Recaps

Su Qing sold his newly developed Dual-Blade Lizards, traded for talismans, and spent most of his growing fortune preparing for a dangerous trip to Black Tiger Mountain. After settling in the abandoned Heavenly Tribulation Gang territory and refining Lizard Warriors, he perfected the puppet blueprint and unlocked a Substitute Doll.

• Su Qing sold Lizard Warriors and three Dual-Blade Lizards, then traded one Dual-Blade Lizard to Tong Chang for two Tier-2 Evil Suppressing Talismans.
• Tong Chang warned Su Qing that a woman would bring him a crisis, and said a trip to Black Tiger Mountain could help repair the damage to his foundations.
• Su Qing returned his rented Spirit House and sold Feng Tianyang's Lotus Root Girl to Tong Xin for twenty-three thousand Spirit Crystals.
• Su Qing spent most of his wealth on War Blades, puppet materials, Mist Concealment Talismans, and Fire Spirit Pills before placing his Spirit House in the Heavenly Tribulation Gang's territory.
• The Heavenly Tribulation Gang moved away overnight, leaving Su Qing to occupy their rent-free land and patrol it with puppets.
• Su Qing perfected the Lizard Warrior blueprint and unlocked the Spatial Type Biomimetic Puppet—Substitute Doll blueprint.

After unlocking the Substitute Doll, Su Qing decided to prioritize crafting the life-saving puppet over refining Lizard Warriors. He tried to order its costly materials from Tong Xin, but the expense drained his remaining Spirit Crystals and left him needing to earn much more.

• Su Qing discovered that he had unlocked the Substitute Doll, which could sacrifice itself to protect him and move him to safety.
• Su Qing went to the Hundred Treasures Small Shop and asked Tong Xin for Ethereal Bamboo and Golden Roc Feathers.
• Tong Xin explained that the shop had Ethereal Bamboo but would need to transfer Golden Roc Feathers from the Central District, and Su Qing learned how expensive the materials were.
• Su Qing asked Tong Xin to transfer three Golden Roc Feathers, but the required deposit of eight thousand Spirit Crystals consumed all the money he had left.
• Su Qing calculated that one Substitute Doll would cost roughly thirty thousand Spirit Crystals and resolved to prepare even more before attempting to refine it.

Su Qing worked tirelessly to earn Spirit Crystals for the Substitute Doll, while Yuan Tianye faced pressure from Lin Shuangmu to recruit skilled cultivators for the Cloud Mountain Sect. The chapter ended with Yuan promising to spend the sect’s allocated funds where they mattered.

• Su Qing sold Puppets, lent them to Tang Wanqing’s squad, stitched wounds at Guo Qiao Lian’s clinic, and secretly sold two Beauty Snakes, gathering a little over fifty thousand Spirit Crystals.
• Su Qing considered buying materials to practice making a Substitute Doll, but the Beauty Snake Yuan Tianye carried stirred as he left the clinic.
• Lin Shuangmu confronted Yuan Tianye for failing to recruit Artifact Refiners, Talisman Masters, and Puppet Masters from the Forward Camp.
• Yuan Tianye said the Forward Camp had few suitable professionals and that the capable ones, including Liang Hai Shun and He Lian Xian, had refused to serve the sect.
• Lin Shuangmu urged Yuan Tianye to spend the sect’s allocated Spirit Crystals, and Yuan promised to use every last one where it counted.

Su Qing visited Yuan Tianye to secure a large Puppet order for the Forward Camp and demonstrated his creations. Yuan Tianye saw promise in the Dual-Blade Lizard and realized Su Qing could make Lizard Warriors in useful numbers, leaving the order under consideration.

• Su Qing insisted that Yuan Tianye give him the Forward Camp Puppet orders, but Yuan initially doubted that the Beauty Snake was practical for combat.
• Su Qing explained that he had developed other Puppets and brought out Dual-Blade Lizards, Dual-Club War Bears, and Lizard Warriors.
• Su Qing demonstrated the Dual-Blade Lizard’s armor-piercing sabers and combat skills, and Yuan Tianye grew interested in buying them.
• Yuan Tianye watched Su Qing demonstrate the Dual-Club War Bear and Lizard Warriors, then asked how many Lizard Warriors he could craft each day.
• Su Qing claimed he could make about three Lizard Warriors per day, and Yuan Tianye concluded that a hundred in a month could be useful.

