to a local city in Japan to participate in the Holy Grail War. The victor at that time was Marisbilly Animusphere."
Holmes turned his gaze back to Ritsuka Fujimaru: "It seems you have gathered a lot of information. I am glad my reasoning is correct. Now, I need to know the answer to another question. According to Hermes' records, he killed six Magus and obtained the Holy Grail, the omnipotent wish-granting machine."
Tohsaka Rin exclaimed in disbelief, "Ah! Does that mean I'm already dead in this world?!"
Holmes looked at the record and said, "Although it says so, there are more problems in the record. Ms. Tohsaka Rin, if you were indeed dead at that time, but it says here that your body has disappeared."
Tohsaka Rin was bewildered. "My body has disappeared?"
Holmes then threw out another piece of information that stunned Tohsaka Rin: "Speaking of which, Ms. Tohsaka Rin, has your own world experienced five Holy Grail War?"
Tohsaka Rin: "Yeah."
What's so interesting about asking that? Could it be...?
Holmes: "Can the Holy Grail be used to make a normal wish?"
Tohsaka Rin shook her head slightly. "No..."
"But it's possible in our world."
Tohsaka Rin paused for a moment, then replied, "So that means there was no contamination during the Third Holy Grail War?"
Holmes: "... Well, that's not known for now, but Lord Marisbilly was able to make his wishes as normal, and thus successfully established Chaldea."
Ritsuka Fujimaru wasn't idle during this discussion either: ' Senior Mo? What exactly is the situation with the Holy Grail War in our world? Has it been corrupted or not?'
Mo Li: 'There are many versions of the Holy Grail War in your world. For example, it's possible to have only experienced one Holy Grail War, or five. This involves Marisbilly's arrangements. Whether it's a corrupted or uncorrupted state depends on his arrangements at the time, but I tend to believe it's an uncorrupted state.'
In the event log, Marisbilly did not participate in the Holy Grail War because the Greater Grail there was already corrupted. So, since he did participate in the Holy Grail War, it is more likely that he was not corrupted.
Mo Li: 'As for the Holy Grail War, even though there were five Holy Grail War, it could easily be made to appear as if there was only one. Perhaps the Three Great Families in your world were just too patient, waiting until 2004, when the Holy Grail War mechanics were fully perfected, before actually starting the first Holy Grail War.'
Ritsuka Fujimaru: 'Wait, why does this feel so familiar? Senior Mo, if this hypothesis holds true, then the biggest Singularity should actually be the Fuyuki Holy Grail War of 2004?!'
"That year and that Holy Grail War were the starting point for everything now. They were the starting point for Chaldea, the Singularity, and even the Lostbelt to come. Without that Holy Grail War, Chaldea would never have been established, and naturally, none of what followed would have happened."
Ritsuka Fujimaru: "If our world really experienced five Holy Grail War, or even more than five, but was ultimately reduced to only experiencing one Holy Grail War... no matter what means were used to achieve that, wouldn't that be no different from Singularity?"
Mo Li: 'Don't worry, Maris's problem will be cleared up later. For now, just focus on saving the world step by step.'
Ritsuka Fujimaru: '... Senior Mo, if I ever want to retire, I'd like to retire with you, okay?'
Mo Li: 'Okay, you're welcome anytime.'
At this point, Holmes also brought up the issue of someone acting as Marisbilly's accomplice, directly pointing out the person's identity, status, age, and so on. There was only one person in Chaldea who fit this description.
Ritsuka Fujimaru did not respond, but Gudao cared deeply about the question, "The head of the medical department... Dr. Roman."
The junior student also said, "Is it Dr. Romani Archaman? The doctor... knew the former director before he came to Chaldea?"