Su Qing sold Yuan Tianye a large order of Puppets and spent his payment on materials before sensing the Demoness disguised as a cultivator inside the camp. After exposing her, he tried to escape, but she appeared before him and left him and Fire Egg unable to move.

• Su Qing agreed to provide Yuan Tianye with fifteen Dual-Blade Lizards and as many heavy-armored Lizard Warriors as he could refine, and Yuan paid him in Spirit Crystals and War Blades.
• Su Qing bought materials for Substitute Dolls and Lizard Warriors at the Hundred Treasures Small Shop, then headed home with his purchases.
• Su Qing spotted a white-robed woman and recognized her as the Demoness despite her disguise, so he shouted a warning and surrounded himself with Puppets.
• The Rogue Cultivators scattered as Su Qing tried to flee, but the Demoness revealed her true face and disintegrated the Lizard Warrior that charged her.
• The Demoness appeared before Su Qing and Fire Egg, and her pressure froze them in place as Su Qing marveled at her beauty.

Su Qing and his Puppets faced Liu Yun'er, a powerful Foundation Establishment Peak Demoness, in the Forward Camp. After the Cloud Mountain Sect cultivators failed to stop her escape, Su Qing worried that she would come after him again.

• Su Qing used his Puppets to resist Liu Yun'er's spiritual pressure and protect himself and Fire Egg, but she destroyed many of them with her charm arts and attacks.
• A Lizard Warrior carried Su Qing and Fire Egg out of Liu Yun'er's spiritual-pressure range just as three Cloud Mountain Sect Foundation Establishment War Cultivators arrived.
• Su Qing warned the three cultivators about Liu Yun'er, then fled to the Hundred Treasures Small Shop and lamented the loss of his costly Puppets.
• Qing He and the others praised Su Qing for exposing and delaying Liu Yun'er, while He Lian Xian assured him that Cloud Mountain Sect would likely reward him.
• Liu Yun'er held off the three cultivators and the Tier-2 formation with Demon Shadows before escaping the Forward Camp, leaving Su Qing afraid she would target him again.

After the Demoness left the Forward Camp without killing anyone, Su Qing mourned his destroyed Puppets and received generous compensation from Yuan Tianye. With his Puppet wreckage attracting scavengers and his protection temporarily weakened, Su Qing accepted Tang Wanqing’s offer to stay with her group while he made new Puppets.

• Su Qing lamented the loss of his Puppets and claimed they had helped protect the Forward Camp, while Yuan Tianye and Lin Shuangmu wondered why he was making the declaration to the crowd.
• Yuan Tianye praised Su Qing’s contribution, promised the Cloud Mountain Sect would cover cultivators’ losses from resisting Demonic Cultivators, and offered Su Qing full compensation plus a Tier-1 High-Grade Magic Artifact.
• Su Qing requested compensation for the special parts on his Armored War Bears and asked for a Magic Artifact that could resist or weaken Foundation Establishment spiritual pressure; Yuan Tianye agreed to arrange it.
• Lin Shuangmu dragged Yuan Tianye away as he and Su Qing continued talking, and Su Qing decided to send Yuan Tianye another Beauty Snake.
• Su Qing confronted rogue cultivators who were picking through his Puppet wreckage, and Tang Wanqing and Sun Yan made them leave.
• Tang Wanqing offered Su Qing a place with her group until he refined new Puppets, and Su Qing accepted.

After realizing how helpless he was against Liu Yun'er, Su Qing planned to rebuild his Puppet team and began refining a Substitute Doll to improve his chances of escape. His first attempts at Tier 2 Spatial Runes failed, leaving him to grind their proficiency while juggling other work.

• Su Qing moved out of Tang Wanqing's residence and regretted neglecting his medicinal soaks and boxing.
• After learning about Foundation Establishment cultivators from Tang Wanqing, Su Qing realized Liu Yun'er could kill him regardless of his Tier 1 Puppets.
• Su Qing broke through to the Sixth Layer of Qi Refining and planned to replace his ineffective Lizard Warriors with Dual-Blade Lizards, Dual-Club War Bears, and other Puppets.
• Su Qing began refining a Substitute Doll, but repeatedly failed to draw its Tier 2 Spatial Rune and gained rune proficiency from the attempts.
• Su Qing decided to focus on improving the Spatial Rune while using simpler, cheaper Substitute Doll structures, despite his Cloud Mountain Sect order and Puppet team needing attention.

Su Qing agreed to use a puppet to help Niu Ya, a newly advanced Tier 2 Body Cultivator, replace his severed head. Niu Ya accepted the risky procedure, and Su Qing prepared to begin.

• Su Qing refined dozens of Lizard Warriors, added more combat puppets, and advanced his Spatial Runes to Tier 1.
• Niu Thirteen told Su Qing that Niu Ya had returned carrying his head, which Physician Guo could not reattach because his body had become too tough.
• Su Qing confirmed Niu Ya was not an Evil Spirit and agreed to help, realizing his Iron Wolf Head puppet might solve the problem.
• Su Qing met Niu Ya patrolling the Stall Area with his head at his waist, then went with him to his residence.
• After Guo Qiao Lian arrived, Su Qing explained that this would be his first head-replacement puppet procedure, but Niu Ya insisted that he proceed.

Su Qing prepared to replace Niu Ya’s head with a Tier-1 Extreme Iron Wolf Head, while learning that Liu Yun’er had nearly killed the Sky Eagle and worrying about her presence in the Hundred Beasts Mountain Range. The chapter ended when Cloud Mountain Sect True Disciple Lin Shuangmu arrived with the rare materials and brought an intimidating display of sect authority.

• Su Qing asked Niu Ya’s men to search for a Golden Wolf King Skull and Black Dog Ash so he could refine a stronger Iron Wolf Head.
• Niu Ya recounted how he became a Tier 2 Body Cultivator after the Sky Eagle was gravely wounded by Liu Yun’er, then lost his head fighting the Scythe Mantis King.
• Su Qing recognized Liu Yun’er from Niu Ya’s description and worried that she planned to remain in the Hundred Beasts Mountain Range.
• Guo Qiao Lian gave Su Qing family-inherited Spirit Medicine and discussed preparations for the dangerous trip to Black Tiger Mountain.
• Lin Shuangmu arrived with sect treasure materials after the Forward Camp shops lacked the needed ingredients, and his presence put pressure on everyone in the Spirit House.

Lin Shuangmu recruited Niu Ya to help defend the Forward Camp, then asked Su Qing to craft him a new head using sect materials. Su Qing prepared to make the Iron Wolf Head, and the chapter ended with Niu Ya’s headless body knocking his head unconscious so the work could begin.

• Lin Shuangmu asked Niu Ya to join the Cloud Mountain Sect, but Niu Ya refused while promising to help against demon beasts.
• Lin Shuangmu gave Su Qing materials to craft Niu Ya a new head and supplied extra Golden Wolf King Skulls and Black Dog Ash.
• Niu Thirteen praised Lin Shuangmu, and Su Qing explained that Lin’s courtesy came from Niu Ya’s new strength and value.
• Su Qing took Guo Qiao Lian and Niu Ya’s head into his Spirit House to work on the Iron Wolf Head, learning that the head had to remain within twenty zhang of its body.
• Niu Ya’s headless body came to the Spirit House and struck its own head unconscious so Su Qing could begin the work.

Su Qing successfully fitted Niu Ya with a Golden Wolf King Skull head, impressing the onlookers and deepening his friendship with the Tier 2 Body Cultivator. After returning home and replenishing his qi and blood, Su Qing opened the Internal Refinement Method of the Immovable Heavenly King Technique.

• Su Qing and Guo Qiao Lian fitted the rune-inscribed Golden Wolf King Skull over Niu Ya's body, and Niu Ya admired his new Golden Wolf Head.
• Su Qing used Black Dog Ash and Niu Ya's qi and blood to join the skull to his body, awakening its runes and powers.
• Niu Ya emerged before the Rogue Cultivators, who marveled at the Golden Wolf Head, and Xuan Niang insisted he keep it on for her.
• Su Qing gained Niu Ya's gratitude and two sets of Tier-2 materials, then shared some of the Rat King Team's beast meat with Guo Qiao Lian.
• Su Qing returned home, replenished his qi and blood with food and medicinal treatments, and opened the Internal Refinement Method of the Immovable Heavenly King Technique.

Su Qing began internally refining Golden Essence Qi to cultivate an Adamantine Furnace, then successfully crafted and activated a Substitute Doll. He planned to make more dolls to protect himself from Liu Yun'er while continuing his body cultivation.

• Su Qing absorbed essence qi from Profound Iron Essence, but his lower dantian did not yet form an Adamantine Furnace.
• After recovering from the failed-to-digest residue, Su Qing returned to crafting a doll, using his Wood Spirit Servant for basic tasks.
• Su Qing completed the doll's runes, inserted a Tier 3 Golden Peng feather, and activated the finished Substitute Doll.
• Su Qing stored the active doll and decided to make seven or eight more so Liu Yun'er could not harm him.

Su Qing spent weeks refining Lizard Warriors and Substitute Dolls before heading to the Hundred Treasures Small Shop to buy materials for a powerful Puppet. A severe, chilling change in the weather led him to Niu's Magic Robe Shop, where he traded a Dual-Blade Lizard for a Cloud Maple Magic Robe and learned how Cloud Mountain Sect had tied Niu Ya’s team to the Forward Camp.

• Su Qing spent over 180,000 Spirit Crystals refining just one additional Substitute Puppet, then worked for more than ten days to produce over a hundred Lizard Warriors without delivering them early.
• Su Qing decided to seek materials to turn the Half Set of Mother-Child Boomerang into a Tier 1 Ultimate Puppet for fighting Foundation Establishment Cultivators.
• Su Qing found the land buried in deep snow and sensed that the spiritual energy carried a freezing, murderous chill, but he continued to the Hundred Treasures Small Shop.
• Niu Ya’s plans to counterattack the Dwarf Mountain Defense Line faltered because the weather weakened his Fire Cloud Heavenly Essence Furnace and Tier 2 Demonic Beasts appeared in the Low Mountain range.
• Su Qing visited Niu's Magic Robe Shop and learned that Cloud Mountain Sect had supplied the Rat King Team with Dharma Robes and favorable terms to keep Niu Ya and his brothers at the Forward Camp.
• Su Qing traded a Dual-Blade Lizard for a Cloud Maple Magic Robe, then promised Niu Thirteen a Golden Wolf Head if he reached the Tier 2 Body Cultivator realm.

Su Qing bought a Gale Cannon Puppet blueprint and materials from Tong Xin, then learned that the Blood Lotus Fruit harvest at Black Tiger Mountain was approaching. He returned home to study the blueprint and prepare for the coming mission.

• Su Qing found Hundred Treasures Small Shop struggling against Niu's Magic Robe Shop and negotiated a Tier-1 High-Grade Gale Cannon Puppet blueprint for thirteen thousand Spirit Crystals.
• Tong Xin held firm on the materials' price, so Su Qing bought over sixty sets and paid the balance with a Golden Wolf King Skull and Heavenly Spirit Crystal.
• Su Qing learned Qing He and Ma Tuan were guarding the Blood Lotus Fruit and that the group would likely be called to Black Tiger Mountain in seven or eight days.
• Su Qing informed Tang Wanqing that they would soon set out, then returned home and opened the Gale Cannon Puppet blueprint.
• Su Qing hoped the Gale Cannon Puppet's power would help him make the Mother-Child Boomerang rival a Tier-2 Puppet.

Su Qing planned to strengthen his Mother-Child Boomerang by fitting it with a Gale Cannon Puppet, preparing for his attempt to steal a Blood Lotus Fruit from the Hundred Treasures Pavilion’s team at Black Tiger Mountain. He successfully refined a standard Gale Cannon Puppet, but still had to solve the challenge of integrating it with the boomerang.

• Su Qing reviewed the Gale Cannon Puppet’s strengths and weaknesses and decided its firepower could compensate for the Mother-Child Boomerang’s low offensive power.
• Su Qing studied the damaged Mother-Child Boomerang and drafted a blueprint to turn its Child Darts into mobile mounts for the cannon.
• Su Qing planned to inscribe the cannon and darts with Spatial Runes and Material Runes so they could shrink for concealment and enlarge for combat.
• Su Qing built the first Gale Cannon Puppet and, after wasting materials on a failed attempt, successfully inscribed its runes.
• Su Qing recognized that integrating the finished cannon puppet with the Mother-Child Boomerang was the hardest step still ahead.

Su Qing modified the Gale Cannon Puppet and Mother-Child Boomerang, combining the resulting Child Darts with cannons into a new aerial weapon. He named the first one Annihilator 1 and planned to make more.

• Su Qing successfully added Spatial and Material Runes to the Gale Cannon Puppet, but its Intelligence Rune caused it to collapse, so he abandoned the attempt to give it a brain.
• Su Qing reinforced the Child Darts and inscribed Biomimetic, Intelligence, Combat, Material, and Spatial Runes on them.
• The Child Darts gained stealth, speed, offensive power, and the ability to change size and form.
• Su Qing mounted a Gale Cannon Puppet beneath each wing of a Child Dart and tested the combination by having it sever an ancient tree with Gale Blades.
• Su Qing named the combined weapon Annihilator 1 and planned to number future versions up to Annihilator 36.

Su Qing built up his Interceptor air wing and began transforming the Mother Dart into a durable, self-sufficient mothership that could support the puppets. With its main structure complete, he considered asking Yuan Tianye to add formations.

• Su Qing refined twenty-two Interceptor Puppets, lost fourteen Child Darts, and assigned surplus Gale Cannon Puppets to Bear One and Bear Two with Wood Spirit Servants to operate them.
• Fire Egg volunteered to fire the cannons, but Su Qing reminded it that carrying him to safety remained its primary duty.
• Su Qing enlarged the Mother Dart and reinforced it with Profound Iron Essence and Heavenly Spirit Gold, then added Charging Slots and Spirit Crystals for the Interceptor Puppets.
• Su Qing used Golden Peng Remnant Feathers, Stealth Bee Wings, and Chameleon Gold to give the mothership a Golden Peng form with some invisibility.
• Su Qing considered asking Yuan Tianye to install offensive and defensive formations on the mothership.

Su Qing abandoned plans to install an array on his Mothership because he could not afford the materials and fee, then completed and activated it as the Golden Roc Mothership. After testing its stealth and puppet-control abilities and adding defensive cannons operated by Wood Spirit Servants, he learned that the panel classified it as a Combination Type Puppet.

• Yuan Tianye quoted the costs of two arrays and a reduced twenty-thousand-Spirit-Crystal setup fee, but Su Qing declined because he could not afford them.
• Su Qing finished drawing the five kinds of Tier 2 runes, powered the Mothership with a damaged half Spirit Stone, and activated its Golden Peng appearance and abilities.
• Su Qing named it the Golden Roc Mothership and tested its ability to conceal itself in clouds, carry Interceptor Puppets, and direct them against targets at long range.
• Su Qing tried to make Dual-Blade Lizards into blade-bearing Guards with Spatial Runes, but one lizard died; he successfully gave Wood Spirit Servants the ability to change size.
• Su Qing installed Gale Cannon Puppets on the Mothership and assigned Wood Spirit Servants to operate them, then saw the panel identify his creation as a Combination Type Puppet.

Su Qing completed the Sky Roc Ship and considered how to handle the Demoness and the upcoming Black Tiger Mountain expedition. Qing He visited him and offered to help him obtain a Blood Lotus Fruit in exchange for buying two Dual-Blade Lizards on credit.

• Su Qing reviewed three newly unlocked high-tier Puppet Blueprints, then added the Cluster Hummingbird swarm to the Sky Roc Ship and judged the ship capable of challenging powerful cultivators.
• Su Qing weighed the Demoness's threat and planned for the Black Tiger Mountain expedition, where he hoped to claim a Blood Lotus Fruit without fighting Qing He and the Hundred Treasures Pavilion War Cultivators.
• Su Qing kept the Sky Roc Ship hidden above the clouds and welcomed Qing He when she came to visit.
• Qing He asked to buy two Dual-Blade Lizards on credit, but Su Qing refused and reminded her to repay her existing debt.
• Qing He offered to help Su Qing secure the other Blood Lotus Fruit if he sold her the Puppets on credit.

Su Qing agreed to join Qing He in competing for the remaining Blood Lotus Fruit, and prepared his Puppets for the expedition to Black Tiger Mountain. At the gathering, he accepted several Rogue Cultivators into his group as the party prepared to depart.

• Qing He persuaded Su Qing to help seize the remaining Blood Lotus Fruit, offering her aid in exchange for two Dual-Blade Lizards bought on credit.
• Qing He left Su Qing's courtyard after reminding him that everyone would gather and depart at dawn.
• Su Qing prepared for the journey, gathered his Puppets, and rode his Spirit Dog to the meeting place in the Abandoned Spirit Field.
• Su Qing arrived to find the Rogue Cultivators gathered with their Lizard Warriors and exchanged greetings with the Professionals.
• Liang Hai Shun and He Lian Xian joined Su Qing, and he also welcomed Guo Qiao Lian and her White Tooth Elephant into the group.

Su Qing borrowed five thousand Spirit Crystals from Guo Qiao Lian before joining a mission to Black Tiger Mountain with Qing He, Leng Feng Xiang, and the others. Leng Feng Xiang brought along the silent Insect Tamer Yuan Hua, whom Su Qing and Fire Egg regarded with suspicion, and the group set out from Forward Camp into the snowy mountains.

• Su Qing asked Guo Qiao Lian to lend him Spirit Crystals, and she gladly gave him five thousand.
• Qing He complained that Guo Qiao Lian had refused to lend her money and asked Su Qing where Tang was, but he denied that Tang was involved in the mission.
• Leng Feng Xiang arrived with Yuan Hua, an Insect Tamer, and introduced him to the group.
• Fire Egg barked furiously at Yuan Hua, and Su Qing restrained it while remaining wary of the newcomer.
• Qing He and Ma Tuan led the party away from Forward Camp toward Black Tiger Mountain as Su Qing considered how many would make it back.

Su Qing's group traveled toward Black Tiger Mountain, encountering and defeating several demon beasts before camping near the Dwarf Mountain Defense Line. During the night, Yuan Hua approached Ding Ping, who froze as the cold spread through his body and the flute music stopped.

• Su Qing's group crossed the low mountains, and Ma Tuan killed two Black Green Python Beasts that Ding Ping's flute revealed.
• The group defeated several more pairs of giant pythons and reached a junction of three mountain ridges near the Dwarf Mountain Defense Line.
• Ma Tuan and Qing He ordered the group to camp for the night, and the Professionals deployed their Spirit Houses while others sheltered in tents.
• Ding Ping played his flute through the night and noticed Yuan Hua remained unaffected by the cold.
• Ding Ping felt the mountain wind grow colder, then saw Yuan Hua's face close to his as his body froze and his flute music stopped.

Su Qing watched Ma Tuan and Qing He destroy the Evil Entity disguised as Ding Ping, then prepared to guard against Leng Feng Xiang and studied a copied Dao Pattern. When he traced it onto his palm, the system unexpectedly registered a failed attempt to refine Puppet Immortal.

• Su Qing watched Yuan Hua absorb Ding Ping and concluded that Yuan Hua was an Evil Entity.
• Ma Tuan and Qing He confronted Leng Feng Xiang, then attacked Ding Ping until only black water and a Corrupt Mark remained.
• Ma Tuan warned Leng Feng Xiang to avoid causing trouble before Black Tiger Mountain, while Qing He silently showed her suspicion.
• Su Qing sent Bee Scouts carrying Exorcism Talismans to the Sky Roc Ship and had the Wood Spirit Servants place talismans on the Gale Cannon Puppets.
• Su Qing examined the Fake Wall and traced its copied Dao Pattern onto his palm, triggering a failed Puppet Immortal refinement prompt.

Su Qing discovered that he could improve the Mountain Sea Capture Dao Heaven Talisman only by refining himself, leaving him badly injured but eager to continue after recovering. The next morning, he learned that Ding Ping and Yuan Hua had disappeared, while Liang Hai Shun began speaking before Su Qing could warn the others about Leng Feng Xiang.

• Su Qing used the Fake Wall's Mountain Sea Capture pattern to refine himself, exhausting his vital energy and blood and damaging his body, but slightly improving his Spiritual Root and Bone Structure.
• Su Qing learned that Puppet Immortal required mastering multiple Dao Heaven Runes and gathering rare treasures, and resolved to recover before attempting another refinement.
• Su Qing emerged from his Spirit House the next day, alarming Guo Qiao Lian and the others, and explained that he had overused essence blood while refining a Puppet.
• The rogue cultivators discussed the disappearance of Ding Ping and Yuan Hua, and Su Qing prepared to warn them about Leng Feng Xiang before Liang Hai Shun spoke up.